Flying Black Coach tactical wheel in charge?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Grish

Liche
True Blood
Oct 11, 2007
5,319
Winnipeg, MB
Zombies
2,624
Hi,

Chariots can make a tactical wheel when they charge (for charging a lone character for example, or a group of skirmishers [I believe, not positive]).

Fliers make a straight charge, there is no tactical wheel.

Can a flying black coach make a tactical wheel when it charges? I believe this would fall under the same rules as Bretonnian flying cavalry.

Thanks,
Grish
 
Why would it matter? The only reason a chariot would wheel after going straight is to get around something in it's way. Being flying and ethereal, you wouldn't care. If you can see the target to declare a charge, you simply fly over/through any units and terrain until you reach base to base with your target (or reach 20" for a failed charge).

In any case I think the short answer is: You charge as a flyer if you use your flight move, or you can wheel if you use ground movement.
 
It absolutely does matter. Consider the following:

_BC
_BC
_BC

EEEEE
EEEEE
EEEEE
__W


BC = Black Coach
E = Enemy RnF unit
W = Enemy wizard

The Black Coach wishes to charge the enemy Wizard.
If the black coach cannot tactically wheel, even though it can see the wizard (as the Black Coach is on a hill), it cannot charge as there is no room to land it.

There are lots of reasons for a tactical wheel, such as wanting to pursue into another unit, or force the unit to flee in a particular direction, or protect your Black Coach from a counter charge.

I would agree with your interpretation of using type of movement to determine if a Tactical wheel can be done.
 
Yes, you can indeed tactically wheel- or rather, pivot in the case of a chariot or monster... with some bizarre consequences sometimes. Pivot once during the charge, but remember, if you don't choose to pivot for the charge at the very start of the charge, then you must move it straight forward (until you wish to use your pivot). So if your Coach is facing directly south, you couldn't pivot it to face southeast and then switch it to southwest after 10" of charge.
 
The Black Coach, if it gets the flying power, makes it a Flier and a Chariot which have different rules for charging.

Is there any way in which one takes preference?
 
I think the fliers rule does force it to charge directly at its opponent actually, which would hamper such plans (For some reason I started writing that last post thinking about a flying black coach, went and looked at something else, came back and forgot you were explicitly talking about a flying coach, hehe).
 
grishnakh99 said:
The Black Coach wishes to charge the enemy Wizard.
If the black coach cannot tactically wheel, even though it can see the wizard (as the Black Coach is a large model), it cannot charge as there is no room to land it.

The black coach isn't a large target anymore, check your book.
 
If I remember correctly, the BRB states than when a charger don't fit well, the charged unit then must move in order to place the charge unit. So if your coach don't fit, the wizard must move back in order to allow the charge. Or I'm wrong?
 
I think you're wrong. That was the whole premise of the 'bunkered' necromancers from 6th edition (using 7th edition BRB rules). They would hide behind a larger unit, but so close that no unit could charge it from the front as there is no room.
 
Grish is correct. In this example, if the charger can not fit in the landing do to the size of the model. It's a failed charge.
 
Grish is correct. In this example, if the charger can not fit in the landing do to the size of the model. It's a failed charge.

I would be very interested where it says this in the rules... could you provide a rules quote or even a page number?

I do know that if the charger is unable to fit, due to interfering models or terrain, you may move the charged unit. Also, there is the line that goes if a model can not charge a unit without hitting another unit, usually because they are flush, you can charge both.
 
You can only charge both if they are to the front. The problem he is talking about is say, for example, a war machine is between 2 blocks of infantry, 2 inches 'deeper' then the front of the infantry models. The distance between the 2 blocks is 35mm. A 50mm wide chariot could not charge the war machine because there isn't enough room between the blocks to reach base to base, thus would be a failed charge. They go half their distance. In the case of a flier, it would go up to infantry blocks, center to center of warmachine, and stop 1" away from the blocks. This is assuming the blocks are within 20" of where you declared the charge.

In the main rule book FAQ, it says,
"The Failed Charge rules on page 21 state that a unit
may fail a charge because ‘the enemy has fled out of
reach, or if you have estimated your charge incorrectly’.
This includes situations when a unit declares a charge
and then finds out that the charge cannot be completed
for reasons other than enemy in the way (e.g. not enough
space to squeeze through terrain, friendly units blocking
the way, and so on). In such cases, the charge is failed,
and the charging unit must stop in contact with the
friendly unit or impassable terrain blocking its way,, or
inside the difficult terrain slowing it down, etc. Note that
the charge reaction declared by the enemy still stands.
 
DevianID said:
Grish is correct. In this example, if the charger can not fit in the landing do to the size of the model. It's a failed charge.

I would be very interested where it says this in the rules... could you provide a rules quote or even a page number?

I do know that if the charger is unable to fit, due to interfering models or terrain, you may move the charged unit. Also, there is the line that goes if a model can not charge a unit without hitting another unit, usually because they are flush, you can charge both.


I would like to thank Reincus for posting the rule.

I would like to see the rule that says that I have to move my unit so the charger can reach me...:| How long have you played VC? The whole idea of the zombie bunker was to make sure nothing could reach, ie land betwen your units to attack our necros, vamps or whatever we wanted to protect.

-----
l l
l l
-----



sssss
sssss
sssss
sssss
zznzz
zzzzz
zzzzz
zzzzz

Flyer, large target so he can see over skeletons, wants to attack necromancer. Since he can't land, and no rules that I know of that say I have to move my unit to make room for him, hence he can't land. Failed charge. He stops 1" in front of skeletons.
 
This problem is old. Can flying large targets - say a dragon - tactical wheel 180 degrees to kill the necro and overrun into the rear of the unit? Most sensible persons say no, because if you fly past the closest part of the target (in order to fit in your charger), you're not flying in a straight line.
 
Yup, and goes back to what I said earlier.

If the chariot moves on the ground it can tactically wheel. If it's absorbed 6 dice already he's ethereal, so can ignore terrian and such, just has a range of 16 in and can't move over units.

If the chariot makes a flight move to charge then it has to go straight.
 
That is true, but we're considering a situation where you want to charge a Skirmishing model, in which case you can zoom forwards, pivot and hit them from the other side :D
 
ArchMagosAlchemys said:
Remember too that you must hit a unit in the same arc as you started, so you could never fly over a unit and 'wheel' to hit it in the rear. If you start in the front arc, you must charge into the front arc.
Let me remind you that single man-sized models on foot (skirmishers) have no arcs at all.
 
You mean Grishnak's diagram? In that diagram (and what we are talking about), we're referring to a lone Wizard operating outside a unit, but close enough so that a flyer cannot land between him and the unit.
 
e.g. not enough space to squeeze through terrain, friendly units blocking the way, and so on). In such cases, the charge is failed,
and the charging unit must stop in contact with the
friendly unit or impassable terrain blocking its way,, or
inside the difficult terrain slowing it down, etc

The ways a charge could fail, other than the enemy being further than the charge distance of the charging model, is that a friendly unit or impassable terrain block its way, or difficult terrain slows the model down to prevent the charge.

Before going into my point, I want to add that it does not state that a charge is stopped because of enemy models blocking their way--this falls under the enemy in the way and the chargers can of course charge the enemy in the way.

OK, so my point here is two fold. First, not being able to fit your charging model due to an enemy unit does not cause the charge to fail... impassable terrain, friendly models, and insufficient distance are the reasons a charge can fail--add to that the rules that state you can move the charged unit if you can reach the enemy but cant rank up, either because of models or impassable terrain..
Second, flying models ignore all terrain, including impassable, and friendly and enemy models when charging. Thus, each reason listed that can cause a charge to fail other than not having the distance is avoided by flying models, as nothing blocks their way.

I see where the confusion comes from, but other than blocking LOS or putting models in units there is no way to protect something from a flyer that I have found.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu