Black Knight vs Blood Knight

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Max zero somehow you forgot to mention the most important thing: black knights use up a special slot while blood knights have two terrible drawbacks, namely frenzy and being a rare choice.

You say nothing in the VC list can do what blood knights can at the same cost.

I say a frenzied cavalry unit that costs 275 points and has 4 wounds with a 2+ armor blows.

No amount of internet theoryhammer is going to make a terribly fragile, overpriced rare choice a good one.

Blood knights are nice and can work if you place them well, for example against daemons but that still doesn't make them a tournament viable unit in any way. They just have too many horrible matchups and everyone knows it so why prove otherwise?
 
ksum said:
Max zero somehow you forgot to mention the most important thing: black knights use up a special slot while blood knights have two terrible drawbacks, namely frenzy and being a rare choice.

You say nothing in the VC list can do what blood knights can at the same cost.

I say a frenzied cavalry unit that costs 275 points and has 4 wounds with a 2+ armor blows.

No amount of internet theoryhammer is going to make a terribly fragile, overpriced rare choice a good one.

Well nothing does have its killing power.

3 str 7 attacks and 2 str 4 attacks for 55 points is a bargin.

They are no more fragile then any other T4 2+ save cavalry.

Frenzy is a drawback but good screening from Dire Wolves you can work around that. Does it always work? No. But nothing has a 100% of success in Warhmmer.

If your looking for a defensive unit get some Ghouls or Skels. But if your need a hammer Blood Knights are embodiment of a hammer unit.
 
Great response Max.

The problem I had with Drakenhof and GG was mobility. I wanted a unit that could take hits and get stuck into a fight. With 9 Black Knights and a BSB, I found that was totally feasible.

With the static CR of a larger number of Black Knights, I found I didnt even need to win combat through kills which is why I usually go with them as opposed to the Blood Knights.

Now again, my usual opponent is WoC so I'm usually not killing stuff because of their armor so static CR is what I have to win through.
 
LordSoth, the thing is, if you add a Banner of Strigos on a Blood Knight unit they will steamroller even Warriors of Chaos with their sheer number of S7 attacks. They will die quick enough when their armor save is reduced to 5+/6+.
 
Bloods with Strigos crush WoC on the charge...unless they roll insanely well on armor saves.

As others have said, 4 bloods with strigos will cure what ails you. Everything else pales in comparison.
 
my preferance is taking a unit of both. each unit has a differant role and as a big fan of cavalry i had to take a unit of each.

blood knights are the premium heavy cavalry of the game. S7 on the charge alone is huge let alone the fact they cause fear and can be raised from the dead. frenzy CAN be a double edged sword but a unit of dire wolves usually solves all your problems here. a unit of 5 throws out 15 S7 hits and 10 S4 hits. give them the banner of strigos to save you from any bad rolls to hit and this unit can and will slaughter anything it faces. i'd be mad not to take a unit of these guys. the role i set this unit up for is line breaker. i generally aim for a big nasty unit and plough it into the dust ready to roll up the enemies flank in the following turns.
i take 5 with a standard bearer and strigos standard, champion and musician aren't needed.

black knights are more of a surgical opposed to the battering ram of the black knights with the key element to their usefulness being ethereal movement. the amount of times i've seen black knights pull an army out of bad situations by zipping accross terrain and then vanhelled into a units flank or rear to save the day or even better when your opponant doesnt realise how they move and thinks he's safe. priceless. i like using this unit 7 strong with champion and standard and banner of undying legion so with US 28 and very likely to win combat the turn i charge (i almost always use the helm to boost their WS to 7) its almost always gonna be an autobreak for the unit i hit. you have to pick your targets carefully as you can't risk not breaking the unit, they simply can't do the damage without charging to win combats and CR will grind them down fast.

out of the two i prefer blood knights because of the raw hitting power, its a unit i can rely on to seriously lay the smackdown in an army of mediocre to outright terrible fighters it's nice to be able to ensure the enemy gets a good doing over without relying on risking your vampires in combat.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu