blood drinker

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I dont find the blood drinker to be any more/less broken than the IF HE Book, or the HE banner that makes complete magic immunity (Eat that magic vortex).

I dont feel near as dirty using a Blood Drinker with Red Fury as I do a Dreadlance with Red Fury.

It is a handy weapon, thats for sure, and at 40 points, its really priced for a Lord and even then, its still almost half your magic point allowance.
 
Gladius Rex said:
I dont find the blood drinker to be any more/less broken than the IF HE Book, or the HE banner that makes complete magic immunity (Eat that magic vortex).

I dont feel near as dirty using a Blood Drinker with Red Fury as I do a Dreadlance with Red Fury.

It is a handy weapon, thats for sure, and at 40 points, its really priced for a Lord and even then, its still almost half your magic point allowance.

dread lance is well pointed in my opinion, you only get to use it in the first round of combat anyways....
 
All I am saying is that I dont find Blood Drinker to be underpriced. At the same value you can get blades that give 2 extra attacks or 2 strength bonus.

SO if it is at that point cost, I am perfectly ok with it working as a single casting of IoN per wound. That doesnt seem broken to me at all.
 
Gladius Rex said:
All I am saying is that I dont find Blood Drinker to be underpriced. At the same value you can get blades that give 2 extra attacks or 2 strength bonus.

SO if it is at that point cost, I am perfectly ok with it working as a single casting of IoN per wound. That doesnt seem broken to me at all.

so, there is basically nothing anyone can do to kill a large unit of blood knights with a vamp lord with blood drinker in it. you kill 7 blood knights from shooting in magic they charge in and they are back to full strength with 0 effort, raising 500 points in one turn is absolutely ludicrous, without spending any resources for that matter..... youd be lucky if you raised 150 points in one magic phase, thats if your unchallenged by dispel dice.
 
To be fair, you're acting like raising getting 9 wounds (500+ points) is easy (0 effort?), which it isn't at all. It's impossible to do so more than one turn first off. Even 8 wounds in one round is really tough in the most ideal situations.

Against the weakest of foes with no parry or ward save, your vampire with infinite hatred has a slightly less than 75% chance to deal a wound with every attack. To get ten wounds in one round is really low (below 5% chance). 8 wounds and you're looking at slightly better odds, but still under 9%. And that's assuming 5+ or less armor (since you're str 5) and/or without parry saves, which are moderately large assumptions to make.
With just a 6+ save, or one extra toughness, (I encounter one of these two more often than not), the odds of striking 8 wounds in one round goes down to roughly 2%. To give you some perspective, that's roughly the same odds of successfully getting 10 IoN off in a row using one die at a time.

So I wouldn't say that blood drinker with bloodknights is necessarily unkillable. Like I've said, I've always read the rules the same way as everyone else and still I've never found it worthwhile to include blood knights with blood drinker.
 
Dklyn said:
To be fair, you're acting like raising getting 9 wounds (500+ points) is easy (0 effort?), which it isn't at all. It's impossible to do so more than one turn first off. Even 8 wounds in one round is really tough in the most ideal situations.

Against the weakest of foes with no parry or ward save, your vampire with infinite hatred has a slightly less than 75% chance to deal a wound with every attack. To get ten wounds in one round is really low (below 5% chance). 8 wounds and you're looking at slightly better odds, but still under 9%. And that's assuming 5+ or less armor (since you're str 5) and/or without parry saves, which are moderately large assumptions to make.
With just a 6+ save, or one extra toughness, (I encounter one of these two more often than not), the odds of striking 8 wounds in one round goes down to roughly 2%. To give you some perspective, that's roughly the same odds of successfully getting 10 IoN off in a row using one die at a time.

So I wouldn't say that blood drinker with bloodknights is necessarily unkillable. Like I've said, I've always read the rules the same way as everyone else and still I've never found it worthwhile to include blood knights with blood drinker.

ive ran it quite a few times, infact in a tournament a goblin player unleashed some fanatics at me beat me up pretty bad, then I charged through them to beat on the goblins, lost about 6 blood knights, raised them all back no problem.

what im saying is for 40 points raising back one blood knight a turn, or even just once a game it has earned its points back, raising 5 grave guard or ghouls or something in one turn it will earn its points back, raising 400+ points of cavalry a turn is absolutely ridiculous in my book.
 
Yay another Blood Drinker thread! Last time this came up, it took six pages of exactly this, Forge vs. the Whole forum :) It got submitted to Direwolf (who write FAQ's for GW, incase anyone didn't know), and here is the quote DoN gave us:

Once again, I will be happy to answer the query but also once again I must point out that only Games Workshop can provide "official" answers.

IMO Blood Drinker does exactly what it says on the tin.

For each unsaved wound inflicted by the Vampire wielding Blood Drinker, the Vampire wielding it (or the unit he is with) immediately regains a single Wound suffered earlier in the battle, as if Invocation of Nehek had been cast on them.

Note that per RAW each wound caused = a wound healed with no restrictions on unit / model type. The Invocation wording appears to be there simply in order to provide the player with guidance on how models in the unit are to be restored.

In 7th edition this was not that big of an issue as the Vampire was pretty much limited to S5 when fielding Blood Drinker - thus he would routinely fail to raise much back.

It rarely featured in Vampire armies as the Helm / Skull Staff caster was far more effective and much less risky, and even for those Stubborn souls intent on fighting with their VC Lord in 7th they usually combined Red Fury with a Lance or the Sword of Might over the Blood Drinker. In essence Blood Drinker in 7th editon was a "fluffy" item or something you took if you knew you were fighting an army full of T3 models.

That however was the past.

8th edition has given the Vampire Lord the ability via the Lore of the Beasts and / or the Potion of Strength  to be Strength 8+ at times (or wounding the enemy as if S10 with the Lore of Shadows) when wielding Blood Drinker.....combined with Red Fury it is obviously extremely powerful.......and when coupled with Blood Knights appears to be a bit insane.

Regardless of the insanity though, that is what RAW appears to be telling us at the moment.

I would recommend that folks should continue to keep some diversionary units in their armies for nasty deathstars such as this. Especially in the case of a Blood Knight Deathstar at least you know the opponent is going to have to overrun after it smashes though your unit of warhounds, great eagle, skirmishers, etc.

Lastly, once again this is my personal opinion based on the rules as they exist today. Only Games Workshop can provide "official" answers and different tournament organizers may rule on this differently than I.

There we go.

For the record, Forge I agree that its OP too and I definitely wouldn't use it because I don't play with Cheese if I can avoid it, but I do think that unfortunately theres no between-the-lines Invocation castings about it, nothing to do with seperate castings or even casting at all, its just regaining wounds. A good analogy would be going "look over there!" and putting models back on, just without the understandable accusations of cheating.
 
Humaneater said:
Yay another Blood Drinker thread! Last time this came up, it took six pages of exactly this, Forge vs. the Whole forum :) It got submitted to Direwolf (who write FAQ's for GW, incase anyone didn't know), and here is the quote DoN gave us:

Once again, I will be happy to answer the query but also once again I must point out that only Games Workshop can provide "official" answers.

IMO Blood Drinker does exactly what it says on the tin.

For each unsaved wound inflicted by the Vampire wielding Blood Drinker, the Vampire wielding it (or the unit he is with) immediately regains a single Wound suffered earlier in the battle, as if Invocation of Nehek had been cast on them.

Note that per RAW each wound caused = a wound healed with no restrictions on unit / model type. The Invocation wording appears to be there simply in order to provide the player with guidance on how models in the unit are to be restored.

In 7th edition this was not that big of an issue as the Vampire was pretty much limited to S5 when fielding Blood Drinker - thus he would routinely fail to raise much back.

It rarely featured in Vampire armies as the Helm / Skull Staff caster was far more effective and much less risky, and even for those Stubborn souls intent on fighting with their VC Lord in 7th they usually combined Red Fury with a Lance or the Sword of Might over the Blood Drinker. In essence Blood Drinker in 7th editon was a "fluffy" item or something you took if you knew you were fighting an army full of T3 models.

That however was the past.

8th edition has given the Vampire Lord the ability via the Lore of the Beasts and / or the Potion of Strength  to be Strength 8+ at times (or wounding the enemy as if S10 with the Lore of Shadows) when wielding Blood Drinker.....combined with Red Fury it is obviously extremely powerful.......and when coupled with Blood Knights appears to be a bit insane.

Regardless of the insanity though, that is what RAW appears to be telling us at the moment.

I would recommend that folks should continue to keep some diversionary units in their armies for nasty deathstars such as this. Especially in the case of a Blood Knight Deathstar at least you know the opponent is going to have to overrun after it smashes though your unit of warhounds, great eagle, skirmishers, etc.

Lastly, once again this is my personal opinion based on the rules as they exist today. Only Games Workshop can provide "official" answers and different tournament organizers may rule on this differently than I.

There we go.

For the record, Forge I agree that its OP too and I definitely wouldn't use it because I don't play with Cheese if I can avoid it, but I do think that unfortunately theres no between-the-lines Invocation castings about it, nothing to do with seperate castings or even casting at all, its just regaining wounds. A good analogy would be going "look over there!" and putting models back on, just without the understandable accusations of cheating.

I still question the forums "direwolf" FAQ, since NONE of these questions ever get uploaded to the official one which would be easy as copy and paste, in fact all the updates to the VC FAQ were never mentioned or asked on the forum FAQ to my knowledge.
 
not to deviate from your discussion on the Blood Drinker but as a side step something I noticed:

Gladius Rex said:
...
The important thing is that characters (im pretty sure all of them) can only ever gain 1 HP from an IoN or SuH.
...

This is a very common mistake...

Models with the vampire rule can only regain one wound per IoN or SoH casting. However, not all characters have the Vampire rule!
We all know that whenever a necromancer has sustained 2 wounds, he died, but this is not the case with our Wight King as he has 3 wounds. According to me, we can heal 2 wounds on a wight king with a single casting of IoN or SuH, as he fulfills all the criteria to do so (and is possible to occur).
 
The wounds aren't resolved at once but seperately, if they were, there would be a single save.

Every time you cause a wound, you get a wound as if IoN has been cast. It isn't an IoN being cast on the unit but it gets a wound for each wound casued as if an IoN had been cast. There is no need determine the amount of times it has been cast because it was never cast, it isn't a spell. The way models are healed is described in the magic item's description.

It may be awesome with a Blood Knight but that doesn't change anything. Blood Knights are a strange unit, devastating if they reach their target but woefully vulnerable to magic and shooting(considering their steep cost). There have always been these kind of items around and when there is such a massive shift in the rules like the 8th edition some units and items will gain power or become completely useless.
 
Danceman said:
It may be awesome with a Blood Knight but that doesn't change anything. Blood Knights are a strange unit, devastating if they reach their target but woefully vulnerable to magic and shooting(considering their steep cost). There have always been these kind of items around and when there is such a massive shift in the rules like the 8th edition some units and items will gain power or become completely useless.

My poor Banner of the Dead Legion... :grave:
 
Maybe I will have an answer from Games Workshop soon.
But, from the answer I got from the ETC referee is that I only restore one wound... :( Possibly, whoever participates in this tournament will not have the chance to raise a whole unit of Blood Knights.
 
skario said:
Maybe I will have an answer from Games Workshop soon.
But, from the answer I got from the ETC referee is that I only restore one wound... :( Possibly, whoever participates in this tournament will not have the chance to raise a whole unit of Blood Knights.

it was ruled this way at Ard boys as well.
 
Local Ard Boyz here ruled the other way, it raised its wounds worth. Funny how there is no consistency amongst these sort of things aint it lol.
 
Gladius Rex said:
Local Ard Boyz here ruled the other way, it raised its wounds worth. Funny how there is no consistency amongst these sort of things aint it lol.

semi finals in LA ruled against multiple blood knights being risen.
 
Forge said:
Gladius Rex said:
Local Ard Boyz here ruled the other way, it raised its wounds worth. Funny how there is no consistency amongst these sort of things aint it lol.

semi finals in LA ruled against multiple blood knights being risen.

because its LA am i suppose to be more impressed or take it as gospel? OMG its a large city... i guess Chicago just doesnt compare....

we poor midwest players.

What i was merely pointing out is that because one tournament makes a ruling doesnt really mean squat. It isnt until GW FAQs it or rewrites our Armies books that there will really be any concensus on the matter.
 
Gladius Rex said:
Forge said:
Gladius Rex said:
Local Ard Boyz here ruled the other way, it raised its wounds worth. Funny how there is no consistency amongst these sort of things aint it lol.

semi finals in LA ruled against multiple blood knights being risen.

because its LA am i suppose to be more impressed or take it as gospel? OMG its a large city... i guess Chicago just doesnt compare....

we poor midwest players.

What i was merely pointing out is that because one tournament makes a ruling doesnt really mean squat. It isnt until GW FAQs it or rewrites our Armies books that there will really be any concensus on the matter.

have you ever played in an 'Ard Boys tournament?

the first stage is locally hosted really not regulated by GW at all, they just provide the missions, and the prizes.

The Semi Finals are located in usually 2 places in each state appointed by GW and are GW enforced.

The Finals are in a pre determined place, I think it was the Battle Bunker this year and is GW enforced.
 
To be fair, 'ard boyz isn't an FAQ and so I wouldn't think it canon. Still worth a mention I suppose.

Out of curiosity though, do you know which wounds were considered a single IoN? Was it all the wounds caused in the CC phase or for the entire turn or what?
 
Forge said:
Gladius Rex said:
Forge said:
Gladius Rex said:
Local Ard Boyz here ruled the other way, it raised its wounds worth. Funny how there is no consistency amongst these sort of things aint it lol.

semi finals in LA ruled against multiple blood knights being risen.

because its LA am i suppose to be more impressed or take it as gospel? OMG its a large city... i guess Chicago just doesnt compare....

we poor midwest players.

What i was merely pointing out is that because one tournament makes a ruling doesnt really mean squat. It isnt until GW FAQs it or rewrites our Armies books that there will really be any concensus on the matter.

have you ever played in an 'Ard Boys tournament?

the first stage is locally hosted really not regulated by GW at all, they just provide the missions, and the prizes.

The Semi Finals are located in usually 2 places in each state appointed by GW and are GW enforced.

The Finals are in a pre determined place, I think it was the Battle Bunker this year and is GW enforced.

yes, i have played in the local Ard Boyz. I have won my local tournament twice and went to one of the state ones once. I could have gone further but my real life as a husband with a wife, child, and full time job who is an advisor for my Fraternity and avid gamer sort of made me not want to actually travel to see how far i could go.

frankly, i enjoy going to ard boyz just to laugh at how cheesy people can make their list, then i do my best with my non cheese list, and then i let someone else go further. All the Ard Boyz ive played in this area allow each wound to raise a single model, GG, Blood Knight, or even all on the Lord.

All i was pointing out is that Ard Boyz is a tournament notorious for its cheese and thus i wouldnt consider any ruling at Ard Boyz to be anything more than to simply say "yep, thats the cheesiest we can make that, so sure" I am actually suprised an Ard Boyz ruled otherwise.

I guess as long as i dont travel out west my blood drinker will work as i think it does and i guess that is good enough for me.
 
Gladius Rex said:
Forge said:
Gladius Rex said:
Forge said:
Gladius Rex said:
Local Ard Boyz here ruled the other way, it raised its wounds worth. Funny how there is no consistency amongst these sort of things aint it lol.

semi finals in LA ruled against multiple blood knights being risen.

because its LA am i suppose to be more impressed or take it as gospel? OMG its a large city... i guess Chicago just doesnt compare....

we poor midwest players.

What i was merely pointing out is that because one tournament makes a ruling doesnt really mean squat. It isnt until GW FAQs it or rewrites our Armies books that there will really be any concensus on the matter.

have you ever played in an 'Ard Boys tournament?

the first stage is locally hosted really not regulated by GW at all, they just provide the missions, and the prizes.

The Semi Finals are located in usually 2 places in each state appointed by GW and are GW enforced.

The Finals are in a pre determined place, I think it was the Battle Bunker this year and is GW enforced.

yes, i have played in the local Ard Boyz. I have won my local tournament twice and went to one of the state ones once. I could have gone further but my real life as a husband with a wife, child, and full time job who is an advisor for my Fraternity and avid gamer sort of made me not want to actually travel to see how far i could go.

frankly, i enjoy going to ard boyz just to laugh at how cheesy people can make their list, then i do my best with my non cheese list, and then i let someone else go further. All the Ard Boyz ive played in this area allow each wound to raise a single model, GG, Blood Knight, or even all on the Lord.

All i was pointing out is that Ard Boyz is a tournament notorious for its cheese and thus i wouldnt consider any ruling at Ard Boyz to be anything more than to simply say "yep, thats the cheesiest we can make that, so sure" I am actually suprised an Ard Boyz ruled otherwise.

I guess as long as i dont travel out west my blood drinker will work as i think it does and i guess that is good enough for me.

I dont see how the interpretation of the rule im advocating is the "cheesy" version.....
 
Gladius Rex said:
maybe you didnt read my post very closely...

I said i was suprised to hear an Ard Boyz tourney ruled OTHERWISE.

Ive never heard a cheesy rule interpretation at an ard boys semi final, and ive been to a few, ive seen lots of cheesy combination's, but never a cheesy ruling.
 
On Topic:

Having read this entire thread front to back I wanted to say it seems pretty clear to me that if you do 5 wounds with the blood drinker you can heal 5 wounds to either the character or the unit (which might include other characters). So you could heal 2 on the vamp, two on the BSB in the unit and 1 on the BK's ... or you could do 1 on the vamp, 1 on the BSB and raise back 3 BK's. I think the argument for this interpretation is the stronger, it is certainly how my and the group I play use it ...

Off Topic:

Having read this entire thread front to back I wanted to say, Forge, someone should show you where to find either the "New Reply" button or the "Quick Reply" box :) . When you are responding the the post immediately above I don't think you need to quote the entire 500 word post ... we all get it... you are talking about the post above. Quoting it every time, in every post is just silly and makes the thread much harder to scan ...

Krys
 
On Topic:

Having read this entire thread front to back I wanted to say it seems pretty clear to me that if you do 5 wounds with the blood drinker you can heal 5 wounds to either the character or the unit (which might include other characters). So you could heal 2 on the vamp, two on the BSB in the unit and 1 on the BK's ... or you could do 1 on the vamp, 1 on the BSB and raise back 3 BK's. I think the argument for this interpretation is the stronger, it is certainly how my and the group I play use it ...

Off Topic:

Having read this entire thread front to back I wanted to say, Forge, someone should show you where to find either the "New Reply" button or the "Quick Reply" box :) . When you are responding the the post immediately above I don't think you need to quote the entire 500 word post ... we all get it... you are talking about the post above. Quoting it every time, in every post is just silly and makes the thread much harder to scan ...

Krys
 
Lets see...
On pg 58 of the VC army book it clearly states that ''Vald carries the Blood Drinker (each Wound restores one wound on Vlad or his unit).''
Now we all know that Vlad is a Vampire and according to some ppl he can only get back 1 wound/combat as IoN. The same thing is claimed about Blood Knigts.
Well I think that the book clearly states the opposite....
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu