Charmed Shield and Poison Attacks

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Okay, I've got a question: What happens when multiple attacks hit a character wielding the Charmed Shield at the same initiative step and some of the attacks hit with poison and some hit normally?

Before people post their "gut feelings" let me say that I'm only really interested in something that is backed up by rules :)
 
I get best sporting when I randomise which hit the charmed shield works against.

4 hits, 2 poison. 4+ it's the poison hit.

5 hits 1 poison. 2+ it's the non poison.

I don't break out a calculator or anything but being that there's no rules on it it's the fairest on both sides and gives no advtantage to either player, although I DO round in my opponent's favor.
 
I would tend either dice it off or check with the organizer.

Edit: Or, If I may be so bold, Before they roll to hit, announce that you have a charmed sheld and have your opponent roll these attacks individually. It may slow the game down by about a minute but it will take away the dice-off thing and if you initiate this then I couldn't see your opponent having an issue with it since you're being up front with him and not trying to be tricky with it. I mean, I may be totally off my rocker here, I just think that would be the easiest and least controversial method.
 
Corien Sumatris said:
Or, If I may be so bold, Before they roll to hit, announce that you have a charmed sheld and have your opponent roll these attacks individually. It may slow the game down by about a minute but it will take away the dice-off thing and if you initiate this then I couldn't see your opponent having an issue with it since you're being up front with him and not trying to be tricky with it. I mean, I may be totally off my rocker here, I just think that would be the easiest and least controversial method.
 
Corien Sumatris said:
I would tend either dice it off or check with the organizer.

Edit: Or, If I may be so bold, Before they roll to hit, announce that you have a charmed sheld and have your opponent roll these attacks individually. It may slow the game down by about a minute but it will take away the dice-off thing and if you initiate this then I couldn't see your opponent having an issue with it since you're being up front with him and not trying to be tricky with it. I mean, I may be totally off my rocker here, I just think that would be the easiest and least controversial method.

I totally agree, this is the most gentlemenly way about it. When the first hit has been dealt and potentially been discarded, you can roll the rest like you normally would.
 
Yay!! I was nervous about that idea at first because, in tournament setting (Atleast 40k) a lot of people use a stalling method. I don't want this idea to be used for stalling, just as the simplest way to deal with a situation without specific rules.
 
I don't consider it stalling at all. It takes less than one second to roll a die. Not much time will be "wasted" while you wait for the problem to resolve.
 
Lol yeah I know, I just worry to much about being sportsman like I don't want that to be an issue. That and I know people who don't like rolling individual die since they feel like they roll worse (It's a die, there are 6 sides and the same odds of getting any one of those sides sticking up).
 
It's because there is no such rules! :tongue:

The rule I believe you are thinking about is the "Sequencing"-rule it's in page 10 in the BRB in a box in the lower right corner. But that hardly apply to this specific problem..

The "problem" here is that no where in the rules does it say you HAVE to roll all dice at the same time, it is a convenience we have as players because it makes sense to roll dice who have the same initiative, to hit, to wound scores and special rules.. They are described under the "fast dice rolling" explanation on page 41 and 51.

Then there is the "randomizing"-rule on page 7:
"Sometimes you'll be called upon to randomly select something - often a model, but sometimes a magic item, a spell or similar. Where this is the case, simply assign a D6 result to each of the things the random selection must be made from, and roll the dice to make your random choice..."

But as we stated it would be a hell of a lot easier for everyone, if the player with the charmed shield, who hopefully is aware that his character is being targeted says it to his opponent, and that the opponent in turn doesn't suddenly decide that he didn't want to hit him anyway. If you are playing someone that lacks the skill of common curtsey then randomize..

*flies away with his BRB in his hoof" :clown:
 
Either that or, after your opponent has allocated their attacks, they roll the dice individually until a hit is scored, you then roll for the charmed shield. After that, roll as per normal. Eg, 6 attacks are allocated to the character with the CS the first attack misses, the second hits with a 6, you do the 2+ and pass, the remaining attacks are rolled normally.

Makes sense to me...
 
Oh I know, The whole search for answers and asking questions is just small talk.

Side question though. Does the charmed sheild work against spirit leech? I mean, in a logic stand point wouldn't something need to hit you in order to hurt you? I'm not 100% on how the whole magic hitting works. I would assume that it does not get affected by the sheild but I don't really know.
 
Nope Corien, Charmed Shield doesn't work on SL as it doesn't cause hits. Though it DOES work on Caress of Laniph after you determine the number of HITS :)
 
The Sun King said:
Rolling one die at a time is fine, but it's hardly correct since all the hits happen simultaneously since it's at the same Initiative step

As long as models with lower initiative don't swing in between those of the poisonous characters/ghouls/what have you, how is it incorrect?
 
A "Hit" is a specific term and rule, not an ambiguous idea

In order for something to "Hit", one of the following must be true
- You rolled To Hit (obviously)
- You rolled To Wound (the hit may have happened automatically, but it still happened. To Wound is to determine how badly the hits landed)
- The word "Hit" is in the description of the attack (If it says it "hits", its a hit)

A Charmed Shield is a magical shield that jumps up automatically and defects an incoming hit with 100% accuracy and unstoppable strength. The fist of a giant, a magic missile from above, a cannonball - all can be deflected by its power.

A Charmed Shield may have a strong magical barrier, but it exists in the mortal realm.

For example, Death Wizard reaches out a dark ebon hand in the spiritual realm, gripping your spirit to weaken your will, resolve or even leech your life essence from within. There was no physical or magical object, no blow to prevent. The great Purple Sun of Xereus is not a bullet or ball of flame - the shield does not detect an incoming "hit". If you are not quick enough to look away, you turn to crystal from within. A death wizard may also call ethereal essences out of the spiritual realm to hurt you in some way (Laniph, Bjuna) - in this case, the shield can deflect the magical essences before they hurt you.

The Death Shriek and Ghostly Howl are potent magical essences which travel through sound waves to melt your soul. There is no way to prevent this damage outside of an extremely potent magical barrier such as those attached to a rare and powerful Talisman of Preservation or the mighty anti-magical essences of a demonic soul. Some simple minded beings are actually able to re-grow the brains that they lost.

Otherwise, you aren't preventing the shriek unless you get yourself some Charmed Earplugs.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu