I think alot of opinions and feelings also rely heavily on your local gaming crowd, plus your own personal attitude.
for example, my area (burlington/oakville/hamilton) has sadly become extremely WAAC due mainly in part to a new southern ontario-wide league that's begun. the 1st place prize is $1,000 worth of shit! with that much actual money on the line, people get greedy and through common sense & sportsmanship out the window...
thus, this translates into an atmosphere akin to 'ard boyz, IMHO one of the very worst things to have ever happened to our hobby. so when you're taking an army of character-centric, terrible initiative, average S/T models into an arena that's dominated by lists all designed for that 1st turn IF dwellers/PSoX/pit of shades/13th spell... it's very easy to look at our book and cry that 'only a cookie-cutter build is possible with
VC'.
the local meta means it comes down to, 'well everyone else is a douchbag, so i've got to be one too to win'.
now, if your gaming area isn't so mindlessly childish & pathetic, then it's easy to see beyond the 'easy answers' and experiment more with the less optimal options we have:
- skellies are awsome! i always take a 40-50 strong spear hoard + 33-35 strong ranked block for negating my opponent's steadfast.
add to them some lore of light and a liberal sprinkling of lore of metal or wyssan's wildform and skellies are top notch!
- a forbidden lore w/vampire magic on a hellsteed w/wristbands & spellshield is a huge laugh! she just floats about, staying out of charge arcs of nasty things and goes casty-happy! good luck dealing with her in one turn when she has a 5+/3++(2++) save...
is it 'the best' combo? probably not, but it's fun so i'll happily use it, even when going for the pureple sun would be 'better' acording to the WAAC's crowd.
- dickenhoff or crutch-hoff banner? who needs it? i don't, and i can still win a game... (despite how dice seem to hate my very being)
- grave guard hoard. okay, i'll use it because i like how it looks and it fits my lahmain theme. but instead of going for the obvious barrows banner, i almost always take the shrieking standard. who says causing fear sucks now? i find it handy when your opponent rolls 3D6 and takes the two highest.
add to the misery of that the additional -1Ld from my nearby lord having aura of dark majesty, and the only units who don't worry are other fear-causers. (at which point, lore of light helps even the odds).
and while i personally won't use ghouls or corpse carts or vargs because they don't fit my theme, that doesn't mean i consider them 'bad'. ghouls for example i feel are one of our easiest answers to stopping an opponent from getting steadfast, since they build ranks for cheap, are tougher than average and still throw out lots of attacks!
corpse carts may be large targets, but if you can spare the pts, they're cheap sources for a diversionary unit. (and who doesn't want to laugh at how mighty a S2 thunder stomp is!)
as for zombies sucking at fighting? well, only if you just blindly throw them in... maybe tray raising a big unit in front of your general and then hitting them with mindrazor? eat my hoard of S10 zombie fun! it'll be mutual annihalation for sure, but my unit only cost me 80VP's!
so sure, maybe for some, it's hard to see beyond the cookie-cutter builds because your local crowds are full of arses and douchbags, it doesn't mean you have to follow suit, and there's ways around almost all the gimmiks...
and if you can't figure out how to stop a 1st turn power scrolled mega spell, well, aside from a tournment (many which are banning the scroll), no one is forcing you to play the beardy git!
cheers!