Deathless Dreamer said:
Why, in your opinion, would having decent infantry make Bretonnians "not Bretonnian"? Literally EVERY other army has decent infantry units.
I think you just answered your own question.
If every army but Bretonnia has an elite/heavy infantry option, then one of Bretonnia's defining characteristics is not having such.
Every army but Dwarves has Cavalry & Magic. Every army but Vampires has missile troops. Every army but Dwarves, Greenskins and Skaven has access to at least some of the BRB Lores.
I could go on, but the key is, as I said before, an army is defined as much by what it cannot do as by what it can.
There certainly is room for expanding Bretonnia's range of models and units, but I feel it can be done without making Bretonnia just like every other army.
For example, the BRB fluff section mentions, well:
BRB said:
Stranger still there are legends of fey spirits appearing from forests, lakes and natural places to aid the Bretonnians -otherworldy guardians, ghostly bowmen from ages past, the souls of long-lost knights, and even the translucent spirits of the land itself.
I'd be thrilled to see ethereal bowmen or a unit of ghost-knights in the army book.
Stop me if I'm wrong, but right now, Bretonnia and
VC are the only armies with ethereal units (not counting temporary spell effects and such)?
Adding more such things to the Bretonnian book would make the army more unique, not less.
Bretonnian ghostly bowmen and lost knights would be very different to
VC Spirit Hosts and Hexwraiths.
Spirits of the Land could also be very cool, providing they're different to the Forest Spirits used by the Woodies.
And I think they would be. Athel Loren is a hostile, brooding place governed by the hunt god who says 'kill or be killed, hunt or be hunted' and the Forest Spirits are as likely to attack Wood Elves as help them.
Bretonnia is a gentle, kind land ruled by loving goddess. I have to believe the spirits of the land would be less like Driads, killin' the bad guys and more like, say, Warrior Priests, buffing the good guys.
Hell, even if these hypothetical units weren't that different to
VC or Woodie units, at least they aren't things shared with all other books.