Forge said:I think people are pulling exceptions out of their "arses"
no where does it say ignore said section of the IoN rule that the blood drinker directly refers to, it says just as if IoN had been cast on them no exceptions no singling out a section of the ruling now if it said
"The order of models replenished are placed as described in the Invocation of Nehek spell."
we would have a totally different argument here, in fact no argument as its specific, Because the blood drinker description is not specific and just refers to IoN as a whole I fully believe that all of the benefits and restrictions should be utilized from the IoN spell listing when using the Blood Drinker.
I've never used blood drinker actually so I have no reason to pull any exception out of anything.
It refers to the IoN rules and you're right, it doesn't say to ignore any of it, but it doesn't have to. You're obviously suppose to ignore some parts of it. For example: IoN section says the target unit regains 1d6 wounds worth of models. Obviously we ignore that part because the description for blood drinker says that it causes a single wound to be regained: it already specified how many wounds you regain so you ignore it in the IoN description without it telling you too, right. IoN also says you target any of your own units within 18". You obviously ignore that part since the description already gives you the targets: the wielder and his unit.
That's kind of the heart of this isn't it? When the description says the unit of the wielder can be targeted, does that include other characters in the unit since IoN says characters in a unit must be targeted separately? I would say yes because the BRB says the character is part of the unit and IoN doesn't say characters are not considered part of the unit ergo it can benefit. I'll admit it's a little bit of a stretch (you have to do some stretching since the wording is unclear), but much less so than saying when the description says the unit can benefit, it ONLY meant R&F troops.
Consider in another light: in 8th edition we can have units comprised entirely of characters if we wanted. If one of these characters has blood drinker, would his unit be able to benefit from those wounds? Saying no to this clearly violates the description of the item! So then why would the blood drinker be applied to a character if there are no R&F troops, but if there are R&F troops it can't, especially when the term R&F troops isn't even mentioned? (excuse the strawman)
To shift gears: Can a lord use this to heal 2 wounds/can a unit of blood knights receive more than 1 wound a turn from this? I'm saying no matter how you look at it (like blood drinker is casting the spell or not) you still are casting one spell per wound gained. If you inflict 10 wounds in CC phase (somehow), it says as clearly as warhammer gets that EACH unsaved wound allows the wielder or the unit he is with to regain a SINGLE wound as if IoN had been cast. That seems fairly clear that each unsaved wound is treated as a separate casting of IoN. As I said, nothing indicates all the wounds caused in CC phase are lumped together as if one IoN had been cast and I would like to hear why you think it is, if you do.
Seeing as a vampire unit is limited to one wound... per casting of the spell... that restriction doesn't apply not because it's ignored, but because each wound is treated as a single IoN granting a single wound. That restriction cannot come into play since you're only gaining one wound at a time.
I think that is literally all I have to say on this subject