Forbidden Lore, FAQ and... General?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
You can't use a FAQ to assume it changes the meaning of a wording or rules in general, only the thing it refers to.

Case in point: Spirit Leech and Unmodified Leadership.
 
What happens if a Master Necromancer, who happens to be the Wizard with the highest Leadership uses the Wizarding Hat?

He is not covered in the FAQ specifically. Also, the Strigoi Ghoul King.

How...

What...

Why...? D:!
 
Demian said:
What happens if a Master Necromancer, who happens to be the Wizard with the highest Leadership uses the Wizarding Hat?

He is not covered in the FAQ specifically. Also, the Strigoi Ghoul King.

How...

What...

Why...? D:!

If I only take a Wight King he can be my general because he can't take Lore of Vampires.
Where's the FAQ that specifically says otherwise????


When I say extensions, I mean not cases where using the exact same rule would work the exact same way.

The problem is you guys are using intense verbal gymnastics to try to push a rule nowhere mentioned in the FAQ based on a single conjunction used in different context.
 
But... I clearly said that I DIDN'T want make things as I wanted, bending the rules (of Warhammer and Grammar) to gain advantage.

I said that like 3 times. Any further words towards the subject are unnecessary, thank you.


As for my question, you know it cannot be answered by your statement "FAQs create new entries that only modify a specific rule"

(Also, there IS a part where it says non-Wizards can't be Generals...)


I started this post to bring some light in this whole mess. The wording seemed funny to me and wanted to try a new perspective of it. In the end, there are several things that can't be concluded because the lack of proper wording:

- Vampires and Vampire Lords who can't choose LoV can still be the Generals. Necromancers are not explained.
- Vampiric Units can't regain more than 1 wound with IoN. Ethereal Units are not explained.
- Wizarding Hat removes any Lore choice from the wearer and forces him to random. Should this new rule conflict with others, simply assume he can still be: Hieropant / VC General. (Hieropants... can do this? are they not restricted? What does their FAQ say?)
- Forbidden Lore in your Army General allows you to fill the last remaining points in your list, if you could not reach your designated points limit and don't want your list to read like 1975pts VC list.
 
Well, to me this FAQ means everything.

The wizarding hat specifically states its generating a lore randomly as a lvl 2 wizard. Therefore you cannot choose since its being generated randomly.
The Forbidden Lore makes you choose out of the 'Forbidden lores' from the BRB, so if you pick that skill and pick a BRB lore you CANNOT choose LoV. Since that skill basically overrules your ability to wield LoV.
This FAQ clearly points in that direction, no its not written down literally but the assumption is very, very obvious and it makes sense in the naming of the skill and it makes sense towards this FAQ-topic.




-------------------------------------------


Lets look at some facts here:

-Vampires cannot take Wizarding hat
-a general must always pick LoV, there can be only 1 general
-if a general of VC dies no one else takes its place, since there can be only 1


Looking at these facts, the whole point of bringing this faq-topic up would make absolutely no sense and would be totally irrelevant.
Now this faq is in line with the Forbidden Lore skill though. You have a Vampire Lord, that has a Forbidden Lore (note the emphasis on the name of this particular skill) ability. This grants your VampLord General to actually take a lore from the BRB that is 'Forbidden' since it is by rule only allowed to wield the LoV, yet this ability grants him the possibilty to break the rules (figuratively) and take one of the Forbidden Lores which, in general, he wouldnt be allowed to wield.

That is the entire purpose of this skill and that is why you pay 25 points for it.


- -------------------------------

More facts:

- a vampire has a natural choice between LoV, shadow and death.
- if he is the general, that choice is narrowed down to LoV, forebidding the others
- 'Forbidden Lore' ability grants acces to all the BRB lores except 'Life'



Here again, The innate vampiric ability grants even your general the power to wield a lore from the BRB, nowhere is it stated that a general CANNOT take this ability. If he does so, he picks a lore from the BRB-lores (shadow and death included) which forfeits his ability to choose LoV. This is the ONLY way for a general to have acces to shadow and death, even though in nature he knows these lores already. Yet it will cost your general 25 points in vampiric abilities to be able to wield it.

What does this imply?
A lord with 'Forbidden Lore' cannot take the standard combo of RF+QB since that is beyond pointallowance. He is therefore more of a spellcaster and his martial prowess is reduced because of it. Taking this 'Forbidden Lore' ability forces your general to be less of a blenderlord, which is by far the most popular build. A true Blenderlord will always be LoV since that grants him the most acces to combat-abilities.

Even though a Vamplord general should by default always take the LoV, it has an option to do otherwise.... yet it comes at a price.



This is what i think is the meaning of the entire ruleset we are discussing about.
Forbidden lore hardly made any sense tbh, i can count the number of times i used it on 1 hand, simply bacause it forced me to take a vamphero to wield it (which kinda sucks hard) who was often better off wielding LoV anyways and cast an extra IoN....


Giving Vampires an option for skills and then prohibiting your general from taking it is ridiculous.

This Faq clearly points towards the fact that 'Forbidden Lore' does exactly what it is called;

It allows you to take a lore that is by rule considered to be forbidden, even if youre a general of the VC.
 
Skittelz, you're pulling teeth and using things outside of the rules to create an argument. The names for things are not part of a rules argument, nor are how you choose to describe the resolution of a particular rule, nor does what you think the rules imply. The only thing that matters is the wording of the rules.
 
there is no clear wording... that the whole point.

And with what youre saying youre simply dismissing the existance of this faq, that would have absolutely no place...
 
Actually the wording is clear:


My General must be:

1. A wizard
2. have LoV as Lore and not shadow and/or death (necro/vamps)
3. if its a vamp and has Forbidden Lore he can be wield another lore.

Faq actually confirms this.


So its beyond clear, its crystal clear.
 
No. Just no.

Also, I don't really understand why this f***ing topic rises up for discussion every three or four months or so.
It's almost as if people deliberately wanted to bend the rules in their favour ...
Oh wait, there's always folks trying to do that, interpreting RAW in the way that'd be most favourable to their situation, or trying to cheese t heir way out of a potential defeat.

The general of a VC army always needs to be a caster and always has to use the LotV if able to do so. Thus, even a Vampire Lord with 'Forbidden Lore' would need to select LotV and the vampiric power purchased would be an utter waste as it wouldn't exclude him from selecting the LotV.
And no, neither the rules nor the FAQ are debatable on this.
Sure, there's nothing stopping you to take FL on a second VL if you're playing something like 3000+ points or so ...

That is actually the very reason you'll almost only see FL on hero level vampires at all. To fulfill their role as a backup support caster ... though even their usefulness is debatable. I love my FL vampires, but most often support lores are rather specific and once your general dies and the whole bunch starts to crumble you'd wish you'd rather brought another LotV caster ...
Especially with the tide-turning changes to the metagame that happened quite recently.

If anyone's interested in a smallish 'guide' to support lores on hero vampires give me a shout, I could write up a short summarization.

And finally, frankly, no one in their right mind would ever slap a Wizarding Hat onto a Vampire Lord ...

EDIT: Spelling
 
I'm afraid I have to agree with Lynks and Mr. West here, Skittelz...

To sum up, the wording is poor. The FAQ may be misleading in mentioning Vampires and Vampire Lord, however the most important part of the rule is unaltered: "If they can't select LoV because of whatever effect that would prevent them to, then it's ok, they can still be the General"

Also, the Forbidden Lore's text could be misleading when it says "can generate" and has no clarification on that (It doesn't say can only generate... nor does it say can also generate). I know people argue that such clarification is not needed at all, yet for the sake of order, it wouldn't hurt to slap something like that in the FAQ.

In the mean time, no matter how much we'd want the FL power to provide a little bit more diversty in our army, it has not enough support to be recognized as official.

I request an all-mighty, forum-master, zombie-raiser, dice-rolling, redirection-expert, deployment-genious, ogre blade-wielding moderator to close the topic. (unless he isn't all of the above)

:D! Thank you fo your input!
 
I never said i was gonna try and persuade my meta to gulp this. I was making a case on this forum :D

Tbh, the whole faq is ridiculous since there is no possibility to become other than LoV (which is strange imo)

So why write an faq about a situation that apparently most people agree on, is impossible?
Somehow, GW apparently thinks it is possible.

Mr. West, 'nobody in his right mind would slap wizarding hat on a vamp general' no idd, since its not even an option, we dont even need to look at that. It will just never happen. Yet it is in the faq....

Why?

the hat is being used as an example for the case a VC general IS other than LoV.......
How is that possible if Forbidden Lore doesnt grant this possibility? Why is the faq there?


Like you explain yourself Mr.West, the entire Forbidden Lore skill is pretty bad in its use overall.
-only available in very high-point games on 2nd lords or babyvamps that can never be more than lvl2 wizards.
-usually like you said yourself, and i said before, youre even better off taking LoV as backup casting since spamming IoN or at least have another shot at it turns out to be more secure, especially in the crumbling after general deaths.

So apart from the "i can count on 1 hand number of games you try out Beasts or anything else", this entire skill is pretty damn useless if it doesnt allow your general to wield a forbidden lore. (theyre all forbidden because he is supposed to take LoV).


The only conclusion you can draw from this faq existing, is that FL actually is allowed on Generals and that it is the only way for a general to have a different lore than LoV. Especially since Wizarding hat is not an item you can take....


We dont have to argue about it further than this since youre not going to change you pov.
This is not me trying to bend a rule in my favour or trying to cheese it out (im not really sure its more cheesy to have a Beastlore general than a LoV blendergeneral), its an faq without any purpose or meaning from your pov, and its an faq with a purpose from my pov.

So go figure what the purpose of this faq is and what actually makes more sense.
 
This forum always reminds me of Will Ferrel's debate in Old School

http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_yYDzLUH1NE

and I mean that in a complimentary way: all give very well-explored ideas and reasonings, I just want an excuse to share that clip :P
 
Skittelz had some good points. This is my take on it.

Wizards Hat state : "...can use a randomly chosen spell lore..."
Vampires Magic state : "...can use the Lore of Vampires, The Lore of Death or The Lore of Shadows"

You would think since the vampire general with the hat now must choose lore of vampires. But according to the FAQ he ends up with the randomly chosen spell. The choice of his initial spell lore was overridden even though the hat rule only say "can".

Forbidden lore state : "The vampire can generate his spells from any one of the lores in the warhammer rulesbook except lore of life"

Following hat example, the forbidden lore choice must again override his default lore choices. Therefore he can no longer pick lore of vampires, if you buy forbidden lore.


Another way to view is whole matter is:
1. The vampire general must pick lore of vampires
2. The vampire with forbidden lore can pick any of the 7 warhammer schools.

This is a matter where the Army book general rule conflicts with an armybook special rule. When this happens the special rule override the general rule.
 
This is getting interesting again.

After all my tries to make people see what the faq implies.
An faq with no use because of said General rule is absurd. Why make it an faq if there is absolutely no possibility. Apparently there is such a possibility: A Vampiric Skill that any Vampire, even a general, can have. A skill that actually overrides the fact that by default he should pick that one same lore always.
A skill that has no use or barely if this is not possible.
An faq that has absolutely no meaning if this isnt possible.

The existance of the faq, although vague by its content, heavily points in the direction of the Vampiric skill being allowed to take on your general and thus choosing 1 of the BRB lores instead of the Vampire lore.

(why else would Mannfred be Loremaster of Death, i know he is also loremaster of Vamps but thats not why you take him. He is your general and he is flaggin Deathlore to the max)
 
Okay, why is it that with the TG screaming out of combat you insist that "may" specifically means anything you want including but here you assume that a conditional modal specifically excluding the other options?

RAW is not pulling the teeth out of grammar to make new builds work, it is not manufacturing vagueness out of potential intersections in rulings, it is reading things, applying verbal logic, and then following it as best you can within the rulings you have.

There's nowhere to go with this.
 
Yet you say nothing about the faq.
Every word used in rules is of utter importance, since every word is deemed to be chosen wisely so that the meaning is clear. the may in the tg issue is undeniably there for the case i was supporting.
Here you have an faq, the name of a skill, the existance of a skill that tend to be a way around the General rule.
Its not pulling grammatical teeth thats what you make of it.
 
Lets go over what is written in RAW:

p26 AB:

Your army's general must be a wizard. If he is able to choose a spell lore, he must use the LoV.


Ok now im going to build a Vamplord General:
I give him:
- Forbidden Lore
- Quickblood
- AoDM
- Fear Incarnate

Now under Forbidden Lore it says: 'The Vampire can generate his spells from any lore in the BRB, except Life'

I am still able to choose, but i cannot chose LoV anymore since it is not from BRB.


So the true question is:
If i take a Vampire as general, be it a Lord or Hero, do i have to choose a Lore BEFORE or AFTER i equip his skills?


If i have to choose a lore before equipping his skills (which is unnatural since its a character with a certain set of skills) then yes, he has to choose LoV out of the 3 given options.
If i have to choose after equipping the skills (which is a natural course, creating a character with a set of skills which defines that said character) then no, i cannot choose LoV since Forbidden Lore does not give me the choice in taking that particular lore.



By default, your Vampire always gets a choice between LoV, Death and Shadow. when he is a general he must then choose LoV. That is what the ruling says i must do.
But: if its a Vampire with a skill that doesnt allow you to choose from the same set of Lores, he cannot choose the Lore he is normally forced to take as a general.


So, for all the naysayers. The part that says he must choose LoV, IN MY OPINION is only directed towards the default choice of his natural Lore choices. Yet giving a Vampire a skill is something you do before anything else. Since that defines the character and what type of person (if you can call it that) it is. Forbidden Lore therefore gives another choice, one that makes you unable to choose LoV and also becomes the one way to choose the 2 other lores you actually know by default but are not allowed to take if youre not a Vampire with the skill to choose a Forbidden Lore.

Hence the name of the skill. (claiming the names of things have nothing to do with anything is bollox. You may say GW sux at a lot of things but everything is named accordingly to either fluff or rules and nothing is named something 'just for fun' Naming this skill the way they did, they had a clear objective in mind. Taking something that is usually forbidden)
 
Bold crap as much as you want. This is still you claiming "words matter" and then refusing to acknowledge the meaning of the word "Can", assuming things that aren't stated, citing the name of the rule and your interpretation of it as a meaning, and then declaring your opinion as a rule.

You do not understand rulings.

This is going nowhere.

This rules forum has seriously lost a huge amount of its quality recently, it is becoming more of a design debate forum than a rules discussion.
 
Skittelz1981 said:
Lets go over what is written in RAW:

p26 AB:

Your army's general must be a wizard. If he is able to choose a spell lore, he must use the LoV.


Ok now im going to build a Vamplord General:
I give him:
- Forbidden Lore
- Quickblood
- AoDM
- Fear Incarnate

Now under Forbidden Lore it says: 'The Vampire can generate his spells from any lore in the BRB, except Life'

I am still able to choose, but i cannot chose LoV anymore since it is not from BRB.


So the true question is:
If i take a Vampire as general, be it a Lord or Hero, do i have to choose a Lore BEFORE or AFTER i equip his skills?


If i have to choose a lore before equipping his skills (which is unnatural since its a character with a certain set of skills) then yes, he has to choose LoV out of the 3 given options.
If i have to choose after equipping the skills (which is a natural course, creating a character with a set of skills which defines that said character) then no, i cannot choose LoV since Forbidden Lore does not give me the choice in taking that particular lore.



By default, your Vampire always gets a choice between LoV, Death and Shadow. when he is a general he must then choose LoV. That is what the ruling says i must do.
But: if its a Vampire with a skill that doesnt allow you to choose from the same set of Lores, he cannot choose the Lore he is normally forced to take as a general.


So, for all the naysayers. The part that says he must choose LoV, IN MY OPINION is only directed towards the default choice of his natural Lore choices. Yet giving a Vampire a skill is something you do before anything else. Since that defines the character and what type of person (if you can call it that) it is. Forbidden Lore therefore gives another choice, one that makes you unable to choose LoV and also becomes the one way to choose the 2 other lores you actually know by default but are not allowed to take if youre not a Vampire with the skill to choose a Forbidden Lore.

Hence the name of the skill. (claiming the names of things have nothing to do with anything is bollox. You may say GW sux at a lot of things but everything is named accordingly to either fluff or rules and nothing is named something 'just for fun' Naming this skill the way they did, they had a clear objective in mind. Taking something that is usually forbidden)


Just my 2 cents. The reason the FAQ allows a Vampire with WH to be the general, is because there is an implication in the WH rule that the wearer has no choice in the lore he can choose. Where it says "The wearer is treated as being a level 2 wizard", right off the bat there is no choice. Even if the Vampire is level 4 he is now level 2 "who can use a randomly chosen spell lore".

As we know the FAQ backed this up by saying yes, the Vampire can still be the general (because it has no choice and can't take LOV).

Whereas with FL I dont see as much of an implication that the Vampire doesnt have a choice. I can definitely see your points and it warrants debate. But I agree with rarermonsters in saying until the FAQ addresses out this specific ruling, you have to play it as the Vamp using FL has a choice to use LOV, which of course means he can't be the general.
 
RarerMonsters said:
Bold crap as much as you want. This is still you claiming "words matter" and then refusing to acknowledge the meaning of the word "Can", assuming things that aren't stated, citing the name of the rule and your interpretation of it as a meaning, and then declaring your opinion as a rule.

You do not understand rulings.

This is going nowhere.

This rules forum has seriously lost a huge amount of its quality recently, it is becoming more of a design debate forum than a rules discussion.



Sure, be a prick.
Its so bad in quality that it actually proved you wrong on the Terrorgheist issue. Great going.
Sorry rarer, the only one losing in quality atm is you.
I didnt declare my opinion as the rule. I stated this is my opinion. Something i think is worth loking into that might have been overlooked or misinterpreted.
You getting personal sounds more like a little frustration.

Since you always care to point out how bad GW is with writing rules, now youre blaming me for debating on unclear rules.

Anyways. Like i said earlier, im not going to try and convince my META about this because theres too many opponents of it. But clearly im not alone on this one.
Also, instead of just bashing it would be more quality to actually post something that is of a certain quality and standard with arguments.
 
This is quoted from Dancing Skeleton´s post earlier±

As we know the FAQ backed this up by saying yes, the Vampire can still be the general (because it has no choice and can't take LOV).

Whereas with FL I dont see as much of an implication that the Vampire doesnt have a choice. I can definitely see your points and it warrants debate. But I agree with rarermonsters in saying until the FAQ addresses out this specific ruling, you have to play it as the Vamp using FL has a choice to use LOV, which of course means he can't be the general.

//////////////


Isnt this the exact same thing?
You take an item (character defining) that makes him a lvl2 wizard (why make him a lvl4 if he is going to wear the hat?) It then says it ´can use a randomly chosen lore´
In the arguments ive seen against my pov, people just say: No, he must choose LoV since he has the choice anyway. The hat allows him to choose randomly but it still says ´can´ not implying he must (like Rarer is trying to make us believe)
Isnt that the exact same wording as FL?
Correct me if im seeing this wrong but its pretty much the same, you take a skill (character defining) that says you can generate from BRB....

How is the sequencing of chosing any different then? If the faq then states that its possible... (the hat is only used as an example, not excluding other similar situations)
 
RarerMonsters said:
The FAQ states that wizards wearing the Hat can't choose LoV. It isn't the "same wording", because in the case of the Hat it's part of the same sentence describing the source of the Wizard Levels and describing what those Wizard Levels can take.

Forbidden Lore is an entirely different context, so you're not going to be able to prove anything hanging your argument on the word can. If a FAQ comes out later saying otherwise, that's one thing.
Check earlier. Everything that'll be said has been said.

Someone should lock this.
 
So:

- Wizarding hat; The wearer is treated as a lvl2 wizard who can use a randomly chosen spell lore, However he also has the stupidity rule.
- Forbidden Lore; The Vampire can generate his spells from any of the lores in the warhammer rulebook, except lore of life.

Theyre both 1 sentence, both say can.
You base the fact that wizarding hat overrules the General rule on the fact that it treats the wearer as a lvl2 wizard that also loses its choice in lore because its in one sentence. (faq definately acknowledges that pov)
You could say the exact same about FL; treats the vampire as a lvl to your chosing wizard that can generate spells from BRB. thus losing its ability to choose LoV.

I dont see your point making your case in your favor tbh. it actually decreases its forte. you pick an item or a skill that overrules the General rule.


Obviously Wizarding hat is not meant for characters that are already casters. its possible but pointless, its there for characters that are not casters and can become one by wearing it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu