mantic's undead

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

qurfy

Zombie
Jan 17, 2012
5
Zombies
5
Would people not like it if I used mantics undead units pretty much for my whole core? like the skeletons look like they could be well gw skellies and possibly graveguard. Do you think their ghouls can be used for our ghouls, they're similar but def. not the same.
 
I really like their ghouls, and I can't imagine anyone outsidere a GW run tournament having any objections. Maybe if you play at a GW store.. I prefer mantics ghouls and zombies over GW's myself, as I think they both look better and are cheaper, so I can have more of them. Also, their zombies don't come with weapons, which I think is a good thing. :)
 
Official tournaments and some gaming clubs would not allow it. Gamers is up to the individual.
I personally allow any cool looking models from whatever manufacturer, especially with the GW prices that seem to have been calculated by some tyrant from the seventh level of hell.

I'd say ask the folks you play with but frankly you'd have to be a real douche to say no if it's not a legal tournament/store/whatever.
 
Zephyr: pretty nice description there. Hehe

As long as the model is more or less the same side, and you are not attempting to gain any model/base size advantages, I agree with zephyr. I remember one tournament, were one playergot to use the avatar model in place of a bloodthirster (40k Btw), and then sent on insisting that he could hide from line of sight in places were the bloodthirster model wouln't even fit. Needless to say, this kind of deliberate abuse won't make you any friends, but I can't see mantic's range of models being objected too. :)
 
GW models are required for GW-run events and for games that take place in GW stores. In most other contexts (independent stores & tournaments, gaming club games), other companies' models are fine, provided you can easily tell what they're supposed to be.


Mantic skeletons are very different in style from GW skeletons. I wouldn't mix them in the same unit. Maybe with TK skeletons. The proportions and details aren't as nice, but they do have more personality then VC skeletons. A goofy sort of 'Army of Darkness' feel. I prefer the soulles lockstep regimented look of GW vamp count skittles, but that's just me.

Mantic zombies are likewise different in style from GW zombies, but not by quite as much, so mixing them in the same unit isn't quite as jarring. In this case, the GW models have a bit more personality, imo, but neither is noticeably better in terms of proportion or detail or overall quality. Not surprising - Mantic's about 10 to 15 years behind GW in sculpting and molding, and that's about how old those zombies are.

Mantic ghouls are, like skeletons, very different in style from the GW models and I wouldn't mix them in the same unit. However, while GW models have finer detail, the Mantic models more closely resemble the 'degenerate villagers' that the fluff has described ghouls as for some time. Also, the GW models are very difficult to rank up, and are posed in such a way that each model is cramming his face into the butt of the model in front of them. If I didn't already have a bunch of GW ghouls (I used to play in a GW store so there wasn't an option), I'd get the mantic models instead.

Mantic revenants, imo, don't hold a candle to GW grave guard. Neither do their characters or vampire knights. I would never buy GW blood knights due to the price, but I'd convert some other model (chaos knights, dragon princes, bret knights, anything really) long before I'd buy the Mantic equivalents.
 
Zephyr said:
I personally allow any cool looking models from whatever manufacturer, especially with the GW prices that seem to have been calculated by some tyrant from the seventh level of hell.

Nope. The 7th circle is for the violent. Greed is only the 4th and is unfortunately not that severely punished. :D
 
Vallasch said:
Zephyr said:
I personally allow any cool looking models from whatever manufacturer, especially with the GW prices that seem to have been calculated by some tyrant from the seventh level of hell.

Nope. The 7th circle is for the violent. Greed is only the 4th and is unfortunately not that severely punished. :D

They are sadists and they take delight in the pain we suffer from having are money taken. They are subtle, but there treachery deserves far worse than the 4th level! As for mantic, I personally love them. Have a ghoul unit from them, and I am currently painting up some zombies. Revenants suck compared to GW GG, but they look so similar to the skeletons you can use them as core skittles, which look decent. Your wallet will thank you if you shop mantic as well.
 
Slightly off topic but... this means that GW's upper management get TWO circles of hell? Whilst the likes of US can only manage one at best. Cushy for some, I suppose...
 
I use Mantic models for my core, grave guard, and black knights. This is my hobby, if someone doesn't like me using those models, it is I who doesn't want to have a game with him/her.
 
I had been dragging my heels putting together a VC army until Mantic made it affordable (I already have four other armies that are all GW minis). I like GW's GG and ghouls, but otherwise I use Mantic's models for the rank and file troopers. I've been piecing my army together from some other companies too. Like others have mentioned, GW stores and events are the only places you wouldn't be able to play. It's funny though, Mantic's tournament rules do allow for minis from other manufacturers.
 
So do pretty much everyone's... Secrets of the Third Reich do, certainly. In general terms, GW is the only company in existence which has decided that a single, monopose character to represent each character type will be ample for even the most gluttonous wargamer's requirements...
 
Jacques Dauger De Cavoye said:
Vallasch said:
Nope. The 7th circle is for the violent. Greed is only the 4th and is unfortunately not that severely punished. :D

They are sadists and they take delight in the pain we suffer from having are money taken. They are subtle, but there treachery deserves far worse than the 4th level!

Indeed and I would call some of their sales tactics pretty violent...

On a more serious note; what my biggest gripe with non GWmodels is, is that the scale seems slightly off. They say 28mm but sometimes they are more LotR in size or a tad bigger.

I do own a few models from a German studio but they were cheap and so good looking I wanted them if only for painting. I'm loathe to buy whole regiments and find out their scale is way off. So far Mantic and some Reaper miniatures seem ok though. Keeping an eye on the alternative manufacturer thread...
 
Zephyr said:
On a more serious note; what my biggest gripe with non GWmodels is, is that the scale seems slightly off. They say 28mm but sometimes they are more LotR in size or a tad bigger.

I think you'll find that it's GW's scale that is slightly off. They are more a 28 mm heroic. I agree it's a pain though. I find that if you buy an entire regiment (perhaps after getting a test batch) that they typically look fine on the same table as GW stuff. It's only when you mix them in the same unit that things get a bit funny.
 
The Dead of Night said:
Zephyr said:
On a more serious note; what my biggest gripe with non GWmodels is, is that the scale seems slightly off. They say 28mm but sometimes they are more LotR in size or a tad bigger.

I think you'll find that it's GW's scale that is slightly off. They are more a 28 mm heroic. I agree it's a pain though. I find that if you buy an entire regiment (perhaps after getting a test batch) that they typically look fine on the same table as GW stuff. It's only when you mix them in the same unit that things get a bit funny.

Indeed. It is GW who breaks the Heroic 28mm mold most.
 
Every fantasy orientated manufacturer is guilty of not being entirely true to scale. I also do historical wargaming and I can pretty much buy what I like but fantasy models...oy.
It's mostly due to exaggeration as realistic poses and such would look boring but yeah GW has always been the worst when it comes to scale, just look at 40K and how too small space marines still need to stack themselves up in a rhino like beer kegs.:rolleyes:
 
Sorry for the intrusion, but I have 80 Mantic Ghouls for sale here:
https://www.vampirecounts.net/Thread-I-have-some-VC-stuff-in-boxes-to-sell
 
Harland said:
HERO said:
Sorry for the intrusion, but I have 80 Mantic Ghouls for sale here:
https://www.vampirecounts.net/Thread-I-have-some-VC-stuff-in-boxes-to-sell

Wrong forum dude! There's another section for that.

Hence why I linked to that section :zombie:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu