The Sun King said:
You miss the point Eggie... TG's are Rare, GG's are special - so I disagree that they fill the same role. Also I've never seen TG's used as an anvil.
That's missing the point. All non-Core troops have to contend for the same points allowance, so comparing them is not off-base, provided you can field said configurations. And one of the big draws of GG is the ability to deal with armor, which is something the TG also offer. Even if you don't want to compare across allowances, you can compare things that have the same basic role in the army, and they do.
The Sun King said:
I disagree. While I love Tomb Guards they cannot match GG's for several reasons:
a) They are 1 point more expensive.
b) they are S5 not S6 and since both units needs to be fielded in horde to really effective ASL doesn't make that much of a difference unless you have gone into a very poor matchup.
c) GG's is a standalone unit, TG's are not.
d) TG's have worse armor.
e) While banner of the undying legion is all well and fine it doesn't make up for Tomb King's poor ability to raise(you cannot even use their signature in CC).
f) While Hatred and WS5(few people would use a Tomb King, Tomb Prince is more likely), they are quite easily killed in close combat since Tomb Kings characters have poor options when it comes to protection and low Initiative. Which means that a good player would try to kill the Tomb Prince and Necrotect(and likely succeed) before the TG's get their swing and therefor the Hatred and WS5 will not take effect.
g) While WS5 is a good defensive investment it is not comparable with Banner of the Barrows because it is so much more expensive(for little other added benefit since a Tomb Prince is not really a blender).
h) Did I mention that we can raise d6+4 per casting of a our sig on these badboys?

i) TG's cannot March... never ever.
j) We can easily get the benefits of hatred with Vanhel's so no biggie there.
k) ... should I do the whole alphabet?
a) True, but not all that relevant. Unlike
VC,
TK aren't being pulled to dump a ton of points in Rare or characters, so what else would you do with those points?
b) Completely untrue after the first round, and sometimes even before that. Firing your salvo first spares you from a lot of potential pain, especially if you're around 40 men strong (aka don't have much room for error). A TG unit with a 'tect and a King/Prince avoids around 8 or so attacks from 40 GG by virtue of going first, and those 8 attacks turn what might have been a loss into a win. It also makes buffs like Speed of Light and Birona's Timewarp better on you.
c) Completely true, and a strike against TG.
d) Mostly irrelevant - what was the last time that 5+ save actually came up for you in combat? Because TG have the same save against shooting (they don't dump their shields).
e) Um... yes it does. It's a IoN casting that's always there for you if you need it, without cutting into any of your casters' spells known. Combine with the fact that
TK actually get magic boosts and it matters a whole lot (because it can't be stopped as easily as IoN), plus Cursed Blades, Protection, and Righteous Smiting are all still combat-friendly. You're right, though, the sig not being usable in combat is dumb.
f) People sometimes field the King, mainly when they want a particular gear configuration that the Prince just doesn't have the allowance for. I've seen the King in a couple of
TK forums' lists, and I have one in my own.
g) A Tomb Prince is +15 points over a Wight King. I wouldn't call that a major investment.
h) True, but only when cast by a L4 (so once per phase in most armies). Otherwise, you get D6+1 or 2, and all of a sudden that looks similar to what
TK get from buffs, except you don't get buffed.
i) Don't need to - the rest of the army can (and should) be geared to make people come to you. Isn't long-range shooting grand?
j)
TK win the buff war handily - can you say 5+ Ward save for the whole unit? Or 5+ KB for the whole unit?
k) Yes, keep going, because you've only made one, maybe two irrefutable points. And I don't play comp either, so it's not like I'm approaching this from the LocalMetaHammer or ETCHammer perspective.