blood drinker

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Forge said:
I think people are pulling exceptions out of their "arses"

no where does it say ignore said section of the IoN rule that the blood drinker directly refers to, it says just as if IoN had been cast on them no exceptions no singling out a section of the ruling now if it said

"The order of models replenished are placed as described in the Invocation of Nehek spell."

we would have a totally different argument here, in fact no argument as its specific, Because the blood drinker description is not specific and just refers to IoN as a whole I fully believe that all of the benefits and restrictions should be utilized from the IoN spell listing when using the Blood Drinker.

I've never used blood drinker actually so I have no reason to pull any exception out of anything.
It refers to the IoN rules and you're right, it doesn't say to ignore any of it, but it doesn't have to. You're obviously suppose to ignore some parts of it. For example: IoN section says the target unit regains 1d6 wounds worth of models. Obviously we ignore that part because the description for blood drinker says that it causes a single wound to be regained: it already specified how many wounds you regain so you ignore it in the IoN description without it telling you too, right. IoN also says you target any of your own units within 18". You obviously ignore that part since the description already gives you the targets: the wielder and his unit.

That's kind of the heart of this isn't it? When the description says the unit of the wielder can be targeted, does that include other characters in the unit since IoN says characters in a unit must be targeted separately? I would say yes because the BRB says the character is part of the unit and IoN doesn't say characters are not considered part of the unit ergo it can benefit. I'll admit it's a little bit of a stretch (you have to do some stretching since the wording is unclear), but much less so than saying when the description says the unit can benefit, it ONLY meant R&F troops.

Consider in another light: in 8th edition we can have units comprised entirely of characters if we wanted. If one of these characters has blood drinker, would his unit be able to benefit from those wounds? Saying no to this clearly violates the description of the item! So then why would the blood drinker be applied to a character if there are no R&F troops, but if there are R&F troops it can't, especially when the term R&F troops isn't even mentioned? (excuse the strawman)

To shift gears: Can a lord use this to heal 2 wounds/can a unit of blood knights receive more than 1 wound a turn from this? I'm saying no matter how you look at it (like blood drinker is casting the spell or not) you still are casting one spell per wound gained. If you inflict 10 wounds in CC phase (somehow), it says as clearly as warhammer gets that EACH unsaved wound allows the wielder or the unit he is with to regain a SINGLE wound as if IoN had been cast. That seems fairly clear that each unsaved wound is treated as a separate casting of IoN. As I said, nothing indicates all the wounds caused in CC phase are lumped together as if one IoN had been cast and I would like to hear why you think it is, if you do.
Seeing as a vampire unit is limited to one wound... per casting of the spell... that restriction doesn't apply not because it's ignored, but because each wound is treated as a single IoN granting a single wound. That restriction cannot come into play since you're only gaining one wound at a time.

I think that is literally all I have to say on this subject :)
 
Yeah that pretty much sums it all up. Well put Dklyn, I feel bad that I can't add anything to your post lol

Perhaps we could take a consensus on the main question, which is, can Blood Drinker be used to target other characters within the wielders unit?

I say yes it can.
 
"Consider in another light: in 8th edition we can have units comprised entirely of characters if we wanted. If one of these characters has blood drinker, would his unit be able to benefit from those wounds? Saying no to this clearly violates the description of the item! So then why would the blood drinker be applied to a character if there are no R&F troops, but if there are R&F troops it can't, especially when the term R&F troops isn't even mentioned? (excuse the strawman)"

the first actual argument against mine thanks for actually playing with logic, but in other parts of the rulebook it clearly defines the difference between targeting the unit and a character in the unit, so my question to that would be how would you regenerate wounds on this impromptu unit if IoN or say regrowth was cast on it? you couldn't could you? you would have to target a specific character in the unit?
 
note i think that it can resurrect as many wounds as it deals, it clearly states for EACH unsaved wound dont know why that even started to be discussed
 
Dklyn said:
Forge said:
I think people are pulling exceptions out of their "arses"

no where does it say ignore said section of the IoN rule that the blood drinker directly refers to, it says just as if IoN had been cast on them no exceptions no singling out a section of the ruling now if it said

"The order of models replenished are placed as described in the Invocation of Nehek spell."

we would have a totally different argument here, in fact no argument as its specific, Because the blood drinker description is not specific and just refers to IoN as a whole I fully believe that all of the benefits and restrictions should be utilized from the IoN spell listing when using the Blood Drinker.

I've never used blood drinker actually so I have no reason to pull any exception out of anything.
It refers to the IoN rules and you're right, it doesn't say to ignore any of it, but it doesn't have to. You're obviously suppose to ignore some parts of it. For example: IoN section says the target unit regains 1d6 wounds worth of models. Obviously we ignore that part because the description for blood drinker says that it causes a single wound to be regained: it already specified how many wounds you regain so you ignore it in the IoN description without it telling you too, right. IoN also says you target any of your own units within 18". You obviously ignore that part since the description already gives you the targets: the wielder and his unit.

That's kind of the heart of this isn't it? When the description says the unit of the wielder can be targeted, does that include other characters in the unit since IoN says characters in a unit must be targeted separately? I would say yes because the BRB says the character is part of the unit and IoN doesn't say characters are not considered part of the unit ergo it can benefit. I'll admit it's a little bit of a stretch (you have to do some stretching since the wording is unclear), but much less so than saying when the description says the unit can benefit, it ONLY meant R&F troops.

Consider in another light: in 8th edition we can have units comprised entirely of characters if we wanted. If one of these characters has blood drinker, would his unit be able to benefit from those wounds? Saying no to this clearly violates the description of the item! So then why would the blood drinker be applied to a character if there are no R&F troops, but if there are R&F troops it can't, especially when the term R&F troops isn't even mentioned? (excuse the strawman)

To shift gears: Can a lord use this to heal 2 wounds/can a unit of blood knights receive more than 1 wound a turn from this? I'm saying no matter how you look at it (like blood drinker is casting the spell or not) you still are casting one spell per wound gained. If you inflict 10 wounds in CC phase (somehow), it says as clearly as warhammer gets that EACH unsaved wound allows the wielder or the unit he is with to regain a SINGLE wound as if IoN had been cast. That seems fairly clear that each unsaved wound is treated as a separate casting of IoN. As I said, nothing indicates all the wounds caused in CC phase are lumped together as if one IoN had been cast and I would like to hear why you think it is, if you do.
Seeing as a vampire unit is limited to one wound... per casting of the spell... that restriction doesn't apply not because it's ignored, but because each wound is treated as a single IoN granting a single wound. That restriction cannot come into play since you're only gaining one wound at a time.

I think that is literally all I have to say on this subject :)

agreed with most of the replacement aspects of blood drinker

my question to you sir is.....

what part of blood drinkers description says that ethereal, vampire, and non infantry models may regain more then a single wound BEYOND the extreme reaching of the definition of a single word like EACH.
 
"he first actual argument against mine thanks for actually playing with logic" Actually, everything I said in the post was against yours. This was probably just the first example I pointed out that you hadn't thought of :). And actually, the beginning is more of what I would think is the reason. Personally, until I hear a reason why you're suppose to use some of the rules for targeting with IoN and not others, I think saying characters can't be benefited by blood drinker is a stretch. But that's because we are different people with different ways of reading the same words, yeah?

"but in other parts of the rulebook it clearly defines the difference between targeting the unit and a character in the unit"
Can you give an example in the BRB of something that targets the unit but excludes characters (as you're thinking blood drinker can do)? I can't think of anything offhand... I can think of some things that can target characters but not R&F models but not the other way around. Sometimes R&F are excluded because the effect is intended to make one model very strong. Perhaps you're referring to shooting at a character in a unit rules (which do not do as I asked: target the unit separate from the character)?

"so my question to that would be how would you regenerate wounds on this impromptu unit if IoN or say regrowth was cast on it? you couldn't could you? you would have to target a specific character in the unit? " Well regrowth specifically cannot be used on characters, no matter the composition of the unit it's in, so that answers that. You can look at it as you can target the unit, but no model in the unit would benefit from it :). Like casting VDM on a unit in CC twice, there's no rule saying you can't do that, it just wouldn't grant any benefits. IoN is also completely clear on how it works and certainly those characters would be able to be healed by that spell. If someone had blood drinker in that unit, he would be able to use those wounds to heal his comrades in the unit. Saying otherwise is blatantly disregarding the exact rules for blood drinker. If you disagree, I'd be interested in hearing how to justify using the wording of IoN to disregard to the wording for the item itself. Ideally I would be able to use that same logic to say "even though it says I get a single wound, IoN says I get d6 wounds." :). I hope you can see where I'm coming from.

I think the biggest difference b/t the way you see it and the way I see it is you're saying the word unit (in blood drinker) refers only to R&F and this isn't usually (if ever) the case. Even IoN still considers characters part of the unit.

"note i think that it can resurrect as many wounds as it deals, it clearly states for EACH unsaved wound dont know why that even started to be discussed" That is because someone answered your question saying that you could not and then someone corrected them and then someone said I disagree etc.

"my question to you sir is.....

what part of blood drinkers description says that ethereal, vampire, and non infantry models may regain more then a single wound BEYOND the extreme reaching of the definition of a single word like EACH."
I like the sir. Makes me picture your avatar with a top hat and monocle. ("I said good day sir!")
Hmm, either I'm not understanding you or you aren't understanding me. Each wound from blood drinker is regarded as a separate casting of IoN (hence the emphasis of single and each). 2 wounds = 2 IoN with one wound each. If you cast IoN twice on a vamp lord, he regains two wounds. So there's no disregarding that rule, it just isn't coming into effect (like if you rolled 1 both times for your d6 wounds for casting IoN, the limitation of 1wound/casting wouldn't matter since your limited to one wound either way). If you're asking something other than that, then I'll need clarification (preferably through a PM or a new thread or something since the thread isn't meant to discuss this aspect of blood drinker.)
 
First off, Blood Drinker needs not specify Ethereal, as there is no possible legal way to field the Blood Drinker inside of an Ethereal Unit. Only Ethereal Characters may join Ethereal Units and to become Ethereal you have to forsake magic items... which includes the blood drinker.

After reading the replies, I do think that Dklyn is correct in his interpretation.

Each wound you deal, is like casting IoN and rolling a 1. So if you rolled up 4 wounds, you basically casted IoN 4 times. Each wound can thus target the wielder, another character, or the unit.

Since each casting of IoN via the BLood Drinker is akin to rolling a 1 in its own right, the same model can be the target of more than one casting of IoN. So of the 4 wounds, you can apply all of them to lets say.. your Zombie Dragon... because its like casting IoN on him and getting 1 each time. If you wanted to use your PD and IoN, you could do it the same way, but the expensive 40 point Blood Drinker lets you free up those PD for other things.... I LIKE IT!!!!

I mean, I liked it before, but now... WOAH!

I agree with you Forge, its pretty borderline broken, but in a world where I see Teclis about 50% of the games i play... i feel im allowed a broken item or two.

I suspect this will all get cleared up when our army book releases for 8th ed, whenever that is.
 
I still dont see the corralation between how your figuring each one counts as a separate casting of IoN.

"....as if Invocation of Nehek had been cast on them."

Not "Invocations" (the plural of Invocation)

a single Invocation, for which wounds dealt effectively replace d6 wounds, and if it is the way it reads, if you have Red fury you may consider it 2 castings of IoN.
 
Forge said:
I still dont see the corralation between how your figuring each one counts as a separate casting of IoN.

Allow me to reiterate. "For each unsaved wound inflicted by the Blood Drinker, the wielder (or unit he is with) immediately regains a single wound...as if IoN had been cast"

For every 1 wound caused = 1 wound gained just as if IoN had been cast. That's separating every single wound gained as a separate IoN. Every wound is considered separately. There's nothing lumping all the wounds caused together. No mention of a limitation per CC phase or anything of the sort. Every wound is gained independent of the other wounds regained. I cannot think of any more ways to say it. Single wound = one IoN. That seems to be the popular interpretation and the one that seems the most reasonable to me.

Now, how can you figure that all the wounds are lumped together as a single IoN? And which wounds for that matter? The ones generated in the CC phase? Ones generated in the magic phase via staff of damnation? Or just all the ones that turn? Or are all the wounds generated by blood drinker for the entire game are to be treated as one big IoN? Your interpretation involves adding a bit to the description it seems and so that's why I feel it's a bit far fetched.

Forge said:
Not "Invocations" (the plural of Invocation)

:slapface: come now... if you cast IoN several times, you don't say "I'm casting invocations of nehek." you say you cast IoN twice or three times or w/e. In any case, even if you did do that, it would still be singular because the description talks about regaining a single wound as if IoN. You can't regain 1 wound from "Invocations" of nehek (or as I would say, from several castings of IoN) ;).

Anyways, I'm think I've taken over this thread enough.
 
Dklyn said:
Forge said:
I still dont see the corralation between how your figuring each one counts as a separate casting of IoN.

Allow me to reiterate. "For each unsaved wound inflicted by the Blood Drinker, the wielder (or unit he is with) immediately regains a single wound...as if IoN had been cast"

For every 1 wound caused = 1 wound gained just as if IoN had been cast. That's separating every single wound gained as a separate IoN. Every wound is considered separately. There's nothing lumping all the wounds caused together. No mention of a limitation per CC phase or anything of the sort. Every wound is gained independent of the other wounds regained. I cannot think of any more ways to say it. Single wound = one IoN. That seems to be the popular interpretation and the one that seems the most reasonable to me.

Now, how can you figure that all the wounds are lumped together as a single IoN? And which wounds for that matter? The ones generated in the CC phase? Ones generated in the magic phase via staff of damnation? Or just all the ones that turn? Or are all the wounds generated by blood drinker for the entire game are to be treated as one big IoN? Your interpretation involves adding a bit to the description it seems and so that's why I feel it's a bit far fetched.

Forge said:
Not "Invocations" (the plural of Invocation)

:slapface: come now... if you cast IoN several times, you don't say "I'm casting invocations of nehek." you say you cast IoN twice or three times or w/e. In any case, even if you did do that, it would still be singular because the description talks about regaining a single wound as if IoN. You can't regain 1 wound from "Invocations" of nehek (or as I would say, from several castings of IoN) ;).

Anyways, I'm think I've taken over this thread enough.

ok how would you write the description of blood drinker to reflect the way I say it is while keeping as much of the wording the same?

you have to say for "each" unsaved wound you regain a single wound otherwise your probably ever only restoring 1 wound with any other writing of that sentence.

I believe the sword is meant to be used in conjunction with Ghouls and grave guard the upgraded version of "the tomb blade" which only works on skeletons. using them on Blood Knights and Black Knights causes you to restore an entire unit within a turn without using any resources other then killing your opponent which isnt hard with a kitted Vampire Lord with blood drinker, does that sound reasonable?
 
Forge said:
Dklyn said:
Forge said:
I still dont see the corralation between how your figuring each one counts as a separate casting of IoN.

Allow me to reiterate. "For each unsaved wound inflicted by the Blood Drinker, the wielder (or unit he is with) immediately regains a single wound...as if IoN had been cast"

For every 1 wound caused = 1 wound gained just as if IoN had been cast. That's separating every single wound gained as a separate IoN. Every wound is considered separately. There's nothing lumping all the wounds caused together. No mention of a limitation per CC phase or anything of the sort. Every wound is gained independent of the other wounds regained. I cannot think of any more ways to say it. Single wound = one IoN. That seems to be the popular interpretation and the one that seems the most reasonable to me.

Now, how can you figure that all the wounds are lumped together as a single IoN? And which wounds for that matter? The ones generated in the CC phase? Ones generated in the magic phase via staff of damnation? Or just all the ones that turn? Or are all the wounds generated by blood drinker for the entire game are to be treated as one big IoN? Your interpretation involves adding a bit to the description it seems and so that's why I feel it's a bit far fetched.

Forge said:
Not "Invocations" (the plural of Invocation)

:slapface: come now... if you cast IoN several times, you don't say "I'm casting invocations of nehek." you say you cast IoN twice or three times or w/e. In any case, even if you did do that, it would still be singular because the description talks about regaining a single wound as if IoN. You can't regain 1 wound from "Invocations" of nehek (or as I would say, from several castings of IoN) ;).

Anyways, I'm think I've taken over this thread enough.

ok how would you write the description of blood drinker to reflect the way I say it is while keeping as much of the wording the same?

you have to say for "each" unsaved wound you regain a single wound otherwise your probably ever only restoring 1 wound with any other writing of that sentence.

I believe the sword is meant to be used in conjunction with Ghouls and grave guard the upgraded version of "the tomb blade" which only works on skeletons. using them on Blood Knights and Black Knights causes you to restore an entire unit within a turn without using any resources other then killing your opponent which isnt hard with a kitted Vampire Lord with blood drinker, does that sound reasonable?

The more I look at it, i do agree with Dklyn. It certainly works just fine on ghouls and graveguard... it just so happens to also work just fine on everything else.

If they didnt intend for the weapon to be used as Dklyn suggests, they would not have needed to put the word EACH in there. It simply could have read.

"The wounds caused by Blood Drinker may restore wounds to the wielder and his unit as though Invocation of Nekhet were cast on them."

If that were the wording, then it would work as you suggest, Forge.

But the word EACH just sells it to me.
 
Gladius Rex said:
Forge said:
Dklyn said:
Forge said:
I still dont see the corralation between how your figuring each one counts as a separate casting of IoN.

Allow me to reiterate. "For each unsaved wound inflicted by the Blood Drinker, the wielder (or unit he is with) immediately regains a single wound...as if IoN had been cast"

For every 1 wound caused = 1 wound gained just as if IoN had been cast. That's separating every single wound gained as a separate IoN. Every wound is considered separately. There's nothing lumping all the wounds caused together. No mention of a limitation per CC phase or anything of the sort. Every wound is gained independent of the other wounds regained. I cannot think of any more ways to say it. Single wound = one IoN. That seems to be the popular interpretation and the one that seems the most reasonable to me.

Now, how can you figure that all the wounds are lumped together as a single IoN? And which wounds for that matter? The ones generated in the CC phase? Ones generated in the magic phase via staff of damnation? Or just all the ones that turn? Or are all the wounds generated by blood drinker for the entire game are to be treated as one big IoN? Your interpretation involves adding a bit to the description it seems and so that's why I feel it's a bit far fetched.

Forge said:
Not "Invocations" (the plural of Invocation)

:slapface: come now... if you cast IoN several times, you don't say "I'm casting invocations of nehek." you say you cast IoN twice or three times or w/e. In any case, even if you did do that, it would still be singular because the description talks about regaining a single wound as if IoN. You can't regain 1 wound from "Invocations" of nehek (or as I would say, from several castings of IoN) ;).

Anyways, I'm think I've taken over this thread enough.

ok how would you write the description of blood drinker to reflect the way I say it is while keeping as much of the wording the same?

you have to say for "each" unsaved wound you regain a single wound otherwise your probably ever only restoring 1 wound with any other writing of that sentence.

I believe the sword is meant to be used in conjunction with Ghouls and grave guard the upgraded version of "the tomb blade" which only works on skeletons. using them on Blood Knights and Black Knights causes you to restore an entire unit within a turn without using any resources other then killing your opponent which isnt hard with a kitted Vampire Lord with blood drinker, does that sound reasonable?

It simply could have read.

"The wounds caused by Blood Drinker may restore wounds to the wielder and his unit as though Invocation of Nekhet were cast on them."

If that were the wording, then it would work as you suggest, Forge.

But the word EACH just sells it to me.

thing is that description wouldnt work, actually i wouldnt know how to use it with that description, I would assume if I did at least one wound id roll a D6 and get that many models back

you need "each" and "single" to make it work as for each wound caused you get a single wound back.

you could replace "each" with "every" and it is the exact same meaning.

I believe "each" is to get the sword to work properly where instead of restoring d6 wounds for every wound caused or only restoring 1 wound total even if you do 4 wounds. "Each" and "single" are vital in ensuring your only get 1 wound for every wound caused and not less or more.

for example

Lacking each (works out to be 1 wound total regardless of wounds caused past 1)
"unsaved wounds inflicted by the Blood Drinker, the wielder (or unit he is with) immediately regains a single wound suffered earlier in the battle, as if Invocation of Nehek had been cast on them."

Lacking single (works out to be d6 wounds regained for every wound caused)
"For each unsaved wound inflicted by the Blood Drinker, the wielder (or unit he is with) immediately regains wounds suffered earlier in the battle, as if Invocation of Nehek had been cast on them."

Original (works out to be 1 wound regained for every wound caused)
"For each unsaved wound inflicted by the Blood Drinker, the wielder (or unit he is with) immediately regains a single wound suffered earlier in the battle, as if Invocation of Nehek had been cast on them."

"every" instead of "each" (works out to be 1 wound regained for every wound caused)
"For every unsaved wound inflicted by the Blood Drinker, the wielder (or unit he is with) immediately regains a single wound suffered earlier in the battle, as if Invocation of Nehek had been cast on them."

This and the fact that "Invocation of Nehek" is singular not plural raises a major eyebrow for me. if they wanted it to work the way most people are saying it would read

".........as if multiple Invocations of Nehek had been cast on them."
 
"Now, how can you figure that all the wounds are lumped together as a single IoN? And which wounds for that matter? The ones generated in the CC phase? Ones generated in the magic phase via staff of damnation? Or just all the ones that turn? Or are all the wounds generated by blood drinker for the entire game are to be treated as one big IoN? "

Answer this/these questions using the rules and then we can discuss further. Unless I'm missing something, your interpretation is equally valid whether you treat all of the wounds for the whole game as one nehek (so using it to heal the wielder once would mean no regaining wounds for the unit no matter how many wounds it caused and vice versa), or all the wounds in a CC phase or all the wounds in one whole turn as one IoN. The lack of any of this information is a bigger problem then just trying to reword the description without the word each :). To me, without any indicator of how many wounds are to be included in the single casting of IoN, it's hard to interpret this any other way but each wound is treated as it's own IoN. I'm really surprised this doesn't hang you up, but the lack of an s on invocation of nehek does. Once again if the plural was present, it would read "regains a single wound as if multiple IoN are cast" which doesn't make much sense anyways.

BTW, not to dwell on this but: Unsaved wounds caused by the blood drinker (in this CC phase/turn/during the game) may be used to recover wounds lost by the wielder or the unit he is with as if a single IoN had been cast on the wielder or his unit. The amount of wounds regained is equal to the amount of unsaved wounds caused by blood drinker. For any additional information, please message Forge on CN.
This description was written offhand, but I think it should work fairly well with your interpretation.
 
totally with Dklyn, it didnt even cross my mind that it would work any other way that dklyn says untill i came across this thread, but the wording is clear "for each usanved wound caused by"...

it is a cool weapon even though i hardly ever use it (even though i believe it can heal ur vampire or unit of cavalry up easily)

and even though it may seem ridiculously good doesnt mean it wasnt ment to work like that, the game, rules, armies, items and everything is full of unbalanced things...some things are just that much better than something else.
and believe me there are alot of unbalanced things in this game, even though i dont understand why since its been developed for so long.

anyways i think it works like Dklyn said.
 
Dklyn said:
"Now, how can you figure that all the wounds are lumped together as a single IoN? And which wounds for that matter? The ones generated in the CC phase? Ones generated in the magic phase via staff of damnation? Or just all the ones that turn? Or are all the wounds generated by blood drinker for the entire game are to be treated as one big IoN? "

Answer this/these questions using the rules and then we can discuss further. Unless I'm missing something, your interpretation is equally valid whether you treat all of the wounds for the whole game as one nehek (so using it to heal the wielder once would mean no regaining wounds for the unit no matter how many wounds it caused and vice versa), or all the wounds in a CC phase or all the wounds in one whole turn as one IoN. The lack of any of this information is a bigger problem then just trying to reword the description without the word each :). To me, without any indicator of how many wounds are to be included in the single casting of IoN, it's hard to interpret this any other way but each wound is treated as it's own IoN. I'm really surprised this doesn't hang you up, but the lack of an s on invocation of nehek does. Once again if the plural was present, it would read "regains a single wound as if multiple IoN are cast" which doesn't make much sense anyways.

BTW, not to dwell on this but: Unsaved wounds caused by the blood drinker (in this CC phase/turn/during the game) may be used to recover wounds lost by the wielder or the unit he is with as if a single IoN had been cast on the wielder or his unit. The amount of wounds regained is equal to the amount of unsaved wounds caused by blood drinker. For any additional information, please message Forge on CN.
This description was written offhand, but I think it should work fairly well with your interpretation.

What im saying is logically my interpretation makes sense, and grammatically it does too.

"Each" is necessary for the item to restore one wound for every wound caused, any other wording would change the outcome of its use.

the lack of the plural of "Invocation" and the absence use of "multiple" or some other word pertaining the same meaning it would not imply, say, or mean that each wound counts a separate casting of IoN if thats what its meaning was it would say that.

Plus the sword becomes point relevant in my interpretation, it is still very good, but its not OP in the fact it can raise upto 500 pts + of models by putting forth no effort besides beating down your opponent in combat, which isnt to hard for a vampire lord, for 40 points its cheap either way, I believe it to be the upgraded version of the "Tomb Blade" and the extra 15 points should not carry that significant of a difference its already great because you can raise grave guard as a unheard of rate.
 
I think this thread is turning into an argument... o_o

Honestly guys, just look at the wording in the Armybook. "For each unsaved wound inflicted by the Blood Drinker, the wielder (or unit he is with) regains a single unsaved wound suffered earlier in battle." The part about IoN only matters for the order of resurrection. 1 wound inflicted -> 1 wound healed. Agree to disagree if you want, but I don't think there's any more substantial proof to either side that hasn't already been stated.
 
Bravo_10 said:
I think this thread is turning into an argument... o_o

Honestly guys, just look at the wording in the Armybook. "For each unsaved wound inflicted by the Blood Drinker, the wielder (or unit he is with) regains a single unsaved wound suffered earlier in battle." The part about IoN only matters for the order of resurrection. 1 wound inflicted -> 1 wound healed. Agree to disagree if you want, but I don't think there's any more substantial proof to either side that hasn't already been stated.

just the fact that your ignoring a HUGE section of the IoN rule on no basis is pretty ridiculous. for 40 points its good, resurrecting grave guard and ghouls is a generous offer and raising grave guard is amazing, resurrecting cavalry is INSANE, and over powered, id pay 100 points for it to do that, it is likely to raise 800 something points of models a game if not more.

RAI what do you guys think it should be? although i dont really believe in RAI the difference is the RAW is clearly there.
 
My views are clear. RAI, it's 1 wound inflicted = 1 wound resurrected. I don't think it was really intended to be slapped in a unit of Blood Knights, but alas, it's possible. I once had a Red Fury lord resurrect 7 knights in one round of combat with the Blood Drinker.

But think about Dragonlords. Would the Blood Drinker even be worth 10 points if, no matter how many wounds you inflicted, either the Zombie Dragon or the Lord only ever regained one wound?
 
Bravo_10 said:
My views are clear. RAI, it's 1 wound inflicted = 1 wound resurrected. I don't think it was really intended to be slapped in a unit of Blood Knights, but alas, it's possible. I once had a Red Fury lord resurrect 7 knights in one round of combat with the Blood Drinker.

But think about Dragonlords. Would the Blood Drinker even be worth 10 points if, no matter how many wounds you inflicted, either the Zombie Dragon or the Lord only ever regained one wound?

idk, would the dreadlance be worth 60 points to a model on foot?
 
well the good news is that Forge can use the sword as he intends and still be fully within the rules so we can all have our cake and eat it too.

if he doesnt want to use the sword to its fullest potential, he doesnt have to, he just can't get too worked up over the rest of us who agree with the other interpretation and do.
 
Gladius Rex said:
well the good news is that Forge can use the sword as he intends and still be fully within the rules so we can all have our cake and eat it too.

if he doesnt want to use the sword to its fullest potential, he doesnt have to, he just can't get too worked up over the rest of us who agree with the other interpretation and do.
from my opponents stand point:

well id be pretty angry if in one round of combat my opponent raises 700 points of blood knights that I had spent a couple turns whittling down and shutting down his magic phase only to be crushed by the blood knights he rose back and run my unit off the board.

this interpretation doesnt sound right nor fair, and seems like extreme reaching to make an already cheap and good weapon even better.
 
How do you raise 700 points in one CC phase? That's at least 10 models and with red fury, you max at 8 attacks. Even then, getting 8 kills in involves a huge amount of luck, even under the best of circumstances (hatred, WS 1 T1 no armor/ward).

Also, I'm still curious to hear you explain that if a single wound doesn't count for a single IoN, how many wounds are included to be considered a single casting of IoN and what rules support that view?
 
Dklyn said:
How do you raise 700 points in one CC phase? That's at least 10 models and with red fury, you max at 8 attacks. Even then, getting 8 kills in involves a fair bit of luck, even under the best of circumstances (WS 1 T1 no armor/ward).

i meant 500, but 10 is possible with the potion that gives devastating charge.
 
Vampire Counts army book said:
For each unsaved wound inflicted by the Blood Drinker, the wielder (or unit he is with) regains a single unsaved wound suffered earlier in battle, as if Invocation of Nehek had been cast on them.

The only question of relevance here is:

Which of these is RAW?

  • a) a separate IoN effect occurs where for each wound inflicted, a single wound is gained as if IoN had been cast on the model/unit (ie. X wounds = X castings of IoN)

    b) a combined IoN effect occurs where for each wound inflicted, a single wound is gained as if IoN had been cast once on the model/unit (ie. X wounds are gained via a single "casting" of IoN)

I do not believe that there is a clear answer... either way

However, I would lean towards option a) because we are told that one wound is regained for each wound inflicted, and that this effect occurs immediately.

The Vampire does not immediately inflict (say) 3 wounds all at once. What if the Vampire has Red Fury? These attacks can NOT even occur until AFTER the initial attacks have resolved... should the "healing effect" wait until the Red Fury attacks have occurred and then lump them all together? Why?

This really only becomes severely broken in a massive death star unit of Blood Knights. I don't think that GW designs their rules around the power level of items taken in that context, but they do so in more of a general context within the overall army.

In an era where entire units disappear from a single spell casting, without saves... magic is powerful.

In the absence of a FAQ, I see nothing that can concretely sway this argument in either direction.
 
Bishop said:
Vampire Counts army book said:
For each unsaved wound inflicted by the Blood Drinker, the wielder (or unit he is with) regains a single unsaved wound suffered earlier in battle, as if Invocation of Nehek had been cast on them.

The only question of relevance here is:

Which of these is RAW?

  • a) a separate IoN effect occurs where for each wound inflicted, a single wound is gained as if IoN had been cast on the model/unit (ie. X wounds = X castings of IoN)

    b) a combined IoN effect occurs where for each wound inflicted, a single wound is gained as if IoN had been cast once on the model/unit (ie. X wounds are gained via a single "casting" of IoN)

I do not believe that there is a clear answer... either way

However, I would lean towards option a) because we are told that one wound is regained for each wound inflicted, and that this effect occurs immediately.

The Vampire does not immediately inflict (say) 3 wounds all at once. What if the Vampire has Red Fury? These attacks can NOT even occur until AFTER the initial attacks have resolved... should the "healing effect" wait until the Red Fury attacks have occurred and then lump them all together? Why?

This really only becomes severely broken in a massive death star unit of Blood Knights. I don't think that GW designs their rules around the power level of items taken in that context, but they do so in more of a general context within the overall army.

In an era where entire units disappear from a single spell casting, without saves... magic is powerful.

In the absence of a FAQ, I see nothing that can concretely sway this argument in either direction.

I would argue in the case of Red Fury it would count as 2 castings simply because one must be resolved before the other continues.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu