Ignoring FAQs

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Sep 26, 2013
138
Zombies
0
I've been wondering for a while why it is that people always seem to pressure others to conform to what GW says the official rules are? Why is the idea of using older rules so alien to many people, and why must players always use the latest FAQs when playing a game?

For example, the FAQ for the Vampire counts book that was released last year. The book clearly states that Blood Knights can be resurrected at the rate of 1+ Wizard Level. There are no two ways about it and it is very clear cut due to one word - MODEL. However, the FAQ effectively changes that word to UNIT.

So, in effect, GW nerfed a unit that was already not that amazingly overpowered especially when you consider the price of Blood Knights in terms of points and money.

I say that if someone spent all that money and all those points on taking blood knights they should be able to do as the book says and disregard the FAQ, because quite frankly it isn't fair to only be able to raise 1 blood knight per casting, especially when opponents frequently take magic-heavy armies that can shut down your magic phase with ease, and take high toughness units with regen and other stuff that can easily hold out against blood knights long enough for them to get counter charged and obliterated.

It's not as if Blood Knights are overpowered even with the 1+ wizard level raising of them - having frenzy is a doubled edged sword after all, and they really aren't that tough with only toughness 4, 1 wound and a measly 2+ armour save with a 4+ ward (against shooting ONLY) if you spend an extra 75 POINTS. Then of course there's the fact that they are undead and have unstable, so if they lose a combat not only do they lose frenzy, they also take wounds!

So like I said, I think that FAQs should only be relevant and heeded when applied to a very old army that doesn't work without it (Bretonnians, Wood Elves, Dwarfs), but for a book that's only been out just over a year?

What do you think?
 
Well, I think it's important to remember that the FAQs are not "official" changes to the rules. They're just recommendations based on the way the studio plays. The errata sections are official changes, but the FAQs are not.

The most important thing, however, is to simply talk with your opponent before the game starts so we're all on the same page. If you're playing with a regular group of guys you'll all no doubt come up with your own variation of house rules and accepted (or ignored) FAQs and other rules interpretations. However, when you're playing someone new it's best to stick to the commonly accepted level playing field. Or at least take the time to discuss the various rules before the game starts.
 
"FAQs, or Frequently Asked Questions are grey areas, points of confusion or places where rules can and have been interpreted in conflicting ways. For each FAQ we provide the answer as determined by the Games Development team; while these are not hard and fast rules text in the same way as Errata, they should be considered the 'official' interpretation."
 
Well I don't play at tournaments. I've never been part of a tournament and I don't intend on ever attending one. There's a real problem in the Warhammer hobby in that too many people conform to what GW says.

"Just because they said something that contradicts their own book, I'm going to do exactly what they say because it's OFFICIAL and I have to follow what everyone else says..."

Personally I'm not going to listen to it and just go by what the book says, mainly because it suits me, but also because I think it's stupid that GW change rules like that. What is the point in making these expensive books only to have them modified by stupid FAQs? Yes if the book is really old, like Brets, then fine FAQ it because it wouldn't work without it.

I'm repeating myself here but that's because I feel very strongly about this.

Just because it's official, that's it, everyone must obey and follow what is said. But why must it be that way?
 
they wrote the book why wouldn't they be able to change/correct things as they see fit?

the thought of facing a big blood knight unit that can resurrect more then 1 model at a time gives me brown trousers :)
 
The thing is though, unlike an online game where you have to go along with changes, this is different. The book is a physical thing, I can choose to use whatever rules I want as long as I can convince my gaming group / opponent that my assessment is correct.

However most people choose not to, and instead choose to conform and become part of the little tribe of powergamers who follow GW's rulings to the letter without fail.

Anyway like I said before, the blood knight "deathstar" with the multiple models per casting rule is not that tough. You can easily shut down a magic phase with dispel scroll etc. then strike hard and knock the blood knights out in one blow. It's not that difficult.

Even if someone pulled out the FAQ and said "You can't do that because this piece of paper says you can't" I'd still argue with them and say that you can simply because it's an FAQ and not part of the actual book.
 
Deathless Dreamer said:
Even if someone pulled out the FAQ and said "You can't do that because this piece of paper says you can't" I'd still argue with them and say that you can simply because it's an FAQ and not part of the actual book.


At which stage, most people would pack up their models and silently decide not to play with you again.

Y'see, there's such a thing as a social contract, and agreement, however informal, which can form between two people.

For example two people deciding to play a game of the warhams is a social contract where both sides agree to certain unspoken rules.

1) We'll use tokens and small plastic cubes with dots on them to simulate a battle according to the disperate collection of rules and rulebooks collectively known as 'Warhammer Fantasy Battles'.

2) No biting.


There are other elements of the social contract, but those are the main ones. 'Warhammer Fantasy Battles' is whatever Games Workshop says it is, including the core rulebook, fifteen Army Books (with the provision for more or fewer in the future) and any supplements or errata Games Workshop might choose to publish.

You might wish to ignore some or all of that, and that is okay, but you have to accept that you aren't actually playing Warhammer at that point. you're playing some other (very similar) game and that's also okay.

However, if your opponent thinks you're both playing Warhammer, he may be justifiably upset to find out that that's not the case.

If you want to play a game similar to Warhammer, but with key differences (that happen to make your army a little stronger) then the onus is on you to make that clear to your opponent before he decides if he wants to play with you.
 
Well the thing is most people at my local club don't give a damn about FAQs, but there is one guy who does. He's one of those hardcore nerdy types that you see too many of at Games Workshop hobby stores and of which a few filter through into local clubs like the one I go to. He's the kind of person who has to follow what games workshop says to the letter. He's also very irritating to be around and very arrogant. Funny that.

Anyway, it's an FAQ. It's just their interpretation of a commonly asked question. If you actually read it says that the only parts you have to follow are the amendments and errata sections - the FAQ is just their answer to a question, nothing more, meaning there is no fundamental problem with the rules that prevents them from working, it's just that many players got confused about it (I don't see how it's worded quite clearly as models). As such I can have my own answer to the question and it is equally valid in the game and equally correct, just not the official answer.
 
Deathless Dreamer said:
As such I can have my own answer to the question and it is equally valid in the game and equally correct, just not the official answer.

And that leaves the door wide open for the rest of the group to come with their own interpretations as well. By using the official answers wherever you can you'll have a more rigid baseline that's easier to follow for everyone if they're the type to keep themselves updated on the game.

As another plus it'll also make your gaming experiences more relatable to most theoretical internet discussions, where using the full official set of rules is common.
 
Nagashizzar said:
"FAQs, or Frequently Asked Questions are grey areas, points of confusion or places where rules can and have been interpreted in conflicting ways. For each FAQ we provide the answer as determined by the Games Development team; while these are not hard and fast rules text in the same way as Errata, they should be considered the 'official' interpretation."

these are not hard and fast rules

They say themselves, the FAQs are not rules. Just interpretations by the GW team. No one is under any obligation to take those interpretations as gospel.

As mentioned above, the key is simply communicating with your opponent so everyone is on the same page.
 
Deathless Dreamer said:
Well the thing is most people at my local club don't give a damn about FAQs, but there is one guy who does. He's one of those hardcore nerdy types that you see too many of at Games Workshop hobby stores and of which a few filter through into local clubs like the one I go to. He's the kind of person who has to follow what games workshop says to the letter. He's also very irritating to be around and very arrogant. Funny that.

Anyway, it's an FAQ. It's just their interpretation of a commonly asked question. If you actually read it says that the only parts you have to follow are the amendments and errata sections - the FAQ is just their answer to a question, nothing more, meaning there is no fundamental problem with the rules that prevents them from working, it's just that many players got confused about it (I don't see how it's worded quite clearly as models). As such I can have my own answer to the question and it is equally valid in the game and equally correct, just not the official answer.

If your club doesn't care about the official rules that is great, you could even write your own FAQ, but take note that this is not the most common way of doing things. As said the reasons for following FAQ's are many, most importantly it is easier as all players use the same rules and the interpretation of these rules.

Just make sure your opponent knows you do not follow the official rulings to buff your army, before you start playing.
 
The only important thing is that you are both playing to the same sheet. If you don't use FAQ, fine. I don't, usually. But if an opponent feels them vital, also fine- I have to play with the aforementioned social contract. Live with it or get off your soapbox.
 
Like it has said before in this thread, you are quite free to poke the player you are playing with.
Just respect his or her decision if he/she wants to play according to the latest FAQ.
 
I... kinda have to disagree with the OP, not to cause trouble, but FAQs, Amendments and Erratas come all from the same source (Games Workshop) and they write the books.

So, if a FAQ says you can or can't do something (and those are very very specific, like using Ghostly Howl in a close combat the user is not itself involved), then we follow those rules.

In the end, any logic anyone uses will have its counter-argument. Warhammer Fantasy is a game that encourages people to both follow a specific set of rules, but also to interpret the grey areas the rules don't quite cover.

FAQs, and all sorts of additional information we get from them, serve to state facts and not assume things.

As an example, if the Goblin Fanatics can move through units and don't have to travel all the distance to come out of the other side and still apply their effect, well that's cool for them. Hexwraiths have no such clarification, even if their effects are practically the same. Without a FAQ, that case will never be clear, and they can't just print "fresh" copies of the book with the amendment on them (well actually they could, in digital versions...)

The point is: if it comes from Games Workshop in an official statement (forum questions are not official, even if answered by a staff member), then it is just as good as if it was printed in the original release of the book itself. Rules as written.

My (debatable) opinion on the matter.
 
Erratas, amendments and FAQs are official changes to the rules. They are to be used. If you choose not to use them, don't pick and choose which ones you use.
 
Demian said:
The point is: if it comes from Games Workshop in an official statement (forum questions are not official, even if answered by a staff member), then it is just as good as if it was printed in the original release of the book itself. Rules as written.

Ravenheart said:
Erratas, amendments and FAQs are official changes to the rules. They are to be used. If you choose not to use them, don't pick and choose which ones you use.

these are not hard and fast rules

It's important to remember that the FAQs themselves state that they are NOT rules. They are how the studio would choose to resolve that particular question. Personally, I think the studio frequently get it wrong and frequently write naff rules to start with. However I usually play with the full suite of FAQs for the sake of player harmony. I would hate for someone to think I was ignoring an FAQ for my own advantage.

But let's not fool ourselves into thinking anything stated by the studio is an official change to the rules. The errata are exactly that: changes to the rules. But the FAQs are just interpretations of grey areas, and we are under no obligation to follow them.
 
Considering the interpretation comes to the people who wrote the rules I would imagine it's mostly wise to follow them x)

But ah well! Like said before in the end stuff can be discussed with those you play with.
 
Blutsauger said:
It's important to remember that the FAQs themselves state that they are NOT rules. They are how the studio would choose to resolve that particular question. Personally, I think the studio frequently get it wrong and frequently write naff rules to start with. However I usually play with the full suite of FAQs for the sake of player harmony. I would hate for someone to think I was ignoring an FAQ for my own advantage.

But let's not fool ourselves into thinking anything stated by the studio is an official change to the rules. The errata are exactly that: changes to the rules. But the FAQs are just interpretations of grey areas, and we are under no obligation to follow them.

EXACTLY.
 
I'm in agreement here. FAQ's are really helpful in clearing things up but some things that they put in the FAQ's are complete contradictions to the army books (Like the Blood Knight thing). I'm not quite sure if they're trying to even out the rules with it (which isn't needed) or if this was what the writers meant when writing the book, but either way, they can be used or forgotten, and as said before, just make sure that your opponent agrees that FAQ's won't be used. That or just see if he'll/She'll just let you ignore that 1 piece of it. I mean, in friendly games house rules are used all the time, there should be no reason why tourney rules should have to be used 100%.
 
Blutsauger said:
these are not hard and fast rules

It's important to remember that the FAQs themselves state that they are NOT rules. They are how the studio would choose to resolve that particular question. Personally, I think the studio frequently get it wrong and frequently write naff rules to start with. However I usually play with the full suite of FAQs for the sake of player harmony. I would hate for someone to think I was ignoring an FAQ for my own advantage.

But let's not fool ourselves into thinking anything stated by the studio is an official change to the rules. The errata are exactly that: changes to the rules. But the FAQs are just interpretations of grey areas, and we are under no obligation to follow them.

What what???? jesus I remember saying this on another forum and people and I thought I was going to get burnt at the stake like a heretic!
 
logan054 said:
Blutsauger said:
these are not hard and fast rules

It's important to remember that the FAQs themselves state that they are NOT rules. They are how the studio would choose to resolve that particular question. Personally, I think the studio frequently get it wrong and frequently write naff rules to start with. However I usually play with the full suite of FAQs for the sake of player harmony. I would hate for someone to think I was ignoring an FAQ for my own advantage.

But let's not fool ourselves into thinking anything stated by the studio is an official change to the rules. The errata are exactly that: changes to the rules. But the FAQs are just interpretations of grey areas, and we are under no obligation to follow them.

What what???? jesus I remember saying this on another forum and people and I thought I was going to get burnt at the stake like a heretic!

I've written the whole discussion off as a House Rules thread.
 
Sounds like your gaming group is pretty insular. If I were a newcomer there, I'd find somewhere outside of your clique to play.

I take offense to you resorting to tropes and stereotypes when it comes to people you disagree with. Call the guy nerdy because he insists on using the faqs? Bro? You play the same hobby he does. I'd pack my stuff up. You don't seem like much fun to play anyways.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu