Grave Guards unit size and formation

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Oh sure, 4 demis slam into you, that's 16 attacks, hitting on 3s, wounding on 3s and 2s with no armor save allowed, and then their 4 S5 stomps are hitting simultaneously with your 10 remaining GG (he just killed 14-15 GG), hitting on 3s, wounding on 2s, that's 7 wounds, armor saving 1/2 of them, that's one dead demi. Combat res, he wins by 12 wounds and a charge, the unit crumbles.

Yep, GG with GWs are great... They just did the same thing 25 zombies would do... Speed bump
 
9 CHs have 36 wounds at T5 with a 5+, heck even if 4 demis WOULD have the flaming banner I'd bet the farm that they still beat 4 demis.
 
eggspr said:
Oh sure, 4 demis slam into you, that's 16 attacks, hitting on 3s, wounding on 3s and 2s with no armor save allowed, and then their 4 S5 stomps are hitting simultaneously with your 10 remaining GG (he just killed 14-15 GG)

Lol, why on god's earth would you field 25 GG? That's lunacy. Go 40 Horde or don't go GG.
 
You must be joking, eggspr - Demis with the Flaming Banner crush Crypt Horrors. The CHs cannot hurt them and their T4/1+ armor combo. This brings me to my point, which is that CHs and GGs fill different roles - CHs are a grinding unit at its best when fighting low-armor troops, whereas GGs are hard-punching infantry to crack open tin cans and the like. And yes, bringing 25 is a bad idea, which what The Sun King and I have been saying all along.
 
The Sun King said:
eggspr said:
Oh sure, 4 demis slam into you, that's 16 attacks, hitting on 3s, wounding on 3s and 2s with no armor save allowed, and then their 4 S5 stomps are hitting simultaneously with your 10 remaining GG (he just killed 14-15 GG)

Lol, why on god's earth would you field 25 GG? That's lunacy. Go 40 Horde or don't go GG.

Hey I'm just going what this guy said

"Which is better in your opinion? 24 GG with Barrows (6-7 wide?), or 29 (horde) without any command group? I can spend max 350pts and max 30 men strong units. I'll be facing mostly cavalry. I tried going 29 horde, but they get wiped out due to combat res, by 10 charging empire knights + priest+bsb..."

Rothgar I'll admit 40 GG with GWs is a can opener unit, moreso than Crypt Horrors. But point for point, CHs are a better piece. How about you place 400 points worth of GG with GWs against 400 points worth of CHs and you'll see how the CHs "grind" and how the GG can open things :)

A blender Lord in a unit of skellies is all the can opening you'll need, everything else must just retain and hold things for him to arrive and, wel... canopen lol

And whoa whoa whoa... 40 GG with GWs and the Barrows banner is 560 points! What comp do you guys play?! My opponents in my meta would laugh me outta the game shop as they feed that unit nothing but chaff while decimating everything else on the table.
 
I'm not going to argue about which is the more efficient buy for the points, as I also believe it is Crypt Horrors. What I'm arguing is that GGs can be a stand-alone fighting unit when invested in properly. I also believe that they're a "go big or go home" unit - if you don't pony up the points for a big Horde, you're better served by bringing Black Knights or Crypt Horrors instead.
 
Also why is your spirit host not fighting the demigryphs? Empire book is scary but honestly ours seems like a hard counter to it. My main problem with GG is their WS, at 3 most combat troops (even core) will be hitting before them on 3's and that will hurt.

As a side not flaming is not scary for horrors in the least unless it is S5+ flaming. S3-4 flaming is laughable
 
All valid points I think - good to see that it's a grown-up conversation(as always on this lovely forum).

@Eggie: I don't play comps - I play 8th Edition ;) And I've not met any opponent capable of outchaffing me yet :thumbsup:

@Rothgar: This is completely off topic I know, but I would take GG's over TG's any day. They cost less(if you give the GG GW and the TG Halberd), they have heavy armor, 1 better strength, access to banner of the barrows AND the can actually be raised(which the Tomb Kings have a very hard time doing).
 
If you're just shoe-horning Tomb Guard into the VC army, I would totally agree. Given the support structure in place for Tomb Guard, I actually disagree with that. S5 at I order is roughly as good as S6 at ASL speed in combat, and you have easy access to both WS6 and Hatred to put them over the top. You'd also be surprised at how well they can be raised - remember that every Nehekhara augment gives you back D3+1 guys, and then you have the Standard of the Undying Legion for what amounts to a L2 IoN. This is compounded by the fact that unlike VC, TK don't have that many quality alternatives to compare and constrast with - Necropolis Knights are really the only other unit who fill that role, and they're nowhere near as easy to buff or raise, plus you have to field them in separate units or hit diminishing returns pretty fast.
 
Speaking of TGs, Terrorgheists can be wonderful replacement for GW GG.

The point equivalent of 2 TGs is 31 GG with GW and Barrows. I'd take 2 TG all day and they can fill the same roll as the GG (hit high armor stuff). In addition they can charge mage bunkers and artillery. True, they can get hurt by cannons, but no more than how a big block of GG can get hurt by a stone thrower.

I wonder, with the role filled using rare choice, what Special choice would be advised to deal with mass numbers with low armour?

CR*P* H*RR*R*

Chuck Woolery, I'd like solve the puzzle, please :thumbsup:

And Merry Xmas :)
 
You miss the point Eggie... TG's are Rare, GG's are special - so I disagree that they fill the same role. Also I've never seen TG's used as an anvil.


rothgar13 said:
If you're just shoe-horning Tomb Guard into the VC army, I would totally agree. Given the support structure in place for Tomb Guard, I actually disagree with that. S5 at I order is roughly as good as S6 at ASL speed in combat, and you have easy access to both WS6 and Hatred to put them over the top. You'd also be surprised at how well they can be raised - remember that every Nehekhara augment gives you back D3+1 guys, and then you have the Standard of the Undying Legion for what amounts to a L2 IoN. This is compounded by the fact that unlike VC, TK don't have that many quality alternatives to compare and constrast with - Necropolis Knights are really the only other unit who fill that role, and they're nowhere near as easy to buff or raise, plus you have to field them in separate units or hit diminishing returns pretty fast.

I disagree. While I love Tomb Guards they cannot match GG's for several reasons:
a) They are 1 point more expensive.
b) they are S5 not S6 and since both units needs to be fielded in horde to really effective ASL doesn't make that much of a difference unless you have gone into a very poor matchup.
c) GG's is a standalone unit, TG's are not.
d) TG's have worse armor.
e) While banner of the undying legion is all well and fine it doesn't make up for Tomb King's poor ability to raise(you cannot even use their signature in CC).
f) While Hatred and WS5(few people would use a Tomb King, Tomb Prince is more likely), they are quite easily killed in close combat since Tomb Kings characters have poor options when it comes to protection and low Initiative. Which means that a good player would try to kill the Tomb Prince and Necrotect(and likely succeed) before the TG's get their swing and therefor the Hatred and WS5 will not take effect.
g) While WS5 is a good defensive investment it is not comparable with Banner of the Barrows because it is so much more expensive(for little other added benefit since a Tomb Prince is not really a blender).
h) Did I mention that we can raise d6+4 per casting of a our sig on these badboys? :)
i) TG's cannot March... never ever.
j) We can easily get the benefits of hatred with Vanhel's so no biggie there.
k) ... should I do the whole alphabet? :D
 
@Sun King

True, they come from a different part of our army book, but they do the same thing which is kill high armor stuff.

GG with GW aren't a hammer unit if u ask me. They are a glass cannon unit with one exception... before the "cannon" can fire, the glass breaks because the cannon always strikes last.

GG with GW are to me obsolete after our 8th edition army book came out. Gone are the days where you can spam VanHels, make them charge in the magic phase, have them ASF which makes them hit at Initiative AND get rerolls to hit.

The only caveat I could see them useful anymore would be to make a list with a horde of GW GG sitting in front of 2 Corpse Carts with Balefire. But this would be more of a draw list bc nobody would come close to that unit as long as the Corpse Carts are there.

So, without all the GW GGs and CCs, I use other things that destroy high armor stuff without getting into CC... TGs :)
 
I think going so far as to say that GG's are obsolete is a bit drastic, they work very well for me - and you seem overhyped with Crypt Horrors so you might not appreciate GG's the same way that I do. I've never said that GG's are a hammer, I've said that they are an anvil.

Reducing GG's to high armor killing is simply too simplistic, they have far more roles on the battlefield than that. They kill everything, the higher toughness all the better. It seems to me that we speak from our experiences and that is all good and fine, but you play with comps whereas I don't - so it's obvious that we won't find the same units to work well :)
 
Very true. Uncomped Warhammer is a world that I seldom visit.

To me, there are farrrr too many broken aspects in the game to have things uncomped. But that's for another topic :)
 
The only caveat I could see them useful anymore would be to make a list with a horde of GW GG sitting in front of 2 Corpse Carts with Balefire. But this would be more of a draw list bc nobody would come close to that unit as long as the Corpse Carts are there.

Just a little detail question:
Is there a specific reason you would rig both of the CC with Balefire? Would it not be more useful to give one of them Unholy Lodestone (provided you would have points to spare)?

And another thing: If you'd have a unit of GG with GW, and run 2 CC close enough behind it, and you would bubble-hit those 2 CC with a LoV spell, would the double Vigour Mortis give the GG ASF ( ergo: first ASF cancels out the ASL of the GW, and the second ASF will actually give the GG ASF), or would the GG only hit on In?
 
The Sun King said:
You miss the point Eggie... TG's are Rare, GG's are special - so I disagree that they fill the same role. Also I've never seen TG's used as an anvil.

That's missing the point. All non-Core troops have to contend for the same points allowance, so comparing them is not off-base, provided you can field said configurations. And one of the big draws of GG is the ability to deal with armor, which is something the TG also offer. Even if you don't want to compare across allowances, you can compare things that have the same basic role in the army, and they do.

The Sun King said:
I disagree. While I love Tomb Guards they cannot match GG's for several reasons:
a) They are 1 point more expensive.
b) they are S5 not S6 and since both units needs to be fielded in horde to really effective ASL doesn't make that much of a difference unless you have gone into a very poor matchup.
c) GG's is a standalone unit, TG's are not.
d) TG's have worse armor.
e) While banner of the undying legion is all well and fine it doesn't make up for Tomb King's poor ability to raise(you cannot even use their signature in CC).
f) While Hatred and WS5(few people would use a Tomb King, Tomb Prince is more likely), they are quite easily killed in close combat since Tomb Kings characters have poor options when it comes to protection and low Initiative. Which means that a good player would try to kill the Tomb Prince and Necrotect(and likely succeed) before the TG's get their swing and therefor the Hatred and WS5 will not take effect.
g) While WS5 is a good defensive investment it is not comparable with Banner of the Barrows because it is so much more expensive(for little other added benefit since a Tomb Prince is not really a blender).
h) Did I mention that we can raise d6+4 per casting of a our sig on these badboys? :)
i) TG's cannot March... never ever.
j) We can easily get the benefits of hatred with Vanhel's so no biggie there.
k) ... should I do the whole alphabet? :D

a) True, but not all that relevant. Unlike VC, TK aren't being pulled to dump a ton of points in Rare or characters, so what else would you do with those points?
b) Completely untrue after the first round, and sometimes even before that. Firing your salvo first spares you from a lot of potential pain, especially if you're around 40 men strong (aka don't have much room for error). A TG unit with a 'tect and a King/Prince avoids around 8 or so attacks from 40 GG by virtue of going first, and those 8 attacks turn what might have been a loss into a win. It also makes buffs like Speed of Light and Birona's Timewarp better on you.
c) Completely true, and a strike against TG.
d) Mostly irrelevant - what was the last time that 5+ save actually came up for you in combat? Because TG have the same save against shooting (they don't dump their shields).
e) Um... yes it does. It's a IoN casting that's always there for you if you need it, without cutting into any of your casters' spells known. Combine with the fact that TK actually get magic boosts and it matters a whole lot (because it can't be stopped as easily as IoN), plus Cursed Blades, Protection, and Righteous Smiting are all still combat-friendly. You're right, though, the sig not being usable in combat is dumb.
f) People sometimes field the King, mainly when they want a particular gear configuration that the Prince just doesn't have the allowance for. I've seen the King in a couple of TK forums' lists, and I have one in my own.
g) A Tomb Prince is +15 points over a Wight King. I wouldn't call that a major investment.
h) True, but only when cast by a L4 (so once per phase in most armies). Otherwise, you get D6+1 or 2, and all of a sudden that looks similar to what TK get from buffs, except you don't get buffed.
i) Don't need to - the rest of the army can (and should) be geared to make people come to you. Isn't long-range shooting grand?
j) TK win the buff war handily - can you say 5+ Ward save for the whole unit? Or 5+ KB for the whole unit?
k) Yes, keep going, because you've only made one, maybe two irrefutable points. And I don't play comp either, so it's not like I'm approaching this from the LocalMetaHammer or ETCHammer perspective.
 
I dont even think it is fair to compare TG and GG. Might as well toss all the equal specials and compare them all in that mindset (White Lions, Greatswords, Bestigor ect)
 
You could do that, just like the dude from Bad Dice with monstrous Cavalry (good stuff in it by the way). I predict that Grave Guard will be on the lower end of the range, because of how virtually all of the others are easier to support.
 
I dabble in them. I own very few models, but I proxy them up and have test games with willing participants on occasion, just so I feel I can understand how they play. My returns on the "fast list" with Chariots and Necro Knights were disappointing, the Khalida list was all right, and I have a TG-heavy infantry list as my new pet project.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu