It's because there is no such rules! :tongue:
The rule I believe you are thinking about is the "Sequencing"-rule it's in page 10 in the BRB in a box in the lower right corner. But that hardly apply to this specific problem..
The "problem" here is that no where in the rules does it say you HAVE to roll all dice at the same time, it is a convenience we have as players because it makes sense to roll dice who have the same initiative, to hit, to wound scores and special rules.. They are described under the "fast dice rolling" explanation on page 41 and 51.
Then there is the "randomizing"-rule on page 7:
"Sometimes you'll be called upon to randomly select something - often a model, but sometimes a magic item, a spell or similar. Where this is the case, simply assign a D6 result to each of the things the random selection must be made from, and roll the dice to make your random choice..."
But as we stated it would be a hell of a lot easier for everyone, if the player with the charmed shield, who hopefully is aware that his character is being targeted says it to his opponent, and that the opponent in turn doesn't suddenly decide that he didn't want to hit him anyway. If you are playing someone that lacks the skill of common curtsey then randomize..
*flies away with his BRB in his hoof"
