ET magic: Bridge of Shadow

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Brainy-O

Zombie
May 17, 2013
16
Zombies
18
Had my first game using the ET magic system (really need to play more games). Not actually owning the book I had no idea about the special ET/SoM spells and got caught out by their non-dispelable nature.

Specifically with bridge of shadow, can a wizard move his own unit? The spell states the unit is removed from play and can appear anywhere in the line of sight of the wizard but we debated on whether it is the line of sight before the spell takes effect or after, which having been removed from play, would be nowhere. We diced for it in the end and allowed it. Boooo!

Having won the deployment phase hands down, I was suddenly faced with Archeron teleporting himself and his pack of bloodcrushers the length of the battlefield. Not nice.
 
Had my first game using the ET magic system (really need to play more games). Not actually owning the book I had no idea about the special ET/SoM spells and got caught out by their non-dispelable nature.

Specifically with bridge of shadow, can a wizard move his own unit? The spell states the unit is removed from play and can appear anywhere in the line of sight of the wizard but we debated on whether it is the line of sight before the spell takes effect or after, which having been removed from play, would be nowhere. We diced for it in the end and allowed it. Boooo!

Having won the deployment phase hands down, I was suddenly faced with Archeron teleporting himself and his pack of bloodcrushers the length of the battlefield. Not nice.
So... After reading Bridge of Shadows and the rules for Augment Spells, the target unit DOES NOT need to be in the caster's forward arc or have line of sight. For placing the unit back on the board, the same applies. However, the target unit must maintain the same formation as when it was removed and must at least 1" away from ANY OTHER unit or impassable terrain. So, yes, the wizard can cast this on his own unit as it is an augment spell.
 
I completely agree that, as an augment, the castor can target his own unit, or any unit within range even if it is out of his front arc/LoS.

My main issue is the wording of the spell's eventual 'target', a point on the battlefield. The unit is removed from play and placed anywhere in the LoS of the wizard. If the unit containing the wizard is removed from play then surely the wizard no longer has a line of sight to the battlefield in order to pick a point of re-entry.

1 - Choose target unit
2 - Immediately remove unit from play
3 - Pick a point on the battlefield in LoS
4 - Place target unit there

If it said pick a point on the battlefield and in LoS of the wizard and THEN the unit is removed from play and placed at that point, then fine. But it doesn't. Perhaps this is intended? Representing the wizards flinging their friends about like a puppet-master seems reasonable to me from a shadow caster, rather than moving themselves (they have the lore attribute for that).

1 - Choose target unit
2 - Pick a point on the battlefield in LoS
3 - Remove unit from play
4 - Place target unit there
 
Does it not say "target is immediately moved from the battlefield and placed anywhere within the wizard's line of sight"?

I'm afraid I don't have a copy of the book so am working from memory.
 
Does it not say "target is immediately moved from the battlefield and placed anywhere within the wizard's line of sight"?

I'm afraid I don't have a copy of the book so am working from memory.
"...place the unit anywhere on the battlefield facing any direction, but the unit must maintain its formation and cannot be placed within 1" of another unit or impassable terrain. If the unit was in combat when it was removed, the unit it was in combat with may make a free reform."
 
Where are you reading yours from? Finally found an image and it reads "The target is immediately removed from the table and replaced anywhere on the battlefield visible to the wizard."

http://www.fanhammer.org/khaine-progress-of-spells-and-magic-items-Book/?lang=en
Hmm... I was reading from the magic cards (don't have the book). I will have to check again to make sure I wasn't reading it incorrectly or I don't have a misprinted card.

The pic says anywhere "visible" to the wizard, but is an augment spell, so does not need Line of Sight... Quite the conundrum. This looks like another GW oversight, but I would say that the field of visibility is from the point of view of the caster where the spell was cast. Think of it as the Nightcrawler effect: He can only teleport somewhere that he can see. I would consider this a 360 degree view, but that is how I interpret it.
 
It certainly is weird for the writers to use the term 'visible to x' when I can't recall another instance of its use as opposed to 'in the line of sight' or 'in the front arc'.

Also very lax of them to print cards that actually read differently to book printed rules (although I think these images might be from White Dwarf), just to sow a bit more confusion into the Khaine magic ruleset, as if it was needed.

Seeing the text again I would not necessarily argue to the death that the wizard is lost in the void if casting it on his own unit, but it should definitely be discussed pre-game. I suppose your view is likely to be pretty different if you're the one with the shadow casters.
 
I would say the target unit can be anywhere 360 degrees as per a normal augment, but there is no way they can be teleported beyond the 90 degree front arc of the wizard. Nothing has a 360 LoS without specific rules saying so. Even a lone character can only shoot in their front arc, and they can pivot as much as they like. The fact is an augment and can target in 360 applies only to the initial target, ie the unit to be moved, not any secondary target, ie a point on the battlefield, that has a specified rule already attached, ie visible to the wizard. And 'visible' in every other context is a 90 degree arc to the front.

I think the major issue still stands. As the unit is removed from play immediately once the spell has been cast, if the wizard is in the unit may they return, as any spot on the battlefield is no longer visible to said wizard?
 
You could interpret it that way, but the way the spell reads I think it works a bit more like a Star Trek transporter. The wizard focuses on the unit and transports it into the void (hence the spell specifically pointing out that it is removed from the game). He then focuses on a point on the battlefield and re-materialises the unit at that point.

Basically, it is a two step process and without a fixed point on the field controlling where they reappear the unit has no way of getting back.
 
You could interpret it that way, but the way the spell reads I think it works a bit more like a Star Trek transporter. The wizard focuses on the unit and transports it into the void (hence the spell specifically pointing out that it is removed from the game). He then focuses on a point on the battlefield and re-materialises the unit at that point.

Basically, it is a two step process and without a fixed point on the field controlling where they reappear the unit has no way of getting back.
I could see that too. I really wish that someone else had commented. Maybe @najo or @MasterSpark has a better explanation or knows who to bring in on it.
 
Last edited:
How I would rule it is the spell all resolves at once. The two effects your referring too even is in one sentence of the spell. As the spell has to resolve and place the unit, you would place it anywhere within sight of where the wizard was at. This would be a RAI ruling though. With that said, I can see the other interpretation. If we want a RAW ruling @Mad 'At would be the best Mod for the job.
 
I'm flattered to hear you say that @najo. I suppose it is true though, I am kind of a RAW fan xD

Since I have little interest in the rules of the End Times I had not really looked into this matter, but since I was summoned here I am. This seems to be a hard one to crack with RAW, as it is written really fussy, but I'll give it a break down.

One solution would be to simply say both the disappearance and selecting of the place to reappear happen at the same time and the order is thus decided by the player who's turn it is. This would mean you can select his own unit, choose a spot and then remove the unit. If he would choose to remove it before selecting a spot the unit would be trapped in the void since the wizard can't see anything while not on the board. This would also mean that another unit could be targeted and removed before deciding the spot, possibly opening up more areas that were obscured by the unit itself.

Another take would be to focus on the word "immediately", which cause a strict order seen in which the effects take place. As soon as the spell is successfully cast the target unit is immediately removed from the table. This is done first. The unit is replaced after at a spot of the wizards choosing, but again if the wizard is not on the board he can't see anything. So with this interpretation there would be no teleporting himself. I think this one falls though due to the use of the word "and" in the sentence. It could be read in such a was that the "immediately" is connected to the reappearance part too, leading to the simultaneous argument.

However, trying to figure this out I noticed another problem with the spell. It says: "The target unit is ... and replaced anywhere on the battlefield visible to the Wizard". What does that mean? At first I assumed he had to see a point on the field and the unit would be placed there, but the I had another thought. I think it means that the unit has to be visible to the caster once it has been placed. Something in the line of "... on the battlefield where it is visible to the Wizard" would have been a better wording, but for it to mean something with a point on the field it would have to be rewritten more. This is borderline RAI I realise, but I do think that is the most correct way to read the sentence. The unit has to be visible to the caster once it has been placed. So how does this work with teleporting his own unit? Simple, it is only a matter of answering the question if a character sees the unit he is in (when in the front rank, he obviously does when in the second). I'd say yes to this. With the reasoning that a corner to corner touch is enough to be in base contact the front arc just barely touching the base of his closest companions should be enough to see them. The problem with this reasoning are the True Line of Sight rules, which use the models rather than the base. Those rules are stupid though in my opinion, and to bypass it still you could always model the wizard far back on his base and the RnF on either side leaning forward so that he sees them. What's silly is what happens when he is on his own, does he see himself?

In conclusion. The wizard only has to see the unit when it is placed in it's final position and since he sees his own unit he can place it anywhere he likes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: najo
Your welcome @Mad 'At. I knew you would have insight into this :) Interesting 4th interpretation came to me after reading your ruling. The second half of the sentence says anywhere on the battlefield visible to the wizard. What if the spell isn't referring to the unit, but actually a point on the battlefield (i.e. some place on the ground). If that is the case, the wizard would just pick a point visible to him and then move the target unit there immediately, correct? What do you think?
 
Your welcome @Mad 'At. I knew you would have insight into this :) Interesting 4th interpretation came to me after reading your ruling. The second half of the sentence says anywhere on the battlefield visible to the wizard. What if the spell isn't referring to the unit, but actually a point on the battlefield (i.e. some place on the ground). If that is the case, the wizard would just pick a point visible to him and then move the target unit there immediately, correct? What do you think?
That's the way I was interpreting it, with the 360 degree view and the OP thought was limited to DLOS.
 
That was my first thought too. Raise Dead and Hand of Gork follow that mechanic, you select a spot and place the unit there. So thinking it would work as those is natural I'd say. Non of those spells have any demand of the point/unit being visible to the caster though, that is unique for this bridge. Those spells also have a clear reference to a point on the battlefield, something the bridge is missing. Let's look at the sentence again: "The target unit is immediately removed from the table and replaced anywhere on the battlefield visible to the Wizard". This can be read in a few different ways depending on where to put the emphasise and if you add any short pauses.

A natural pause is needed between the word battlefield and visible. With it there the part "visible to the Wizard" is referring to the unit rather than the battlefield. These are the only two objects in the sentence that the wizard could trace visibility too. To help read this pause a comma could very well have been added, but it is not really necessary.

Without the pause the sentence reads that you can place the unit anywhere on the battlefield, as long as that battlefield is visible to the caster (adding "that is" after battlefield to the sentence makes it easier to see). So the wizard just has to see a little part of the table and you can place it anywhere on that table. There is no reference to any specific part of the battlefield having to be visible, just the battlefield itself. That is the demand. If it is visible you can place it anywhere you like on said battlefield.

I can't see any way of reading that sentence so that it refers to a specific point on the battlefield, but I am quite likely to have missed something I admit.
 
Now that we've discussed it and there is no punctuation in the sentence, my interpretation would be:

1) cast spell
2) pick a spot on the battlefield the wizard can see and immediately move it there, placing the unit as described in the spell. This is because of the line "anywhere on the battlefield visable to the wizard".

Now, I know it seems like steps, but I that sentence is occurring at once and the point they moving to is be qualified is all. The simplest resolution that fulfills the spell's effects is immediately hoping to a place the wizard sees. Get what I'm saying? There is no holding in the void, the whole action is immediately.
 
Like all spells. Once successfully cast you target anywhere legal for the spell and then resolve the effect, it doesn't matter if the point stops being legal part way or at the end of the spell, that isn't when you choose a target.
 
Excellent! I think the general feeling is that a wizard can indeed move his own unit. Many thanks for all the replies, those shadow casting vamps are even more useful now :)
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu