Ignoring FAQs

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Vortaine said:
Sounds like your gaming group is pretty insular. If I were a newcomer there, I'd find somewhere outside of your clique to play.

I take offense to you resorting to tropes and stereotypes when it comes to people you disagree with. Call the guy nerdy because he insists on using the faqs? Bro? You play the same hobby he does. I'd pack my stuff up. You don't seem like much fun to play anyways.

Oh you hurt my feelings.

Seriously though, if you want to follow games workshop like a drone then be my guest. It's not just my gaming group either. It's everywhere. FAQs are NOT, I repeat NOT official rulings. If you want to think they are then by all means do so. However it's not the case. Also the guy I mentioned IS arrogant, what more do you want me to say? Then again you seem to be behaving just like him.
 
Adam_Barrow said:
I've written the whole discussion off as a House Rules thread.
I just skim read it ;)

Deathless Dreamer said:
Oh you hurt my feelings.

Seriously though, if you want to follow games workshop like a drone then be my guest. It's not just my gaming group either. It's everywhere. FAQs are NOT, I repeat NOT official rulings. If you want to think they are then by all means do so. However it's not the case. Also the guy I mentioned IS arrogant, what more do you want me to say? Then again you seem to be behaving just like him.

I've tried explaining this to people many times over the years, I've seen it all over warseer, well GW use FAQ as errata's! You can point out the disclaimer and nothing, it will never sink in, people will apply them no matter how little sense they make, that seems the nature of the game. Be thankful, the people you know actually know the rules! jesus, last time I went into my LGS I had to switch to off to all the bullshit coming out of peoples mouths. Now I hardly play 40k, but I do know that power weapons have a set points cost and you pick the one you like. I mean these guys had a 5 minute discussion about it! I remember some other silly things which are rules which haven't really changed since 4th ed!
 
@Vortiane: Now lets not be rude. These are oppinions and DD can have his own about people, just as you can, but lets try to be respectful to everyones ideas.

@Deathless Dreamer: I know you didn't start it but lets try not to retaliate. You have one idea and others have their own ideas.

Lets all just be civil, there is no reason that we need to be disrespectful to others, forums are about opinions and questions. There is no right or wrong answer, just ideas.

Now that thats done:

@Logan054/Deathless Dreamer: While I agree that the FAQ's are not rules, I don't think that they are to be completely ignored. There are many iffy areas that the FAQ's do indeed clear up, and I think that this is why people use them as official rulings. If there is an argument that is cleared up by an FAQ then that is what people go by. I personally always play by all FAQ's as if they are written in stone. Not because I agree with all of them, or I like all of them, but because that is how tourney's are played.

I see ignoring FAQ's the same way that I see a 7th ed game or beerhammer. It's a house rule/fun style game. There is no reason why you should ever feel the need to have to follow specific rules in the book for fun games if you don't want to.
 
logan054 said:
I've tried explaining this to people many times over the years, I've seen it all over warseer, well GW use FAQ as errata's! You can point out the disclaimer and nothing, it will never sink in, people will apply them no matter how little sense they make, that seems the nature of the game. Be thankful, the people you know actually know the rules! jesus, last time I went into my LGS I had to switch to off to all the bullshit coming out of peoples mouths. Now I hardly play 40k, but I do know that power weapons have a set points cost and you pick the one you like. I mean these guys had a 5 minute discussion about it! I remember some other silly things which are rules which haven't really changed since 4th ed!

It's not so much the nature of the game, it's more that the people who play it tend to be zealously obsessed with following games workshop. They want to be part of the whole "official organisation" thing, and they enforce it like it's the law, stifling out all other alternatives. There seems to be this looming spectre of "the way it's done at the tournaments" that makes these people go "ooooh if I don't do that the way they tell me to then I will diiiiiieeeee".

I think it stems from wanting to have everything organised in a rigid manner, even when it says in the rules they so adamantly and obsessively follow like frothing zealots that the FAQs are not actual rules at all. But to them, sadly, the developers and game designers at GW are some kind of neolithic gods, that must be obeyed or there will be serious retribution. :lol:
 
Or they just trust the judgment of GW. As often the FAQ answers mean some unit ( or so it seems ) are nerfed. So of course players using said units don't want to use the FAQ :P
 
Maybe this will help us... continue arguing? hahaha

"FAQs, or Frequently Asked Questions are grey areas, points of confusion or places where rules can and have been interpreted in conflicting ways. For each FAQ we provide the answer as determined by the Games Development team; while these are not hard and fast rules text in the same way as Errata, they should be considered the 'official' interpretation."

This is on GW's page.

So... all of us are right. They are both not "hard rules", yet they are official interpretations.

=D
 
Calling me a drone is amusing, given this whole "discussion" has been your dismissal of anyone who plays it differently. I didn't even mention how I played and yet how I supposedly choose to play is mocked.

This isn't a discussion. You are telling me how I should play the game, just like GW supposedly tells you how you should play. If you and your cliche want to play without FAQs or with your own that's *fine,* and I encourage it, but your group becomes insular the more that happens.

I routinely play new people and that's where using the FAQs as official (which they are, even if they are only the official opinion) simplifies things since we start on the same page.

Case in point, two weeks ago I played 3.5 edition chaos vs 6th edition space marines, 5,000 points of nostalgia. I did it with a regular buddy of mine and it was cool because I hate current chaos (the book is garbage) but it was something we arranged. Would I bring it to my FOGS and just whip it out unexpectedly? No, and I'd argue for the sake of arguing that a better case is made to allow old codices and army books since nowhere (if i remember correctly) does it say I have to use the newest edition when organizing a battle.

The guy who posted about the social contract hit it spot on. If you want to play with your buds this way, go for it. Don't expect to walk in and get a game in with me if we aren't on the same rules-page otherwise.
 
Errata's and FAQs are very important for books that are designed to work with old editions of the game
I know books like the dwarves have changes to entire stat lines of units (i.e. the Anvil) so that they are compatible with the current edition of the game. You clearly acknowledge in your original post that
rulings like this are necessary.

Who are you to decide which FAQs and erratas are to be followed and which aren't? I am certainly not going to listen to your choices over the creators of the game.

Are dwarf players supposed to ignore rulings that make their army playable in this edition of the game
just because you want to ignore a ruling that makes one of your units a bit weaker? Or should you follow the FAQs and Erratas that allow their army to be playable in this edition of the game? How long does the new vampire book have to wait before they make changes or suggestions on how the book should be played? 2 years? Next Edition?

This conversation seems silly to me. I am not sure why you would not want to play with up to date and clear rulings on the intentions of how units are supposed to function in the game.

If you want to play house rules with some friends that is your prerogative but don't expect gaming groups to want to ignore errata's and FAQ's just so that it will benefit you as a general. Rulings are released for a reason, regardless of whether or not you dislike that reason or feel it is unfair or hate Games Workshop. They cannot play test all outcomes prior to releasing a book. They are only human as you suggest and hence why Errata's and FAQs exist.
 
Willis_Zen said:
Errata's and FAQs are very important for books that are designed to work with old editions of the game
I know books like the dwarves have changes to entire stat lines of units (i.e. the Anvil) so that they are compatible with the current edition of the game. You clearly acknowledge in your original post that
rulings like this are necessary.

Who are you to decide which FAQs and erratas are to be followed and which aren't? I am certainly not going to listen to your choices over the creators of the game.

Are dwarf players supposed to ignore rulings that make their army playable in this edition of the game
just because you want to ignore a ruling that makes one of your units a bit weaker? Or should you follow the FAQs and Erratas that allow their army to be playable in this edition of the game? How long does the new vampire book have to wait before they make changes or suggestions on how the book should be played? 2 years? Next Edition?

This conversation seems silly to me. I am not sure why you would not want to play with up to date and clear rulings on the intentions of how units are supposed to function in the game.

If you want to play house rules with some friends that is your prerogative but don't expect gaming groups to want to ignore errata's and FAQ's just so that it will benefit you as a general. Rulings are released for a reason, regardless of whether or not you dislike that reason or feel it is unfair or hate Games Workshop. They cannot play test all outcomes prior to releasing a book. They are only human as you suggest and hence why Errata's and FAQs exist.

Erm well if you'd actually read what I said instead of jumping to conclusions like a fool you would know that I said nothing of the sort. I fully acknowledge that ERRATAS and AMENDMENTS are ACTUAL CHANGES to the rules, but NOT FAQs.

You are JUST like most of the people who play this god-forsaken game anyway - a bunch of drones (and I repeat the word "drone" because it is extremely apt) who worship games workshop like they're some kind of god.

I went to my local club today and I spoke to the aforementioned arrogant nerd and he literally said to me that "Games workshop are the gods of the Warhammer world." He literally said that. So you can see where I get my evidence from. But, of course, you don't believe me, and of course you won't listen to me because, again, you're arrogant and you think that a lowly peasant like me cannot ever hope to reach a level of greatness that Games Workshop did.

You can deny it all you want but it is the truth. FAQs are NOT RULES, they are THEIR ANSWER TO A GREY AREA. Why don't you, instead of mindlessly following games workshop, actually assess the game yourself? If you did you would realise how balanced Blood Knights being raised at 1+ Wizard Level actually is when compared to goddamn nuke spells like effing Dwellers, Pit of Shades, and Final Transmutation.

I am so sick of being harassed and told that I am wrong when all I am doing is reading the rules as they are written instead of brainlessly following GWs unfair assessment of an already relatively weak army.
 
Vortaine said:
Calling me a drone is amusing, given this whole "discussion" has been your dismissal of anyone who plays it differently. I didn't even mention how I played and yet how I supposedly choose to play is mocked.

This isn't a discussion. You are telling me how I should play the game, just like GW supposedly tells you how you should play. If you and your cliche want to play without FAQs or with your own that's *fine,* and I encourage it, but your group becomes insular the more that happens.

I routinely play new people and that's where using the FAQs as official (which they are, even if they are only the official opinion) simplifies things since we start on the same page.

Case in point, two weeks ago I played 3.5 edition chaos vs 6th edition space marines, 5,000 points of nostalgia. I did it with a regular buddy of mine and it was cool because I hate current chaos (the book is garbage) but it was something we arranged. Would I bring it to my FOGS and just whip it out unexpectedly? No, and I'd argue for the sake of arguing that a better case is made to allow old codices and army books since nowhere (if i remember correctly) does it say I have to use the newest edition when organizing a battle.

The guy who posted about the social contract hit it spot on. If you want to play with your buds this way, go for it. Don't expect to walk in and get a game in with me if we aren't on the same rules-page otherwise.

You have taken what I said COMPLETELY out of context. I did not say anything about using old army books or codices, so your argument is completely and utterly invalid. However it seems you are adamant on playing the part of arrogant snob, so I'm probably wasting my time with you.

Again, (for it seems I must keep repeating myself to break through your indoctrination) I am talking about, quite specifically in fact, FAQs and FAQs alone. No old editions, no previous army books. FAQs.

FAQs are NOT OFFICIAL RULINGS. It says that ON THE DOWNLOAD PAGE ITSELF - perhaps you should read that little side note? They are to be used only when two players cannot reach an agreement about a specific rule. They are not the gospel, no matter how much you want to preach it.

On a side note, I often think to myself that people like you would be better off in a church serving as a priest.
 
Maybe you shouldn't play Games Workshops games?

Regardless of whether you like Games Workshop or not it is their game and their rules. If you don't want to follow them then don't play their game.

You could make your own rule set with all sorts of rules that you like.
If you write a good rule set and have a good business model maybe you could get people to follow those rules.

As for myself, I play Warhammer and will follow the rules that are released. Their FAQ like you said clears up the "GREY" area about how many Blood Knights may be resurrected with Invocation. I wouldn't play this game with you either because I put in my 2 cents in on the matter and you call me a "brainless" "fool" "drone".

You ever take a step back and think "Man, all these "drones" disagree with me; maybe I am incorrect about this"? I was not present for this game but I could see you trying to play a game like this; having your opponent point out the ruling and than arguing with him about it for 10 minutes. Why not just say alright, no worries, I understand that you want to follow the FAQ that was released lets move on and enjoy playing the game. If he was rude about it RISE ABOVE him and move on.

Are you any better than him? It is just a game. Were you going to lose the game if that ruling didn't work in your favor? Oh well. Were you upset because you were going to lose? If you weren't going to lose then why does the ruling even matter?
 
Yeah but the thing is I know I am not incorrect, and I know that you are just mindlessly following Games Workshop. I like Warhammer, in fact I love it, but what I really hate is when people try to enforce unofficial rules like what you're doing so that they can have an advantage over someone else's army and THEN have the audacity to demand that I conform to what you say is the "official ruling" when it clearly is NOT the official ruling, and then threaten me, the person who is simply reading the book as it is written, with isolation. Which is exactly what makes you agree with what GW say on the matter, and which is exactly what you get your kicks out of.

Also, how can you enjoy a game when your opponent clearly has a massive advantage over you in the form of simply going "oh well hurr durr the FAQ says you can't do that". I just won't accept this kind of crap where Games Workshop's answers are taken as gospel - it really is like trying to argue with a religious person. That's the level of zealotry common amongst "gamers" like you - there simply is no other way than Games Workshop's way, no matter what the actual books say, no matter what it says on their own website.

Oh and Shareya, change your signature, it's effing irritating. And if you think I'm an "ass" then you know what you can do.
 
Deathless Dreamer said:
You have taken what I said COMPLETELY out of context...
... so I'm probably wasting my time with you.
On a side note, I often think to myself that people like you would be better off in a church serving as a priest.

This thread serves absolutely no purpose.
It didn't even do so in the beginning.
Your mind is set, you don't want to argue, so what's the point ?

And the only thing you've been onto for the last few posts has been to repeadetly insult people because they do not share your opinion about silly FAQs.
Period.


FAQs are NOT OFFICIAL RULINGS. It says that ON THE DOWNLOAD PAGE ITSELF - perhaps you should read that little side note? Bla bla bla ...

If all this is so crystal clear, then why did you start this topic in the first place ?

Now, pretty please with some icing on it, could a mod please lock this farce of a 'thread' before someone gets seriously hurt ?

Gods, I miss Johnny ...

West
 
while these are not hard and fast rules text in the same way as Errata, they should be considered the 'official' interpretation."

Again I need to point out it still is the whole "The people who make the rules are stating how the rule actually works." You can't blame people for taking their word for it x)
 
Does a Magical Vortex template hurt a unit that it moves over beyond it's normal distance because it can't land on top of another unit? Grey area. Some say yes, others say no, FAQ says no.


Demian said:
Maybe this will help us... continue arguing? hahaha

"FAQs, or Frequently Asked Questions are grey areas, points of confusion or places where rules can and have been interpreted in conflicting ways. For each FAQ we provide the answer as determined by the Games Development team; while these are not hard and fast rules text in the same way as Errata, they should be considered the 'official' interpretation."

This is on GW's page.

So... all of us are right. They are both not "hard rules", yet they are official interpretations.

=D


but what I really hate is when people try to enforce unofficial rules like what you're doing so that they can have an advantage over someone else's army

They are official, not actual rules. It's been said a bagillion times here. Why is it that people are still arguing? Now it's just name calling.

DD: Play how you want! I'm not going to bust into your shop and say that you aren't playing the game right because you're not following every rule.

Myself? I will continue playing with every FAQ as if they were in the initial rulebook. Why? because that is how I expect others to play. Call me what you may. Drone, Fool, Arrogant, Moron, What-have-you. But in the end I know that I will not be stepping on anyones toes by picking and choosing which parts of the FAQ to use and which not to. There are to many rules in this book to go through picking and choosing and still having a smooth game.
 
This thread was started with the intention of me getting confirmation that FAQs were not official rulings - and if you read back you would see that others have agreed with me multiple times.

You complain that I am insulting people? Why don't you actually look and see that it was they who initiated the insults with the clear intent to derail this thread?

Admittedly I could have ignored them. But it really riles me up when I have to deal with such preachers of nonsense.
 
Deathless Dreamer, I beg you to stop calling people names, either directly or indirectly. Re-read some of your posts, calling people "mindless", "drones", "arrogant", this is just on this page of this thread.. Jesus.. More namecalling can be found in other of your posts.

I like the VERY civil tone on this forum, if you do not, there are a lot of other fora where you can throw internet-linguistic-feces.

People are not mindless just because they do not share your oppinion.

I follow the FAQ's because it is easier, there are other grey areas not covered by FAQ's that often needs addressing during a game, if following an FAQ can make a game run more smoothly I do so, as it too me adds to the enjoyment of the game more than it takes away.
 
Deathless Dreamer said:
but what I really hate is when people try to enforce unofficial rules like what you're doing so that they can have an advantage over someone else's army.

Is this not exactly what you are doing?

You are saying "I can res my Blood Knights more than 1 model per casting."

Everyone else is saying: "Games Workshop (The creator of the rule set) officially stated on a release on their website that you may not."

Whether it be a FAQ or an interpretation or an Errata. It doesn't matter, people who play the game will read that and think. "Oh my Vampire Counts opponent will not be able to do this when I play against them"

Now you are upset because people don't agree with you for choosing to ignore what they all read on the official Games Workshop website so that your unit of Blood Knights has an advantage over your opponents army.

Do you see where the confusion comes in? "Let's use Errata's and Not FAQs" or "Let's ignore this FAQ because it suits me better" Where do you draw a line in the sand? Why wouldn't you use up to date posted rules that everyone reads and has access to? Saying "because it makes you a drone, man!", "I don't follow GWs rules!", "I am a rebel" is not an argument. You just admitted that you are not following the rules.
 
[mod]Deathless Dreamer - having read and reviewed this thread, I am in agreement that your tone and language has been unnecessarily offensive to other forum members.

On CN this is unacceptable. If you have not already done so, please read the forum rules. Whilst everyone is free to express their opinions, it is their own responsibility to do so in a non-offensive manner. Even after you were reminded of this in a friendly manner by other members, the posts continued, resulting in an argumentative thread.

I have also noted that the people you called "drones" etc where the people who disagreed with you. If you wish people to respect your opinion, you need to show the same respect in kind. You may find other peoples views frustrating but that does not grant you the right to insult them.

I will be monitoring further posts, and will take necessary action should any further posts in breach of forum rules occur.

If you wish to discuss this further then please PM me.

Disciple of Nagash[/mod]
 
It is true that some grey areas have been left uncovered, and sometimes the rulings don't quite make sense:

a) Do Mortis Engine's Reliquary explosion add to combat resolution?

Some may say yes, others would say no. Hell, GW will even say something and then take it back (remember Soul Leech and Mindrazor?)

And yes, it IS annoying that some rules change in favor/against some armies (remember Death - Fist Ogres?)

And yet... that is the fun of the game! Expecting everything to remain the same is (at least for me) kinda boring. I always look forward to the release of new books, even non-VC because I want my vampires to face ever changing enemies! I like that some elves became immune to magical attacks! I like it that my Terrorgheist can melt stuff that is fighting zombies, but he (is it a he.. or a she?) himself is safe from combat resolution.

I liked the time when crumbling would prevent overruning, and I like it now that it doesn't. It challenges me to become a much better general, instead of just using Invocation on every blood knight unit to keep it alive.


In the spirit of the game, we don't actually make any rules, we follow them, but never mindlessly; we do so to enjoy a game with difficulty. Now, FAQs should not be different from any other rules, they state (very clearly) what happens in a given situation.

Why follow FAQs? because in this forum, we like to test new stuff against changing rules, and overcoming obstacles! Blood Knights seem a bit underpowered? try them against Dark Elves! (my most recent endeavor) and watch them shine, even better than a Terrorgheist/Vargulf/Mortis Engine, our all-time classics!


Even if this is just my opinion, I make it so it will inspire, not to restrict... and that's why it should matter to be read!
 
I also disagree, FAQ are the official interpretations of certain rules and how they apply to the game, when someone looks up the rules and wishes to prepare a defence, they will refer to the FAQ to ensure they understand the rule correctly, for you to then turn around and deny them that, is wrong

That being said, I will say that GW are bloody awful at woolly writing and contradictory definitions, if a FAQ is not clearly written I think its acceptable to contest the meaning, however, if you ignore the FAQ completely, you are not being fair on your opponent (unless you play regularly and you both agree on your revised ruling)
 
I'm going to be that guy who tries to use real life as an example, and cramps everyone's style. xD But without further ado, a simple comparison:

Errata/Amendments: Statute

FAQ: Common law (sort of)

If England didn't have the latter, murder wouldn't be a crime. FAQs are rulings from GW on how they (the people who wrote your book and know what they intended, or if a different interpretation comes up that would be even better) would interpret the rules.

Yes, the official errata change bits in the book. But the body of FAQs can't just be dismissed as suggestions when they come from the only official authority on the book.
 
Calling me a drone is amusing, given this whole "discussion" has been your dismissal of anyone who plays it differently. I didn't even mention how I played and yet how I supposedly choose to play is mocked.

This isn't a discussion. You are telling me how I should play the game, just like GW supposedly tells you how you should play. If you and your cliche want to play without FAQs or with your own that's *fine,* and I encourage it, but your group becomes insular the more that happens.

I routinely play new people and that's where using the FAQs as official (which they are, even if they are only the official opinion) simplifies things since we start on the same page.

Case in point, two weeks ago I played 3.5 edition chaos vs 6th edition space marines, 5,000 points of nostalgia. I did it with a regular buddy of mine and it was cool because I hate current chaos (the book is garbage) but it was something we arranged. Would I bring it to my FOGS and just whip it out unexpectedly? No, and I'd argue for the sake of arguing that a better case is made to allow old codices and army books since nowhere (if i remember correctly) does it say I have to use the newest edition when organizing a battle.

The guy who posted about the social contract hit it spot on. If you want to play with your buds this way, go for it. Don't expect to walk in and get a game in with me if we aren't on the same rules-page otherwise.
 
Vortaine said:
Calling me a drone is amusing, given this whole "discussion" has been your dismissal of anyone who plays it differently. I didn't even mention how I played and yet how I supposedly choose to play is mocked.

This isn't a discussion. You are telling me how I should play the game, just like GW supposedly tells you how you should play. If you and your cliche want to play without FAQs or with your own that's *fine,* and I encourage it, but your group becomes insular the more that happens.

I routinely play new people and that's where using the FAQs as official (which they are, even if they are only the official opinion) simplifies things since we start on the same page.

Case in point, two weeks ago I played 3.5 edition chaos vs 6th edition space marines, 5,000 points of nostalgia. I did it with a regular buddy of mine and it was cool because I hate current chaos (the book is garbage) but it was something we arranged. Would I bring it to my FOGS and just whip it out unexpectedly? No, and I'd argue for the sake of arguing that a better case is made to allow old codices and army books since nowhere (if i remember correctly) does it say I have to use the newest edition when organizing a battle.

The guy who posted about the social contract hit it spot on. If you want to play with your buds this way, go for it. Don't expect to walk in and get a game in with me if we aren't on the same rules-page otherwise.

Shutup Vortaine, I'm sick of your attitude. Stop trying to bait me into arguing with you.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu