Make way!!

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I'm not buying that. If I read what you are saying correctly you mean that the only thing that matters is that there are more or equal numbers of models (from both sides) in contact after the reform than there were before. If that is how it was meant to be it is very strangely written, taking about models not being allowed to moved out of combat instead of just the number of models. To me that suggest that no individual model can be out of B2B after the reform if it was before it.

If what you say is true I don't see what would stop this scenario: A 10 wide unit of Grave Guards with a Vampire Lord at one corner of the front charges a 5 wide unit of Clanrats. The VC player wants to kill as many a possible and therefore uses the chargemove to bring the Vampire Lord and 6 GG into B2B. After combat the Skaven player announces that he wishes to make a combat reform and passes his test. The VC player fears what he will do and announces that he too wishes to reform. They roll off and the Skaven player goes last. The VC player is not sure what the Skaven player is up to and therefore knows no way of preventing it so he does nothing. The Skaven player then slides his Clanrats along the Grave Guard unit, away from the Vampire Lord and therefore preventing him from striking in the next combat round. And since the VC player reformed first there is nothing he can do about. Of course, if the VC player had know about these sneaky tactics before he could have taken actions to prevent them. He could have reduced his own frontage to make it impossible for the Skaven player to slide his unit without reducing the number of models fighting. Or he could move his Vampire Lord towards the centre of his unit so that there is no place where the Clanrats can stand without being in contact with the vampire and still be in contact with 7 models. But both of these actions could be to a disadvantage for the VC player (losing horde or moving his general's bubble).

I don't think this is what was intended with the combat reform ability, but it sure would bring another tactical aspect to the game.
 
Shoot, So does anyone have their book with them? I don't. The Combat reform rule states something about models being able to move anywhere as long as they remain in combat, the book specifically states that the model doesn't need to be in combat with the same unit, just that it needs to be in combat. Thus you can move a character to a flank if you got flank charged and whatnot, but that rule right there may have some type of information that is bugging Mad 'At.
 
The character must remain in combat if he was already in combat, though where he is depends on the reform. What I meant earlier was that your opponent can reform wider than you and slide the character to the corner of where your unit is. He can't slide out of combat.

I'll try and dig up page references.

It's also like if you're flank charged, you make way to the side, you win, when you reform that character must remain in combat, though where is up to you, he can slide once his unit turns sideways.
 
Okay, I think we are a bit lost in translation here. Lets start new with these two questions:

1. The two units bellow are fighting.
Combat1a_zpsd263bda4.webp


Only the VC player wishes to reform. Can he move his Vampire so that it is no longer in basecontact with any clanrat and therefore cannot be attacked by anything in the next round?

2. The two units bellow are fighting.
Combat2_zpsf05baf81.webp


Only the VC player wishes to reform. Can he move his Vampire so that it can attack in combat in the next round?

My answer would be no to both questions because of what is written on page 55 in the BRB under Reforming from victory:
-it cannot be used to get a model (friend of foe) out of base contact with the enemy if it was in contact before the reform was made.
If you do reform like suggested above you would have to move a model that was in contact before the reform to be out of contact after it, in the first example this would be the vampire and in the second a RnF.

EDIT: Damn it, my letter diagram didn't work very well. Gonna try to fix something better.

EDIT2: Better.
 
1. No, you can't reform so the Vamp is out of contact. You could slide the vamp in the middle of the unit if you wish, allowing more clan rats to attack him. Also, the Skaven player cannot slide his unit down to get the VL out of BTB contact with the clanrat unit.

2. Yes, you can bring the VL into combat via a combat reform. Also, the Skaven player can slide the unit down to the VL into BTB contact with the VL. Though if there was a ghoul champ on the left side of your diagram, the champ may prohibit the clanrat unit from sliding away from being in BTB contact with the champ.

It's a character (different profile) thingy... ill look and see if it's in the Character section of the rulebook.
 
Question 1 I totally agree that you cannot get characters out of combat.

Question 2 however, I do agree with Eggie. You cannot move a model out of base contact/You cannot remove the model out of base contact.

Definition of A: used as a function word before singular nouns when the referent is unspecified <a man overboard> and before number collectives and some numbers <a dozen>

Definition of THE: used as a function word to indicate that a following noun or noun equivalent is a unique or a particular member of its class <the President> <the Lord>

The difference between A model and THE model is based around the words themselves and not a rule in the book.

A refers to non-specific where The refers to specific.
 
I'm no English expert, nor am I an expert in any other language, so I can't really argue with that.

It does however seam strange to me that it would work one way but not the other. I mean, in both cases you move a model out of contact. The sentence makes no note that it would make a difference if it is a character model or a RnF model.
 
Holy hell what a debate, always played it like you couldn't make way at any other point than at the very first round of a given combat. Not sure this is true anymore though..

Remembering that the rules try to mimic real combat as much as possible.

When reading the following: "Should a combined unit be fighting in close combat, it is only right that a mighty hero will push his way through to the fighting."

"At the start of the combat" and "before impact hits are made" are just to clarify that you can't move your character into combat at the time that suits you the best (after impact hits, after the enemys character attacked).

Why does "at the start of the combat" equal the first round of the combat? That is normally called the first round of combat, fx in the hatred rule. Although the Challenge rule just a few pages later uses the term "at the start of the combat round".


On the reform thing:
As I read it you are not allowed to remove a model from b2b contact by reforming not even to put a character into the combat. To get the character into combat you would have to use the make way rule as this specifically gives you permission to push aside a RnF troop.

RAW: to me is still unclear.. It boils down to gramatical nitpicking and either "school" could argue forever til they find an agreement, all in all it is still, in this case, an individual interpretation and thus becomming RAI. (Mindfuck)

RAI: you can not move your character into combat by removing another from b2b contact with the enemy with a combat reform. You are permitted to make way as much as you like at the beginning of every cc phase.

Hmm, this sucks..:tongue:
 
Oh I believe the opposite! Makeway is indeed only at the beginning of the entire combat, not just the phase, which is fine. But you can reform because you are not removing a model from base contact, just replacing.
 
Dang forgot to look in the errata:

Page 55 – Combat Reform, Reforming From Victory. Change the first sentence of the second paragraph to “A combat reform is essentially a standard reform (page 14), save for the fact that the centre point of the reformed unit does not have to stay in the same place.”
Change “[...]is one special restriction[...]” to “[...]are two special restrictions[...]” and change “[...]was made[...]” to “[...]was made, and the unit may not reform in such a way as to contact a different facing on any enemy unit it is in contact with[...]” in the second paragraph.
 
The make way at either the beginning of:

1) every round of CC
or
2) the 1st round of CC

Is certainly debatable. There is no clear-cut rule :(. Though in my world, the ETC world,?the ETC FAQ committee made a clearcut ruling.

"Can a character make way at the beginning of every combat phase?"
Answer: Yes

In non ETC environments, you'll have to clarify this your opponents, your gaming group or local tournament organizers.

On the reforming thing... You can bring a character to the front with a reform. You are allowed to displace rank/file with characters. Following the "unless you make way with your character, he can never see combat unless he's the last man standing" logic, you can't combat reform your unit with your character in the front rank to face a unit in your flank while keeping the character out of combat, because only rank/file troops were touching the flanking unit? But characters must be in the front rank if possible? But how can he displace rank/file if can't?

Oh wait, he can. :)
 
Damn straight eggy!! A character should never have to wait his turn in line when standing behind (Or next to in some cases) standard rank-and-file bros. It just doesn't make any sense!!
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu