Convincing friends to play Fantasy

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Patrunkenphat7

Grave Guard
Mar 4, 2014
226
Zombies
191
My local hobby shop just announced they will be carrying Warhammer products and are in the process of creating terrain boards. I'm super pumped! The problem is that a lot of my Magic: the Gathering friends and others at the shop immediately gravitate towards 40k… Why the heck does this always happen? I just don't understand the appeal over Fantasy. I am trying to convince them why Fantasy is more fun if you must choose one, but they don't seem to care. I'm pretty sure most people just like guns and tanks (which I guess they could get from Empire… :D). Any advice on how to convince friends to play Fantasy over 40k??
 
Patrunkenphat7 said:
I just don't understand the appeal over Fantasy. I am trying to convince them why Fantasy is more fun if you must choose one, but they don't seem to care. I'm pretty sure most people just like guns and tanks (which I guess they could get from Empire… :D). Any advice on how to convince friends to play Fantasy over 40k??

How are you so sure WHFB is more fun than 40k? I'd disagree with you there, especially with WHFB in the current shape it's in, clunky cheese festing. 40k's not much better, but it's better enough, and facilitates more of the hobby than WHFB does. I think it's a bit selfish to assume their reasons are shallow, especially as WHFB isn't as much deeper than 40k, in spite of WHFB player's claims.

I knew where my loyalties lied the day someone on a forum told me of one of the best army themes I'd ever heard of in wargaming, of an Empire Militia army made up of survivors of ravaged towns during the Storm of Chaos, with banners that were from their taverns, and a old rusty cannon that was a monument from one of the towns. He was discouraged from making this awesome idea from angry Warhammer players who told him he was a moron for making a weak army list. FFS. Sums it up really.

I'd say your bias is doing you no favours. Maybe you should try 40k.
 
"This one has dragons and wizards."

That was enough for me.

I played 40k for a while as well, but man that game was boring to me. Shooting games don't do a thing for me, and if you hold 40k at arm's length the whole thing looks like a Shooting Phase.

See you in the Magic Phase, fantasy fans.

-Edit-
Also, after the first 50 Spess Mahreen vs. more different Spess Mahreen games, well--the punchline kinda writes itself.
 
Buy the starter set, paint the models and run some demos. I honestly believe you can't play the game and not enjoy it.
 
40k is just a lot easier to get into. To play a game of 40k I only need to paint 10-30 models. For fantasy, 10-30 models is just one unit. 40k is cheaper, quicker to set up, easier to learn, quicker to play, involves less maths......

Also, 40k has more fun things you can do with it, with Allies, Kill-Team, Apocalypse, A large variety of different missions, etc.

Fantasy is really not a good entry point into the hobby.

Also, you should never try and convince people to play something they don't want to play. If they approach you and start asking about fantasy, thats when you try and sell it to them. If you just keep bothering them to start a fantasy army, they will probably just get annoyed at you.
 
40K: Cool races shooting at eachother with invincible saves and somewhat-cool vehicles.

Fantasy: Cool races grinding eachother down in combat backed by awesome monsters, magic, and wizards.

Both are awesome games but I would rather have a prominent combat and magic phase than a semi-important movement phase and a dominant shooting phase.
 
Adam_Barrow said:
Also, after the first 50 Spess Mahreen vs. more different Spess Mahreen games, well--the punchline kinda writes itself.

Y'see, once upon a time I thought 'you don't have to play the exact same mirror-match every single game would be the ultimate atomic-powered unblockable super argument for converting 40k players.


I was wrong. I realised that 40k players increasingly don't see Marines vs Marines every game as a bug, but a feature. All of those (us) who don't like facing Marines every game have already quit 40k and the rest are happy where they are.

Oh, they will complain about the endless mirror-matches, but they will never do anything about it.

Remember, if you get ten space Marine players together and suggest that the ubiquity of Space Marines is a bad thing for 40k all ten will agree with you and say that those other nine people should play something else. And then all ten of them will go and start another space Marine army in a slightly different colour of armour.


@Patrunkenphat7 - I cannot help you convert 40k players. No-one can. however, I can offer some encouraging words. If you manage to get two other fantasy players, you three will have twice the variation in opponents as any 40k player.
 
Minty said:
I was wrong. I realised that 40k players increasingly don't see Marines vs Marines every game as a bug, but a feature. All of those (us) who don't like facing Marines every game have already quit 40k and the rest are happy where they are.

Where on earth do you people game? I haven't played against a marine army in weeks, and I mostly play 40k. It's a shame this has been your experience, but I can't say I like your sweeping generalisation. Yes, Marines are a given, but it's no different to expecting a Power Gaming Elf, Chaos Warrior, Lizard or Daemon Player in every single gaming club.

Minty said:
Oh, they will complain about the endless mirror-matches, but they will never do anything about it.

This is gaming in a nutshell. It's not exclusive to 40k.

Minty said:
Remember, if you get ten space Marine players together and suggest that the ubiquity of Space Marines is a bad thing for 40k all ten will agree with you and say that those other nine people should play something else. And then all ten of them will go and start another space Marine army in a slightly different colour of armour.

I get a bit of variety with WHFB, but sooner or later I still see the usual suspects (Elves, Lizards and Chaos). I am tired of playing against Chaos. I don't mind playing against Space Marines, because there are ways to undermine them, whereas Chaos can be used effectively by a moron, especially as WHFB is now a race in the forward direction, and Chaos Warriors are a forward facing steamroller.

Sanai said:
Also, you should never try and convince people to play something they don't want to play. If they approach you and start asking about fantasy, thats when you try and sell it to them. If you just keep bothering them to start a fantasy army, they will probably just get annoyed at you.

This.

You can't change people through insistence, or twisting at people. Gaming Clubs that force anything, be it painting, or anything else tend to cause more problems and kill more gaming clubs. People don't like being told what to do. If people are going to change, the best way is encouragement. Make a good Warhammer fantasy army built, offer a few demo games. Telling them 40k is rubbish (when it isn't) is a sure fire way to get yourself the one being left out.
 
I guess I should clarify that I'm not trying to convert 40k players to Fantasy - I'm trying to show people who don't play Warhammer at all yet that Fantasy can be at least as fun if not more fun than 40k. My problem is that people who know nothing about Warhammer seem strangely drawn to tanks and guns. Like the fluff or perceived gameplay is more appealing to a lot of people.

I'm also not trying to convince people to do something that they "don't want to do" for some weird personal gain. I honestly think they'd love Fantasy. I really think it's a fluff issue.

@Adam: I'm not familiar with that game.
 
Allow me:
http://lmgtfy.com/?q=mordheim

One of the more lamented GW games. It's also all those things I said up there somewhere. The short version is it's very accessible and highly recommended by most of the folks I've ever encountered that have played it.

And did I mention free rules?

P.S. Just playing with you up there. You made me feel old. :p
 
Patrunkenphat7 said:
My problem is that people who know nothing about Warhammer seem strangely drawn to tanks and guns. Like the fluff or perceived gameplay is more appealing to a lot of people.

What's so strange about that? It's definitely a fluff issue. The fluff of 40k is, in spite of the best efforts of the dyslexic ante-chrisp (Ward) to ruin the 40k fluff and write constant wank about how amazing Fantasy is, 40k still has a better setting, a more interesting backstory and more interesting races. There are elements about 40k that are singular. WHFB is so Tolkeinesque it made the world think Orcs are greenskins.

As to gameplay, it has it's issues, but so does fantasy. Hold it at arms length and you largely have a clunky movement phase, a stupid charging system with no skill or nuance, overpowered magic bullshit (although at least it's less broken than 7th) and makes deathstar units needlessly difficult to counter and largely dependent on luck.

I've been gaming for a bit over 20 years, and I still find WHFB a chore, perpetuated by the misplaced smugness of a large section of it's fanbase. It's an okay game, but it doesn't offer much over 40k, or more importantly, other wargames (like Specialist Games like Mordheim, Or Warmahordes, Historical etc) that actually play better.

If I was in your position I wouldn't be bothering with either WHFB or 40k. I'd be trying to get them to play anything else. Like a proper wargame instead of a wardian clusterfuck
 
The present state of 40k is a cluster*$%&. It's so bad they are talking about releasing 7th only 2 years after 6th came out. 40k is a horrible game in its present state. And in any state, in my opinion, is inferior to fantasy.

Fantasy has a more dynamic, far more important movement phase, is vastly more tactical, is MASSIVELY more ballanced than 40k is, has better spread and variety of armies ... the only bonuses for 40k are lower model count/cost to get into.
 
I love Warhammer Fantasy. No offense, Dimreapa, but this is the last place I wanted to encounter Warhammer Fantasy haters or people who recommend others should play any game except Fantasy… :/ I know a segment of the population exists that dislikes the game, but you don't need to waste time in an army-specific Warhammer Fantasy forum bashing the game…


I agree with everything countulrich just said which is why I'd really love to see my friends play Fantasy. I'm just trying to get them past the phase where 40k seems more 'cool' so I can show them the fun, tactical gameplay of Fantasy and how the armies are more balanced.

EDIT: Dimreapa, I just took a few minutes to glance at your post history. It seems like at least half of your posts are bashing the rules or the game in general… Why is it enjoyable for you to post in this forum if you dislike the game so much?
 
Hey now everyone, the language starting to get little heated, lets remember that we are all people here and it's nice to be kind to one another before we devolve into slandering and I have to bring out the ban hammer eh? Being nice is in the forum rules after all xD
 
Patrunkenphat7 said:
EDIT: Dimreapa, I just took a few minutes to glance at your post history. It seems like at least half of your posts areb bashing the rules or the game in general… Why is it enjoyable for you to post in this forum if you dislike the game so much?

Who said I find it enjoyable? I truly want to like WHFB more than I do. Yes, I gather you expected nothing but confirmation of your own view, but this is a forum, and you just got mine.

P.s. I haven't been on this forum long. I'm hoping VCs will give me a second wind with fantasy. If it doesn't I'll sell up and stick to the games I prefer. (PPS whilst I admit some of this is irritation at the dismissal of 40k, there is a big difference between criticism and bashing. I'm critical of GW. Doesn't mean I'm not still a fan. It just means I'm a more borderline example of one.)

I can't say I'm surprised, or upset to see bias for WHFB, but I just don't get the idea that fantasy is so superior or so much more tactical. Each have their own nuances.

I said the games are okay. But they are just okay. I play a lot of wargames and I never look to GW for balance. 40k is more fun, offers more variety, and better hobby and modelling opportunitues.

WHFB is definitely a bit more balanced, but not anywhere near justifying the arrogance directed at WHFB.
 
If it doesn't 'grab' you, it just doesn't. I've tried countless times to get into 40k and I never get past the first 500-750 points before I lose interest; there just aren't any factions that really blow my hair back. Meanwhile in fantasy, it's a struggle not to start a new army every other week. But like I said above, buy IoB, paint the models up and run some demos. People will like it if they play it.
 
@Lynks: Sorry if it sounded heated, I didn't mean for it to sound that way! I have not been a member on these forums for very long, but I enjoy being part of a community that loves the game and enjoys playing Vampire Counts in particular. It just seems like hardcore trolling to join a forum for a game and then say every other game is better or more fun…

Dimreapa, you are absolutely entitled to your opinion, and I have definitely heard that opinion before, but I don't think the Vampire Counts forum is a great place to fight for that point of view. Also I didn't really want to get into a Fantasy vs 40k bashing post, I really just wanted to see how other people show their friends how fun Fantasy is to entice them to play and raise the question of why players who are new to miniatures are drawn to 40k.

@Ripper: I guess you're right that the best way is to run demos of actual gameplay. Sounds like a pretty large task for me to get models specifically for a demo (I am painfully slow at painting and assembling models), but I'm going to try to see if a buddy from a neighboring town could come by and play.
 
That's fair enough. I certainly don't want to derail the thread. For what it's worth there are some gamers like me who rage about WHFB fans who have the "fantasy is for real manz" attitude that is similar to PC vs. Console gaming. So all I would say is that the "fantasy is so much better" argument isn't always a good idea.

I got unnecessarily offensive pushing that, but that's the basis of it.

One way that my local staffer manager has had success with WHFB is building up from small: starting with Heroquest/Mordheim light, and then building the army up, starting with the character. It's a bit tricky to organise, and you'll need some dungeon minions and board with the heroquest route, but it's doable. Drop me a PM if you want any details of how he did it. It's the least I can do for screwing over your thread.

And sure, it does seem trollish for WHFB to be my least favourite wargame (well after inquisitor, but that's an abomination), but I'm not going to be dishonest just because I'm on a forum dedicated to it. Besides, it's the game I have issue with. I joined Carpe Noctem for hobby advice, which is the most important part of wargaming for me.
 
Dimreapa said:
...
And sure, it does seem trollish for WHFB to be my least favourite wargame (well after inquisitor, but that's an abomination), but I'm not going to be dishonest just because I'm on a forum dedicated to it. Besides, it's the game I have issue with. I joined Carpe Noctem for hobby advice, which is the most important part of wargaming for me.

That's reasonable, glad you're here. Maybe one day we'll win you over :)
 
Patrunkenphat7 said:
@Ripper: I guess you're right that the best way is to run demos of actual gameplay. Sounds like a pretty large task for me to get models specifically for a demo (I am painfully slow at painting and assembling models), but I'm going to try to see if a buddy from a neighboring town could come by and play.

Nothing worth doing is ever easy. 2 years from now when you and all your buddies have 3000 point fantasy armies, the couple weeks you spent painting that starter set will have been well worth it.
 
Ain't that the truth! And besides, you'll probably end up with two armies anyway at some point. May as well start now!
 
I guess you can only convince people to play fantasy if they like the setting (being a fan of fantasy/medieval usually helps) and showing them how the game works.

As for alot of people's penchant and attraction to 40k... i dont understand it. Getting attracted by the tanks? i think theyre all fugly and toy-ish. If i want tanks and modern combat ill simply buy Tamiya or Revell miniatures, at least thats proper realism. But thats just a matter of taste.

Even though i am a big scifi fan, usually preferring scifi over fantasy, i have to admit that 40k isnt really attracting me. I never played it so i cant comment on the game but when choosing between fantasy and 40k i was immediately sold to fantasy.

My guess is that alot of people that join the game/hobby are drawn in to the choice simply by the crowd they hang with. If the majority plays 40k, youre gonna go 40k, just because it gives you the most play-options.
Fact is that 40k sells better and is played more, that is already a big decisionmaking fact that im sure lures alot of people towards 40k rather than fantasy.


I dont even want to 'convince' people that play 40k or anything else to go for warhammer, that interest will have to come from the person itself, not from my conniving abilities to persuade some1. This is different with new players that still have to make that decision, they can still be brainwashed :D
 
Yeah I'm not trying to convince current 40k players, but rather a large group of my Magic: the Gathering friends. They are probably going to choose one of the games, but they are gravitating towards 40k…

I'm thinking about breaking my Vamps into 2 smaller armies to play some games. This might be a compromise with the "paint a new army" idea. If I go ahead and assemble/paint these GG, I think I could definitely field 2 interesting lists. I might post them over in the army list section to see if people can help me balance them.
 
Sanai said:
Also, you should never try and convince people to play something they don't want to play. If they approach you and start asking about fantasy, thats when you try and sell it to them. If you just keep bothering them to start a fantasy army, they will probably just get annoyed at you.
This is probably the best advice anyone has given yet... The best way to convince some people to try fantasy is to have a couple of small fantasy armies that showcase the best of fantasy... i.e., more interesting movement, actual magic, real psychology rules, cool cavalry, some fantasy monsters... Maybe you can print two cutout armies on cardstock (make some tent cards in the dimensions of the units), write up a brief scenario...

Come to think of it, this is something GW should already have -- like a free, paper sampler. I think WotC has something like this for DnD...

Anyway, I'm of the opinion that players should choose between 40k and WHFB based on which fluff they prefer. Both systems have equal clunks, I think most would agree, and more importantly these will evolve as new editions and codexes are released. But the fluff will likely stay the same so, like the decision to pick and play the models you love (which should also factor in the decision between the two systems), you can't go wrong if you go with the fluff you like better.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu