Characters and Champions in Challenges

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Do champions count as characters for challenges?

  • The paragraph on Refusing a Challenge should be re-written to mention that champions can fight in pl

    Votes: 6 85.7%
  • Champions can accept challenges, but a character in the unit still retires in ignominy.

    Votes: 1 14.3%

  • Total voters
    7
  • Poll votes is visible for users with special permission.
  • Poll closed .
Lynks said:
The Sun King said:
Lynks might be able to sort this out :)


So Here's the breakdown.

Character declares challenge

Champion accepts challenge

Agreed. Nothing wrong so far.

Character sent to back

Assuming Refusing a Challenge (as written) takes precedence.

Champion and challenger character fight

Okay so far.

Character cannot direct attacks to champion ("These these two characters must direct all of their attacks against each other")

What???

Champion cannot attack character (cannot fight in a challenge, only the two characters can direct attacks against each other) Champion is free to attack whoever he pleases.

Champion is not immune to being attacked for the same reason that the character is.

This makes no sense at all.

If the champion survives and the character survives the challenge continues

Makes sense

The end result-> if a champion accepts a challenge the unit must send a character back, however the challenger is made almost as useless as the character sent to the back as he is now in a fight in which neither can attack the other.

No offence, but this seems severely flawed. (as if the rule in question wasn't bad enough). Could you explain exactly WHY a character and a champion would not be able to attack each other.
 
Wilhelm das Blutige said:
Lynks said:
The Sun King said:
Lynks might be able to sort this out :)


So Here's the breakdown.

Character declares challenge

Champion accepts challenge

Agreed. Nothing wrong so far.

Character sent to back

Assuming Refusing a Challenge (as written) takes precedence.

Champion and challenger character fight

Okay so far.

Character cannot direct attacks to champion ("These these two characters must direct all of their attacks against each other")

What???

Champion cannot attack character (cannot fight in a challenge, only the two characters can direct attacks against each other) Champion is free to attack whoever he pleases.

Champion is not immune to being attacked for the same reason that the character is.

This makes no sense at all.

If the champion survives and the character survives the challenge continues

Makes sense

The end result-> if a champion accepts a challenge the unit must send a character back, however the challenger is made almost as useless as the character sent to the back as he is now in a fight in which neither can attack the other.

No offence, but this seems severely flawed. (as if the rule in question wasn't bad enough). Could you explain exactly WHY a character and a champion would not be able to attack each other.

Because of the exact same very flawed RAW logic used by yourself to misinterpret the rule in the first place. In the "fighting a challenge part" champion is never used and by your logic does not have to follow these rules and is thus able to strike out of a challenge.

------

In a challenge a champ. works like a character, but does not have to accept a challenge, if he do accept one the boo! hiss! rule is never used as noone refused the challenge in the first place.
 
Bullhax said:
Wilhelm das Blutige said:

No offence, but this seems severely flawed. (as if the rule in question wasn't bad enough). Could you explain exactly WHY a character and a champion would not be able to attack each other.

Because of the exact same very flawed RAW logic used by yourself to misinterpret the rule in the first place. In the "fighting a challenge part" champion is never used and by your logic does not have to follow these rules and is thus able to strike out of a challenge.

------

In a challenge a champ. works like a character, but does not have to accept a challenge, if he do accept one the boo! hiss! rule is never used as noone refused the challenge in the first place.

No need to sound mean Bullhax. The reasoning is that As "fighting in challenges" only mentions characters not champions, so only characters are affected by the rules for fighting in challenges.

Given that it states that the two characters must attack each other and that nobody but the two characters can attack them this means that a champion cannot attack the character (because he is not a character in the challenge) and the character cannot attack the champion (because he is not a character in the challenge)
The champion is free to attack whoever he likes (because he is not a character in the challenge) other than the character in the challenge and the character is unable to attack anyone else (because he is a character in the challenge)

There kinda isn't a way to explain it without being wordy.

The entire argument hinges on the fact that "fighting in a challenge" just mentions characters fighting in a challenge, just like the argument that you have to send a character back even if the champion accepts because champions are not mentioned in that part either.

As I said, this clearly isn't the way to play, just a way to show how it SHOULD be played.
 
Final word (from me) on Characters and Champions in Challenges

It seems that there is a variety of opinion on the matter of whether a champion can accept a challenge on behalf of a character without a character being sent to the back ranks. Even on other forums besides this one the question has been raised, with opinion leaning for characters having to retire in ignominy and against on others.

The RAI vs RAW issue further confuses the matter. I know that some people have been playing Warhammer for a long time, and maybe in previous editions the challenge rules were a bit better written (I'm not saying that they were). However, new gamers, and those that can keep up with the latest version of the rules without being coloured by how they used to play it according to previous versions, may have a different outlook to the more veteran gamers who have 'always played it a certain way'.

Let us disregard the RAI issue for the moment (assuming that there IS a clear INTENTION on the role champions play in challenges) and look at the rules AS WRITTEN (after all, this is a war-game that can get competitive, and so the rules need to be clear; not Dungeons & Dragons, where players and DMs were free to rewrite the rules if they didn't like them).

1) p 53

"Challenges are a special type of close combat performed only by characters"

This looks like an oversight in the rules, and is contradicted in the chapters on Command Groups and Characters.

2) p 93

"Champions can accept and issue challenges in the same manner as a character"

This means quite simply that champions can accept and issue challenges, and in the same manner as a character.

It does NOT say 'Champions are treated exactly as Characters with respect to accepting, issuing or even refusing challenges' (which is the way some people seem to be interpreting it).

The case of whether or not a champion can stand in for a character in a challenge without a character involved in the fight losing face under this ruling is further weakened (though still not clarified) by the FAQ.

"Q: Do enemy unit champions count as characters? p93/96"

"A: No"

3) p 102 Accepting a Challenge

"...you can now accept...with one of your characters or champions"

There is nothing wrong with this part of the challenge rules. It is quite clear.

It still does not answer the question raised in the next paragraph. The confusion arises because the next paragraph is rather unfortunately titled "Refusing a Challenge", which leads people into the line of thought of 'I've accepted the challenge. If I have accepted the challenge then I haven't refused the challenge. I can therefore ignore completely the section on refusing a challenge'.

4) p102 Refusing a Challenge

"If no enemy character steps forward to meet the challenge, one of them must retire in ignominy."

As it is written, this makes no mention of what happens if a champion accepts the challenge when there is also a character (or characters) involved in the fight. It simply says that if no CHARACTER (not champion) meets (i.e. accepts) the challenge, then a character must retire to the back ranks.

Enough of the rules flaws analysis.

I have already illustrated both cases for and against why a champion would fight on behalf of a character and whether the character would lose face in front of his troops for being a coward or whether the champion is fulfilling his role of protecting his lord.

It could (not should) be argued that champions are there to accept challenges, and can do so in place of a character with no loss of pride for the character.

Conversely, if the ruling were that a character must retire in shame EVEN IF A CHAMPION ACCEPTS THE CHALLENGE, the price of cowardice is a small one, and the declining player should live with the (potentially minor) consequences. The character retires to the back ranks. His leadership cannot be used FOR THAT TURN and he cannot make any attacks IN THAT ROUND OF COMBAT. He is not removed from play altogether (and on subsequent turns could even Make Way to get back into the fight).

My final word on this is that, unless/until resolved by GW, we play it as the Refusing a Challenge takes effect even if a champion accepts the challenge when we play at home. At clubs and tournaments we go with the general consensus.

I don't know when or how often GW updates the FAQ's (the last one was in April - so I'm guessing July), but a question has been sent to the FAQ team, and with any luck the issue will be resolved.
 
Wilhelm das Blutige said:
My final word on this is that, unless/until resolved by GW, we play it as the Refusing a Challenge takes effect even if a champion accepts the challenge when we play at home. At clubs and tournaments we go with the general consensus.

Well, I hope you're just as happy for my Champion to render your Character useless in combat. After all, a Character in a challenge can only attack another Character. Since we've just decided that a Champion is NOT a Character, then a Champion in a Challenge cannot be attacked.

That's fair, right?
 
Blutsauger said:
Wilhelm das Blutige said:
My final word on this is that, unless/until resolved by GW, we play it as the Refusing a Challenge takes effect even if a champion accepts the challenge when we play at home. At clubs and tournaments we go with the general consensus.

Well, I hope you're just as happy for my Champion to render your Character useless in combat. After all, a Character in a challenge can only attack another Character. Since we've just decided that a Champion is NOT a Character, then a Champion in a Challenge cannot be attacked.

That's fair, right?

Sounds about right.
 
Blutsauger said:
Wilhelm das Blutige said:
My final word on this is that, unless/until resolved by GW, we play it as the Refusing a Challenge takes effect even if a champion accepts the challenge when we play at home. At clubs and tournaments we go with the general consensus.

Well, I hope you're just as happy for my Champion to render your Character useless in combat. After all, a Character in a challenge can only attack another Character. Since we've just decided that a Champion is NOT a Character, then a Champion in a Challenge cannot be attacked.

That's fair, right?

Very! 10 points to render DP's or other standalone characters useless, seems like the way to play it.!
 
Wilhelm das Blutige said:
My final word on this is that, unless/until resolved by GW, we play it as the Refusing a Challenge takes effect even if a champion accepts the challenge when we play at home. At clubs and tournaments we go with the general consensus.

Good idea. You can also get javelins for your whole army until it's FAQed :)

P90. "A model is assumed to have sufficient javelins to last the entire battle"
 
I sent a link to this thread to a friend of mine, asking for his thoughts, and this is the reply I got:

"I think the following: that people who take part in rules discussions invariably have too much time on their hands; that I am a person with too much time on my hands, and should therefore weigh in; that GW does not write rules with competitive gaming in mind - consequently, the technical writing is poor and the rules break down and cease to function if one tries to apply them literally, and therefore Rules as Intended should always be taken into account (one person brought up D&D, and that rules in that are flexible and can be rewritten by the players if they don't work - GW encourages much the same, and their rules should be looked at in the same light); the rules give permission for champions to accept and issue challenges, but the rules governing challenges state that characters fight in them, so either we accept the challenge rules don't work at all, or we take it as read that all instances of "character" in the challenge rules mean "character or champion", with the exception of the rule sending characters to the back if challenges are refused as champions have a specific exception; and that as only characters who could accept can be sent to the back, a case could be made that as a champion has accepted no character is in a position to, and therefore no-one can be sent to the back; and lastly, I think that this sentence has run on long enough."
 
Wilhelm das Blutige said:
My final word on this is that, unless/until resolved by GW, we play it as the Refusing a Challenge takes effect even if a champion accepts the challenge when we play at home. At clubs and tournaments we go with the general consensus.

I have no idea what clubs or tournaments you play at but if you find yourself down Throne of Skulls this year try suggesting that to the event staff as I have played in tournaments and I have never seen this "interpretation" of the rules there or anywhere else for that matter in all my years in the hobby nor has anyone else here it sees as you seem set on ignoring them which begs to ask, why ask in the first place.
You get a unanimous no it does not work like that and still say it does?..... :O

Now I will ask though as you said this is on other forums for debate as well can you please link to any of them so we may partake? (preferably not ones you have started yourself)



Adam_Barrow said:
My brain after this thread. My poor brain.

Right up there with you mate, this is what 2am thread surfing does to you. :(
 
Wilhelm das Blutige said:
My final word on this is that, unless/until resolved by GW, we play it as the Refusing a Challenge takes effect even if a champion accepts the challenge when we play at home. At clubs and tournaments we go with the general consensus.


This entire discussion is just ... mind-boggling ... no one would agree to this peculiar missinterpretation of the rules, no tourney organizer in his (or her) right mind would have it, and personally I haven't seen an attempt at rules-bending quite like this in the last ... 24 years. (Well, maybe except for the recent BotWD bullshit trying to classify Dragon Princes and bearers of the Dragon Helm as dragons ...)

There's only one thing I can do ...

[video=youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yCucem8IseM[/video]
 
Sorry for the delay, but I needed to translate the following into coherent English. Some punctuation would have been helpful.

Duke Danse Macabre said:
Now I will ask though as you said this is on other forums for debate as well can you please link to any of them so we may partake? (preferably not ones you have started yourself)

Here are a couple (there are others... you will just have to take my word for it...or hunt for yourself).

http://warhammer.org.uk/phpBB/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=112214

http://www.warseer.com/forums/showthread.php?302969-No-more-2nd-rank-rangers (you might want to scroll down a bit)

Update: Here's another one, the whole group seems to have read the rules and interpreted them as written.

http://www.tekbot.com/warhammer/index.php?topic=2272.0

From here on in, I'll just update this post and put any new links I find below.
 
So after reading that thread the answer to your question was ansered by the end of page 1. Same answer that people came up with here. The last 2 pages had more to do with picking on the poor champion and whether people should/shouldn't direct attacks against him.
 
midean said:
So after reading that thread the answer to your question was ansered by the end of page 1. Same answer that people came up with here. The last 2 pages had more to do with picking on the poor champion and whether people should/shouldn't direct attacks against him.

This.

You have found in this post ONE other person who had the same question as you it was answered in the same manner as we did.

I can't understand why you NEED GW to tell you what to do when eveybody and their grandmothers all have told you the exact way to deal with it.
 
Wilhelm das Blutige said:
Sorry for the delay, but I needed to translate the following into coherent English. Some punctuation would have been helpful.

Duke Danse Macabre said:
Now I will ask though as you said this is on other forums for debate as well can you please link to any of them so we may partake? (preferably not ones you have started yourself)

Here's one (there are others... you will just have to take my word for it...or hunt for yourself).

http://warhammer.org.uk/phpBB/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=112214


So reading that they have come to give the same answer as here with one person who started the thread arguing to the contrary against everyone else, much like yourself.

Everyone knows the rule, everyone has backed up the rule and have went on to explain it, going any other way is a blatant attempt to bend the rules out of shape for personal advantage in a game that is meant to be fun and anyone who argues this point against me in a game I will laugh in their face.
Its not even a Rules as Written vs Rules as intended issue, its Rules vs Wishlist Rules.
 
Shame on me for reading through 3 pages of this... It was good though, just a shame I didnt have popcorn :lol:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu