blood drinker

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

hebejebus

Zombie
Feb 6, 2011
8
Zombies
6
can blood drinker be used to gain back wounds on other characters in the wielders unit?

was my view that seen that it can regain wounds for either the wielder or the unit as cast like IoN and IoN states that characters must be targeted separately from the unit, that the characters are not valid targets for blood drinker as it only states two targets the unit or the wielder.

the opposing argument is that the characters are part of the unit so can be targeted, but my question would be are you really still targeting the unit by targeting a character?
 
In my opinion it can. Other characters are indeed part of the unit if they are in that unit.

For instance, if you get hit with a Infernal Gateway spell and it removes the target "unit" you would lose both characters.

The important thing is that characters (im pretty sure all of them) can only ever gain 1 HP from an IoN or SuH. Thus if your blood drinker does 4 wounds (thus restores 4 hp) you cant dump 2 on your Lord and 2 on the WK BSB in the same unit.

You COULD hover toss one wound to the Lord, one wound to the WK BSB in the same unit, and restore 2 normal Graveguard.

that is my understanding and application of the weapon. If they are not in the same unit then they are out of luck, that is what SUH is for.
 
I have always applied the effects of the Blood Drinker like a Summon Undead Horde spell (which also uses the IoN rules) yet allows you to distribute points to characters and units both at the same time, just following the rules for IoN while doing so.

The IoN rules simply means:

Infantry models can gain 1 model back per wound restored up to their max.

Cavalry, Ethereal, Warbeasts, etc all gain only a single model.

Anything with the Vampire special rule gains back only 1 wound per casting.

Since Summon Undead Horde uses similar wording in its rules as the Blood Drinker does, I have applied both types of healing in a similar fasion, thus the Blood Drinker in games that I have used it, has worked as I mentioned and noone has ever called me on it, so if I am wrong, then it is news to me.
 
My understanding of the rule was that each wound counted as a separate casting, so a unit of blood knights could regain 3 wounds for example
 
summon undead horde specifically states across all units and characters (according to army builder can someone check the book wording please)
where as blood drinker does not
 
"The important thing is that characters (im pretty sure all of them) can only ever gain 1 HP from an IoN or SuH. Thus if your blood drinker does 4 wounds (thus restores 4 hp) you cant dump 2 on your Lord and 2 on the WK BSB in the same unit."

Well I may have to argue that point, the swords rules are wielder of unit he is with regains a wound for each unsaved wound caused.
This would not filter though to other characters, however I would this this a great item if you are running a unit of blood knights. :devil2:
 
I would think other characters would benefit: the rules for the sword say that members of his unit may benefit from the wounds regained from the sword and the character is part of the unit.
The stipulation in IoN saying that characters are targeted separately can be ignored since the rules for the sword already give the rules for who can be targeted: him or the unit he is with. It's the same reason you can't use blooddrinker to heal a unit up to 18" away even though IoN says you can :). The purpose of this rule is clearly to avoid saying a unit of skeletons regains three wounds, one of which goes to the vampire and 2 the skeleton.

I haven't looked too much into this (I've never used blooddrinker actually) but I understood that each unsaved wound is treated as a separate IoN casting with one wound, meaning the wielder could heal himself twice with it if two wounds were inflicted since it's like two castings of IoN. Same reason why a unit of blood knights can get more than one model back per CC.
 
The exact wording is the unit, I would rather they do but I am going by the word unfortunately.
It says the character and the unit, it depends where you draw the line at unit.
Either way if it is such the sword does not work like the spell so there is no limit to the wounds that can be regained per character.
 
Actually, you can fully replenish characters with the Blood Drinker. All it says is that "for each unsaved wound inflicted by the Blood Drinker, the wielder (or the unit he is with) regains a single unsaved wound suffered earlier in battle, as if Invocation of Nehek had been cast on them."

The only reason they even reference IoN is so that you know the order in which models are resurrected. First the Champion, then any command models, and then RnF. I like to think of each wound as a single casting of Invocation of Nehek. While this isn't technically how you are supposed to treat it, it helps to decide which models are healed or brought back to life.
 
I guess that makes the item even better than how I had been using it. I think anything that you put in that unit counts as part of the unit. Like i was saying before, anywhere else where the word unit is used you would assume the characters are a part of it. I mean the rules for characters refers to them as "Joining the Unit" thus if you JOIN something, you are apart of it

For instance, the Banner of BLood Keep grants the "Unit" a +4 ward save. So does that mean the character holding it as a BSB doesnt get the save? Nor any other character in the unit doesnt get the save?

Of course they get the save... they are apart of the unit. I think the same thought process applies to who is considered part of the unit for Blood Drinker.
 
Dklyn said:
I would think other characters would benefit: the rules for the sword say that members of his unit may benefit from the wounds regained from the sword and the character is part of the unit.
The stipulation in IoN saying that characters are targeted separately can be ignored since the rules for the sword already give the rules for who can be targeted: him or the unit he is with. It's the same reason you can't use blooddrinker to heal a unit up to 18" away even though IoN says you can :). The purpose of this rule is clearly to avoid saying a unit of skeletons regains three wounds, one of which goes to the vampire and 2 the skeleton.

I haven't looked too much into this (I've never used blooddrinker actually) but I understood that each unsaved wound is treated as a separate IoN casting with one wound, meaning the wielder could heal himself twice with it if two wounds were inflicted since it's like two castings of IoN. Same reason why a unit of blood knights can get more than one model back per CC.

This too is how I understand it
 
Gladius Rex said:
I think anything that you put in that unit counts as part of the unit. Like i was saying before, anywhere else where the word unit is used you would assume the characters are a part of it. I mean the rules for characters refers to them as "Joining the Unit" thus if you JOIN something, you are apart of it

For instance, the Banner of BLood Keep grants the "Unit" a +4 ward save. So does that mean the character holding it as a BSB doesnt get the save? Nor any other character in the unit doesnt get the save?

Of course they get the save... they are apart of the unit. I think the same thought process applies to who is considered part of the unit for Blood Drinker.

And the BRB agrees! p. 99 "Whilst a character is part of a unit, both he and the unit... are treated as a single combined unit for all rules purposes."
 
yeah i 100 percent agree its reference is for the way you resurrect wounds
and if you cast IoN on a unit does it resurrect wounds for characters?

cause blood drinker only gives 2 targets the unit or the wielder as if IoN was cast
 
hebejebus said:
yeah i 100 percent agree its reference is for the way you resurrect wounds
and if you cast IoN on a unit does it resurrect wounds for characters?

cause blood drinker only gives 2 targets the unit or the wielder as if IoN was cast

And the character is part of the unit, ergo, he is one of the 2 targets
 
The key to IoN on your unit that contains a characters is to make sure that IoN only restores one wound to characters per casting. This also goes for non infantry units and ethereal units.

So if you cast IoN on a unit of Graveguard with two characters in it and roll a 6 for wounds restored. Each character can only take 1 wound (if they are missing a wound) and the graveguard can be restored the rest or up to its starting number. Any excess is wasted.

If you get the same result on Black Knights with 2 characters in the unit. Each character may take 1 (if they are missing a wound) and the the Black KNights would gain 1 model. The other 3 wounds are wasted.

The Blood Drinker considers each wound it restores as a seperate casting of IoN, so if the sword deals 3 wounds, those wounds can go to any or all characters in the unit and even restore the unit on a 1 for 1 basis. Which is phenomenal when you consider how many attacks you can generate with Red Fury on a Lord.
 
Darius the Insane said:
hebejebus said:
yeah i 100 percent agree its reference is for the way you resurrect wounds
and if you cast IoN on a unit does it resurrect wounds for characters?

cause blood drinker only gives 2 targets the unit or the wielder as if IoN was cast

And the character is part of the unit, ergo, he is one of the 2 targets

eh im sorry but are you saying "targeting a character in a unit" is equal to "targeting a unit"???? by that logic if i can target a unit with a spell i can single out a character in it

at least your supplying an argument to support that characters are a valid target cause some the others in this convo seem to miss the point

the rule book seems to always iterate when you can target a character, especially in resurrect spells, be it tomb kings, vc or lore of life so seen it is omitted here would leave me to believe it cant
 
hebejebus said:
eh im sorry but are you saying "targeting a character in a unit" is equal to "targeting a unit"???? by that logic if i can target a unit with a spell i can single out a character in it

at least your supplying an argument to support that characters are a valid target cause some the others in this convo seem to miss the point

the rule book seems to always iterate when you can target a character, especially in resurrect spells, be it tomb kings, vc or lore of life so seen it is omitted here would leave me to believe it cant

I can see the confusion, but if you think about it, excluding other characters from the effect could be against the rules to the same degree (ie if you think of it as a spell effect, you would be saying that the character is immune to a spell affecting the unit even though he is a part of it, which is generally not right). It's a strange one, because usually you can get a sense of what the designers intended, even if the rules are badly written; but in this case I have no idea. I would say it does affect other characters in the unit, simply because that seems closest to RAW; in order to exclude characters you would have to add new text to the rules which doesn't currently exist.
Probably a good candidate for an FAQ.
 
nice reply ,and the remark about difference between targeting the unit and the character was merely to show the false logic being used, but i feel exclusion would come from the IoN rules stating that characters cannot gain wounds when you target the unit. and it states that the only two targets available are the unit, and the wielder. So as it is written at the moment, to use it to resurrect wounds on other characters would be saying that targeting an ability/spell at a character in a unit is equal to targeting the unit. It just cant be logically inferred by how it is currently written. Definitely needs FAQ attention
 
Gladius Rex said:
The key to IoN on your unit that contains a characters is to make sure that IoN only restores one wound to characters per casting. This also goes for non infantry units and ethereal units.

So if you cast IoN on a unit of Graveguard with two characters in it and roll a 6 for wounds restored. Each character can only take 1 wound (if they are missing a wound) and the graveguard can be restored the rest or up to its starting number. Any excess is wasted.

If you get the same result on Black Knights with 2 characters in the unit. Each character may take 1 (if they are missing a wound) and the the Black KNights would gain 1 model. The other 3 wounds are wasted.

The Blood Drinker considers each wound it restores as a seperate casting of IoN, so if the sword deals 3 wounds, those wounds can go to any or all characters in the unit and even restore the unit on a 1 for 1 basis. Which is phenomenal when you consider how many attacks you can generate with Red Fury on a Lord.

No.

If you target the unit and cast IoN only the unit may have wounds restored to it, not the characters, you have to target the characters separately.

I fully believe that you may not restore more then 1 wound on a vampire, ethereal, or cavalry model. theres nothing in the wording or rule that says you can ignore that part of the IoN rule that the blood drinker uses to restore wounds.

and even if it was the way I believe it is you may still give a wight king on foot multiple wounds as it does not fall under the 1 wound restriction in the IoN rules.

my game store lets me use it the way everyone else says it works tho although they see how freaking ridiculously over powered it is and are starting to think the way I do about it now after I raised 7 dead blood knights in one round of combat then the blood knights raped the rest of his unit.
 
Dklyn said:
Forge said:
I fully believe that you may not restore more then 1 wound on a vampire, ethereal, or cavalry model. theres nothing in the wording or rule that says you can ignore that part of the IoN rule that the blood drinker uses to restore wounds.

and even if it was the way I believe it is you may still give a wight king on foot multiple wounds as it does not fall under the 1 wound restriction in the IoN rules.

my game store lets me use it the way everyone else says it works tho although they see how freaking ridiculously over powered it is and are starting to think the way I do about it now after I raised 7 dead blood knights in one round of combat then the blood knights raped the rest of his unit.

I'm very confused by your interpretation. IoN says that UNITS with vampire, ethereal, and non-infantry units will only regain a single wound. Nothing about models are mentioned. So if you don't think a lord can cure two wounds, then why can a unit of bloodknights receive more than one wound?

I think he's saying that he uses the interpretation which is most beneficial to him, even though he doesn't think it's right.
 
UmbraMortuum said:
Dklyn said:
Forge said:
I fully believe that you may not restore more then 1 wound on a vampire, ethereal, or cavalry model. theres nothing in the wording or rule that says you can ignore that part of the IoN rule that the blood drinker uses to restore wounds.

and even if it was the way I believe it is you may still give a wight king on foot multiple wounds as it does not fall under the 1 wound restriction in the IoN rules.

my game store lets me use it the way everyone else says it works tho although they see how freaking ridiculously over powered it is and are starting to think the way I do about it now after I raised 7 dead blood knights in one round of combat then the blood knights raped the rest of his unit.

I'm very confused by your interpretation. IoN says that UNITS with vampire, ethereal, and non-infantry units will only regain a single wound. Nothing about models are mentioned. So if you don't think a lord can cure two wounds, then why can a unit of bloodknights receive more than one wound?

I think he's saying that he uses the interpretation which is most beneficial to him, even though he doesn't think it's right.

I actually argued my point of view to some people at my store, they didnt agree with me, so i was like alright sweet ill play it the way you guys say it works no skin off my back. ended upwinning ard boys with it o_o
 
Really what the issue there is does each unsaved wound count as a separate casting of IoN or do all the wounds put together in a CC phase count as a single casting of IoN?

"For each unsaved wound inflicted by the Blood Drinker, the wielder... immediately regains a single wound ... as if IoN had been cast"
I would agree with the people at your store that the rules support each unsaved wound as a separate casting of IoN based on the emphasis on single and each. There's nothing to indicate that all the wounds given in CC is meant to be treated as a single casting of IoN. Whether or not that's fair is a different issue :).
hebejebus said:
nice reply ,and the remark about difference between targeting the unit and the character was merely to show the false logic being used, but i feel exclusion would come from the IoN rules stating that characters cannot gain wounds when you target the unit. and it states that the only two targets available are the unit, and the wielder. So as it is written at the moment, to use it to resurrect wounds on other characters would be saying that targeting an ability/spell at a character in a unit is equal to targeting the unit. It just cant be logically inferred by how it is currently written. Definitely needs FAQ attention

I think the way you are looking at it (to break it down): Blood drinker casts IoN that can only target the wielder or the unit and grants 1 wound per unsaved wound. Another way to look it at as blood drinker causes himself or his unit to regain a wound following the rules IoN sets up for adding models (stop at starting size, adding command models first).
Given that the FAQ seems to indicate the this (along with Tomb blade) doesn't gain other benefits of casting IoN (master powers or unholy lodestone), I lean towards the latter interpretation. But I suppose it's not 100% clear.
 
I think people are pulling exceptions out of their "arses"

no where does it say ignore said section of the IoN rule that the blood drinker directly refers to, it says just as if IoN had been cast on them no exceptions no singling out a section of the ruling now if it said

"The order of models replenished are placed as described in the Invocation of Nehek spell."

we would have a totally different argument here, in fact no argument as its specific, Because the blood drinker description is not specific and just refers to IoN as a whole I fully believe that all of the benefits and restrictions should be utilized from the IoN spell listing when using the Blood Drinker.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu