Gunhearts OOC Thread - Not valid - Old Gunhearts

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Yeah but Gree.. those books are slightly biased towards Marines aren't they.. I mean the Marines wouldn't be very heroic if they got their ceramite clad arses handed to them by a few Orks
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Last edition Ork codex there was a story about a mob of Orks going Hand-to-hand with a squad of Marines it was a pretty even fight
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

knightofni said:
Yeah but Gree.. those books are slightly biased towards Marines aren't they.. I mean the Marines wouldn't be very heroic if they got their ceramite clad arses handed to them by a few Orks

Regardless it still happened. And we have many examples of them doing it.

goulking88 said:
Last edition Ork codex there was a story about a mob of Orks going Hand-to-hand with a squad of Marines it was a pretty even fight

Last marine codex had 100 Marines taking on 50,000 orks and winning. And no, the story you were talking about was one nob and the orks took heavy casulties from the bolters before they even got there. And even then I could say that story is biased to the orks.

The difference is we have far, far ,far more examples of Marines destroying far greater numbers of orks than we do the opposite.

Which makes sense considering there are only a million Marines compared to countless billions of orks. The fluff for the Second War of Armegeddon had the Blood Angels destroy half of the entire ork army. 50 Iron Snakes take on 10,000 orks and walk away without a single casualty.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

yeah but you gotta remember only about a quarter of those Ork actualy got into melee the Marines did their little line up and shoot
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

And only the nob really did any damage.

Regardless, we still have far, far, far more examples of Marines taking on larger numbers of orks in close combat and winning.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

The only reason Orks are as strong as marines tabletop wise are just for balance, marines are definitely stronger and impossibly harder to kill due to their armor (dark heresy rules heavily confirm this). Plus, I didn't kill it with my headbutt, I ripped its head off.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

If you want to justify it we are the elite Deathwatch armed with the best weapons and armor. These orks are just scavengers mostly, poorly armed and funneled into a killing zone. In Sentius case he already is an elite ork killer even before enterign the Deathwatch.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFkFo5SBx-g

this is what a propper Ork/Marine Brawl is like

I just don't like how you crushed a Ork's skull with one punch a better representation would be if you punched it in the face and then decapitated it with your sword
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

goulking88 said:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFkFo5SBx-g

this is what a propper Ork/Marine Brawl is like

Your opinion of course, I'm going with the dozens upon dozens of books, stories and depictions in the codices as opposed to single animation for a video game were a Sergant decided to charge out of a defensive position for some strange reason.

goulking88 said:
I just don't like how you crushed a Ork's skull with one punch a better representation would be if you punched it in the face and then decapitated it with your sword

Sorry, my interpretation. And it's only one sentence. I don't see how it is major at all.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Think we could stop all the arguing in the OOC and get back to advancing with the killi- story in the main topic?
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Gree said:
goulking88 said:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFkFo5SBx-g

this is what a propper Ork/Marine Brawl is like

Your opinion of course, I'm going with the dozens upon dozens of books, stories and depictions in the codices as opposed to single animation for a video game were a Sergant decided to charge out of a defensive position for some strange reason.

goulking88 said:
I just don't like how you crushed a Ork's skull with one punch a better representation would be if you punched it in the face and then decapitated it with your sword

Sorry, my interpretation. And it's only one sentence. I don't see how it is major at all.

Dramatic Effect, Video Games don't have to be logical! :P

Anyway, in Gunhearts Marines are better than Orks.

That's that.

So how many more of them are their Gree?
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

this is going nowhere.

I'm just saying a Ork can easily go hand-to-hand with a Marine and not get his skull crushed by a cashual backhand tau or Eldar yes Ork or Tyranid no
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

goulking88 said:
this is going nowhere.

I'm just saying a Ork can easily go hand-to-hand with a Marine and not get his skull crushed by a cashual backhand tau or Eldar yes Ork or Tyranid no

Alright, I did't want to do this but.....

My roleplay, my rules. I try to accept various opinions of power levels due to the variety of different depictions. I expect other people to allow me leeway when writing my posts as I do their's. Sorry, but I'm going with the majority of GW fluff on this one. It's a minor point anyway.

knightofni said:
Give us a little bit longer with the Orks

It would still be orks, just a different troop type. I meant dealing with the common boyz.
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Gree said:
goulking88 said:
this is going nowhere.

I'm just saying a Ork can easily go hand-to-hand with a Marine and not get his skull crushed by a cashual backhand tau or Eldar yes Ork or Tyranid no

Alright, I did't want to do this but.....

My roleplay, my rules. I try to accept various opinions of power levels due to the variety of different depictions. I expect other people to allow me leeway when writing my posts as I do their's. sorry, but I'm going with the majority of GW fluff on this one.


No it's a fair point Gree, you're running the show.


Anyway I'm off for tonight, so I'll post tommorrow (which I guess will be roughly when we advance things)
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

Well if we're about to fight something big, let me go ahead and get my crozius back :P
 
RE: Gunhearts OOC Thread

I don't know, I'm away for a few hours and an argument breaks out xd

Anyway, nicely handled Gree. Logical comeback with supporting sources. And just so anyone is not clear on this: As it said in the first post, Gree calls the shot on this RP, the only one who should be arguing with him is me (which I wouldn't do anyway xd).

Anyway I'm glad you didn't progress, as with me getting back late I need a chance to post.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu