Female models in Warhammer

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Are you really that stupid? There are already LOTS of female models and that's more than enough. MORE than you could digest. WH SHOULD not be turning female and I believe it will not. You personally can sit at home instead of your woman and let her fight instead of you, but in the normal world it's nonsense.

It's not "instead of" but "alongside". War is war, it's neither masculine nor feminine, men and women are equally capable of being violent and psychotic, equally capable of killing, equally capable of bravery, courage, mental discipline, physical strength and martial prowess, equally capable of everything. Women just tend to look prettier while doing it. xD

You think it's nonsense? You should look around and see how many female heroes there are in the real world. Since you live in Germany, the leader of your country is a woman, and as such you of all people should see that women are just as capable as men.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: owain_b
Wow, so heavily disagree. I do not for one minute believe that the sculptors were thinking this.

Far more likely they were given a brief on Slaanesh, who encompasses both masculine and feminine qualities, and that he/she/it is the god of excess, most commonly explored through the theme of lust and debauchery.

"which are obviously modelled after the stereotypical idea of what an evil, promiscuous sex fiend is like." is a sentence I could agree with.

Let's be truthful here, the general stereotypical image of homosexual people in mainstream media is that of a promiscuous sex fiend. Also the Daemons in general are based on Christianity anyway. The two are strongly linked. Maybe I should have worded it differently, but I'm not condemning GW's daemonettes. I just think it could have been a little bit better executed. But definitely the concept of Slaanesh is based on a conservative-minded person's idea of the whole affair, but exaggerated and made abstract and put into a fantasy world.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menkeroth
It's not "instead of" but "alongside". War is war, it's neither masculine nor feminine, men and women are equally capable of being violent and psychotic, equally capable of killing, equally capable of bravery, courage, mental discipline, physical strength and martial prowess, equally capable of everything. Women just tend to look prettier while doing it. xD
I don't argue that. I'm just trying to say it's not normal - in all times, when women went to war alongside men, it was a sign that the things were going VERY bad. Just this, especially considering that in WHFB women fight alongside men not only in the elvish realms and they have more than it needs to be.
You think it's nonsense? You should look around and see how many female heroes there are in the real world. Since you live in Germany, the leader of your country is a woman, and as such you of all people should see that women are just as capable as men.
Aye, fair point, and I don't neither deny nor argue that. But in WHFB they are more than present and it suffices.
 
I don't argue that. I'm just trying to say it's not normal - in all times, when women went to war alongside men, it was a sign that the things were going VERY bad. Just this, especially considering that in WHFB women fight alongside men not only in the elvish realms and they have more than it needs to be.

Aye, fair point, and I don't neither deny nor argue that. But in WHFB they are more than present and it suffices.

Yes, in the past that's how things were done. But in modern armies women fight alongside the men, and not only that, but they also allow homosexual, transgender and any sex/gender to join and fight. Not that I agree with people joining the army in the first place but whatever, my point still stands, times have changed, this is the 21st century.
 
Warhammer isn't about ancient times. Remember, they went through an entire enlightened age before getting to this point. Their history is likely longer than ours.

It's also not historical to begin with, it's a fantasy. 'women in the kitchen' is not a viable or supportable fantasy in the real world today.
 
Warhammer isn't about ancient times. Remember, they went through an entire enlightened age before getting to this point. Their history is likely longer than ours.
It likely is, but I'd not match this world with ours anyway.
It's also not historical to begin with, it's a fantasy. 'women in the kitchen' is not a viable or supportable fantasy in the real world today.
It depends on a country, don't you think?
 
Care to cite evidence? I don't see that at all. Except the Bloodthirster is fairly modern-red-Devil, but let's face it, they were just ripping off the Balrogs the same way TSR did with the Balor demons.

It's not about evidence, it's an observation. They have a very strong "Seven Deadly Sins" vibe to them. Slaanesh represents many of them, but the others do too. Lust, greed, envy, pride, vainglory, all these are represented in Slaanesh. Khorne has Wrath and Pride going on. Nurgle is Sloth and gluttony and acedia (apathy), Tzeentch is again pride, and a few of the others. The Warp is based on Hell, and the Gods of Chaos are like Satan but divided into 4 separate entities.

The Warp has different realms or layers, like in Dante's Divine Comedy, where Hell is shown as having many levels each representing different sins or evils, as does the Warp. The Chaos Gods seek to destroy the mortal world, just as mythological demons and Lucifer are shown as wanting to destroy God's children (humans) to spite and insult God, although in Warhammer there is no God type figure, although in 40k there's the Emperor and I suppose Sigmar is now like the Christian God with his angelic warriors etc.

Then of course you have strong influence from Doom, with the whole cyber-demon style and parallel dimensions etc.

I would have thought it fairly obvious that it's based on Christianity.
 
Are you really that stupid? There are already LOTS of female models and that's more than enough. MORE than you could digest. WH SHOULD not be turning female and I believe it will not. You personally can sit at home instead of your woman and let her fight instead of you, but in the normal world it's nonsense.

One of the most deeply insulting posts I've read on here, you are a disgrace.

Leaving this thread because I'll only end up getting moderated.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Undying Scourge
No, Menk. I don't think that.
And you should. Or you don't respect the islamic or asian way of thinking? You think you're cleverer than them? I doubt it honestly.
And if you're not trying to match the AoS world with ours, stop trying to use real world historical gender roles as your main supporting argument.
If you have better ideas than to be based on our experience and history, let me know.
 
The physical object, if there even is such a thing, is a medium for that conversation, and the direction and nature of that conversation simply isn't something the artist gets to dictate. Neither is the makeup of their audience.

True, artists have no control over how people perceive their art or what they read into it, but the audience really doesn't have any say over what the artist does. And again, the artist isn't "deciding" who the audience is, the audience, (actually, lets say "fans" since it's more appropriate to the point I'm trying to convey. "Audience" is simply whoever sees it. The "fans" are whoever likes it.) The artist isn't making a conscious decision who he wants his fans to be. (Some artists do, though. Is their work any better or worse for it? That's subjective.) He simply produces work and the fans are whoever likes it. And that's not (or ever going to be) everyone.

Again, 'art', divorced from relevance and shielded from critique, ceases to even be art.

All art is certainly subjective. But art does not "cease to be art" simply because no one gets to tell the artist that they are doing it wrong.

I think we are starting to argue toward different points, @Malisteen. You seem to be heading toward how the audience views, interprets, and discusses a work of art, and I'm going toward the notion that, regardless of how an audience receives a work of art, they don't have any place to insist their views upon the artist if the artist doesn't want them.

That's two different things. People certainly can (and should) critique art, but the artist isn't under any obligation to listen.

It's like someone writing a letter to an artist telling him what they wish he did differently, and the artist telling them, "Sorry, but the painting is already finished. You are welcome to enjoy it or not enjoy it as you see fit, and your concerns won't be taken into consideration next time because I paint what I want to paint, not what you would like me to paint. That's why I didn't consult you when painting the first one." (Sure, that would be a dick move, but that's not the point.)

In that example, the viewer/writer is certainly a member of "the audience" but perhaps not the intended audience, and certainly not a fan. And it's not the artist's job to make him a fan. And he doesn't cease to be an artist because he doesn't listen to unsolicited criticism.

We can rag on Rob Liefeld all day but he's never going to draw correct anatomy. That doesn't make what he does "not art" simply because he refuses to make corrections.

But like I said above, Mal, I think I'm talking about the artist's obligation to listen (or lack therof), and you're talking about people's right to have the conversation. To which I'm saying that the artist doesn't necessarily need to be part of that conversation. Some artists will and some artists won't. How that affects their future work is subjective at best.

What the creator wants ceases to be the defining feature of a work the minute it leaves their hand, and the creator who seek to dictate meaning to their audience rather than create it with them is failing as an artist altogether.

What the viewer wants is only relevant if the creator cares what they want. And I guess that depends on what's trying to be accomplished. Some creators will simply produce a work and say "here. Take it or leave it." (Not everyone has that kind of freedom, though, and sure artists that exist in a vacuum might be missing out on potential to grow.)

If you think dictating meaning to their audience is "failing" as an artist, let's take films as an example: Because that's exactly what film directors do. They tell the audience what they are supposed to be feeling at any given moment through the use of music, lighting, camera angle, even the orientation and direction of the protagonist as he moves through the frame. If people feel sad when ET gets back on the space ship [SPOILER ALERT:tongue:] it's because Steven Spielberg wanted the audience to feel sad. Some filmmakers do it better than others, some are very subtle with it, and some are egregious with it to the point of losing or muddling the tone they're trying to convey.

But by manipulating the audience's emotions, effectively "telling" them how they're supposed to feel, the director hasn't failed. The exact opposite; if it works and you don't notice it, the director has actually done his job perfectly.

In a post-post modern, information-economy world, the dialog between creator and audience, conversation within the audience, that is the art. The physical object, if there even is such a thing, is a medium for that conversation, and the direction and nature of that conversation simply isn't something the artist gets to dictate. Neither is the makeup of their audience.

I'd say that the "art" isn't the discussion about what the artist creates. It's the creation itself. Sure, that creation may be born out of interaction with an audience, but without a "physical work," there's no discussion to be had in the first place.

Remember, we're not collaborators with GW, we're customers. We're not clients, either. Clients get to work with a producer to get the product that the client wants. Customers buy what the producer sells, but don't necessarily get to dictate what the producer makes. Sure they can speak with their wallets and effect change, but that's not necessarily deciding what the product should be. It's usually finding a different product that has what they want, to the detriment of the initial product's sales. If sales are low enough, maybe they'll try something different or have a discussion with their audience about what they would like. But that lends itself differently to different mediums. Generally speaking, "creative" works don't ask for help from their audience because it's their story to tell or message to convey, not the audience's.

People review, critique, and discuss Steven King books. But I'm pretty sure Steven King doesn't collaborate with his fans about what he's going to put in his next book. If he did, then it wouldn't really be a Steven King book, would it? It would be a book by Steven King and Co. If people don't like Steven King books, that's fine, he writes them for the people who do like them.


That's really all I can say about the whole "artist versus audience" debate this has turned into. Back on topic:

In the case of GW, they are creating a specific setting (and I'm giving them the benefit of the doubt that there are still creative people who care about the product, and not just a bunch of corporate suits trying to maximize profits). And that setting is based on medieval archetypes. And medieval archetypes were mostly patriarchal archetypes. Women in the Warhammer game are about as represented as women throughout real-world medieval history.

Sure, GW is trying to broaden their customer base with the new game, but they apparently aren't going to do that at the expense of changing the fictional "medieval analog' setting that they want to create.

I guess I just see the argument for adding more female models into the Warhammer setting as akin to me complaining that there aren't enough explosions in romantic comedies. I mean why not? They might draw me in as a fan of romantic comedies if there were more explosions and action. But it's pointless for me to make that argument because that's not what romantic comedies are supposed to be. They have their fan base and that's not me, and that's okay. Same with Warhammer. If people want more women, they might be better served looking for a setting where women are more prevalent than trying to change the medieval fantasy setting that GW has worked very hard to establish. Just because the world exploded and new realms were created doesn't necessarily mean that the patriarchal politics have evolved. Not unless GW decides that they have because it fits the story they're trying to tell. (If noting else, GW has (arguably) demonstrated that they are not concerned with what their customers want.)

Hell, if they were genuinely concerned about increasing their market share, they'd shitcan tabletop gaming altogether and turn WFB and 40K into video games exclusively (forget adding more female models; just drop the need for any models at all). More people will sit and play video games for hours on end than will sit patiently painting miniatures for the same number of hours. Like, millions more. And with millions of opponents immediately, anywhere, anytime. But GW is not eliminating that much larger barrier to entry because they still want to produce a game that involves building and painting models and playing by rolling dice. That also caters to a very specific niche market. No assumptions to whether it is male or female, the market is simply people who like spending countless hours painting miniatures and then playing games with them.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Menkeroth
@Undying Scourge No evidence = no argument. Because science. Most of those points you make come from media--though admittedly entrenched media like Dante--but not from religious texts. That's all I needed. Thanks for clarifying your position, though I respectfully disagree with it. Cheers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menkeroth
It's not about evidence, it's an observation. They have a very strong "Seven Deadly Sins" vibe to them. Slaanesh represents many of them, but the others do too. Lust, greed, envy, pride, vainglory, all these are represented in Slaanesh. Khorne has Wrath and Pride going on. Nurgle is Sloth and gluttony and acedia (apathy), Tzeentch is again pride, and a few of the others. The Warp is based on Hell, and the Gods of Chaos are like Satan but divided into 4 separate entities.

The Warp has different realms or layers, like in Dante's Divine Comedy, where Hell is shown as having many levels each representing different sins or evils, as does the Warp. The Chaos Gods seek to destroy the mortal world, just as mythological demons and Lucifer are shown as wanting to destroy God's children (humans) to spite and insult God, although in Warhammer there is no God type figure, although in 40k there's the Emperor and I suppose Sigmar is now like the Christian God with his angelic warriors etc.

Then of course you have strong influence from Doom, with the whole cyber-demon style and parallel dimensions etc.

I would have thought it fairly obvious that it's based on Christianity.

Yeah totally agree with this, I think most ideas of demons and devils come from one religion or another. I never really thought of the chaos gods with the 7 deadly sins in mind, but now I think of it, it really fits :)

@Adam_Barrow where do you think Tolkien got the idea of the balrog from ;)
 
@owain_b He certainly didn't get it from x'tian religious texts. Nowhere is Lucifer the Deceiver described as a creature of shadow and flame (with or without wings ;) ). Though I wager the basic form was shaped by later writings /about/ the x'tian Devil.

And that's my main point. The popular look for the Devil is not given in the x'tian bible. That came much later from popular writing. That's a simple thing to google for verification. If anything, Lucifer more closely resembles Professor Tolkien's description of the Maiar Sauron, first cloaked as a glorious angelic figure to deceive the Numenoreans and Celembrimbor the forger of the Rings of Power.

Pardon me if I sound wordy, please. I'm a scholar of both mythologies, both Judeo-Christian and Middle-Earth.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menkeroth
Leaving this thread because I'll only end up getting moderated.

Speak of the devil. Although you guys did literally speak of the devil o.o

In either case, there are some posts here that could be more considerate. Try to keep it civil guys. This goes for @Menkeroth and a few others.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Adam_Barrow
@owain_b He certainly didn't get it from x'tian religious texts. Nowhere is Lucifer the Deceiver described as a creature of shadow and flame (with or without wings ;) ). Though I wager the basic form was shaped by later writings /about/ the x'tian Devil.

And that's my main point. The popular look for the Devil is not given in the x'tian bible. That came much later from popular writing. That's a simple thing to google for verification. If anything, Lucifer more closely resembles Professor Tolkien's description of the Maiar Sauron, first cloaked as a glorious angelic figure to deceive the Numenoreans and Celembrimbor the forger of the Rings of Power.

Pardon me if I sound wordy, please. I'm a scholar of both mythologies, both Judeo-Christian and Middle-Earth.

You don't need evidence when talking about something as ridiculous as religion. Because as soon as someone asks for evidence when you start criticising their faith you are putting yourself on a slippery slope into their bullcrap, and it's ironic when they ask for evidence when religion itself is baseless myth.

Also maybe the actual look of the devil isn't in the bible, but it was certainly implied. Hell is described as a realm of fire and suffering.

Matthew 13:50New International Version (NIV)
...and throw them into the blazing furnace, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth.

Which is exactly what the Warp is.

Also, you call my argument bullshit but you put Christianity on a pedestal as being above media when it is only a form of media itself. That's quite silly. So is Tolkien. It doesn't matter if it's the "popular look" it's the most well known look and it is inspired by the bible and heavily linked to the bible, as such it is the prime inspiration for the look of many of the daemons in Warhammer.

The whole idea of daemons and devils comes from catholic Christianity anyway. The appearance of Satan in pop culture comes from faith. The belief in God and the belief that Satan is the enemy makes any believer want to make Satan look inhuman and monstrous so that they can show everyone how bad and frightening he is supposed to be. Daemons in Warhammer are a representation of the holdover beliefs from the medieval period, the "old enemies" of the old faith.

Though religion is dying out in Europe it's still very strong in the USA, and in Europe although people are not overtly christian or religious very much (although there are definitely a lot of crazy religious people here) the toxic, insidious messages in religious texts influence many people's views and beliefs and determine what they think is right and wrong, it's where the idea of morals come from, and many laws, but these christian virtues have been translated into social policies which were implemented in the Victorian era and before that still exist today. Because of these laws and the fact that many people are brought up with pseudo-religious teachings you get a society that has a strong double-standard.
 
Yeah totally agree with this, I think most ideas of demons and devils come from one religion or another. I never really thought of the chaos gods with the 7 deadly sins in mind, but now I think of it, it really fits :)

@Adam_Barrow where do you think Tolkien got the idea of the balrog from ;)
The idea of Chaos and Order with gods and the like is more ancient than the world itself. Christianity and other monotheistic religions didn't invent it, they copied and mutated it. Nothing more.
And what's more, the idea of different realms in Age of Sigmar comes not from christianity or the like but from the Scandinavian mythology (or Indian or Japanese, if you like). And it looks like it is exactly so.
 
@Infernal Skull -

I'm not dictating what GW has to do though. And I never claimed I was? I merely expressed a reaction to the work they produced, as a product, as an introduction to their new game, and as representation of its direction. That reaction was simply "I wish there had been some overtly female figures here". Not "I am going to go to GW and hold a gun to their head until they recall AoS and put out a new box that has some".

A clever and effective film production - not just director, because films have hundreds of people working on them and the director isn't even always the most important creative presence among them - gets the audience to feel what they wanted them to feel - but the audience still does the feeling. The audience still chooses that reaction. That's what I mean by creators creating the art with their audience, not dictating it to them. The audience is allowed to, and often does, react in some other way, positive or negative, and when directors can't handle audiences reacting in unexpected ways, when they throw little public tantrums because audiences didn't 'get it' we rightfully mock them.

In the past, where communication between artist and audience was difficult, and works were individual and isolated, that's all there was, but this is not the past. This is the now. Communication is easy, instantaneous, and omnidirectional. The artist can see what the audience does with their work and respond to it in future work or even within the same piece, and that is so powerful and revolutionary a tool that refusing to take advantage of it, refusing to explore and exploit its possibilities, just feels deliberately backwards. And from the Denny's tumblr to Ryan Reynolds' deadpool movie tweets, corporations today get that. Independent auteurs get that, too - Andrew Hussie's forum posts, forumspring and tumblr and twitter accounts, are as much a part of homestuck as the fanart that he's incorporated into the panels of the comic itself.

And part of that rising tide of audience participation is the rise of audiences that creators never envisioned in the first place, the increasing presence of the non-straight or non-white or non-male fan in the previously straight-white-cis-male space, whether via welcomed invitation or subversive infiltration, and this, too, creators and corporate funders are beginning to openly adopt, with varying degrees of success and elegance admittedly. But as the budgets of mainstream film and game products continue to balloon, they find they can no longer afford to limit their productions to a single target demo, and you know what? I find the products as a whole benefit from this more than they suffer. Pacific Rim was not 'watered down' for its international focus and diverse cast. The Marvel movies owe a large share of their ticket sales to non-straight-male audiences appreciative of interesting female characters like Black Widow and 'female-gaze' shots of some of the male stars, who yes are occasionally filmed as objects of attraction and not just power fantasies, and again I feel the films benefit from that on the whole, though I don't want to heap too much praise on Disney/Marvel here, since we still haven't seen them put out a movie that didn't have a Straight White Dude as the main viewpoint character

Female geeks, non-white geeks, anything out side of the 'teen to late 20s straight white male upper-middle' demo, that is the future of our community. That is where the growth is, and those are where the most interesting, previously untapped new voices - both as audiences and as creators - are to be found. And yeah, I'd characterize a failure to openly embrace that as a mistake worthy of criticism in GW's new Age of Sigmar starter box offering. Not a fatal flaw, surely. Not damning. Didn't stop me from picking up a box, and it won't stop me from liking or playing the game. Just another area I feel had room for improvement, much as I criticize the game rules for its handling of bases.

I critique the things I like, the things I don't like aren't generally worth my time.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Undying Scourge
@Undying Scourge Man, you just could not have swung any wider than what you just said. Not the least of which by calling me a x'tian apologist.

My own religious views (spoilers: I have none) were purposefully left out because I was interested in the textual basis for your claim. You've already established there is none, so to me we're done here.

And just as an aside, you need to chill man. I'm the last person who would be defensive about religious mythology, because I'm a scientist. I literally laughed out loud at you for that. So congrats, you've run another person out of what started as a civil conversation. You've a knack for that, apparently. Good day.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Menkeroth
@Undying Scourge Man, you just could not have swung any wider than what you just said. Not the least of which by calling me a x'tian apologist.

My own religious views (spoilers: I have none) were purposefully left out because I was interested in the textual basis for your claim. You've already established there is none, so to me we're done here.

And just as an aside, you need to chill man. I'm the last person who would be defensive about religious mythology, because I'm a scientist. I literally laughed out loud at you for that. So congrats, you've run another person out of what started as a civil conversation. You've a knack for that, apparently. Good day.

How am I supposed to know that? I don't know you, all I have to go on is what you said in your post and it seemed to me that you were apologising for it. You're being very unreasonable and overreacting. Also please don't call me "man". You're a scientist, fine, but I didn't know that so what do you expect? Too much it seems.
 
This should be indicative enough. Now get the last word after this post so you can feel better and the whole thing can be put behind us. All hail the Report Post feature.

You have a problem. You've completely derailed this thread to provoke me so you can report me for stepping on your toes. You started this argument, not me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu