CHAOS IS COMING!

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Not necessarily - You cannot give up magical weapons as per the WFRB - but any army book can supersede those rules (much like the Fanatic rule overriding the rule about always having to charge if Frenzied).

So taking that into account both could stand true quite easily. Personally, considering you are giving each knight a +3S on charge with a magical weapon, the upgrade cost is quite low, so I would say no. However that's the only thing I can think of.
 
darebear said:
Well played.

As far as enscrolled weapons go, the local GW store agrees with my statement above. You cannot willingly give up a magical weapon if you have one. Upgrading to lances simply means they are now enscrolled lances. The key word here is "upgrade". This will not doubt be clarified in their FAQ.

You're being ridiculous, even Phil Kelly said it himself that the Lances are not Ensorcelled weapons and you are wrong on that statement that you cannot "willingly give up a magical weapon".

Ensorcelled Weapons have Magical attacks, they are not in terms of rules "Magical Weapons" like the Magic Items section of the rulebook.
Not only that, if you upgrade, you replace, its not that you attach a lance to the sword, you REPLACE.

Also if you use Bear's Anger or Flaming Sword of Rhuin you are also losing your magical weapon to attack - you willingly cast the spell on yourself.
As Disciple of Nagash said, the upgrade would make them cost way more - S7 magic should not cost dirt cheap compared to S5 magic, think about it for a sec and realize how you're wrong.
If it had been meant to be Ensorcelled Lances, it would've stated Ensorcelled Lances, not Lances.

I really can't believe some people try to play with rules so much to their advantage like this.
 
darebear said:
As far as enscrolled weapons go, the local GW store agrees with my statement above. You cannot willingly give up a magical weapon if you have one. Upgrading to lances simply means they are now enscrolled lances. The key word here is "upgrade". This will not doubt be clarified in their FAQ.
If you 'upgrade' the magic weapon in this case to a lance, you don't have a magic weapon any more. It's a switch. No S7 for chaos knights. At least, that's the consensus on most sites. Not really any point discussing it outside your local gaming group though, before the FAQ.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu