I'm not buying that. If I read what you are saying correctly you mean that the only thing that matters is that there are more or equal numbers of models (from both sides) in contact after the reform than there were before. If that is how it was meant to be it is very strangely written, taking about models not being allowed to moved out of combat instead of just the number of models. To me that suggest that no individual model can be out of B2B after the reform if it was before it.
If what you say is true I don't see what would stop this scenario: A 10 wide unit of Grave Guards with a Vampire Lord at one corner of the front charges a 5 wide unit of Clanrats. The VC player wants to kill as many a possible and therefore uses the chargemove to bring the Vampire Lord and 6 GG into B2B. After combat the Skaven player announces that he wishes to make a combat reform and passes his test. The VC player fears what he will do and announces that he too wishes to reform. They roll off and the Skaven player goes last. The VC player is not sure what the Skaven player is up to and therefore knows no way of preventing it so he does nothing. The Skaven player then slides his Clanrats along the Grave Guard unit, away from the Vampire Lord and therefore preventing him from striking in the next combat round. And since the VC player reformed first there is nothing he can do about. Of course, if the VC player had know about these sneaky tactics before he could have taken actions to prevent them. He could have reduced his own frontage to make it impossible for the Skaven player to slide his unit without reducing the number of models fighting. Or he could move his Vampire Lord towards the centre of his unit so that there is no place where the Clanrats can stand without being in contact with the vampire and still be in contact with 7 models. But both of these actions could be to a disadvantage for the VC player (losing horde or moving his general's bubble).
I don't think this is what was intended with the combat reform ability, but it sure would bring another tactical aspect to the game.
If what you say is true I don't see what would stop this scenario: A 10 wide unit of Grave Guards with a Vampire Lord at one corner of the front charges a 5 wide unit of Clanrats. The VC player wants to kill as many a possible and therefore uses the chargemove to bring the Vampire Lord and 6 GG into B2B. After combat the Skaven player announces that he wishes to make a combat reform and passes his test. The VC player fears what he will do and announces that he too wishes to reform. They roll off and the Skaven player goes last. The VC player is not sure what the Skaven player is up to and therefore knows no way of preventing it so he does nothing. The Skaven player then slides his Clanrats along the Grave Guard unit, away from the Vampire Lord and therefore preventing him from striking in the next combat round. And since the VC player reformed first there is nothing he can do about. Of course, if the VC player had know about these sneaky tactics before he could have taken actions to prevent them. He could have reduced his own frontage to make it impossible for the Skaven player to slide his unit without reducing the number of models fighting. Or he could move his Vampire Lord towards the centre of his unit so that there is no place where the Clanrats can stand without being in contact with the vampire and still be in contact with 7 models. But both of these actions could be to a disadvantage for the VC player (losing horde or moving his general's bubble).
I don't think this is what was intended with the combat reform ability, but it sure would bring another tactical aspect to the game.