Not necessarily - You cannot give up magical weapons as per the WFRB - but any army book can supersede those rules (much like the Fanatic rule overriding the rule about always having to charge if Frenzied).
So taking that into account both could stand true quite easily. Personally, considering you are giving each knight a +3S on charge with a magical weapon, the upgrade cost is quite low, so I would say no. However that's the only thing I can think of.
So taking that into account both could stand true quite easily. Personally, considering you are giving each knight a +3S on charge with a magical weapon, the upgrade cost is quite low, so I would say no. However that's the only thing I can think of.