Forbidden Lore, FAQ and... General?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.

Demian

Vampire Count
True Blood
Oct 28, 2011
1,245
Zombies
1,274
Hey all. I was browsing to see if any new FAQs had been released.

Sadly, no =(

However, when the pdf was loading, it stopped in the question regarding "A Vampire or a Vampire Lord being unable to choose Lore of Vampires... but still being the General of the army"

I was struck with this:

The text reads:

"If a Vampire or Vampire Lord is unable to choose the Lore of the Vampires as their spell lore (due to the Wizarding Hat for example) but is still the wizard with the highest leadership in the army, must he still be the army's General?
- Yes"

Now... I know we closed this issue long ago, but I failed to recall if this argument was made:

Vampires (hero Vampires, I mean) cannot take the Wizarding Hat... so why include them in the whole text? Also, why not Master Necromancers too, since they also could equip the Hat?

This is too much of a mess here, yet... couldn't this mean there must be a way for a Hero-Vampire to not have a choice regarding his Lore and still be the army's General?

In other words, doesn't this FAQ (from.. more than a year ago) clears any Vampire that can purchase Forbidden Lore to use spells NOT from LoV, and as any other wizard?

Thoughts?

:D
 
FAQs are written to cover any eventuality - at least to the best ability of the writer (let's not have that argument here?).

One result of this is that they try to be broad, mentioning, for example, hero-level Vampires even though there is currently no way to remove the Lore of Vampires from their options.
 
There is a way.
Forbidden lore.
I know..... There we go again. But this faq kinda gives room for the interpretation.
You lord has a vampiric ability (which is innate to that character) that gives acces to other lores. Due to that he is unable to choose the LoV, even though he should by default take it as the general. thus the faq reads, if he is for some reason unable to take LoV he is still the general due to highest ld.

The whole Forbidden Lore ability has so far been quite irrelevant due to thinking that it is not allowed on your general. giving acces to the skill only to heros or in very largepoint games (which is absurd).
This faq kinda opens up and grants you the forbidden lore (its not called forbidden for fun, it seems to be appropriate to the ruling that a general is forbidden to have anything else than LoV. yet having the forbidden lore skill grants him the forbidden lores that are forbidden) on your general.

Im happy, finally my vamplord general can go lvl4 lore of beasts/shadow/death etc. (to take shadow or death as general would still require the Forbidden lore ability.)
 
The FAQ is simply accounting for any potential situations that may arise in the future where the choice of lore might be restricted. Currently there is no way other than the wizarding hat for this to occur. The FAQ gives no room for new interpretation (especially considering this is quite an old element)

It has been said many times, forbidden lore does NOT restrict the choices you have available. While it does grant your vampire/vampire lord access to the lores from the BRB, it does not restrict you from choosing the lore of vampires and, then the general must pick it.

the wording is quite clear.

"The vampire can generate his spells from any one of the lores in the warhammer rulebook except the lore of life."

It doesn't say "the vampire generates his spells..." or anything of the like. Even with forbidden lore you have the choice of lore so you MUST choose the lore of vampires.
 
The wording in in the book under Forbidden lore makes it quite clear

"The Vampire can generate his spells from any one of the lores in the warhammer rulebook, except lore of life"

he CAN generate his spells from any, it doesn't say he must, nor that he no longer can use LoV.
 
Like... the wording on how is a spell Cast and Successfully cast, in the same book? Rendering the Dark Acolyte vampiric power useless until a clarification was made.

I do not wish to return to old arguments and counter-arguments here.

I merely wanted to point out that such wording (along with the Vampiric example of the same FAQ which does NOT include Ethereals...) is so poor that one must find the extreme RAW and apply it.


There are many questions here, regarding that FAQ:

Why say Vampire and Vampire Lord, but not Ghoul King? he can also equip the Hat. I can understand why a Necromancer wouldn't ever be able to chance his lore, however... why not a Master Necromancer? He can also equip the Hat.

Now, maybe this is the same example as with Vampiric units. By saying "Vampiric Units can only ever regain 1 wound with IoN" SHOULD include all other of the same ruling, them being Ethereals and Large Targets, however they won't specifically state it because of the obvious.


But GW is never clear D:

What I propose is this: if your particular group would allow such exception to be made in light of that poor wording, then until a FAQ or official response... or anything makes it crystal clear, you could play Forbidden Lore in your General. If you do so, even in a friendly game...

tell us your findings!!! =D

You can't go Red Fury, Quickblood and Forbidden Lore anyways... a SGK would not benefit much from other lores... Master necros can't use that power and it would be nice to have some battle reports with a Master of Black Arts - Forbidden Lore General, see what happens!
 
There are other ways for a vampire hero to not be able to know spells from The LOV, such as: Magical Feedback and the Sword of Spelltheiving. Although the vampire could become a Level 0 wizard, he might still be the wizard with the highest leadership. Especially in lower point games, Vampires are hesitant to take more than one wizard. So even though he may have started out knowing LOV, if he has no spells, he no longer knows the lore.
 
Demian said:
But GW is never clear D:
Objection! This is circular reasoning. "The rule is unclear because GW is unclear, GW is unclear because the rules are unclear."

There's no wiggle-room here: The FAQ refers to when a vampire CAN'T take Lore of Vampires. Forbidden Lore doesn't do that. Perfect clarity.

What I propose is this: if your particular group would allow such exception to be made in light of that poor wording, then until a FAQ or official response... or anything makes it crystal clear, you could play Forbidden Lore in your General. If you do so, even in a friendly game...
Objection! It doesn't matter what your group allows. My group would probably allow me to run Empire Halberdiers as my core if I take Vlad von Carstein, doesn't make it a rule.

And what am I going to do, show up with a Lvl 4 Light caster at a game and say "A bunch of guys on the forum said their group was cool with it."

Also, we have a FAQ on this. You posted it. It doesn't cover the situation, mainly because it's not necessary because this rule actually is clear.
 
While i agree that the rules are pretty clear, where i begin to scratch my head is with the faq. When i read the description for the Wizarding Hat it also uses the world CAN leaving me to think that when i buy that upgrade my vampire is able to choose one of the lov, los or lod spell lore or i can choose to randomly roll for one out of the book. So agin if its my general whith that hat then im still forced to select the vampire lore. Perhaps there is a faq on the description of the hat itself that i didnt see. Im i reading that right?
 
Mmm, yes you still can take LoV, yet my innate skill let me take a Forbidden Lore which make me can choose another lore. As soon as i wield another lore i cannot wield LoV. There is no rule that says i cant, other than that i must take LoV as a general. Yet my innate skill had me choose something else, which is Forbidden. I paid 25 points for that and directly made that general less combat-oriented himself.
Its a trade off and the faq supports that 'for any reason if not possible to take LoV, he is still the general' Since wizarding hat makes no sense since its not even something you can buy, the only thing that actually makes this faq have any sense is the Forbidden Lore skill.


I know a whole lotta people are gonna disagree.
I know its an open argument with just interpretation as a final solution.

Yet this faq makes absolutely no sense whatsoever if the situation is really impossible. Which makes you think why its there in the first place, apparantly it is possible and the only possibility is Forbidden Lore and how described it.
 
Skittelz1981 said:
Mmm, yes you still can take LoV, yet my innate skill let me take a Forbidden Lore which make me can choose another lore. As soon as i wield another lore i cannot wield LoV. There is no rule that says i cant, other than that i must take LoV as a general. Yet my innate skill had me choose something else, which is Forbidden. I paid 25 points for that and directly made that general less combat-oriented himself.
Its a trade off and the faq supports that 'for any reason if not possible to take LoV, he is still the general' Since wizarding hat makes no sense since its not even something you can buy, the only thing that actually makes this faq have any sense is the Forbidden Lore skill.


I know a whole lotta people are gonna disagree.
I know its an open argument with just interpretation as a final solution.

Yet this faq makes absolutely no sense whatsoever if the situation is really impossible. Which makes you think why its there in the first place, apparantly it is possible and the only possibility is Forbidden Lore and how described it.

Well, not really. You already have 2 other lore options, by that logic without it you could just take Shadow and then claim you "cannot" take LoV
 
No since that is not a skill that you pay for that specifically states that its Forbidden. Both shadow and death are part of the Forbidden lores of the BRB. the only way to make your general something else than LoV seems to be the skill, which you will need to buy to access death and shadow as a general.
 
Ok, I really need to make my points clear...er. This whole mess is sprung by GW's wording. Much like the bi... like other books with rules and codes.

But since this turned into a discussion anyways, let's have some solid non-circular non-interpretative arguments! :D!

Under Magic in the Vampire and Vampire Lord's profile reads:
"A Vampire Lord is a level 1 Wizard. He may use spells from one of the following..."

Under Magic in the Necromancer's profile reads:
"A Necromancer is a level 1 wizard. He uses spells from..."

Does this change anything? Well of course not. Both define what lores they use (may or otherwise).


Now, let's go over some dramatic evidence, shall we?

Wood Elves army book, in Spellsingers, under Magic it reads:
"Weavers and Singers are Wizards who use spells from one of the eight Lores of Battle Magic in the wharhammer rulebook. Spellweavers can instead use spells from either the Lore (...)"

In this case (aside than Spellsingers being more limited in their magic lores than Weavers) their wording is rather... specific. It says Battle Magic, or High Magic, or (that's why it says "from either") Dark Magic.


Forbidden Lore reads: "...can generate his spells from any one of the lores in the Warhammer..."
The Vampiric power never reads: "can also generate his spells..."

This, coupled with what Skittelz found in the wording of the Wizarding hat... "who can use a randomly"

SHOULD NOT be viewed as a hard law, but open the possibility for reflection upon the ruling, and maybe allow us to try a Magic-heavy list, so that all of us can share knowledge.
 
"If a Vampire or Vampire Lord is unable to choose the Lore of the Vampires as their spell lore (due to Forbidden Lore for example) but is still the wizard with the highest leadership in the army, must he still be the army's General?
- Yes"


i think the ruling is there to avoid free death/shadowlore generals. forbidden lore makes the exception.
Where normal vamps could take shadow or death freely, they would still require the skill for other battlelores.
The general however must take the skill to be anything else than LoV. which forfeits his position as a true blenderlord somewhat, altho not entirely.
 
But you can. You CAN take LoV. Forbidden Lore gives you more options, but LoV is still an option.

The fact that you have to struggle this much with conjunctions and non-specific implications and comparisons means that this isn't RAW, and compared to a clear RAW you're still stuck with it.
 
Well, I've seen that 40,000 got their updated FAQs in May 27th.

So... let us all hope for a revision of Fantasy as well and soon. AND, let us hope they address this issue here somehow. If they don't, then it will be clear that they want all VC Generals to use LoV, with the only exception of it being Wizarding Hat (since loosing Wizard levels has no effect whatsoever in your VC army selection, upgrades, etc. which are chosen from before playing). Oh, and adding a clarification text like: "The Army's General cannot take this power / would not benefit from this power / gains Loremaster: Vampires"

:D!
 
Here is the problem with this. the Wizarding Hat reads as follow: The wearer is treated as being a level 2 wizard who can usea a randomly chosen spell lore. However, he also has the Stupidity special rule.

Forbidden Lore: The vampire can generate his spells from any one of the lores in the warhammer rulebook, except the lore of life.

The Faq says
Q: if a Vampire or Vampire Lord is unable to chose the lore of vampire as their spell lore (due to the Wizarding Hat for example) but is still the wizard with the highest leadership in the army, must he still be the general. (p26)
A: Yes


Now nowhere in the Wizarding hat wording does it say he cant use the lore of Vampire. It says he can use a randomly chosen spell lore. The question is Why IS THIS QUESTION IN THE FAQ? The wording in both the wizarding hat and Forbidden Lore still gives you the option to take Lore of Vampires.
 
Isn't it that for Forbidden Lore it clearly states the choice of Lores is from the BRB, whereas the wizarding hat vaguely says "randomly chosen spell lore". Now this isn't RAW, but I always assumed those randomly chosen spell lores meant the ones in the BRB in the same way, not AB lores like Nurgle or LoV.
 
jbizzle113 said:
Here is the problem with this. the Wizarding Hat reads as follow: The wearer is treated as being a level 2 wizard who can usea a randomly chosen spell lore. However, he also has the Stupidity special rule.

Forbidden Lore: The vampire can generate his spells from any one of the lores in the warhammer rulebook, except the lore of life.

The Faq says
Q: if a Vampire or Vampire Lord is unable to chose the lore of vampire as their spell lore (due to the Wizarding Hat for example) but is still the wizard with the highest leadership in the army, must he still be the general. (p26)
A: Yes


Now nowhere in the Wizarding hat wording does it say he cant use the lore of Vampire. It says he can use a randomly chosen spell lore. The question is Why IS THIS QUESTION IN THE FAQ? The wording in both the wizarding hat and Forbidden Lore still gives you the option to take Lore of Vampires.

The FAQ states that wizards wearing the Hat can't choose LoV. It isn't the "same wording", because in the case of the Hat it's part of the same sentence describing the source of the Wizard Levels and describing what those Wizard Levels can take.

Forbidden Lore is an entirely different context, so you're not going to be able to prove anything hanging your argument on the word can. If a FAQ comes out later saying otherwise, that's one thing.
If not, then no. And nobody, I mean NOBODY outside of VC are going to buy this argument.
 
RarerMonsters said:
jbizzle113 said:
Here is the problem with this. the Wizarding Hat reads as follow: The wearer is treated as being a level 2 wizard who can usea a randomly chosen spell lore. However, he also has the Stupidity special rule.

Forbidden Lore: The vampire can generate his spells from any one of the lores in the warhammer rulebook, except the lore of life.

The Faq says
Q: if a Vampire or Vampire Lord is unable to chose the lore of vampire as their spell lore (due to the Wizarding Hat for example) but is still the wizard with the highest leadership in the army, must he still be the general. (p26)
A: Yes


Now nowhere in the Wizarding hat wording does it say he cant use the lore of Vampire. It says he can use a randomly chosen spell lore. The question is Why IS THIS QUESTION IN THE FAQ? The wording in both the wizarding hat and Forbidden Lore still gives you the option to take Lore of Vampires.

The FAQ states that wizards wearing the Hat can't choose LoV. It isn't the "same wording", because in the case of the Hat it's part of the same sentence describing the source of the Wizard Levels and describing what those Wizard Levels can take.

Forbidden Lore is an entirely different context, so you're not going to be able to prove anything hanging your argument on the word can. If a FAQ comes out later saying otherwise, that's one thing.
If not, then no. And nobody, I mean NOBODY outside of VC are going to buy this argument.

I'm holding the Faq in my hand and now where does it say he cant take lore of the vampire. I typed the whole Q&A for it, i also give the exact wording for Wizarding hat and Forbidden lore. Can you please show me in the Faq where is says he cant use lore of the Vampire, b/c from what i read is say :if a Vampire or Vampire Lord is unable to chose the lore of vampire as their spell lore (due to the Wizarding Hat for example)
the Wizarding Hat reads as follow: The wearer is treated as being a level 2 wizard who can usea a randomly chosen spell lore. However, he also has the Stupidity special rule.
 
"is unable to chose the lore of vampire as their spell lore (due to the Wizarding Hat for example)"

Keep in mind, GW FAQs are not rule clarifications, they are entirely new rules. What's published in a FAQ doesn't clarify an operation, it establishes a new rule specific to that mention.
 
RarerMonsters said:
"is unable to chose the lore of vampire as their spell lore (due to the Wizarding Hat for example)"

Keep in mind, GW FAQs are not rule clarifications, they are entirely new rules. What's published in a FAQ doesn't clarify an operation, it establishes a new rule specific to that mention.

I see the point your making but my point it that although you take a Wizard hat its ruling still allow you to use lore of the vampire. now it would be crazy to do but you still have that option and that is why i said what i said. Unless the wizarding hat now states you must or have to or something like that in its wording it still say you can chose a randomly chosen lore.
 
jbizzle113 said:
RarerMonsters said:
"is unable to chose the lore of vampire as their spell lore (due to the Wizarding Hat for example)"

Keep in mind, GW FAQs are not rule clarifications, they are entirely new rules. What's published in a FAQ doesn't clarify an operation, it establishes a new rule specific to that mention.

I see the point your making but my point it that although you take a Wizard hat its ruling still allow you to use lore of the vampire. now it would be crazy to do but you still have that option and that is why i said what i said. Unless the wizarding hat now states you must or have to or something like that in its wording it still say you can chose a randomly chosen lore.
That's the point, this FAQ states exactly that. This FAQ is a new rule which makes you unable to take other lores with the Hat.
 
RarerMonsters said:
jbizzle113 said:
RarerMonsters said:
"is unable to chose the lore of vampire as their spell lore (due to the Wizarding Hat for example)"

Keep in mind, GW FAQs are not rule clarifications, they are entirely new rules. What's published in a FAQ doesn't clarify an operation, it establishes a new rule specific to that mention.

I see the point your making but my point it that although you take a Wizard hat its ruling still allow you to use lore of the vampire. now it would be crazy to do but you still have that option and that is why i said what i said. Unless the wizarding hat now states you must or have to or something like that in its wording it still say you can chose a randomly chosen lore.
That's the point, this FAQ states exactly that. This FAQ is a new rule which makes you unable to take other lores with the Hat.

And my point was the FAQ, not the wording of... anything (that came up later in the posts): If the FAQ creates a new rule, then fine, not a probem there. If the FAQ is changing the meaning of the Wizarding Hat from the "can use" to "can (only) use the randomly selected lore..." then..

As with The Vampiric and IoN FAQ, it would include any other effects that alter your Lore options. Same goes for Etherals and IoN. It is not exactly explicit in the FAQs, but everyone knows that if Vampiric Units are affected, Ethereals should be affected as well.

Yet... it doesn't say that exactly. So we run around wasting Forbidden Lore and Raising 1+ Wiz Level Hexwraiths until yet another clarification covers these up.

D:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu