Bretonnia next?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Ravenheart said:
The issue I have with a unit of knights on foot is simply that the knights are the nobility. The nobility are brought up to fight with horse and lance. The floor is for peasants.

You're right though, the Brets could do with a fighting infantry unit to break steadfast. That's why we have M@A and wyssan's wildform. If M@A were able to be upgraded to yeomen, much like orcs with big'uns, they would easily become a competent unit.

As it is, my 35 M@A have helped me win games just by holding up a key enemy unit long enough to get knights in there. Well worth the 190 points spent on them (no champion taken, just banner and musician).

Out of curiosity, what lore(s) would you want for the Brets? Life, beasts and heavens are three of the best, and most fitting, lores in the brb. All three buff the knights (life even brings them back) as well as doing some damage with the right spells rolled.

I am a Bretonnian player first and foremost (have been since 5th ed) and my VCs reflect my style of play. I love the book we currently have, it has seen me through 3 editions of the game. We don't need a new book, we just need an update in our rules to bring the army in line with 8th.

Yeah but Men at arms are just a tarpit. I want a unit of infantry that can actually fight, and win, by its own merits and not by being buffed by magic. Even when buffed by magic Men at arms are still nothing but a tarpit because of their lousy stats.

Also the nobility fighting on foot, in my opinion, only makes them more noble and heroic. For real life references, the Scottish nobility in the Middle Ages fought on foot.

You still don't seem to understand what I am saying - Bretonnians are too one dimensional! I don't care if we can win with what we already have, I want to try different tactics with my bretonnians! I want to be able to take solid infantry, more war machines such as a ballista. Maybe some crossbowmen, maybe some different types of Men at Arms, whatever.

Keep the focus on cavalry by all means, just make it so that we can rely on something other than cavalry.

And for god's sake get an avatar man.
 
Ravenheart said:
Out of curiosity, what lore(s) would you want for the Brets? Life, beasts and heavens are three of the best, and most fitting, lores in the brb. All three buff the knights (life even brings them back) as well as doing some damage with the right spells rolled.

I loathe the Lore of Beasts. I hate it. I would never, ever even consider using it save for fluff reasons (which means I do use it since I have a Beasts-themed damsel model).

It's never done anything other than waste power dice, though.

My Prophetess always uses Heavens. If I could use Heavens on a Damsel, I'd never use another Lore at all (I'd repaint my Damsels to Heavens theme immediately!).

That said, I'd like to see the next Bret book grant access to Light magic for both (and obviously, access to Heavens for Damsels).

Light would be both fluffy and very effective for Bretonnia.

A Prophtess with Heavens and a Damsel with Light (and optional second Damsel with Heavens) would be wonderful!
 
Deathless Dreamer said:
What happened to the fair land where everyone had plenty?

Minty said:
Any 8th ed book will probably be back to shining armour and noble awesomeness. I'd like that.

MAN UP LADIES!! Bretonnia is no sissy little fairy tale, however that said I feel its fluff isn't very well represented on the table top

The Knights do need Plate Armor and the Blessings of the Lady should give them a better ward save.

units with the Grail vow should force nearby Undead and Deamons to take a crumble test

I would like to see the lores of Fire, Shadow, Death and Light being added to the lore choices for the Damsels

I'd love a Peasant hero like Captain Of the Yeo or something.

I'd like a Yeomen upgrade for Men-At-Arms like the Orc Big 'uns
 
Ghouly said:
Deathless Dreamer said:
What happened to the fair land where everyone had plenty?

Minty said:
Any 8th ed book will probably be back to shining armour and noble awesomeness. I'd like that.

MAN UP LADIES!! Bretonnia is no sissy little fairy tale, however that said I feel its fluff isn't very well represented on the table top

The Knights do need Plate Armor and the Blessings of the Lady should give them a better ward save.

units with the Grail vow should force nearby Undead and Deamons to take a crumble test

I would like to see the lores of Fire, Shadow, Death and Light being added to the lore choices for the Damsels

I'd love a Peasant hero like Captain Of the Yeo or something.

I'd like a Yeomen upgrade for Men-At-Arms like the Orc Big 'uns

"Sissy little fairy tale?" What's wrong with wanting to be the ultimate good guys?

Give me dismounted knights or give me death! In fact they don't even have to be knights, just plate or heavy-armoured footmen or something like the ones in Warcraft 3. Some proper soldiers, not peasants with big shields and pointy sticks.
 
Deathless Dreamer said:
You still don't seem to understand what I am saying - Bretonnians are too one dimensional! I don't care if we can win with what we already have, I want to try different tactics with my bretonnians! I want to be able to take solid infantry, more war machines such as a ballista. Maybe some crossbowmen, maybe some different types of Men at Arms, whatever.

At the risk of being flippant, what you're saying is that you want to play Empire. They have all of those things, plus solid Knights.

Which is of course, what I've been saying all along. Bretonnia is defined by not having access to all the same things as everyone else.



Case in point: I am an admitted Elf fanboy. Even before I played the warhams I've always been imersed in Fantasy lit, roleplaying etc and always have been an elf fan.

My first Fantasy army were High Elves, partly because they were in the starter set, but mostly because they're Elves.

I recently sold the army, however. I simply didn't like the way they played. I love the fluff and the models, but they way they play on the table left me cold. I just had to accept that, rather than demanding a fundamental aspect of the army change for me.



Some people do use the Empire book with their Bretonnian models. Try it for a few months, it might be exactly what you're looking for. (I'm not being flippant there, I think you really might enjoy that.)
 
Nothing's wrong with wanting to be the ultimate good guys, it's just not how they are currently represented in the fluff. Having said that, with the fantasy and 40k universes progressing deeper into darkness most of the time as they try to move away from their initial parody I don't see the goodness coming out for a while.


Men at arms aren't terrible if you give them halberds. Dismounted knights would be cool but i hope they take the time to make them unique if they do include them- no point just having empire greatswords in a different skin.
 
I'd love to face more expensive--oops, meant elite--infantry in any army. Oh, you haven't met my friend Stomp Attacks?

Sounds like the Grave Guard problem all over again. And most of us concede that GG are too everything (slow, expensive, in need of list tailoring to make work, /Stompable/, cumbersome to maneuver in those big hordes.)
 
The main issue the Brets have, quite simply, is that GW don't seem to know what to do with them. Anything cool, albeit outlandish in the Empire book.

Magic - heavens, life, beasts and light are fitting. The addition of light will help make knights hit first on the charge. Metal and fire at a push. Shadow and death really don't work with the fluff.

Infantry - Bretonnia is a feudal state where the nobility fight from horseback and the peasants fight on foot. The Bretonnian way of war is very different to the empire's. They have state troops, we have peasants drafted in to fight or bullies in 'armour'. Yes M@A are a tarpit but, that's all we need.

War machines - the trebuchet is a wonderful tool. It will be changed in the new book (most likely increase in points - it throws chunks of building rather than stones after all). A variant would be nice. Bolt throwers wouldn't fit though (why would knights allow peasants a weapon capable of killing knights?).
 
Ravenheart said:
The main issue the Brets have, quite simply, is that GW don't seem to know what to do with them. Anything cool, albeit outlandish in the Empire book.

Magic - heavens, life, beasts and light are fitting. The addition of light will help make knights hit first on the charge. Metal and fire at a push. Shadow and death really don't work with the fluff.

Infantry - Bretonnia is a feudal state where the nobility fight from horseback and the peasants fight on foot. The Bretonnian way of war is very different to the empire's. They have state troops, we have peasants drafted in to fight or bullies in 'armour'. Yes M@A are a tarpit but, that's all we need.

War machines - the trebuchet is a wonderful tool. It will be changed in the new book (most likely increase in points - it throws chunks of building rather than stones after all). A variant would be nice. Bolt throwers wouldn't fit though (why would knights allow peasants a weapon capable of killing knights?).

How would a bolt thrower not fit? Ballistas were commonly used in the middle ages. Also in feudal states knights commonly fought on foot, in all nations, even France, and in Japan. And there were trained soldiers in those days, not just knights.

Men-at-Arms in the Middle Ages were professional, well-trained footmen. This was even reflected in the old Bretonnian army book - Men-at-Arms had the same stats as Empire state troops. Yes there were peasant levies, but they were never given halberds or shields and armour, they just marched along with the army and tried their best to fight.

There should be two types of infantry - peasant hordes and actual soldiers. Men-at-Arms should have a WS of 3 for crying out loud. I don't know why they have WS 2 when even in the current book it says that they are well-trained and professional soldiers.
 
I don't play - at all - but for fluff reasons, I would say peasant levies, men-at-arms with the option of having a yeoman leader OR a knight on foot, rather than a unit of Knights on foot. That wouldn't be fluffy, I agree ...
 
Ravenheart said:
Magic - heavens, life, beasts and light are fitting. The addition of light will help make knights hit first on the charge. Metal and fire at a push. Shadow and death really don't work with the fluff.

(why would knights allow peasants a weapon capable of killing knights?).

The Lady is a Warrior Goddess Fire and Death fit right in "come feel the Wrath of the Lady" and whatnot and the Lore of Shadow is all misdirection and illusion which fits right in the Fey feel that Damsels are supposed to have.


and as for the Weapons capable of killing knights every Peasant family owns a longbow which is the ultimate knight killer and Bretonnia doesn't have any laws against peasants owning crossbows or guns their just to expensive for any peasant to afford
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu