Bretonnia next?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Narenzade

Wight King
Mar 22, 2012
465
Zombies
370
Some ramblings around the internet are Bretonnians are taking the Dark Elf release slot.

I can't really confirm or deny anything, but spread more internet rumors. Word is that some Bretonnian character models got removed from the GW website and stores are having a hard time getting certain items, etc.

http://warhammer.org.uk/phpBB/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=116742

http://www.games-workshop.com/gws/catalog/armySubUnitCats.jsp?catId=cat440036a&rootCatGameStyle=wh

What's everyone think?
 
Well, I still noticed that all of the special characters and some of the others are on there. I didn't notice any change. I wish brets would get redone simply because I want to see what there new book would hold!
 
bretts taking DE spot would be...
....
...SWEET!!! More time with my lovely items abd low costed troops :D

seriously, same is rumored on DE and dwarfs, and theirs was removed/ hard to get a month ago or more, so this have me think the gallant knights come early next year.

if im wrong, yay. trying to get white barding look good atm.....crusaser look suck :( or my skills do, atleast
 
Maybe early next year? I do not play Brets myself but a friend does and I sincerely hope for him they will see a release soon. I love playing against this characterful army.:)
 
Here's hoping Brets soon - I held onto this army only because i spent so many freaking hours painting knights. God dang, they're a rough hobby army.

-luke
 
Narenzade! We all love you, In fact, if it was possible for me to have your baby then I would consider it, for a price ;) But you see, I have the wrong anatomy for it so I can't help out to much there.
 
I know, I only posted that to get a response. I am glad you entertained my ploy.

If you send me your name, address and credit card number then I'll send you an autographed photo.
 
If and when they do update the Bretonnians... PLEASE give them Dismounted Knights so that I can field a more English-themed army! They are seriously in dire need of some strong infantry that can actually fight. Also give them stronger magic!

But more importantly than all that, make the cavalry better on the charge because striking in initiative order really screws knights over.
 
My main army is Bretonnia and I really would not like to see dismounted Knights.

An army is defined as much by what it doesn't have as what it does, and Bretonnia doesn't have heavy infantry. Or skilled Infantry. Nor should it.
 
Minty said:
My main army is Bretonnia and I really would not like to see dismounted Knights.

An army is defined as much by what it doesn't have as what it does, and Bretonnia doesn't have heavy infantry. Or skilled Infantry. Nor should it.

Well boo to you too.

Also, why not? It was very common in medieval armies (which the Bretonnians essentially are, with some fantasy elements) for knights to fight on foot, and if you think about it, it would be common in Bretonnia too. Not all Knights are wealthy, and if their horse was killed in battle, or if they couldn't afford a horse, or if they simply preferred to fight on foot, they would fight dismounted.

Alternatively they could be a special order of knights who are more selfless and less arrogant than other knights. The possibilities are endless.

If they made them a special choice rather than core, heavy armour, hand weapon and shield standard, blessing of the lady, ability to take polearms or great weapons, ability to take magic banners, gave them an appropriate points cost (like 16 - 17 points each) I could see them being a balanced unit.
 
Minty said:
My main army is Bretonnia and I really would not like to see dismounted Knights.

An army is defined as much by what it doesn't have as what it does, and Bretonnia doesn't have heavy infantry. Or skilled Infantry. Nor should it.

Actually, in at least one Black Library book I've read, some knights will fight on foot to lead the peasants, who may otherwise flee or break due to their cowardly natures ... Especially in the face of such unnatural creatures that the armies of Bretonnia fight ...
 
@Deathless Dreamer: I agree with all of your points.

I still don't want Foot Knights in the Bretonnian Army book.

One could make points like those in favour of, say, Vampire Counts having Skeleton Archers... High Elves having Handgunners, Empire having Pegasus Knights.

By the same token one might ask why only Orcs may ride Wyverns, why Dwarves have never seen the military applications of the Rhinoxen and Sabretusks which live above them or why Plate Armour is unique to the Empire*?

It's because these things are part of the flavour of each army. There are fluff reasons, of course, and good thing too, but the real reason is that we want 16 different armies, not 12 different models all armed and equipped the same way.



*Let the record show, I'd actually be in favour of Plate Armour being expanded to Bretonnia and VC...


Malochai said:
Actually, in at least one Black Library book I've read, some knights will fight on foot to lead the peasants, who may otherwise flee or break due to their cowardly natures ... Especially in the face of such unnatural creatures that the armies of Bretonnia fight ...

And that's an option in the current Army Book. Pay five Skaven Slaves and any Knightly character can go on foot (compared to the 7 or more Slaves for the otherwise required mount) and gains improved 'inspire the rabble' potential.

An individual Knight may go on foot in the current Army Book, but whole units of foot knights are another matter.
 
Minty said:
@Deathless Dreamer: I agree with all of your points.

I still don't want Foot Knights in the Bretonnian Army book.

One could make points like those in favour of, say, Vampire Counts having Skeleton Archers... High Elves having Handgunners, Empire having Pegasus Knights.

By the same token one might ask why only Orcs may ride Wyverns, why Dwarves have never seen the military applications of the Rhinoxen and Sabretusks which live above them or why Plate Armour is unique to the Empire*?

It's because these things are part of the flavour of each army. There are fluff reasons, of course, and good thing too, but the real reason is that we want 16 different armies, not 12 different models all armed and equipped the same way.



*Let the record show, I'd actually be in favour of Plate Armour being expanded to Bretonnia and VC...


Malochai said:
Actually, in at least one Black Library book I've read, some knights will fight on foot to lead the peasants, who may otherwise flee or break due to their cowardly natures ... Especially in the face of such unnatural creatures that the armies of Bretonnia fight ...

And that's an option in the current Army Book. Pay five Skaven Slaves and any Knightly character can go on foot (compared to the 7 or more Slaves for the otherwise required mount) and gains improved 'inspire the rabble' potential.

An individual Knight may go on foot in the current Army Book, but whole units of foot knights are another matter.

But why would a knight NOT fight on foot?

Also in reality all armies could be said to be just "different models armed the same way". Why can Bretonnians not have a solid infantry unit to support the lousy men at arms?

I mean in the previous army book Men at arms had better stats, making them an actually decent unit that was comparable to Empire state troops.

Taking one knight on foot in the entire army is not what I am talking about. Why, in your opinion, would having decent infantry make Bretonnians "not Bretonnian"? Literally EVERY other army has decent infantry units.

And that "Every army is different" argument is not quite true. All armies, bar Bretonnians, have well-rounded army lists with a number of options with which they can deal with any threat effectively. As an example, here are the "elite infantry" units of other armies (in my opinion):

Vampire Counts - Grave Guard
Empire - Greatswords
Chaos - Chaos Warriors / Chosen
Lizardmen - Saurus Warriors
Tomb Kings - Tomb Guard
Skaven - Stormvermin
High Elves - Swordmasters of Hoeth, Phoenix Guard, Lions of Chrace
Dark Elves - Witch Elves
Ogres - Ironguts
Wood Elves - Wardancers (Okay they aren't that good but still)
Dwarfs - Ironbreakers
Beastmen - Bestigors? (Don't know much about Beastmen)

And poor Bretonnians have... oh wait they don't even have any decent infantry units because KNIGHTS.

I mean they don't even have any units that can hold their ground in combat, and don't say Questing Knights, because everyone knows they just die in the first round of combat because they strike last.

They just aren't a well-rounded army AT ALL, while every other army has tons of options and you can field them in many different ways.
 
Deathless Dreamer said:
Why, in your opinion, would having decent infantry make Bretonnians "not Bretonnian"? Literally EVERY other army has decent infantry units.

I think you just answered your own question.

If every army but Bretonnia has an elite/heavy infantry option, then one of Bretonnia's defining characteristics is not having such.

Every army but Dwarves has Cavalry & Magic. Every army but Vampires has missile troops. Every army but Dwarves, Greenskins and Skaven has access to at least some of the BRB Lores.

I could go on, but the key is, as I said before, an army is defined as much by what it cannot do as by what it can.

There certainly is room for expanding Bretonnia's range of models and units, but I feel it can be done without making Bretonnia just like every other army.



For example, the BRB fluff section mentions, well:

BRB said:
Stranger still there are legends of fey spirits appearing from forests, lakes and natural places to aid the Bretonnians -otherworldy guardians, ghostly bowmen from ages past, the souls of long-lost knights, and even the translucent spirits of the land itself.

I'd be thrilled to see ethereal bowmen or a unit of ghost-knights in the army book.

Stop me if I'm wrong, but right now, Bretonnia and VC are the only armies with ethereal units (not counting temporary spell effects and such)?

Adding more such things to the Bretonnian book would make the army more unique, not less.

Bretonnian ghostly bowmen and lost knights would be very different to VC Spirit Hosts and Hexwraiths.

Spirits of the Land could also be very cool, providing they're different to the Forest Spirits used by the Woodies.

And I think they would be. Athel Loren is a hostile, brooding place governed by the hunt god who says 'kill or be killed, hunt or be hunted' and the Forest Spirits are as likely to attack Wood Elves as help them.

Bretonnia is a gentle, kind land ruled by loving goddess. I have to believe the spirits of the land would be less like Driads, killin' the bad guys and more like, say, Warrior Priests, buffing the good guys.


Hell, even if these hypothetical units weren't that different to VC or Woodie units, at least they aren't things shared with all other books.
 
That's not what I am getting at though. I am talking about the strategies available to Bretonnian players. They are too one dimensional, too all-or-nothing, because if you mess up your first charge, you're screwed because you have no solid units that are good in the second or third rounds of combat. Also the whole "spirits of the land" thing is already covered by the Green Knight.

My problem with Bretonnia's fluff as it is now is that they are too dark, aren't Arthurian enough, aren't *good* enough - there's too much peasant oppression going on. What happened to the fair land where everyone had plenty?
 
Deathless Dreamer said:
That's not what I am getting at though. I am talking about the strategies available to Bretonnian players. They are too one dimensional, too all-or-nothing, because if you mess up your first charge, you're screwed because you have no solid units that are good in the second or third rounds of combat.

Like most Bret generals, we both have third-turn-syndrome. The slightly unpleasant realisation that most of our games are won or lost by the bottom of turn three.

Empire doesn't have that, but the solution isn't to be Empire junior.

I believe that if the Blessing worked better against shooting the problem would vanish.

One of my favourite parts of the Bretonnia game is the movement, the manouvering and lining up that oh-so-perfect charge. The look in the other man;s eye when he's about to take two fifteen-man lances to the flank and there's nothing to do but prey I'll be gentle.

Of course every turn I spend dicking about in the middle of the table lining up is a turn I'm loosing Knights and Ranks to Magma Cannons and Searing Doom.

If the blessing of the Lady were a little better against shooting I'd feel less impetus to charge on turn two or three



Deathless Dreamer said:
My problem with Bretonnia's fluff as it is now is that they are too dark, aren't Arthurian enough, aren't *good* enough - there's too much peasant oppression going on. What happened to the fair land where everyone had plenty?

Sixth Edition happened. Brets were shining beacons in a grimdark world in 4th and 5th ed. Then the current Army Book (Reynolds) played up the Monty Python's Dung-Eating Peasants bit. (Lady help us there's a Python reference right on the inside front cover!)

WHFRP 1st ed which came just before 4th ed painted Bretonnia as a hellhole.

See, these things are all cyclical. Any 8th ed book will probably be back to shining armour and noble awesomeness. I'd like that.
 
The issue I have with a unit of knights on foot is simply that the knights are the nobility. The nobility are brought up to fight with horse and lance. The floor is for peasants.

You're right though, the Brets could do with a fighting infantry unit to break steadfast. That's why we have M@A and wyssan's wildform. If M@A were able to be upgraded to yeomen, much like orcs with big'uns, they would easily become a competent unit.

As it is, my 35 M@A have helped me win games just by holding up a key enemy unit long enough to get knights in there. Well worth the 190 points spent on them (no champion taken, just banner and musician).

Out of curiosity, what lore(s) would you want for the Brets? Life, beasts and heavens are three of the best, and most fitting, lores in the brb. All three buff the knights (life even brings them back) as well as doing some damage with the right spells rolled.

I am a Bretonnian player first and foremost (have been since 5th ed) and my VCs reflect my style of play. I love the book we currently have, it has seen me through 3 editions of the game. We don't need a new book, we just need an update in our rules to bring the army in line with 8th.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu