Make way!!

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

eggsPR

Vampire Count
True Blood
Aug 28, 2011
1,136
Dublin
Zombies
878
The BRB says a character can make way in the beginning of combat.

Can a character make way (not talking about combat reforming into BTB contact) after the initial combat phase????

After 2 rounds of combat, can a guy use the make way rule in a combat that has already been in combat?


The key word is phase.

Be specific!! I need answers

Thanks!!
 
I would say NO.
pg 100 BRB "At the start of the combat (before impact hits are resolved)......" This is the key part because it says "start of THE combat". We know that THE combat refers to that specific combat, which continues until a unit is destroyed, breaks, etc...

I don't know the exact circumstance of your experience, but a good argument for this is-
An opponent refuses a challenge. You then nominate a character to be placed out of base contact with your own troops per the rule for refused challenges. Now it says that character slinks to the back ranks and is not allowed to attack THAT ROUND. "That round" can be a bit confusing, but it is only proper that the Character is not allowed to then "make way" to get in the fray for further rounds of combat.

If it said "a" combat or "combat phase" then perhaps... but it says "THE" combat.

If a combat were prolonged and opponents unit was countercharged in the flank, that may open the window for the argument that it is a new combat.
 
Valid point Geordie!
There is a rule that Characters must always be placed in the front rank if possible, but command models must also be placed in the front rank. This tactic is often used with ethereal walls or MI (ogres).
Characters may displace Command models as part of their make way move.

I think eggspr is alluding to a scenario in which a char does not make way at the beginning of a combat to avoid a threat, but when that threat is removed, makes way into the fray.

I.E. A char is on the end of a horde charged by a unit with frontage of 5. Char is not in base contact, chooses not to make way. Following combat phase enemy unit is under debuff (-3 str) (it's a lot safer now...) I'll make way!

eggspr- Care to chime in on specifics?
 
I see BBB's point but I'm not sure that I agree:

"At the start of the combat (before Impact Hits are resolved), if a character's unit is in combat, but the character is not in base contact with the enemy, the controlling player can swap his position with another model that is in base contact"

The thing is that it reads "if a character's unit is in combat" which alludes to Make Way! being doable in subsequent turns of combat. Also if you think about it BBB's reading would mean that if a character were in base-to-base with an enemy in a multiple combat and killed the unit in base-to-base it wouldn't be able to move to the other engaging unit in the subsequent turn.
 
Soooo.... which statement is true lol

A) A character can make way in the beginning of subsequent rounds of an ongoing combat.

or

B) A character cannot make way in the beginning of subsequent rounds of an ongoing combat.


A or B?

There shouldn't be any "It depends...." right?
 
I say A, because impact hits could be made every round if another unit charged. Just because someone else joined, does that make it a "new" combat? Or just the same combat that someone else has joined?

If a new unit joining created new combats, wouldn't an overrunning unit not be able to fight in a combat already taking place that turn? In the case of one combat finishing and a unit overrunning into a new one, it is assumed they just join an ongoing combat.

Similarly when the book says you can make way "At the start of the combat (before Impact Hits are resolved), if a character's unit is in combat, but the character is not in base contact with the enemy, the controlling player can swap his position with another model that is in base contact"-- So I would think that you would check off what occurrences happened:

Is it before impact hits? (Basically in the start of the combat phase)
Is my unit in combat with an enemy unit?
It my hero out of base contact with an enemy unit?
Do I want to switch my hero with another model in base contact with an enemy?

That's the way I see it.
 
Okay Okay, glad I found this before I started a new thread. I had a very very similar issue. So I go charged by 2 of those stupid Chaos Dwarf mini god rare choices that they have (Their name escapes me) and my Vamp Lord killed one thus is now not in base contact. I cannot "Make Way" with my lord.

Here is where the issue comes into play.

Combat Reform Pg. 55 "- It cannot be used to get a model (Friend or Foe) out of base contact with the enemy if it was in contact before the reform was made". This statement as RAW means that I cannot switch my vamp lord for a grave guard as that would be removing a model from base contact that was in base contact.

Removing Casualties page 51 "Remove models from the rear rank" Meaning the "Models" in base contact never get removed.

BRB FAQ Pg. 9 "Must a character be moved to the front rank of a unit as soon as a space becomes available" Space doesn't become available until the rest of the unit has died.

Thus ... You now don't have you Lord in combat. You can't make way with him. You can't reform him into combat replacing a model already in base contact. You then reform to put him in the 2nd rank. Then you get 1 supporting attack and the opponent needs to kill all of the grave guard in the 2nd, 3rd, etc. ranks before you can get you character back into combat.

There is a dead unit and 1 bad round of combat is bound to happen and then your lord crumbles away without being able to be effective.
 
You can combat reform a character so he can displace a rank/file in order to get him in comabt. Of course, if your unit is pinned by 2 sides then you can't do anything - no reforming at all.

As long as the number of models are the same, everything is cool. Since your Lord doesn't decrease the models in comabt, you're fine. If he was mounted or something then maybe your could as you'd displace more models than originally was in comabt.

If you turn to face him and there's rank/file models then the characters MUST displace them, with you choosing who goes to the front rank if you ahve 1+ characters.

You can even combat reform characters AWAY from models he's already in contact with, so long as your unit has equal or more models in combat than prior to the reform. This is why it's important to roll-off to see who can reform 1st.
 
Is there any page number or errata bringing this statement to light, I got rule hammered hard with the
Combat Reform Pg. 55 "- It cannot be used to get a model (Friend or Foe) out of base contact with the enemy if it was in contact before the reform was made"

The key word here is Model. The BRB specifies that a model is a single figure that has it's own specific stat line and special rules. Therefore a Model cannot be moved out of base contact. This means that if there are only rank and file in the front rank before the Combat Reform then only rank and file can be in B2B after the combat reform.

If you can show me where it states that no matter what characters displace rank and file, end of story, then that would help in my quest to find the true idea of this!

I'm frusterated because the whole idea of what my opponent did was a game deciding event, and I have absolutly no problem losing, but losing to getting the rules bent to favor drives me crazy.

Also, What page in the BSB destinguishes the differenct between "A Combat", "THE Combat", and "A Round of Combat"?
 
Look it from another angle.
If what you were saying was correct the make way rule would never work in any scenario.

I view the make way rule as an exception to what you have highlighted
 
Oh I agree, You can Make Way to displace models in base contact, you can also displace models in base contact with challenges, but you cannot with a combat reform. Which means that you have no way of getting characters back into combat if they get out, for instance if there is a multiple unit combat and 1 unit gets eliminated. Now your character cannot make way because it is not the start of the combat, and you cannot combat reformto get him into combat.

FYI: I'm not saying that this is how it is, or how it should be, I'm just looking for proof that states that my thought process is completely wrong! I want to be wrong here ya'll, I'm just not sure how to prove it with the rules!
 
Yes it states models... but not specific models, just the number.

The same number (or more) models must in combat after a combat reform. You cannot reduce the number of models in combat from a combat reform.

Though, it's a different story with challenges...

Let me give you an example:

5 HE archers charges 30 zombies (5wide x 6 deep) with a Vampire Blander Lord while a Frost Phoenix flank charges you. Your Vamp Lord blends the HE archers.

End of combat... let's say it's a draw (no muso for zombies).

You roll to reform. You pass on unmodified Ld...........


Are trying to tell me that I can't reform to face the Frost Phoneix AND bring the Blender in BTB contact with the Frost Phoenix!?

Bc this is just Warhammer 101... let your opponent show me in the BRB that this move is illegal... I dare him. I double dare him... I triple dog dare him (always skip the double dog lol)
 
Combat Reform Pg. 55 "- It cannot be used to get a model (Friend or Foe) out of base contact with the enemy if it was in contact before the reform was made". This statement as RAW means that I cannot switch my vamp lord for a grave guard as that would be removing a model from base contact that was in base contact.

If it said "Number of Models" then I would agree with you and be satisfied, but as it stands in the BRB the rule states a model. The "A model" statement is what the dude used to say that I couldn't swap a character for a Rank-and-File. I was mad, but I wasn't going to argue it there. I went through the rules and RAW makes me seem to lean towards agreeing with him although I really don't want to.

In my mind, it's people like that that make me want to be a hardcore rule bender. Because if what he did is how it should actually be then all you need to do is run a unit of 10 HW's into a unit along side of a conga line unit of dogs. Then if you position it right then you dual charge with the HW's and Dogs, Dogs hit the character in the unit and the HW's stay out of base contact with him. Now you will be sacrificing the dogs but the character will never be able to get into contact with the HW's from that point forward.

This S**t needs to get erratad real bad!
 
A model.... not THE model.

Otherwise you and your friend not playing by the rules of Warhammer :(

this is not my opinion... it is fact.
 
Holy crap Eggy! You just did it for me!

Okay, So if he is going to go by the "You can only make way at the start of THE combat", then I can get him by saying the difference between "A Model" and "The Model" is the same as "A Combat" and "The Combat".

"A" does not equal "The"

You my friend closed a loop that was going to drive me crazy until I found the point of correct.

+Rep for you fine sir.
 
Yes Mad At, you can reform a character out of combat with a particular model by moving him away from BTB contact, however the character must be in contact with the enemy unit... We call it electric sliding.

That's why it's important to see who reforms first... Many times you want your opponent to reform first, so when he "electric slides" his wizard out of BTB with your BSB, you then electric slide your BSB to where he went.
 
I suppose there's nothing stating u can't do that. You can reform into a horde and put the character away from the 5 model-wide unit. Though if u do it first he can reform wide enough (if he has the models) to catch you.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu