The physical object, if there even is such a thing, is a medium for that conversation, and the direction and nature of that conversation simply isn't something the artist gets to dictate. Neither is the makeup of their audience.
True, artists have no control over how people perceive their art or what they read into it, but the audience really doesn't have any say over what the artist does. And again, the artist isn't "deciding" who the audience is, the audience, (actually, lets say "fans" since it's more appropriate to the point I'm trying to convey. "Audience" is simply whoever
sees it. The "fans" are whoever
likes it.) The artist isn't making a conscious decision who he wants his fans to be. (Some artists do, though. Is their work any better or worse for it? That's subjective.) He simply produces work and the fans are whoever likes it. And that's not (or ever going to be) everyone.
Again, 'art', divorced from relevance and shielded from critique, ceases to even be art.
All art is certainly subjective. But art does not "cease to be art" simply because no one gets to tell the artist that they are doing it wrong.
I think we are starting to argue toward different points,
@Malisteen. You seem to be heading toward how the audience views, interprets, and discusses a work of art, and I'm going toward the notion that,
regardless of how an audience receives a work of art, they don't have any place to insist their views upon the artist if the artist doesn't want them.
That's two different things. People certainly can (and should) critique art, but the artist isn't under any obligation to listen.
It's like someone writing a letter to an artist telling him what they wish he did differently, and the artist telling them, "Sorry, but the painting is already finished. You are welcome to enjoy it or not enjoy it as you see fit, and your concerns won't be taken into consideration next time because I paint what I want to paint, not what you would like me to paint. That's why I didn't consult you when painting the first one."
(Sure, that would be a dick move, but that's not the point.)
In that example, the viewer/writer is certainly a member of "the audience" but perhaps not the
intended audience, and certainly not a fan. And it's not the artist's job to
make him a fan. And he doesn't
cease to be an artist because he doesn't listen to unsolicited criticism.
We can rag on Rob Liefeld all day but he's never going to draw correct anatomy. That doesn't make what he does "not art" simply because he refuses to make corrections.
But like I said above, Mal, I think I'm talking about the artist's
obligation to listen (or lack therof), and you're talking about people's
right to have the conversation. To which I'm saying that the artist doesn't necessarily need to be
part of that conversation. Some artists will and some artists won't. How that affects their future work is subjective at best.
What the creator wants ceases to be the defining feature of a work the minute it leaves their hand, and the creator who seek to dictate meaning to their audience rather than create it with them is failing as an artist altogether.
What the viewer wants is only relevant if the creator
cares what they want. And I guess that depends on what's trying to be accomplished. Some creators will simply produce a work and say "here. Take it or leave it." (Not everyone has that kind of freedom, though, and sure artists that exist in a vacuum might be missing out on potential to grow.)
If you think dictating meaning to their audience is "failing" as an artist, let's take films as an example: Because that's
exactly what film directors do. They tell the audience what they are supposed to be feeling at any given moment through the use of music, lighting, camera angle, even the orientation and direction of the protagonist as he moves through the frame. If people feel sad when ET gets back on the space ship [SPOILER ALERT:tongue:] it's because Steven Spielberg
wanted the audience to feel sad. Some filmmakers do it better than others, some are very subtle with it, and some are egregious with it to the point of losing or muddling the tone they're trying to convey.
But by manipulating the audience's emotions, effectively "telling" them how they're supposed to feel, the director hasn't failed. The exact opposite; if it works and you don't notice it, the director has actually done his job perfectly.
In a post-post modern, information-economy world, the dialog between creator and audience, conversation within the audience, that is the art. The physical object, if there even is such a thing, is a medium for that conversation, and the direction and nature of that conversation simply isn't something the artist gets to dictate. Neither is the makeup of their audience.
I'd say that the "art" isn't
the discussion about what the artist creates. It's the creation itself. Sure, that creation may be born out of interaction with an audience, but without a "physical work," there's no discussion to be had in the first place.
Remember, we're not collaborators with GW, we're customers. We're not clients, either. Clients get to work with a producer to get the product that the client wants. Customers
buy what the producer sells, but don't necessarily get to dictate what the producer
makes. Sure they can speak with their wallets and effect change, but that's not necessarily deciding what the product should be. It's usually finding a different product that has what they want, to the detriment of the initial product's sales. If sales are low enough, maybe they'll try something different or have a discussion with their audience about what they would like. But that lends itself differently to different mediums. Generally speaking, "creative" works don't ask for help from their audience because it's
their story to tell or message to convey, not the audience's.
People review, critique, and discuss Steven King books. But I'm pretty sure Steven King doesn't collaborate with his fans about what he's going to put in his next book. If he did, then it wouldn't really be a Steven King book, would it? It would be a book by Steven King and Co. If people don't like Steven King books, that's fine, he writes them for the people who
do like them.
That's really all I can say about the whole "artist versus audience" debate this has turned into. Back on topic:
In the case of GW, they are creating a specific setting (and I'm giving them the benefit of the doubt that there are still creative people who care about the product, and not just a bunch of corporate suits trying to maximize profits). And that setting is based on medieval archetypes. And medieval archetypes were mostly
patriarchal archetypes. Women in the Warhammer game are
about as represented as women throughout real-world medieval history.
Sure, GW is trying to broaden their customer base with the new game, but they apparently aren't going to do that at the expense of changing the fictional "medieval analog' setting that they want to create.
I guess I just see the argument for adding more female models into the Warhammer setting as akin to me complaining that there aren't enough explosions in romantic comedies. I mean why not? They might draw me in as a fan of romantic comedies if there were more explosions and action. But it's pointless for me to make that argument because that's not what romantic comedies
are supposed to be. They have their fan base and that's not me, and that's okay. Same with Warhammer. If people want more women, they might be better served looking for a setting where women are more prevalent than trying to change the medieval fantasy setting that GW has worked very hard to establish. Just because the world exploded and new realms were created doesn't necessarily mean that the patriarchal politics have evolved. Not unless GW decides that they have because it fits the story they're trying to tell. (If noting else, GW has (arguably) demonstrated that they are not concerned with what their customers want.)
Hell, if they were
genuinely concerned about increasing their market share, they'd shitcan tabletop gaming altogether and turn WFB and
40K into video games exclusively (forget adding more
female models; just drop the
need for any models at all). More people will sit and play video games for hours on end than will sit patiently painting miniatures for the same number of hours. Like, millions more. And with millions of opponents immediately, anywhere, anytime. But GW is not eliminating that
much larger barrier to entry because they still want to produce a game that involves building and painting models and playing by rolling dice. That also caters to a
very specific niche market. No assumptions to whether it is male or female, the market is simply
people who like spending countless hours painting miniatures and then playing games with them.