Is a strength test magic damage

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Skittelz1981

Varghulf
Apr 28, 2013
707
AMS
Zombies
623
Last night we had a situation.

Opponent casts a vortex, he misfires it and scatters it across his own unit.
The vortex forces a strength test, if failed the models that failed it are slain outright no as allowed only a single wardsave.

Now the issue is that his bsb had Ring of Hotek which also increases magical resistance so he claimed to have an improved wardsave on the 'wound' he got by failing his strength test since the source of the test is a vortex.

Imo this is wrong:

- the vortex is magic, yes
- a strength test doesnt do damage, which is what the magic forces you to take
- failing the strength test doesnt do damage magically, it just slays your model because you fail a characteristics test.

He failed the regular wardsave but saved it because of the MR, i think his bsb shouldve died and that MR isnt allowed on characteristics tests, no matter what the source is.
 
Skittelz1981 said:
Last night we had a situation.

Opponent casts a vortex, he misfires it and scatters it across his own unit.
The vortex forces a strength test, if failed the models that failed it are slain outright no as allowed only a single wardsave.

Now the issue is that his bsb had Ring of Hotek which also increases magical resistance so he claimed to have an improved wardsave on the 'wound' he got by failing his strength test since the source of the test is a vortex.

Imo this is wrong:

- the vortex is magic, yes
- a strength test doesnt do damage, which is what the magic forces you to take
- failing the strength test doesnt do damage magically, it just slays your model because you fail a characteristics test.

He failed the regular wardsave but saved it because of the MR, i think his bsb shouldve died and that MR isnt allowed on characteristics tests, no matter what the source is.

A characteristic test doesn't do any damage. I think MR definitely applies to the Dwellers Below.
 
Skittelz1981 said:
- a strength test doesnt do damage, which is what the magic forces you to take
- failing the strength test doesnt do damage magically, it just slays your model because you fail a characteristics test.

It's called a 'direct damage' spell. How does a 'direct damage' spell not do damage? I'd feel pretty damaged if I was slain outright. As a general rule I'd stick to, if you can save it with a wardsave, you can improve the WS with magic resistance. The question whether damage is magic, is simply checking, is this damage coming from a spell or from a miniature, or from dangerous terrain (there are no other sources of damage in the game), in this case it came from the spell, so it's magic damage.
 
helemaalnicks said:
Skittelz1981 said:
- a strength test doesnt do damage, which is what the magic forces you to take
- failing the strength test doesnt do damage magically, it just slays your model because you fail a characteristics test.

It's called a 'direct damage' spell. How does a 'direct damage' spell not do damage? I'd feel pretty damaged if I was slain outright. As a general rule I'd stick to, if you can save it with a wardsave, you can improve the WS with magic resistance. The question whether damage is magic, is simply checking, is this damage coming from a spell or from a miniature, or from dangerous terrain (there are no other sources of damage in the game), in this case it came from the spell, so it's magic damage.

Its not direct damage, its called a vortex.
Furthermore the vortex magically forces a characteristics test (which isnt damage in the raw sense of the word)
A characteristics test doesnt count as damage to my knowledge, thus is claiming MR not allowed.

Because if what you say is true, i might call the extra strength bonus from Wyssans wildform to be magical damage (since it magically increases strength) and thus i might take a MR wardsave, coz it turns the attacks into magical attacks? No.
Characteristics tests is not the same as damage, Magical damage is a magic missile, a direct damage or a vortex that does hits and wounds (related to close combat and shooting).
A characteristics test is something else entirely. The orginis of the test is magic, true, but since it is not damage, MR cannot be claimed imo.


Looking forward to more thoughts and opinions on this.
 
You wouldn't get MR from magically buffed attacks anyway, it only helps against spells ;)
Happened to me yesterday with Bladewind (Lore of Dark magic). Every model in the unit had to take a WS test, when failed they get a S4 hit. On which I could use MR.

In your example, I would say the failed strength test results in damage to the unit. Not as a result of a direct damage spell, but you still take wounds as a result of the spell. So I would allow MR here.
 
Being a vortex doesn't have ANYTHING to do with whether or not a spell causes damage. (See Wind of Death) A characteristic test has NOTHING to do with whether the spell causes damage (See penumbral pendulum)
Admittedly, the BRB is vague about exactly what Damage constitutes, but since it doesn't specifically limit it to hits/wounds, in absence of any ruling I feel the only reasonable reading is that it helps against spells that allow ward saves.

Also, the claim that Characteristic tests aren't damage by RAW is incorrect. The lack of specific reference one way or the other is not the same thing as RAW saying the negative.

I seriously see no other purpose for MR to even exist in the game if people are going to argue that spells that specifically allow ward saves ignore it.
 
I see purposes for MR against regular Vortexes, magic missiles and direct damage spells that cause hits and wounds (which is most of them).

Also a wardsave is not the same as MR.
MR is an improvement on the wardsave used specifically against magical damage. Since you succeeded in explaining yourself that this is not damage, i find it hard to understand why MR can be used in this specific case with this specific spell.
Theres enough uses for MR.


Actually Rare, you had a post yourself about the Curse of Anraheir and magical resistance not so long ago.... in which got to an agreement that MR couldnt be used against it even though the spell causes the dangerous terrain tests. It is a very, very similar situation.
Characteristic tests are not qualified as damage, thus MR becomes useless.
 
Skittelz1981 said:
Also a wardsave is not the same as MR.
MR is an improvement on the wardsave used specifically against magical damage. Since you succeeded in explaining yourself that this is not damage, i find it hard to understand why MR can be used in this specific case with this specific spell.
Theres enough uses for MR.
I didn't explain that this wasn't damage. I stated that damage is vague in the BRB and that it isn't specifically limited to hits and wounds.

Actually Rare, you had a post yourself about the Curse of Anraheir and magical resistance not so long ago.... in which got to an agreement that MR couldnt be used against it even though the spell causes the dangerous terrain tests. It is a very, very similar situation.
Actually, first, I was talking about the BotWD, not magic resistance. The difference is that the spell isn't causing DT tests, terrain is and it's only a difference in how the unit interacts with terrain.

Here, the spell is causing the damage, directly, with no intermediary. Regardless of the actual rule, the situations aren't similar.
 
RarerMonsters said:
Skittelz1981 said:
Also a wardsave is not the same as MR.
MR is an improvement on the wardsave used specifically against magical damage. Since you succeeded in explaining yourself that this is not damage, i find it hard to understand why MR can be used in this specific case with this specific spell.
Theres enough uses for MR.
I didn't explain that this wasn't damage. I stated that damage is vague in the BRB and that it isn't specifically limited to hits and wounds.

Actually Rare, you had a post yourself about the Curse of Anraheir and magical resistance not so long ago.... in which got to an agreement that MR couldnt be used against it even though the spell causes the dangerous terrain tests. It is a very, very similar situation.
Actually, first, I was talking about the BotWD, not magic resistance. The difference is that the spell isn't causing DT tests, terrain is and it's only a difference in how the unit interacts with terrain.

Here, the spell is causing the damage, directly, with no intermediary. Regardless of the actual rule, the situations aren't similar.



The spell isnt causing DT???? The spell forces your unit to see all T as DT and fails on 1 AND 2..... how is the spell not causing the DT?????????????
Fact is, it is not MAGICAL DAMAGE, which a characteristic test ALSO IS NOT.
 
Skittelz1981 said:
The spell isnt causing DT???? The spell forces your unit to see all T as DT and fails on 1 AND 2..... how is the spell not causing the DT?????????????
Fact is, it is not MAGICAL DAMAGE, which a characteristic test ALSO IS NOT.

First off, please stop taxing our world's limited question mark supply.

Second, yeah. If I cast an augment that makes models wound on 3s instead of 4s, the models are still causing the wound, even though they are happening because of Curse of Anraheir.

Neither of which have anything to do with this question.

Here, the spell causes the effect directly. No intermediate circumstance that it affects. And I don't see any ruling anywhere stating that characteristic tests aren't damage, or defining spell damage in a way that would exclude them.
 
As a follow up, consider Dweller's Below.

It involves Characteristic Tests or dying immediately. It is a direct damage spell (And therefore definitely a spell that causes damage.)
Therefore, being a characteristic test does not mean something is not damage.
 
Look, you'd never get a save of any kind against a characteristic test. Tests don't cause damage. It's what comes AFTER the test that causes damage. A characteristic test is a way of separating models, it doesn't cause any damage by itself.

Once a model fails it's characteristic test, then something ELSE happens to it. In this case, it dies. And as such, it gets a ward save. And since the cause of the dying is damage dealt by a spell (remember, the damage is not caused by the characteristic test) then they get any magic resistance bonuses they are entitled to.

This is different to Curse of Anraheir, which simply causes dangerous terrain test. Then unit can remain stationary, and receive no damage. The spell does not deal damage, it changed the way the unit interacts with terrain. Arnizipal's Black Horror does not change the way the unit interacts with anything, it directly damages it itself.
 
The spell in question sounds like Arnzipal's Black Horror from the Lore of Dark Magic. The spell specifically states that models passed over by the template must pass a Strength test or be "slain outright" with "no armour saves allowed. (A model may take a single ward save, if it has one - the model remains in play if the save succeeds)."

So you do get ward saves against the spell. The question is whether being "slain outright" is "damage caused by spells." If you look under the rules for Killing Blow (on the same page of the BRB), you can see that "A ward save can be attempted - if passed, the ward save prevents all damage from the killing blow."

So I would argue that - yes - "slaying a model outright" is causing damage, and is therefore damage caused by spells, and would therefore trigger magic resistance to increase ward saves attempted against the spell.
 
There´s a lot of spells that do not allow any kind of salvation (Final Transmutation, Dwellers below, Pit of shades, Purple Sun of Xereus and some others) causing damage through special attacks involving test of atributes or even just rolling a dice and getting more or less than a single given number . But they clearly state that no salvation of any kind is allowed.

Please notice that in the group is included ARNIZIPAL´S DIMENSIONAL DOOR, a Storm of Magic spell specially interesting in this discussion; it uses a strength test too and it clearly states no salvation of any kind allowed.

On the other hand, there are some others (Curse of da Bad Moon comes to my mind in addition to Arnizipal´s Black Horror) with the same special damage delivery structure but only stating no armor save is allowed. Just by sensible extention, it means non armor saves can be rolled, so ward saves are allowed.

MR improves ward saves and, if a unit or miniature has no ward save itself, MR gives one (MR3, ws 4+, MR2, ws 5+, MR1, ws6 ). So the MR given ward save is allowed against Arnizipal´s Black Horror, first because it only forbides armor saves, and second because the damage is caused by the spell (the atribute tests do not cause any damage themselves, they are just a way to see if something happens or not according to the BRB).
 
You get a ward save, it's damage from a spell, so you get to buff that ward save with MR.

A good rule of thumb is: look at the situation. Does interpreting it your way make a massive difference that helps you and could possibly win you the game?

If yes, then you are probably wrong and you just can't see it because wanting to win is clouding your judgement. You see this every game, hell, I do this kind of crap all the time. It's why my approach is always to let my opponent have their way, go home, research it, come back next week and show them how they're wrong. Arguing at the table is 'that guy' territory.

In the heat of the game, no one wants to have to consult the book, but that's what the book is there for. Consulting the book in this case would have cleared it all up pretty quickly. Pg. 72: 'A model with Magic Resistance has a bonus to its ward save when saving against damage caused by spells... Magic resistance can even give a ward save to models that do not have one at all'

If, even after consulting the book, and your club's resident Longbeard, you can't agree, let your opponent have his way, if he wins because of it, who cares? It was because he fudged the rules. But next time it happens, be armed, chapter and verse, with the way to dispute it. If he continues to be a knob, just pack up and call it a day. It always amazes me when people get into arguments over rules at the table. I take these situations as opportunities for my opponent and myself to LEARN. Just last game my opponent pointed something out that, as a long time OnG player, I never realized: If used as a character mount, a Giant Wolf gives that character the fast cavalry rule! Then I taught him something, if you have an armour save of better than 5+, you are no longer fast cavalry.

Unless it's a tournament, in which case, let the judge decide and abide by his decision.
 
Skittelz1981 said:
helemaalnicks said:
Skittelz1981 said:
- a strength test doesnt do damage, which is what the magic forces you to take
- failing the strength test doesnt do damage magically, it just slays your model because you fail a characteristics test.

It's called a 'direct damage' spell. How does a 'direct damage' spell not do damage? I'd feel pretty damaged if I was slain outright. As a general rule I'd stick to, if you can save it with a wardsave, you can improve the WS with magic resistance. The question whether damage is magic, is simply checking, is this damage coming from a spell or from a miniature, or from dangerous terrain (there are no other sources of damage in the game), in this case it came from the spell, so it's magic damage.

Its not direct damage, its called a vortex.
Furthermore the vortex magically forces a characteristics test (which isnt damage in the raw sense of the word)
A characteristics test doesnt count as damage to my knowledge, thus is claiming MR not allowed.

So... do you have any rules to back this up? I think you're really just reading this into it. I'm going to take a stab here, you've played a lot of magic the gathering?

Cause that game is all about using the right terminology. This think is damage (red spells), and then there is destroy, or even remove from play, and preventing one damage with a tapfeature of a creature, would not help you against a dispell, or a destroy spell.

I don't think this is true for warhammer, the rules are pretty straightforward, magic resistance helps you against magic damage, and damage is stuff that hurts. Simple as can be.

Btw, you talk about a dark magic vortex, but there are spells that make you take char tests, that are direct damage spells. The fact that it's a char test, does not implicate that is not damage, that's proven by the brb. In my opinion, you're arguing against the rulebook, unless there is a rule you can quote that backs your interpretation.
 
Ok, seeing all the replies given, i am bound to give another reply.
Ive put in some extra thought on this matter.

First off, i want to state that this post is not meant to convince anyone of anything. I have accepted the fact that it counts as magical damage and thus MR is allowed. I will just try to explain at my best what my issue was here (english is not my native language), as structured and clearly written as i can (not my strongest point)



Why did i think that there was no damage involved (in a RAW-sense?)

-Usually damage in Warhammer implicates hits and wounds, and are named so in every spell/attack/etc.

-There are different types of spells; their name/description (ie magic missile/direct damage/etc) is used for qualifying when and how it is allowed to be used (front arc/los/in combat/etc) rather than explaining wether it does (magical) damage or not.
* Net of Amyntok comes to mind, it is a hex but if the strengthtest is failed, the unit takes d6 hits. Clearly a hex usually doesnt do any damage, yet in this case it specifically states you get hits/wounds from the barbs.
* Cascading fire cloak, augment spell that ultimately causes hits/wounds
* Fulminating flame cage, another hex that causes hits/wounds
All these spells clearly do damage by allocating hits and possibly wounds, which is damage done magically

-All Direct damage spells, magic missiles and Vortexes usually and specifically say that hits are distributed and sometimes wounds. Clearly pointing towards damage being done.

-Some of the spells, force a characteristics-test, either leadership, strength, initiative etc. Characteristics tests usually do not fall under the damage-range from the 'hits+wounds' perspective, they just have a very unpleasant outcome if failed. One might view it as damage but i find this to be arguable enough. Lets look at some examples:
* Final transmutation; just turns you to gold, not even a test, it makes you a casualty if failed, no saves of any kind allowed (i know very specific). i dont think you could count that as damage in any way. Called Direct damage but doesnt do any IMO.
* Pit of Shades; Getting dragged to your DOOM!, i dont think that would count as damage in any way, again no saves of any kind (very specific). Its called a Direct damage spell but doesnt do any damage IMO (hence the no saves allowed)
* Purple sun; failed test is slain outright, no saves of any kind. i know, no saves allowed at all. My only q is: is it damage that is done? or is it just a failed test and something nasty happens?
*Arnzipals black horror (the spell this is all about); basically just like Purple sun with the exception of an allowed wardsave, why? because this Lore already has very hardhitting spells and it wouldnt be right to add a vortex that is similarly strong as purple sun. Q is here again, is the aftereffect of failing a characteristics test, which does slain outright, magical damage or even damage at all?
If this is not damage that is being done than MR would not be allowed, since MR only works against magical damage.


This would i think sum up what my issue is/was.
A major reason why i got thrown towards this is the post by Rarermonster about the Curse of Anraheir, where the DT-test forced by the spell, ultimatley results in being a physical, non-magical "attack" that would result in wounds (damage). Even though it is a spell, the DT-test and the result of failing it gives no allowance to the improved wardsave.
I viewed that failing a characteristics-test (which a DT-test also is) then doesnt really count as damage, especially not if there no hits/wounds involved but simply getting slain outright.


Now if i would look at it from a very fluffy POV i could say this:

* Arnzipals black horror is a magically conjured vortex that dramatically increases gravity in its Area of effect. All the models passed over suddenly have to cope with this greatly increased and crushing gravity, requiring strength to keep alive.
The survivors are obviously the ones that were strong enough and passed the stregth-test, yet the ones that fail proved too weak, failing their strength-test got them crushed under this immense gravity. Yet if a model is equipped with a wardsave it could still use its magical abilities to remain alive.

Now, the question arises: The source is magical, yes. But is increased gravity (a physical condition) something you can count as magical damage?
Magic made gravity increase, but failing to be strong enough against the gravity is a physical condition. Having a wardsave against it is one thing but using Magical resistance is another entirely.

Obviously i translate this into gravity but this is just one fluffy POV which can be replaced by another one.

In any case, my point was whether or not it is magical damage being done, many say yes, others (like me) might view this as something that can be argued.



Have i played Magic the Gathering? yes but only very briefly (only 8 games orso) and i do not recall much of it since i find cardgames like that to be quite boring and way too random. Why buy Magic if you can play on your phone or on the pc for free at similar games (Hearthstone springs to mind) Warhammer already is a luck-based dicegame, which often disturbs me. Let alone having a 50-card deck you shuffle and randomly pull out cards, hoping to get that synergetic sequence and follow-up you need against the deck opposite you.



-----On a side note, for the people claiming that the type of spell defines wether it does damage or not, there is a very interesting case:

Wind Blast, lore of Heavens.
It is a magic Missile, so according to some, this spell does magical damage (which it does since you get d6 hits) BUT:

You get pushed away by the spell, this is the effect, the hits and wounds are caused by getting into contact with terrain or units.

Thus: could you use MR against this?? IMO: NO.
reason: the pushing back is not damage, thus you wouldnt get MR against it, not even a wardsave for that matter.
The damage is caused by a physical source rather than magical again denying MR.
But in this case, armoursaves and wardsaves against the damage taken are allowed, since it inflicts hits and wounds (damage in RAW/raw sense.)

Now one could argue that since its a magic missile, you could even MR the pushing back, coz hey, its a magic missile, so that counts as magical damage just by the definition of the type of spell. And ultimately the source of the damage taken, if any, was magical.

This bit off topic, but its just to showcase situations in which the definition of the spell has nothing to do wether you count it as damage or not, and if so, what type of damage (physical or magical)

Magic missile, direct damage, vortex, the definition of the spell doesnt mean it actually does any magical damage. Thus using that as an excuse to qualify damage as magical, purely based on the spelldefinition, is wrong.
 
Thanks for the effort, Skittelz1981, really hard because english is not your mother tongue. I understand your line of thought.

But maybe you should try to see it from BRB´s point of view and not your own, just because it makes thing easier when resolving a potential issue.

Personal view usually mess things even more. For instance, I keep on thinking as a huge absurdity that the wounds from a spell can be saved by an armor save in some cases, or hits from a magical weapon (something so rare and powerful that needed to impact an etereal miniature) then being saved by armor and not by wards only when attacking a "solid" miniature. There are more examples in BRB that I could find non consistent (for instance flee rules and obstacles, heroes charging out of a unit, multiple combat resolution, no more foes in multiple combat related to crumbling and some others) but just my personal view, just me, nothing else, and it should never interfere with rule interpretation.

It´s not a question of right or wrong. Just a question of fitting the rules or not.
 
Skittelz1981 said:
Last night we had a situation.

Opponent casts a vortex, he misfires it and scatters it across his own unit.
The vortex forces a strength test, if failed the models that failed it are slain outright no as allowed only a single wardsave.

Now the issue is that his bsb had Ring of Hotek which also increases magical resistance so he claimed to have an improved wardsave on the 'wound' he got by failing his strength test since the source of the test is a vortex.

Imo this is wrong:

- the vortex is magic, yes
- a strength test doesnt do damage, which is what the magic forces you to take
- failing the strength test doesnt do damage magically, it just slays your model because you fail a characteristics test.

He failed the regular wardsave but saved it because of the MR, i think his bsb shouldve died and that MR isnt allowed on characteristics tests, no matter what the source is.

You were robbed.

Ward saves prevent wounds from being taken. In fact, on the same page on Ward Saves (p44 of the BRB) is some boxed text on Instant Kills, which applies in this situation. The models failing their Strength (or whatever other attribute is required to be tested against) test are simply slain, with no ward saves. Magic Resistance and Regeneration work in a similar manner.

Also, Look Out Sirs! cannot be taken against these types of spells (although in some tournaments, they may be allowed, but this is more for the sake of even play).
 
@Sigmar's Bane: You are forgotting to add that in the same boxed text is clearly stated that no salvation allowed against instant kills if not otherwise specified. For instance, Killing Blow, an instant killing special attack, just avoid armor saves and regeneration, not ward saves.

Arnizipal´s Black Horror causes an special kind of Instant Kill if a strenght test is failed, and specifies no armor saves allowed. By extention, ward saves are, MR improves Ward Saves when spells involved, the Strenght Test is caused by a spell so nothing was wrong between Skittelz1981 and his opponent.

Regarding the Look out Sir, not sure what you mean. It can be tried (2+ in a D6) against template impacts unless 4 or less miniatures in the unit, and vortex uses a template. Or you tried to mean something different.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu