Patrunkenphat7 said:
My problem is that people who know nothing about Warhammer seem strangely drawn to tanks and guns. Like the fluff or perceived gameplay is more appealing to a lot of people.
What's so strange about that? It's definitely a fluff issue. The fluff of
40k is, in spite of the best efforts of the dyslexic ante-chrisp (Ward) to ruin the
40k fluff and write constant wank about how amazing Fantasy is,
40k still has a better setting, a more interesting backstory and more interesting races. There are elements about
40k that are singular.
WHFB is so Tolkeinesque it made the world think Orcs are greenskins.
As to gameplay, it has it's issues, but so does fantasy. Hold
it at arms length and you largely have a clunky movement phase, a stupid charging system with no skill or nuance, overpowered magic bullshit (although at least it's less broken than 7th) and makes deathstar units needlessly difficult to counter and largely dependent on luck.
I've been gaming for a bit over 20 years, and I still find
WHFB a chore, perpetuated by the misplaced smugness of a large section of it's fanbase. It's an okay game, but it doesn't offer much over
40k, or more importantly, other wargames (like Specialist Games like Mordheim, Or Warmahordes, Historical etc) that actually play better.
If I was in your position I wouldn't be bothering with either
WHFB or
40k. I'd be trying to get them to play anything else. Like a proper wargame instead of a wardian clusterfuck