Deathless Dreamer
Ghoul
Ravenheart said:The issue I have with a unit of knights on foot is simply that the knights are the nobility. The nobility are brought up to fight with horse and lance. The floor is for peasants.
You're right though, the Brets could do with a fighting infantry unit to break steadfast. That's why we have M@A and wyssan's wildform. If M@A were able to be upgraded to yeomen, much like orcs with big'uns, they would easily become a competent unit.
As it is, my 35 M@A have helped me win games just by holding up a key enemy unit long enough to get knights in there. Well worth the 190 points spent on them (no champion taken, just banner and musician).
Out of curiosity, what lore(s) would you want for the Brets? Life, beasts and heavens are three of the best, and most fitting, lores in the brb. All three buff the knights (life even brings them back) as well as doing some damage with the right spells rolled.
I am a Bretonnian player first and foremost (have been since 5th ed) and my VCs reflect my style of play. I love the book we currently have, it has seen me through 3 editions of the game. We don't need a new book, we just need an update in our rules to bring the army in line with 8th.
Yeah but Men at arms are just a tarpit. I want a unit of infantry that can actually fight, and win, by its own merits and not by being buffed by magic. Even when buffed by magic Men at arms are still nothing but a tarpit because of their lousy stats.
Also the nobility fighting on foot, in my opinion, only makes them more noble and heroic. For real life references, the Scottish nobility in the Middle Ages fought on foot.
You still don't seem to understand what I am saying - Bretonnians are too one dimensional! I don't care if we can win with what we already have, I want to try different tactics with my bretonnians! I want to be able to take solid infantry, more war machines such as a ballista. Maybe some crossbowmen, maybe some different types of Men at Arms, whatever.
Keep the focus on cavalry by all means, just make it so that we can rely on something other than cavalry.
And for god's sake get an avatar man.