Charmed Shield and Poison Attacks

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
How can you roll poisonous attacks in the same roll as non-poisonous attacks?
They are two different types of attacks. First you have to roll for poisonous attacks separately so that you dont get mixed up with the normal attacks that still need to roll to hit.
At least from the first post by Sun King i get the feeling that poisonous and non poisonous attacks are being rolled in one hand just because its the same inititative?
Thats totally wrong.
If 4 attacks have the poison rule then those will need to be rolled separately, since he might miss all his poisons on 6+ which then turns into normal attacks that need to roll to hit. If you roll them together with non-poisonous attacks its easy for the attacker to claim that any 6 rolled is a poisonous autowound, which is false. That 6 might have come from a nonpoison attack and thus is not a poisonous autowound but simply a hit.
Ofc you can differentiate that with dice of different colors.
Charmed shield blocks the first hit suffered i believe.. so autowounds by poison attacks are blocked as well since its nothing else than a hit that actually wounds directly. But the shield negates the hit so wound is not caused either.
So depending on what attacks were rolled first by the attacker, the charmed shield blocks the first incoming.
If all are rolled simultaneously but with different color dice then i say its up to the defender and wearer of the item to decide what is blocked. You are the wearer, not the attacker. The attacker cannot decide for you what you legally block.

There is no rule for this situation, there is no faq. So all you are left with is common sense and fairplay.
I do not completely agree with the suggested way to play earlier.
I think that the wearer of an item has predominance over how and when to use it.
If a flurry of attacks come in simultaneously then its up to the wearer to choose what is blocked and what is not.
 
Last edited:
@Skittelz - You easily can have poisonous and non-poisonous attacks occurring simulatasnously on the same intiative. Yes, you roll them separately but they are occurring at the same time.

The real question here isn't poison vs non-poison hits. Its what happens when you are hit by different attacks simulatenously. If a S6 and S3 hit at the same initiatives step, how do you determine what one to cancel with the charmed shield?

Either is is randomized or it is your choice. The shield needs a way to select. Those are the only two options. Which is most supported by the spirit of the rules? My vote is you choose how to use your charmed shield when attacks are simultaneous.
 
Like i said, the wearer decides.
I mean as a defender you clearly have the choice whom you want to block. So if a S6 and a S3 attack happen at the same time, as a defender youre obviously going to use your shield to lock a S6....
That is what using an item is for, to your advantage. Its not a question about how you determine what happens first, its about who do you turn your back to and who do you face and put your guard up.

Obviously the attacks happen simultaneously and obviously, I, as a defender with Charmed shield, am going to block that poisonous attack. I am wearing the item, those attacks come in at same initiative so I get the choice. Not my opponent, nor is it randomized. I am defending myself and i choose to block poisons over normal attacks, this is my full right to do so.


So agreed with Najo, wearer decides.
 
Last edited:

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu