TVC II OOC General OOC Discussion (New)

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I don't think the Skaven see the Horned Rat as a chaos god- to them he is just "god".

Besides, theres only one faction that the skaven would allow to rule the world- and thats the skaven. They don't want competition for World Domination.
 
I don't think the Skaven see the Horned Rat as a chaos god- to them he is just "god".

Besides, theres only one faction that the skaven would allow to rule the world- and thats the skaven. They don't want competition for World Domination.

@Sanai

I wouldn't advocate the idea that the skaven might ally with chaos to share the world...however, chaos seems to be a very convenient alliance for them at the moment. They might have plans to dispose of the forces of the other four gods later, after using them to deal with their ancient enemies (namely, the lizardmen) as well as their more immediate foes (the Carstein empire and the human empire). Right now, the forces of the other four gods would probably seem the most favourable armies to ally with at this point in the TVC II timeline for the skaven - they are the least likely to be hostile to them, and they are definitely a very powerful tool to manipulate for the skavens' own nefarious ends.

Whilst the skaven may not see the Horned Rat as a chaos god, the grey seers lead skaven based on their interpretation of will - and if the chaos gods are forming a united front, it's possible that the Horned Rat may be involved (or taking a role on the sidelines). That said, the Council of the Thirteen might have sent representatives to the vampires - the horned rat or the council of the thirteen might want to play the council and chaos against each other. I prefer to see it that way, because the skaven are always manipulating their allies and enemies against each other - it's in their nature.

Regardless of the skavens' perception, the horned rat is a chaos god. What's more, the battle at drakenhof showed that many skaven were willing to fight the council under and alongside a wizard who had suspiciously strong connections to the main four chaos gods. I can see the roleplayer's dilemma that skaven characters therefore might not be able to justifiably fight alongside the council, but a number of reasons must be taken into account here to recognise that such doubts are needless:

- DoN recommended that some of us made characters allied to chaos/against the council
- The council of the thirteen may have sent Nithek to gauge the council's strength
- They may have sent him to stimulate conflict between council and chaos forces and to ensure that the skaven benefit as much as possible from such a conflict
- They may fear having their seats taken by zealous skaven followers of chaos, and want chaos to be stopped for their own personal gains
- Of course, they might have sent him in the hope that the council disposes of him - they may want him dead as he previously failed to destroy the council forces at drakenhof, or they may perceive him as someone with enough potential to usurp their seats
- Nithek may be joining the council as a skaven who despises the ratmen who have joined forces with chaos, and wants to stop them; another option is that he sees the possibility of unrest amongst the clans during a vampire-chaos war as an opportunity to make massive gains in personal power through machinating the vampire council

Therefore, the possible allegiance of a large body of skaven with the forces of chaos does not pose a roleplaying problem here. However, as Lexicanum states, the skaven are widely perceived to be forces of chaos, and so a great proportion of them siding with the forces of the other four chaos gods as representatives of the Horned Rat is not an entirely unbelievable prospect.
 
Let's open up the Skaven dictionary, shall we?

Ally: Enemy not currently being fought due to utility against greater enemy. See also subordinate.
 
Last edited:
@Ordo Cruentus Rosa El-Hashem (who looks to be quite an exciting character) is accepted - I'm looking forward to seeing you participate in the TVC II. Hooray for vampiric pirate mercenaries!

*Gasp!

You mean it?!

1384448365989.webp


I've been waiting for so long...

*Sniff

I'm happy! I'm so happy!
 
@The Dread King, As @Sanai said the majority of the Skaven don't see the Horned Rat as a Chaos god. Furthermore, it's all about threat assessment - the Vampire Council would be much easier to deal with on their own than the entirety of Chaos (as there is no way they would allow, or attempt to not allow, chaos to remain in power for long). As such, the intelligent thing for them to do would be eliminate chaos first, and then work on their 'allies'. Especially as, as far as I am aware, they have no immediate quarrel with the vampire council, whereas Chaos is already poised to take over the world... And by take over I probably mean destroy, given that it's chaos.

I don't know what's planned for the TVC, but to me it seems that skaven would have to help stop chaos or be destroyed/subjugated. Once Chaos has been dealt with they would have all the time in the world to deal with their other enemies.
 
@Harland

I may have phrased my previous point poorly. It doesn't matter whether the skaven see the Horned Rat as a chaos god or not, because he knows what he is (a chaos god), and many of them try to interpret and then do his bidding. If he wanted some of his servants to not attack chaos, no doubt they would do so.

BTW, I'm pretty sure Chaos don't want to destroy the world; they only want to subjugate it so that its mortals can further the gods' own goals. If the world was destroyed, they lose their mortal power bases, which strengthen and please the chaos gods through their followers' acts.

Also, the skaven do have a quarrel with the council, or, at least, its members - chaos is no doubt involved in the weakening of necromancy. Without this weakening, the Carstein empire could be close to taking over the empire by this point in the TVC II timeline. It has rapidly advanced in power, and a vampire council has been able to achieve what the council of the thirteen was barely able to do - kill Nagash. Their display against skaven forces at Drakenhof further suggests to the skaven that the vampires are a real threat - and if the skaven can wear chaos down by getting them to destroy their mutual enemies at the vampires' (and indeed the Empire's) weakest point, then they can tackle any chaotic threat later. Besides, nobody can be quite sure of the size and potency of the chaos armies, but Sylvania has displayed a demoralising amount of power - enough to seriously threaten the skaven.

If they try to do the opposite (wear down the council by getting it to destroy chaos), they stand a fair chance of losing this initial struggle and then being killed (as chaos may seem too strong to be defeated by the Council at this point, at least to the skavens' knowledge) - and, being cowards, they would probably pick the safer option in such a dilemma. However, the point I am trying to get across is that not all skaven will agree with whatever consensus some of them come to - as their constant feuds prove, they are most certainly not united, and the Council of the Thirteen does not have all of skavendom under its thumb; its members are too engaged in their own opposing schemes to maintain constant control over every one of the skaven clans (which number in the thousands). Therefore, some skaven will no doubt oppose the chaotic forces, but others will definitely support them. Others still will watch from the sidelines and go to the highest bidder, maximising on backstabbery whenever the opportunities present themselves.

Chapter 2 shows that some skaven work under chaos (or alongside it as emissaries of the Horned Rat) - Skarhulk did, and it's worth remembering that his brother escaped from the slaughter at Drakenhof with the sorcerous cabal of skaven mages.

Edit: @Bounce (and, indeed, to everyone posting in chapter 4; Bounce was simply the latest RPer to post there and progress towards the end of chapter 4). Fantastic post, but you implied that the route to the carriages is clear. In IC terms, it is still blocked by a few assassins and wights who recently relocated themselves. Elanor couldn't have blocked them behind a flaming wall because she would need to be in front of them to do so; in my last IC post, they just moved in front of all of the vampires to cut them off. I'm not trying to create a fully-fledged battle here, and of course they can be circumvented (with justified IC reasoning, of course; by all means, you could edit your post to have her get past them. The other vampires, in IC terms, haven't done so yet, though).

However, whilst I encourage IC posting in this chapter at the same phenomenal speed as it has been posted in for the past few days, it doesn't seem reasonable on (in IC terms) to get to the carriages at lightning speed. The assassination was no doubt well-planned (in terms of lore), not a shambles, so whilst the assailants can be overcome, they shouldn't be made a mockery of. GoW's two lengthy IC posts that detail how Dieter overcame just two assassins are a good example of how one might want to act in IC at this point in the RP. They are extremely descriptive, don't portray Dieter as too overpowered, but at the same time demonstrate Dieter's in-game talent and experience. Perhaps most importantly of all, despite describing the defeat of only three enemies of Dieter, these posts still manage to maintain the fast pace that RPers want to show their characters reacting with in a situation like this. Progressing too quickly also leaves other RPers characters stranded. I understand that the RP shouldn't wait for too long for RPers who are extremely slow or inactive, but some were just absent for a short time and might want the opportunity to post before the chapter ends. Namely, @Kavok , @Ghouly , @Simon von Carstein , and @Dark_Wolfen . Of course, these RPers could simply post a flashback of how they escaped the Pinnacle in chapter 6, but if the characters of the other RPers got to the carriages too quickly, we would follow the protocol described in the reboot and wait for a few days for other posters to contribute before DoN wrapped up chapter 4 regardless of their posts. In that time, we would be in a 'and now we wait' situation in the carriages, which wouldn't make too much sense, lore-wise. It would be much better to focus one's posts on smaller areas of the struggle, like GoW has done (but a balance is needed here - as I said before, this should not turn into fully-fledged battle, but merely a controlled retreat against fierce opposition. The vampires can't flee too quickly, or they would leave themselves defenceless against the assassins still blocking their retreat). I'm not asking for filler fight scenes, merely advising that we shouldn't have our characters make it possible to leave the Pinnacle in scant few posts.
 
Last edited:
BTW, I'm pretty sure Chaos don't want to destroy the world; they only want to subjugate it so that its mortals can further the gods' own goals. If the world was destroyed, they lose their mortal power bases, which strengthen and please the chaos gods through their followers' acts.

A fair point. However, my point still stands as total subjugation would be just as bad as, if not worse than, annihilation.

Also, the skaven do have a quarrel with the council, or, at least, its members - chaos is no doubt involved in the weakening of necromancy. Without this weakening, the Carstein empire could be close to taking over the empire by this point in the TVC II timeline. It has rapidly advanced in power, and a vampire council has been able to achieve what the council of the thirteen was barely able to do - kill Nagash. Their display against skaven forces at Drakenhof further suggests to the skaven that the vampires are a real threat - and if the skaven can wear chaos down by getting them to destroy their mutual enemies at the vampires' (and indeed the Empire's) weakest point, then they can tackle any chaotic threat later. Besides, nobody can be quite sure of the size and potency of the chaos armies, but Sylvania has displayed a demoralising amount of power - enough to seriously threaten the skaven.

If they try to do the opposite (wear down the council by getting it to destroy chaos), they stand a fair chance of losing this initial struggle and then being killed (as chaos may seem too strong to be defeated by the Council at this point, at least to the skavens' knowledge) - and, being cowards, they would probably pick the safer option in such a dilemma. However, the point I am trying to get across is that not all skaven will agree with whatever consensus some of them come to - as their constant feuds prove, they are most certainly not united, and the Council of the Thirteen does not have all of skavendom under its thumb; its members are too engaged in their own opposing schemes to maintain constant control over every one of the skaven clans (which number in the thousands). Therefore, some skaven will no doubt oppose the chaotic forces, but others will definitely support them. Others still will watch from the sidelines and go to the highest bidder, maximising on backstabbery whenever the opportunities present themselves.
That's not a quarrel, that's the Carsteins being a thread. And Chaos is likely a much larger threat, and certainly a more immediate one. While opposing chaos may be riskier in the short run, by the exact same argument (that they are stronger than the council) it is less likely to go wrong in the long wrong. Think about it - if they side with chaos, then they have the entirety of chaos to deal with afterwards - and, in all likelihood, not a very weakened one given that they may well be able to overpower the Carsteins on their own anyway. However, if they side with the Vampires, and defeat chaos, then the Carsteins would be substantially weakened. This also happens to be the scenario when the world as they know it doesn't come to an end.

Chapter 2 shows that some skaven work under chaos (or alongside it as emissaries of the Horned Rat) - Skarhulk did, and it's worth remembering that his brother escaped from the slaughter at Drakenhof with the sorcerous cabal of skaven mages.

Ah yes, I should mention at this point that I am in no way arguing that the entirety of the skaven would choose the same side. Really, it's religious feilty vs calculation - some will go one way, some will go the other. (and some might decide that siding with Chaos is the safer choice, whereas others might believe that the horned rat might prefer it if the other chaos gods didn't exist). We do agree on this, but I am arguing that Nithek wouldn't necessarily present a small, outcast minority.

Edit: @Bounce (and, indeed, to everyone posting in chapter 4; Bounce was simply the latest RPer to post there and progress towards the end of chapter 4). Fantastic post, but you implied that the route to the carriages is clear. In IC terms, it is still blocked by a few assassins and wights who recently relocated themselves. Elanor couldn't have blocked them behind a flaming wall because she would need to be in front of them to do so; in my last IC post, they just moved in front of all of the vampires to cut them off. I'm not trying to create a fully-fledged battle here, and of course they can be circumvented (with justified IC reasoning, of course; by all means, you could edit your post to have her get past them. The other vampires, in IC terms, haven't done so yet, though).

However, whilst I encourage IC posting in this chapter at the same phenomenal speed as it has been posted in for the past few days, it doesn't seem reasonable on (in IC terms) to get to the carriages at lightning speed. The assassination was no doubt well-planned (in terms of lore), not a shambles, so whilst the assailants can be overcome, they shouldn't be made a mockery of. GoW's two lengthy IC posts that detail how Dieter overcame just two assassins are a good example of how one might want to act in IC at this point in the RP. They are extremely descriptive, don't portray Dieter as too overpowered, but at the same time demonstrate Dieter's in-game talent and experience. Perhaps most importantly of all, despite describing the defeat of only three enemies of Dieter, these posts still manage to maintain the fast pace that RPers want to show their characters reacting with in a situation like this. Progressing too quickly also leaves other RPers characters stranded. I understand that the RP shouldn't wait for too long for RPers who are extremely slow or inactive, but some were just absent for a short time and might want the opportunity to post before the chapter ends. Namely, @Kavok , @Ghouly , @Simon von Carstein , and @Dark_Wolfen . Of course, these RPers could simply post a flashback of how they escaped the Pinnacle in chapter 6, but if the characters of the other RPers got to the carriages too quickly, we would follow the protocol described in the reboot and wait for a few days for other posters to contribute before DoN wrapped up chapter 4 regardless of their posts. In that time, we would be in a 'and now we wait' situation in the carriages, which wouldn't make too much sense, lore-wise. It would be much better to focus one's posts on smaller areas of the struggle, like GoW has done (but a balance is needed here - as I said before, this should not turn into fully-fledged battle, but merely a controlled retreat against fierce opposition. The vampires can't flee too quickly, or they would leave themselves defenceless against the assassins still blocking their retreat). I'm not asking for filler fight scenes, merely advising that we shouldn't have our characters make it possible to leave the Pinnacle in scant few posts.

I should like to point out that every assassin Roland has dispatched so far has been caught by surprise (the one in the shadows, the one sneaking up on him, and both one's attacking Faust). I intend him to go toe to toe with an assassin next post, things should get more interesting.

However, I disagree with the fact that we should wait for absent people - or at least, not stop posting for them. I know I posted that Roland had cleared the path, but I never intended it to last very long (I was going to have more assassins pop out next post). At the very least, the battle would turn into a fighting retreat.

Which brings me onto my next point - there is no way that the council member's would reach the carriages soon anyway - since we disembarked, we have been walking for at least an hour, obviously so we wouldn't have an easy method of escape. It's not going to be as simple as "get to the carriages!"
 
the Vampires can probably run faster then the carriages anyway, I think best bet would be to ditch them. anyhow aren't these two chapters supposed to cull off all the inactive characters
 
Sorry for any confusion there but by Elanor's words I am saying we should head towards the carriages not that this will be easy or quick. As we were surrounded I thought the flame wall might help ward off foes on one side meaning we would have less to deal with.
 
Wow so many posts!

Just to have my 2 cents: I am more in agreement with Sanai. Skaven (whilst a chaotic force) are ultimately about self-preservation. From an objective viewpoint in this scenario it is very clear that the unified Chaos force is the clear threat, just as when Nagash was about to cast his ultimate spell. Back then they could have tried to maintain their alliance but they knew that they would also be subjugated and/or killed.

They know that the forces of Chaos do not view them or their god as equal, but more like the runts of the litter. I think that viewing this situation they would placate the forces of Chaos in the meantime, whilst actually supporting the Carsteins / Empire and hoping that in the end all three will be weak enough for the Skaven to conquer.

In regards to the posting, yes please make sure your fights with the assassins reflect their skills, they are highly trained and specifically skilled at killing vamps :vampire3:

Also, how come no one has posted in the Wastes chapter yet?
 
the Vampires can probably run faster then the carriages anyway, I think best bet would be to ditch them. anyhow aren't these two chapters supposed to cull off all the inactive characters

@Ghouly The carriages are black coaches, which are unnaturally fast and pulled by nightmares. Most of the vampries won't be able to outrun them. And yes, these chapters do deal with the inactive characters. However, the RPers I mentioned in my last post expressed interest in this reboot and are clearly not inactive. I didn't mention the inactive poster in chapter 4 (Mello).

I'm not even sure How I'm going to approach this fight with Slyvie
I don't know what I'm supposed to do in wastes and I am hesitant on approaching the fight with the assassins cause I can't picture them in my head

The assassins are in black cowls and seem to be - in terms of IC - former members of Akarin's order of assassins. They have Old World weapons and Eastern fighting techniques including advanced hand to hand combat skills. The following picture is not entirely accurate and is not quite how I picture the assassins, but I think it could give you a rough idea of what they look like (minus the bow, and completely brace - no brown armour whatsoever):
thief-video-game.webp


@Ghouly @Disciple of Nagash For the Wastes, what to post is pretty open at the moment, which is why it is quite hard to write a decent post in it. It is tempting not to make the first post - because that involves setting loose parameters for the next few posts in the chapter, and nobody would want to make a hash of that - so they leave the job to someone else. The chaos army have still not arrived, and Nekhlior has not opened a portal yet. Writing the next post in chapter 5 well will be tough, but kudos to you if you do it, Ghouly (and that goes for everyone else with characters in chapter 5. Some ideas to consider, from your perspective:

- Should Graveclaw run back to the camp with Rowhaine or not?
- If he does, why did he do so? Perhaps explore his internal reasoning in your next post. One thing Graveclaw could do at the camp would be to use his keen sight to study the chaos forces and look for weaknesses in them. He's not a tactical genius but he could report to the council what they have, e.g. "Watch out, they brought a sssssssssssssssskull cannon!" You could add some tension to this post by having the chaos forces begin their attack from afar in some way (e.g. arcane missiles, conventional ranged weaponry, or, indeed, a skull cannon, among other weapons in the chaos armoury)
- If he does not, why did he not follow Rowhaine? Is he trying to hunt down the leader of the ambush/take out one of their more formidable weapons/determine whether Vekarin is amongst the chaos forces? Try and describe the start of his search without making important plot information, as DoN no doubt has plans for most, if not all, of the things that I just described in this point (if you had a PM conversation with him about this, however, he could sort out with you what would be acceptable for Graveclaw to search for/find/fight). He could also try to delay the chaos forces by fighting them (and putting his life in extreme danger in the process) to protect the council group in the wastes

Ah yes, I should mention at this point that I am in no way arguing that the entirety of the skaven would choose the same side. Really, it's religious feilty vs calculation - some will go one way, some will go the other. (and some might decide that siding with Chaos is the safer choice, whereas others might believe that the horned rat might prefer it if the other chaos gods didn't exist). We do agree on this, but I am arguing that Nithek wouldn't necessarily present a small, outcast minority.

@Harland @Sanai @Disciple of Nagash Fair enough, I suppose. I wasn't trying to suggest that Nithek held a minority viewpoint, but that other skaven would disagree with him (e.g. certain crazed fanatics believing that serving chaos was the Horned Rat's bidding, and the calculating type @Harland mentioned in his last post in this thread). I think with the chaos undivided front being intact without an everchosen to lead them demonstrates cooperation between the powers that suggests that they would be more open to the Horned Rat (in the case of the four chaos gods) and his followers (in the chase of the followers of the aforementioned four gods). Perhaps the majority of the skaven are against chaos, but in light of the new alliance, the prospect of siding with chaos would certainly seem more favourable to some of the skaven at this point in the TVC II (whilst it would no doubt aggravate other skaven).

An alternative take on this would be to have the council of the thirteen against chaos, but have chaos-backed skaven fanatics like Skarhulk trying to sabotage its work and overthrow it. A faction of insane skaven declared heretical by the council of the thirteen that have armies and/or a secret society, the members of which have concealed their alliance to the majority of skavenkind. This cult could have followers in high places in Skavenblight, and would probably see the skaven opposing it as heretical.

Regardless of how this turns out in the TVC II storyline, hooray for skaven politics! :clown:
 
@The Dread King, the calculating skaven I mentioned would me more likely to side against chaos, for reasons I discussed. But that's just for clarification.

Wow so many posts!
In regards to the posting, yes please make sure your fights with the assassins reflect their skills, they are highly trained and specifically skilled at killing vamps :vampire3:

What in particular makes them good against vamps? I'm curious, plus information on their fighting style is useful for a more in-depth understanding of the combat.

@Ghouly Nobody's still in the carriages, everyone has been walking with us towards the Silver Pinnacle
 
@Ghouly The assassins are in black cowls and seem to be - in terms of IC - former members of Akarin's order of assassins. They have Old World weapons and Eastern fighting techniques including advanced hand to hand combat skills. The following picture is not entirely accurate and is not quite how I picture the assassins, but I think it could give you a rough idea of what they look like (minus the bow, and completely brace - no brown armour whatsoever):

Pretty much but if the player want's to write them as having no cowl that's fine. Weapon wise they carry whatever they're best with and what suits the current job so Longsword, shortsword, dagger, bow, crossbow, knives, staff, axe etc. Write it as you wish just so long as it's not too outlandish.

The image is a good guide, I've been picturing the as

League_of_Assassins_members.webp


@The Dread King,What in particular makes them good against vamps? I'm curious, plus information on their fighting style is useful for a more in-depth understanding of the combat.

Mostly thanks to training, they've been trained to, and have, killed vampires during their times as undead assassins (the youngest of which have been dead for 50 years and most would be older) and they would likely have at least a few silvered weapons (even if just as heads for their arrows and bolts). They might also have poisons.

Much of the equipment is left up to the individual member to make best use of their talents (and to give each roleplayer some freedom in their posts).

Fighting style wise, the ones that are currently attacking the Council use Imperial (Western) weaponry and are trained in western grappling and various martial arts from Nippon and Cathay.

The more powerful ones would also have some skill in Illusionary magic but that is so rare that none may be present.

They can also all use a lesser version of Akarin's Shadow-step. This allows them to move from Shadow-to-Shadow and merge with existing shadows to become hard to see (a little like Fades from the Wheel of Time series).



Sorry if that isn't too useful, it's late and I don't have much time to post.
 
Last edited:
I have a couple questions, mainly, is Igor going to make it through the portal? I could see Igor hearing/seeing movement, hiding, backtracking to the camp, seeing the attack, and sneaking through the portal while still hidden.
 
I assume I should wait to post until the assassination scene is over?

The assassination scenes are only for existing characters - basically, they are just a way of wrapping up the current chapters. In a few weeks or so, once everything has been sorted out and new people have joined, we will be effectively "rebooting" the TVCII. There will be some sort of meeting at Drakenhof, and that's where all the new characters will come in.
 
Alright everyone, let's get posting in Chapter 5. To sum up what Nekhlior has done.

- Told everyone they need to get to the tear.
- Hid the present council members (So not Igor and possibly not Graveclaw if he didn't follow Rowhaine) while creating illusionary clones to momentarily distract Chaos (very momentary since they're only intangible copies).
- Whilst keeping them hidden he teleported them out of sight of the Chaos armies (but they'll eventually catch up).
- Nekhlior is not temporarily disabled due to the backlash of using the above magic without prep.

So let's get going!
 
The assassination scenes are only for existing characters - basically, they are just a way of wrapping up the current chapters. In a few weeks or so, once everything has been sorted out and new people have joined, we will be effectively "rebooting" the TVCII. There will be some sort of meeting at Drakenhof, and that's where all the new characters will come in.

Fair enough.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu