WHFB - 7th Corpse Carts in units?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
ArchMagosAlchemys said:
On page 43 of the army book, under Designer's Notes, it specifically states that the Corpse Cart moves and fights as a monster.

OMG (OH MY VAMPIRE) how couldI miss that.
But like grishnakh99 said it say that it moves and fights like a monster it don't say that it's a monster. So I think (like grishnakh99 said) that you can get around the rule Monster Reaction.
 
This is exactly the source of my personal confusion. If it's a monster why didn't they say "The Corpse Cart is a Monster.". Saying it moves and fights like a monster is implying that it is not a monster, just acts as one in certain ways.

I think that this was the EXACT intentions of GW. In Combat(close and shooting) it gives a mounted necromancer added protection. and as far as movement...I don't think they wanted to make it a chariot, giving VC two different chariot options, but making it MOVE like a monster allows it more fluid movement when charging, marching etc...

So I'm assuming that ONLY dealing with the Corpse Carts, movement and combat, do you follow the rules for monsters[/quote]
 
I remember the lack of unit clarification caused some issues a while ago so GW tied it all up in the current rulebook...then they release the Corpse Cart and take a step back.

I would just try RAW as best as possible, if it moves like a monster then it follows all the rules for moving monsters including whether they can join units or not and if it fights like a monster then it attacks like a monster in cc (challenges etc).

That's the way I see it, but I'm not currently using the Corpse Cart so never really thought about it.
 
Although I doubt it was GWs intention for the Corpse Cart to be able to join units (lack of images, mention in rules etc) it certainly seems that the rules allow it.

The reason for this is that although the rules are clear that it is a Monsterous Mount for Combat and Moving, they never explain what it is in other cases.
Going through the various model types in the rulebook, it seems clear to me that the corpse cart should be categorised as a monster (until GW clarify otherwise).

Although as someone has already accurately pointed out, if that is the case why did GW not simply say it was a monster, instead of saying in which ways it is like a monster.

In the end I will play it the same way I play all ambigious rules which although valid RAW I doubt are intent:
> I personally won't put Corpse Cart Necromancers in units.
> If an opponent wants to I will allow it.
 
Monster reaction is not psychology, as far as I am aware. Otherwise, an oldblood riding a carnosaur that was knocked off, the Carnosaur would not have to make a reaction test because it was frenzied.
 
Necromancer mounted corpse carts can join units but when the Necro dies the Corpse cart separates from the unit at end of phase and apparently Corpse Carts take monster reaction tests as well(?)

Source: Direwolf FAQ's
 
mannfred: Nothing against Direwolf but tbh I don't much care what they FAQ it as (either it's official GW, or it is just opinion).

But yes everything you said is how the RAW work, you can even cast the beast cowers on a corpse cart if you so wished, regardless of whether their is a necromancer on it or not.
 
I don't see where the confusion comes from. It says in the Corpse cart rules it counts as a monster for movement and fighting. Its also listed in the reference as a monster.

It says in the Necromancer army listing that a CC can be taken as a mount.

Mounted + Monster = Monstrous mount

A character on a monstrous mount can join units.

Whats the problem?

And for the RAW purists a quote:

p58 of the rule book the very first paragraph under the heading of 'The Monster Model':

Monsters always fight individually; they can never join other models to form a unit, except when they are ridden by a character.

Simple
 
grishnakh99 said:
Monster reaction is not psychology, as far as I am aware. Otherwise, an oldblood riding a carnosaur that was knocked off, the Carnosaur would not have to make a reaction test because it was frenzied.

The concept of a monster reaction test is not ignored for undead, yet people (not here) keep acting like it's a weird concept for a Corpse Cart to take one because it's undead... presumably they've never considered what happens to an Abyssal Terror or Zombie Dragon whose rider is killed.
 
I think it is simply a case of people knowing of rule, not knowing the exact wording and then applying it 'logically'. I can see why some people don't expect something undead to need to roll, although personally I think it makes perfect sense.
- - -

Max zero: Maybe I missed it, but I don't think the question about mounted corpse carts and units was ever one that was really rules based.
The rules support the fact a Corpse cart is a monsterous mount and can thus join units. I still have doubts this was GWs intention when they wrote the rules how ever, but of course it is impossible to know what they intended so I would never stop someone using a rule on those grounds.

Reasons why I have doubts:
1/ The corpse cart is very much like a chariot, as alluded to in the designers note saying it is not truly a chariot or monster.
2/ None of the pictures or example lists make use of this ability.
3/ Why can't a Zombie monster/chariot join a Zombie unit.

Again, it is not the case that I doubt the rules support the fact that a Corpse Cart is a monster, and thus when mounted can join units. I simply have a nagging doubt that this is something that wasn't considered when writing the rules.
 
N1AK said:
I think it is simply a case of people knowing of rule, not knowing the exact wording and then applying it 'logically'. I can see why some people don't expect something undead to need to roll, although personally I think it makes perfect sense.
- - -

Max zero: Maybe I missed it, but I don't think the question about mounted corpse carts and units was ever one that was really rules based.
The rules support the fact a Corpse cart is a monsterous mount and can thus join units. I still have doubts this was GWs intention when they wrote the rules how ever, but of course it is impossible to know what they intended so I would never stop someone using a rule on those grounds.

Reasons why I have doubts:
1/ The corpse cart is very much like a chariot, as alluded to in the designers note saying it is not truly a chariot or monster.
2/ None of the pictures or example lists make use of this ability.
3/ Why can't a Zombie monster/chariot join a Zombie unit.

Again, it is not the case that I doubt the rules support the fact that a Corpse Cart is a monster, and thus when mounted can join units. I simply have a nagging doubt that this is something that wasn't considered when writing the rules.

Why would it be a chariot? What chariot like features does it have?

As for pictures....thats a bit of a stretch.

As for why it can't join Zombies? Because nothing can.

To me the intention seems very clear. If they didn't want it to join units they would leave it unmountable. I don't think its a accident that a mounted CC comes in just under the 5 unit strength limit for mounted characters in units so they can't be picked out and benefit from the 'LOS!' rule.
 
You don't see pictures of Corpse Carts in unit because it doesn't actually look very good- and wouldn't even look good if they could join Zombies.

Course I doubt it was intentional, but hey, it makes a bad option slightly more worth taking. Which is the kind of rules loophole I like!
 
Actually like the CC.

If you put it into a GG unit with GW you actually get the CCs full cost back and then some due to being able to drop 8 GG.

In effect its free.

Add to that the extra bound spell plus Balefire.
 
I personally only have my Corpse Cart count as one model per rank (anything else is a bit cheeky after all), but even then it'll save you over 50 points of Grave Guard models...
 
Yeah I suppose having it count as 8 is a bit much. Still even with 4 your basically making the CC costs 1/2 price (I always take Balefire).

Balefire is greatly underrated. It's basically an improved +1 dispel. The difference is it works before the spell is cast and if it works the spell is not even cast saving you from have to use an DD dice at all. It makes spells both harder to cast and easier to dispel.

The Khorne -2 casting banner is effective even though Khorne daemon armies have very few DD. Imagine how effective it is in an army that has the DD to back it up?

I have seen 2 used against my VC army and it really hurt my casting.
 
And I personally only count things like this as one single model. For the unit. Not per rank or anything. That way it obeys all rules without question.

CC w. Balefire would really hurt the casting of VC as they spam spells. Khorne will really hurt it! -2 DD? Ouch.
 
Max zero said:
Balefire is greatly underrated.

You jest! All I ever hear about for the Corpse Cart is "balefire balefire balefire". Balefire's rated highly by all, although I'm not a huge fan because well over a third of armies I face have next to no magic to begin with, and spending 50 points on upgrades that do nothing never sits well with me (I don't even like taking scrolls).

The Khorne -2 casting banner is effective even though Khorne daemon armies have very few DD. Imagine how effective it is in an army that has the DD to back it up?

Indeed, very powerful. Just a quick sidenote on that Khorne banner though (Best to get these things said in advance): it doesn't affect the Invocation of Nehek, since it's not part of any Lore, and the Khorne Banner only affects one specific Lore. So that banner will be nasty to us, but not game-breakingly so.
 
I just want to make this last point. To my knowledge, there is NO monster in the game that can be fielded without Riders and/or handlers. So what happens when u field the CC without a Necro??? Do you take a monster reaction test?? I think you do not just for the fact the CC is not a mounter monster. I just REALLY WISH GW will give us a FAQ....
 
Whoa there sailor, there's no reason to get worked up and demand an FAQ in this case. There are loads of unridden monsters in the game that don't need handlers or riders. I presume you've heard of some of these:
-Tomb Scorpions
-Gorgers
-Great Eagles
-Treemen
-Chaos Spawn
-Shaggoths
-Giants
-Varghulf
and so on and so forth. You only take a monster reaction test when a monster's rider is killed, so if there's no rider, you'll never need to take a test. It couldn't really be any simpler or clearer...
 
I think Skillmatic11 meant a monster you can field alone that can also be fielded with a rider.

-Great Eagle would be an example of a monster you could field alone or as a mount, and it will take a monster reaction test.

I think people are putting too much thought into it. It's the walking dead; do we need a good reason why they'd go crazy when their master gets knocked off? Maybe the magic went awry. It doesn't really matter. I'm sure a creative mind could find a fluffy reason why it would indeed take a monster reaction test.

The only unit type a corpse cart could be is a monster or a chariot (or a weird combination of both). As it obeys none of the rules for chariots, I am of the firm mindset it is a monster in all ways, not just for moving or fighting.

If it is a monster in all ways, it takes the Monster Reaction test according to the rules.
 
You don't need the magic to go whacky...

It could just as easily be explained that the zombies that are pulling the cart do whatever the reaction table says.
They stand there like they are stupid (Seems zombie like to me)
They leave the board (Eh... stupid zombies)
They charge the nearest enemy. (BRAINSSSS!!!!)

I don't see how it is difficult to understand... well, actually I do...

People are viewing the cart as just a inanimate cart, when in actuality it is a cart pulled by impaled zombies, while the bodies of zombies are piled on it...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu