My philosophy: point to list comparison 8th edition

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Darius the Insane said:
Forge said:
so you do not take grave guard? all skeletons ghouls and a 5 man unit of blood knights, no helm of commandment? interesting....

I normally run 10 blood knight plus vamp plus wk lol its the deathstar I mentioned. I don't always take that and I don't always take GG, sometimes I don't take either. Correct, no HoC, its not part of my fluff.

Regardless, my point is, much like everybody else's (especially Mortus, kudos on your post) you do not have to take the same old same old. Diversify, experiment, take an 'underdog' army, don't be afraid to change things up and know that if you can keep your 85% win margin intact (I think thats what you said?), then you will know that you are a better General than your opponent. Instead of the guy who can write OP, broken and BORING army lists.

there is a big difference between defending a 5 man blood knight unit with a thrall and blood drinker, then running 10 blood knights vamp and wight king, THAT is an effective unit a unit I have ran many times, although i feel the frenzy really does us in most respects. 5 blood knights on the other hand i believe to be a total waste of effort points, and usually the game.

as to the post about not using grave guard or blood knights,that doesnt leave you with much to choose from, skeletons, ghouls, black coach, varghulfs, wraiths,what do you use as a hammer?
 
Some of your issue, Forge, may well be the point value you are playing at. At 1500 pt game, i dont take Blood Knights either, you cant hardly fit them in the list.

When 8th ed first came out and I was playing at 2K, I did some lists with Blood Knights in them and thus I had no specials. The list still worked, I just used my skeletons and ghouls as anvils and the blood knights as the hammer.

at 2K I also had lists where i had no rares, just core and specials (being ghouls, skeletons, graveguard and black knights.

If i field blood knights, i either field 6 of them, or a field 5 with a Vamp Thrall with them, depending on the point value of the game and the number of total units i have to support, just as I often run a Wight King with the black knights on a skeletal steed... it was sort of like he was meant to go there.

i think when people are saying they use certain units, it is impicated that they have the proper support. I use Zombies now and then, but only if I bring the Helm of Command to give them a fighting chance, or if I go Shadows to give them Okkams Mindrazor because NOONE expects a Strength 10 zombie with WS 7.... noone.
 
Gladius Rex said:
Some of your issue, Forge, may well be the point value you are playing at. At 1500 pt game, i dont take Blood Knights either, you cant hardly fit them in the list.

When 8th ed first came out and I was playing at 2K, I did some lists with Blood Knights in them and thus I had no specials. The list still worked, I just used my skeletons and ghouls as anvils and the blood knights as the hammer.

at 2K I also had lists where i had no rares, just core and specials (being ghouls, skeletons, graveguard and black knights.

If i field blood knights, i either field 6 of them, or a field 5 with a Vamp Thrall with them, depending on the point value of the game and the number of total units i have to support, just as I often run a Wight King with the black knights on a skeletal steed... it was sort of like he was meant to go there.

i think when people are saying they use certain units, it is impicated that they have the proper support. I use Zombies now and then, but only if I bring the Helm of Command to give them a fighting chance, or if I go Shadows to give them Okkams Mindrazor because NOONE expects a Strength 10 zombie with WS 7.... noone.

I just firmly believe that a 5-6 model unit's chances of living through a battle is quite slim no matter what point value, if they were 100 something points that is understandable and acceptable losses, but throwing away 600 something points on the other hand in a 2000 or even 2500 point game you know what even 3k is not acceptable the things you have to kill to make up for that extreme loss is heavy, 2-3 units if not more of your enemies force.

6-7 wound unit< 30+ wound unit

the only reason a larger unit of blood knights will work is because it can survive long enough to get into hand to hand and restore models via blood drinker, the character holding blood drinker ( an expensive model no less) is protected via look out sirs, and if you take a few more blood knights you might as well take a couple more and be able to break ranks.
 
FirestormXL said:
Dklyn said:
Blood knights are rare not special friend.

And a question for Mortus: how does a 5X10 unit move O.O? Just a slight wheel would eat up a good chunk of movement.


Oh I'm not running them not because they aren't rare, I'm not running them because i don't like how they looks :s All about flair!

Fair enough! I have yet to use blood knights as well, just wanted to make sure you knew we weren't discussing Black knights.
 
Mortus946736 said:
It doesnt eat up any more wheeling then any other 5 wide base... Exactly the same

Am I going crazy? I'm pretty sure it does... but it's been a while since I studied anything like that. My thinking: No model can move more than twice the movement and the models in the back I'm pretty sure will be moving more if in a longer unit for the same angle. When you wheel you "immobilize" one of the front corners (treating it as a spoke of a wheel) and the furthermost model is like the outside rim of the wheel right (which I think in units greater than 5x5 is the back corner)?

It's like comparing a car tire to a tricycle right? If they both rotate the same angle, the car tire will go further...?
 
Dklyn said:
Mortus946736 said:
It doesnt eat up any more wheeling then any other 5 wide base... Exactly the same

Am I going crazy? I'm pretty sure it does... but it's been a while since I studied anything like that. My thinking: No model can move more than twice the movement and the models in the back I'm pretty sure will be moving more if in a longer unit for the same angle. When you wheel you "immobilize" one of the front corners (treating it as a spoke of a wheel) and the furthermost model is like the outside rim of the wheel right (which I think in units greater than 5x5 is the back corner)?

It's like comparing a car tire to a tricycle right? If they both rotate the same angle, the car tire will go further...?

You are correct, any unit that goes deeper then its front will lose out on its wheel slightly. 5x10 kinda alot, thats what musicians are for.


Btw, we are WAYY off topic. back to the topic, the original meaning off this thread was to point out the scaling issues of points to balance of VC lists.

anything above 2250 or so begins to sway towards the unbalanced side, more so at 2500+
 
I really havent had any problem in 8th ed keeping a unit of Blood Knights alive. I get them into combat quickly and do my best to keep them there. Once they are there, they typically get the job done. I have ran them at 2000-3000 point lists, sometimes supported by special units, sometimes supported only by cores and characters.

Either way, my unit tends to be about 450 points, not 600. If you are counting the Thrall, then yes, i may push 600 points, but then again, it also doesnt die. I agree that a unit of 30 graveguard has more wounds than 5 or 6 blood knights.

But how long do you make those units last is the question.

Graveguard are at a 5+ armour if you use greatweapons. Blood Knights are at a 2+. Assuming that niether unit has the Hoff banner in it ( it could easily go in the BK unit as well) your wounds divy out as such.

a unit fighting graveguard with GW that have ws of 5, they hit can hit on 3s, and if they are strength 5 (which isnt really that rare) will wound on any roll except a 1 or 2. So if you have 20 attacks incoming that hit on 3-6, that is 66% likely to hit or 14 hits. With str 5, you wound on 3 as well. Out of 14 that makes 9 models dead out of 30 with no roll to save them. So you have lost 9 models out of your unit before you even get to swing. 9 Graveguard at 13 points a piece means you have lost 117 points lost.
.
the same unit fighting blood Knights, you have the same 20 incoming attacks, but only landing 50% so 10 hits on average. If the unit is again, str 5, you still wound on 3+, so that is still 6 wounds dealt. The difference now is that you have a 4+ armour roll to save with. That is 50% saved so you end up with 3 dead Blood Knights. 3 Blood Knights at 55 points a piece is 165 points lost in combat.

So if you are looking to charge head on into oblivion, you are correct, the Graveguard unit is clearly better. Now lets look at the a flank charge of the same unit.


Graveguard will get 5 incoming attacks, 66 % land or 3 land with half those wounding, thus you lose 1.5 (most likely 2)

Blood Knights will have 5 incoming attacks, 50% land or 2 land, with half wounding meaning 1, but now you get a 4+ armour save, so you lose .5 (possibly 1).

Points lost in Graveguard = 2x13 = 26 points

Points lost in Blood Knithts = 55 points (if you lose one at all)

So clearly calvary models and infantry models have differnent roles to fill. Graveguard hitting the flank 5x? with command will give you 11 greatweapon attacks at str 6. not shabby at all. BLood Knights will give you 16 attacks at str 7 + 5 attacks at str 4. Clearly better for a flank charge.

Disruption and all of that is well and good, but again, thats why it takes an anvil (infantry like Graveguard) and a hammer unit (like BLood Knights) working together to reallly put the hurt on someone.

Infantry can withstand the head on fight with another rank n file unit, so use them that way, let the cavalry hit in the flank like they were intended and do a job they are capable of doing.

(just a note, Helm of Command, Hoff Banners, and the like characters in units drastically change things, I am aware, this is just a quick analysis of how you can run either as a flank charger and not lose the farm)
 
Gladius Rex said:
I really havent had any problem in 8th ed keeping a unit of Blood Knights alive. I get them into combat quickly and do my best to keep them there. Once they are there, they typically get the job done. I have ran them at 2000-3000 point lists, sometimes supported by special units, sometimes supported only by cores and characters.

Either way, my unit tends to be about 450 points, not 600. If you are counting the Thrall, then yes, i may push 600 points, but then again, it also doesnt die. I agree that a unit of 30 graveguard has more wounds than 5 or 6 blood knights.

But how long do you make those units last is the question.

Graveguard are at a 5+ armour if you use greatweapons. Blood Knights are at a 2+. Assuming that niether unit has the Hoff banner in it ( it could easily go in the BK unit as well) your wounds divy out as such.

a unit fighting graveguard with GW that have ws of 5, they hit can hit on 3s, and if they are strength 5 (which isnt really that rare) will wound on any roll except a 1 or 2. So if you have 20 attacks incoming that hit on 3-6, that is 66% likely to hit or 14 hits. With str 5, you wound on 3 as well. Out of 14 that makes 9 models dead out of 30 with no roll to save them. So you have lost 9 models out of your unit before you even get to swing. 9 Graveguard at 13 points a piece means you have lost 117 points lost.
.
the same unit fighting blood Knights, you have the same 20 incoming attacks, but only landing 50% so 10 hits on average. If the unit is again, str 5, you still wound on 3+, so that is still 6 wounds dealt. The difference now is that you have a 4+ armour roll to save with. That is 50% saved so you end up with 3 dead Blood Knights. 3 Blood Knights at 55 points a piece is 165 points lost in combat.

So if you are looking to charge head on into oblivion, you are correct, the Graveguard unit is clearly better. Now lets look at the a flank charge of the same unit.


Graveguard will get 5 incoming attacks, 66 % land or 3 land with half those wounding, thus you lose 1.5 (most likely 2)

Blood Knights will have 5 incoming attacks, 50% land or 2 land, with half wounding meaning 1, but now you get a 4+ armour save, so you lose .5 (possibly 1).

Points lost in Graveguard = 2x13 = 26 points

Points lost in Blood Knithts = 55 points (if you lose one at all)

So clearly calvary models and infantry models have differnent roles to fill. Graveguard hitting the flank 5x? with command will give you 11 greatweapon attacks at str 6. not shabby at all. BLood Knights will give you 16 attacks at str 7 + 5 attacks at str 4. Clearly better for a flank charge.

Disruption and all of that is well and good, but again, thats why it takes an anvil (infantry like Graveguard) and a hammer unit (like BLood Knights) working together to reallly put the hurt on someone.

Infantry can withstand the head on fight with another rank n file unit, so use them that way, let the cavalry hit in the flank like they were intended and do a job they are capable of doing.

(just a note, Helm of Command, Hoff Banners, and the like characters in units drastically change things, I am aware, this is just a quick analysis of how you can run either as a flank charger and not lose the farm)

the thing you are forgetting about is the fact that you spend 2-3 turns out of combat, who is going to survive the onslaught of easily aimed war machines and over powered magic? who is going to have models left at the end of the turn to be raised back by one summon undead horde or some IoN, who gets a possible 6X better effect from IoN.

plus a 29 man grave guard unit with FC and banner of the barrows is 452 points about the same you will pay for your blood knights, substitute the thrall with blood drinker for the wight king with hoff banner and its about the same, except the grave guard are far more effective in combat and survivability. Plus your most likely going to have helm of commandment on your grave guard almost always, putting the helm on the blood knights is a waste in most cases.

I agree in SOME cases your blood knights might survive to get into combat, but in alot of cases 1 spell will wipe them out, a concentrated shooting phase will wipe them out, if they get charged its over, then you have to make a comeback from the huge point loss.
 
First off, i dont consider magic to be very OP right now. Winds of magic is pretty fickle and i have more success getting my blood knights into combat now than i ever had and it never takes me 3 rounds. More often than not, they see close combat in round 2 (or i at least attempt that charge in round 2) Typically I give my opponent one round of shooting at them before he missed his chance.

Warmachines never kill that many blood knights in my experience. Cannons hit 1, maybe 2 at best so with a 4+ save... maybe 1 dies. Templates are even worse. Most of the time, they drift off the knights completely and noone dies. THe worst I have taken in blood knights fatalities prior to getting into CC was from the Orc N Goblin Doom Diver and the one time i failed my ld roll and charged over a fanatic, but those sorts of things just happen and the silly fanatic doesnt count as shooting, so I didnt get my ward save. buggery!

but the things you say about graveguard are not immune either. My HE friend pretty much focuses his entire magic and shooting phases on graveguard EVEN if i have blood knights on the table. If I field 30 grave guard, it is not uncommon for me to get all 4 repeater bolt throwers to lob a volley of 6. Thats 24 shots that armour pierce and i have lost up to 10-15 at times from it. Then he unleashes magic as well on them which does in a number of graveguard as well. Ive also had the winds of magic screw me to the point i couldnt get my units restored even with IoN only to watch them get shot up more. And Graveguard having slower movment may not be able to get into combat in round 2, so you may have to endure even more shooting and magic than a faster moving unit.

If i run Blood Knights, i typically bring a bigger block of ghouls (like 40) and a Thrall with Ghoulkin somewhere on the board. That gives me some rank n file infantry that get a jump start so they reach the same unit as the blood Knights at about the same time (assuming i dont roll double 1 on a charge roll or something stupid like that happens)

6 wide Ghouls from the front, Blood Knights from the flank... not alot will surivive that and then you reduce Steadfast on your opponent and watch him cry.

I mean, thats 19 poison attacks and 16 lance attacks and the 5 measly little Nightmare attacks.

The only army i have problem geting that to work on is Dwarves because they are so damn slow and typically will sit back, so it takes an extra round, so against dwarves I try to get some terrain in some prime locations to grant me some extra protection as I move the extra round to launch my assault.

like i have said in various threads... you gotta play your strategy through the entire game, from terrain setup to close combat.

and lets leave the helm of command out of it... you can use that helm on anything including Blood Knights for a turn if your enemy unit demands it. If you want to go that far, then I could counter with saying that Phas Protection makes half your worries a non issue, or putting the Hoff BSB mounted in the Blood Knights adds extra close combat protection to help save those wounds, or that Shadow damage can reduce the opponents strength so that the T4 will last longer.

There are a million combinations when you start tossing magic into the mix of which we cannot possibly cover them all.
 
Gladius Rex said:
First off, i dont consider magic to be very OP right now. Winds of magic is pretty fickle and i have more success getting my blood knights into combat now than i ever had and it never takes me 3 rounds. More often than not, they see close combat in round 2 (or i at least attempt that charge in round 2) Typically I give my opponent one round of shooting at them before he missed his chance.

Warmachines never kill that many blood knights in my experience. Cannons hit 1, maybe 2 at best so with a 4+ save... maybe 1 dies. Templates are even worse. Most of the time, they drift off the knights completely and noone dies. THe worst I have taken in blood knights fatalities prior to getting into CC was from the Orc N Goblin Doom Diver and the one time i failed my ld roll and charged over a fanatic, but those sorts of things just happen and the silly fanatic doesnt count as shooting, so I didnt get my ward save. buggery!

but the things you say about graveguard are not immune either. My HE friend pretty much focuses his entire magic and shooting phases on graveguard EVEN if i have blood knights on the table. If I field 30 grave guard, it is not uncommon for me to get all 4 repeater bolt throwers to lob a volley of 6. Thats 24 shots that armour pierce and i have lost up to 10-15 at times from it. Then he unleashes magic as well on them which does in a number of graveguard as well. Ive also had the winds of magic screw me to the point i couldnt get my units restored even with IoN only to watch them get shot up more. And Graveguard having slower movment may not be able to get into combat in round 2, so you may have to endure even more shooting and magic than a faster moving unit.

If i run Blood Knights, i typically bring a bigger block of ghouls (like 40) and a Thrall with Ghoulkin somewhere on the board. That gives me some rank n file infantry that get a jump start so they reach the same unit as the blood Knights at about the same time (assuming i dont roll double 1 on a charge roll or something stupid like that happens)

6 wide Ghouls from the front, Blood Knights from the flank... not alot will surivive that and then you reduce Steadfast on your opponent and watch him cry.

I mean, thats 19 poison attacks and 16 lance attacks and the 5 measly little Nightmare attacks.

The only army i have problem geting that to work on is Dwarves because they are so damn slow and typically will sit back, so it takes an extra round, so against dwarves I try to get some terrain in some prime locations to grant me some extra protection as I move the extra round to launch my assault.

like i have said in various threads... you gotta play your strategy through the entire game, from terrain setup to close combat.

and lets leave the helm of command out of it... you can use that helm on anything including Blood Knights for a turn if your enemy unit demands it. If you want to go that far, then I could counter with saying that Phas Protection makes half your worries a non issue, or putting the Hoff BSB mounted in the Blood Knights adds extra close combat protection to help save those wounds, or that Shadow damage can reduce the opponents strength so that the T4 will last longer.

There are a million combinations when you start tossing magic into the mix of which we cannot possibly cover them all.

Helm of commandment is not magic, there is nothing finicky about it you pick a target within 12 inches and it has it.

no respectable, even relatively new player will let you get a flank charge off on turn 2, youll be lucky if you get one on turn 3.

turn 1 to move closer to the enemy, turn 2 to angle your anvil, turn 3 charge the flank (IF he charges your anvil)

calvary are generally slower this edition, their charge range used to be what made them awesome, now its anywhere between 9 and 19 inches instead of 14.

as far as losing 10-15 grave guard to bolt throwers with a total of 24 shots, your either horribly un lucky considering your probably going to have some sort of cover even if not, 4+ regen should have saved alot more, unless your implying your not taking drakkenhoff, then theres the root of your problem, same reason you wouldnt not take banner of blood keep on the blood knights. moving the regen banner into the blood knights? ok if you want to make your already horribly expensive blood knights more expensive without adding much survivability.

ive seen magic break peoples spirits, ive seen in wipe half an army in one cast, ive seen magic decimate 1200 in one cast and cause a chain reaction making the rest of the guys forces flee.

for example, I went first, i cast normal purple sun with my scout vampire lord with lore of death first turn. I had lined my self up with both his 2 hell cannons and his 40 man marauder block, it cast, killed both hell cannons and all their crew, killed like 15 mauraders, rolled my dice to get the power dice back, got 5, he had used all his dice to try to dispel my purple sun, cast spirit leach on his sorcer lord on disc did a wound, casted fate of bjuna on him did 3 wounds. he conceded. 5 minutes into the game.
 
He shouldnt loose that many if he is woc... Period. He rolled terrible, you rolled well... '

Admitely, that such a thing is possible is a major thorn in the side... but i find that most of the time big flashy magic fails.... hard.
 
I didnt say the helm is finicky, i said that magic items and magic lores you can put on characters in a million combinations that make units infinitely better or worse. Whatever you want to do to make a graveguard unit better you can do to blood knights as well.

And I do get my blood knights into flanks in round 2 all the time. Its the prime reason I run ghoul anvils in large blocks. Ghoulkin allows me the extra movement.

Ghoulkin movement - move closer to enemy. Turn 1, angle the anvil, turn 2 - blood Knight charge.

I dont find cavalry to be any slower, no more than i find infantry to be faster. Every now and then you get a better than average charge from infantry and every now and then you get a slower one. I find that to not be an issue. I typically fall drastically short on a bogus roll or overkill my charge by several inches with a spectacular one, otherwise i land about where I expected and when i expected. I know one thing is for sure, its alot easier to hit a target that cant flee because its in combat, which as i think we both agree, the anvil unit of infantry is necessary, be they ghouls or graveguard.

if my ghouls move 8 inches before combat begins via ghoulkin (which i honestly us quite a bit and is probably just as much the key to my successes as the other units supporting this tactic) then my enemy moves up in round 1. I can then typically charge him in round 1 or in the magic phase with VdM. So I typically have no problem getting my anvil into position and making the charge or at best setting up the anvil to get charged so the Blood Knights can come crashing in.

i really dont see how this is so difficult. If you have problems making it happen then the level of competition you play against must just be spectacular, because i play against some guys who OBSESS over this stuff and have some pretty high IQs. Its a large part of why I have to keep mixing up my stuff to keep them from being able to predict and calculate my every move.

frankly I give up man, there is no convincing you, you are set in your ways and a victim of your own boundries. I hope you give some of these units a chance in a list sometime and I hope it works out for you and you have a change of heart.
 
and a side note, i am not a prisioner of the Hoff. I use it from time to time, and yes, sometimes, it finds its way onto Thralls back as he rides with the Blood Knights.

Though last time i fielded that unit in that fashion... it got a universal ban from ever appearing in my game shops tournaments again.

If you havent noticed, I run all sorts of different set ups, if for no other reason, to watch my opponent flip his lid when he brings all that fire... to find i have no regen, just more armour than he planned for. The time I lost that many graveguard, they were HW&S and yes, I did not have the BSB in that unit. My graveguard did bite it pretty hard, but it didnt mean i lost the game :thumbsup:
 
So much controversy over Blood Knights!
I myself have yet to use them in 2k and under, I prefer reliable in games of this size, and blood knights are delicious, and if they make it into a unit supported and alive, they will chew through them quite nicely.... but I too cannot justify sinking almost a quarter of my allowance into one unit.

I also play Skaven and you try your hardest chopping your way through 50 slaves before I pummel them to death with wind mortars and jezzails, blood knights are far too situational for smaller games, I think that is all Forge is trying to say?

I actually take Grave guard before anything, then black knights, cause I converted a heap up and I love them! only in larger games of 2500+ would I consider blood knights.

Let's not take any comments or opinions/ or views too personally either guys! We all play a different game, hell I know people who refuse to paint their armies or put any real effort into it, and they truly play a purely math-hammer game, others play for the fluff and character building of their force and many make their armies in between.

I thought I should also mention, magic is fickle? clearly you don't fight Lizardmen often with one of them crazy toads often!
Cupped hands, calm ruination will just ruin your day!
 
You know... i have always wanted to fight lizardmen. I know one guy who plays them and the one time i got to play a team game with him. i was on his team. Odd couple i know, but id love to clash with them because i hear they are about the worst army for us to contend with maybe short of another VC army.

and at 1500 points, yeah the Blood Knights are expensive and I dont blame you for not taking them, thus why I said also that I use black knights. Forge has stood his ground that ONLY graveguard are worth it. He even seems to refuse to try Black Knights. I started using blood knights in my examples simply because they do get a nice banner that helps with shooting and magic, which was his complaint about the black knights, but if you go back far enough in this rediculously long thread... you will see where i even bring up the Black knights.

and really, like i have said about 100 times as well... i dont blame him for loving graveguard, we all do, but I dont see how having two units of Graveguard (one anvil and one to flank with) is so much greater than running a unit of graveguard as an anvil (or ghouls or skellies or whatever) and then using a cavalry unit to smash a flank.

Im must trying to help Forge out by tossing some options his way to help him break the mold that he started this entire thread complaining about.
 
First off, cavalry are NOT generally slower in this edition. The only parts that were slower are their ability to flee/pursue. Marching is unaffected as far as I can tell, and the average roll for swiftstride charge is 9". So, instead of adding 7 to our barded movement, we add an average of 9! Now it CAN be slower, but in general, the charge range is actually 2" longer. As someone who plays against bret's commonly, I can attest that this is a painful truth. What is true is that the gap b/t infantry and cavalry is much narrower than it use to be as far as charge distances are concerned.

Funny enough, I played against a slann last night who miscasted twice. The second one caused him a str 10 hit for everyone in base contact with him and thanks to his nice big base, 11 temple guards died :D. It's also fantastic when he rolls a 1 for cupped hands. So yes, magic can even be fickle for the toads. I also don't think they are too awful for us to deal with, but I don't want to discuss that in detail on this thread :).
 
Dklyn, i am not quite sure you are correct there unless i misunderstand the charge rules.

Swiftstride is pointless when it comes to charging. I am pretty sure all units roll the same 2d6 for a charge. Swiftstride is used in pursuing/overrunning, and fleeing. Charging is the only time the Swiftstride rule seems to have gotten omitted from being useful.

unless I am just missing it.

So 7 + 2d6 gives you the 9-19 range that both Forge and I have commented on.

Woah... Forge and I agreed on something. Check the thermometer... its freezing somewhere lol.
 
Gladius Rex said:
Dklyn, i am not quite sure you are correct there unless i misunderstand the charge rules.

Swiftstride is pointless when it comes to charging. I am pretty sure all units roll the same 2d6 for a charge. Swiftstride is used in pursuing/overrunning, and fleeing. Charging is the only time the Swiftstride rule seems to have gotten omitted from being useful.

unless I am just missing it.

So 7 + 2d6 gives you the 9-19 range that both Forge and I have commented on.

Woah... Forge and I agreed on something. Check the thermometer... its freezing somewhere lol.
BRB p. 76 under swiftstride: "when charging, units entirely made of models with the swiftstride special rule roll 3d6, discard the lowest result and add the result to their move value." Very first sentence :) It goes on to give the same rules for fleeing/pursuing. Blk knight, fel bats (who do get swiftstride thanks to being warbeasts) and wolves just got a little better eh?

You probably were looking under charging which for some reason it's not mentioned. It's worth mentioning that the range (9-19) is the same, it's just skewed towards the end since you lose the lowest results. (9 is the average instead of 7)

Even if it was 2d6, that means you would add an average of 7 to your movement, exactly as 7th edition was for barded mounts, so they wouldn't be slower anyways, just equal chance of being slower or faster.
 
I think alot of opinions and feelings also rely heavily on your local gaming crowd, plus your own personal attitude.

for example, my area (burlington/oakville/hamilton) has sadly become extremely WAAC due mainly in part to a new southern ontario-wide league that's begun. the 1st place prize is $1,000 worth of shit! with that much actual money on the line, people get greedy and through common sense & sportsmanship out the window...

thus, this translates into an atmosphere akin to 'ard boyz, IMHO one of the very worst things to have ever happened to our hobby. so when you're taking an army of character-centric, terrible initiative, average S/T models into an arena that's dominated by lists all designed for that 1st turn IF dwellers/PSoX/pit of shades/13th spell... it's very easy to look at our book and cry that 'only a cookie-cutter build is possible with VC'.
the local meta means it comes down to, 'well everyone else is a douchbag, so i've got to be one too to win'.

now, if your gaming area isn't so mindlessly childish & pathetic, then it's easy to see beyond the 'easy answers' and experiment more with the less optimal options we have:
- skellies are awsome! i always take a 40-50 strong spear hoard + 33-35 strong ranked block for negating my opponent's steadfast.
add to them some lore of light and a liberal sprinkling of lore of metal or wyssan's wildform and skellies are top notch!

- a forbidden lore w/vampire magic on a hellsteed w/wristbands & spellshield is a huge laugh! she just floats about, staying out of charge arcs of nasty things and goes casty-happy! good luck dealing with her in one turn when she has a 5+/3++(2++) save...
is it 'the best' combo? probably not, but it's fun so i'll happily use it, even when going for the pureple sun would be 'better' acording to the WAAC's crowd.

- dickenhoff or crutch-hoff banner? who needs it? i don't, and i can still win a game... (despite how dice seem to hate my very being)

- grave guard hoard. okay, i'll use it because i like how it looks and it fits my lahmain theme. but instead of going for the obvious barrows banner, i almost always take the shrieking standard. who says causing fear sucks now? i find it handy when your opponent rolls 3D6 and takes the two highest.:vampire3:
add to the misery of that the additional -1Ld from my nearby lord having aura of dark majesty, and the only units who don't worry are other fear-causers. (at which point, lore of light helps even the odds).

and while i personally won't use ghouls or corpse carts or vargs because they don't fit my theme, that doesn't mean i consider them 'bad'. ghouls for example i feel are one of our easiest answers to stopping an opponent from getting steadfast, since they build ranks for cheap, are tougher than average and still throw out lots of attacks!
corpse carts may be large targets, but if you can spare the pts, they're cheap sources for a diversionary unit. (and who doesn't want to laugh at how mighty a S2 thunder stomp is!)

as for zombies sucking at fighting? well, only if you just blindly throw them in... maybe tray raising a big unit in front of your general and then hitting them with mindrazor? eat my hoard of S10 zombie fun! it'll be mutual annihalation for sure, but my unit only cost me 80VP's!


so sure, maybe for some, it's hard to see beyond the cookie-cutter builds because your local crowds are full of arses and douchbags, it doesn't mean you have to follow suit, and there's ways around almost all the gimmiks...
and if you can't figure out how to stop a 1st turn power scrolled mega spell, well, aside from a tournment (many which are banning the scroll), no one is forcing you to play the beardy git!

cheers!
 
Valdiroth said:
So much controversy over Blood Knights!
I myself have yet to use them in 2k and under, I prefer reliable in games of this size, and blood knights are delicious, and if they make it into a unit supported and alive, they will chew through them quite nicely.... but I too cannot justify sinking almost a quarter of my allowance into one unit.

I also play Skaven and you try your hardest chopping your way through 50 slaves before I pummel them to death with wind mortars and jezzails, blood knights are far too situational for smaller games, I think that is all Forge is trying to say?

I actually take Grave guard before anything, then black knights, cause I converted a heap up and I love them! only in larger games of 2500+ would I consider blood knights.

Let's not take any comments or opinions/ or views too personally either guys! We all play a different game, hell I know people who refuse to paint their armies or put any real effort into it, and they truly play a purely math-hammer game, others play for the fluff and character building of their force and many make their armies in between.

I thought I should also mention, magic is fickle? clearly you don't fight Lizardmen often with one of them crazy toads often!
Cupped hands, calm ruination will just ruin your day!

Exactly what im trying to say, a quarter or more of my army sunk into a 5-6 wound unit with no ward save in hand to hand and only a 4+ from shooting is so risky, and blatantly is the life line of your army, all your opponent has to do is concentrate on it first turn and it should disappear (more dice on target), once it dies your going to have to struggle to gain those points back, thats a HUGE chunk for something I wouldnt even consider much killier then grave guard, infact the opposite, if your going to take calvary your better off taking double the size of black knights, but even then they have their draw backs, and at anything less then 2500 points I would run grave guard.

I have mentioned it countless times, I have played the blood knight death star, It won me my local ard boys, how many times would it have been killed in the course of the battle if it wasnt due to the vampire lord with blood drinker and red fury? probably about twice on average, Knights arnt hard to lose, why did they survive? because I had to many to kill in one single turn, they were smashing into units negating static combat resolution, and they had things like hatred from the BSB with them.

as far as second turn flank charges go, I have no idea what your doing, unless your opponent is just mindlessly marching forward giving no thought to the fact that there is enemy calvary on his flank, plus you start off 24 inches apart, you move 14 inches with your march, you WILL be located in all of your opponents front arc, idk how you wouldnt be, unless you went second and your opponent moved up marching full speed ahead first, but then get this you march up to his flank, no self respecting player will let you charge his flank, he reforms or wheels and negates that.
 
@ Anubis: I do agree with you completely. Local metagame does make a difference. The League i play in at my shop goes for 2 month periods. Whoever wins the most number of games, gets 30 dollars in store credit to spend however they so please. 20 dollars goes to the person who just flat out plays the most games. 10 dollars goes to the person who has played the greatest number of different players.

In general, alot of people at my shop are Ard boys players. They use big spells, scrolls, and some pretty cheesy crap from time to time, so I dont mind to stoop to their level now and then and field a mounted Lord with a Dreadlance and Red Fury, but I also do alot of other things to keep them more honest when they play me (as i have mentioned before).

Some of my antics have caused those guys a great ammount of stress when their 6 die Power scrolled Purple Sun is met with my Lord snickering and holding out a Feedback Scroll. They purple sun'd my graveguard and I lost a fair number, but i regrew over the next few rounds after the Feedback scroll destoryed their caster and basically handed me every magic phase from turn 2-6.

So just because your local metagame is Ard Boys-riffic, doenst mean you can teach them a thing or two.

@ Forge... i guess the players i play against are just a bit mindless then, because i typically never go first, even if i get the +1, and my enemys first move, even if I move with ghoulkin... is typically to march forward with little disregard for the Black Knights or Blood Knights. I think alot of them think like you do and assume that Cavalry "sucks" now and in round 2, I quicky remind them why they are still an ok choice. The Warriors of Chaos guy i beat had given up on his Chaos Knights alltogether, then he saw what my Blood Knights did to his warriors and his mauraders, and his chosen.... then he quickly rewrote a list using a unit of Chaos Knights.

*shrug* or maybe I am just that lucky, but you watch me roll some dice and you wouldnt think it.
 
Gladius Rex said:
Some of my antics have caused those guys a great ammount of stress when their 6 die Power scrolled Purple Sun is met with my Lord snickering and holding out a Feedback Scroll. They purple sun'd my graveguard and I lost a fair number, but i regrew over the next few rounds after the Feedback scroll destoryed their caster and basically handed me every magic phase from turn 2-6.

Great tactic, I wish that were legal, but, from BRB FAQ:

Q: Can there ever be more than one attempt at dispelling a spell per
magic phase? Can a Wizard use a scroll if it isn’t allowed to make a
dispel attempt, for example the spell was cast with irresistible force
or the wizard has previously failed to dispel a spell that turn? (p35)
A: No to both questions.
 
Gladius Rex said:
@ Anubis: I do agree with you completely. Local metagame does make a difference. The League i play in at my shop goes for 2 month periods. Whoever wins the most number of games, gets 30 dollars in store credit to spend however they so please. 20 dollars goes to the person who just flat out plays the most games. 10 dollars goes to the person who has played the greatest number of different players.

In general, alot of people at my shop are Ard boys players. They use big spells, scrolls, and some pretty cheesy crap from time to time, so I dont mind to stoop to their level now and then and field a mounted Lord with a Dreadlance and Red Fury, but I also do alot of other things to keep them more honest when they play me (as i have mentioned before).

Some of my antics have caused those guys a great ammount of stress when their 6 die Power scrolled Purple Sun is met with my Lord snickering and holding out a Feedback Scroll. They purple sun'd my graveguard and I lost a fair number, but i regrew over the next few rounds after the Feedback scroll destoryed their caster and basically handed me every magic phase from turn 2-6.

So just because your local metagame is Ard Boys-riffic, doenst mean you can teach them a thing or two.

@ Forge... i guess the players i play against are just a bit mindless then, because i typically never go first, even if i get the +1, and my enemys first move, even if I move with ghoulkin... is typically to march forward with little disregard for the Black Knights or Blood Knights. I think alot of them think like you do and assume that Cavalry "sucks" now and in round 2, I quicky remind them why they are still an ok choice. The Warriors of Chaos guy i beat had given up on his Chaos Knights alltogether, then he saw what my Blood Knights did to his warriors and his mauraders, and his chosen.... then he quickly rewrote a list using a unit of Chaos Knights.

*shrug* or maybe I am just that lucky, but you watch me roll some dice and you wouldnt think it.

well if your opponents play like that? cant argue with your choice then, they probably dont even target your blood knights if they arnt smart enough to wheel an inch to make you charge their front, this would never fly at my store, my opponents actually use maneuvering to win/contribute to their games.
 
Forge said:
well if your opponents play like that? cant argue with your choice then, they probably dont even target your blood knights if they arnt smart enough to wheel an inch to make you charge their front, this would never fly at my store, my opponents actually use maneuvering to win/contribute to their games.

The feedback scroll doesnt dispel. The Wizard gets his spell of successfully, the Feedback Scroll just makes him roll every die he used to wound himself. Thats why it still works. Since the Feedback scroll states that the spell succeeds, i think it is still within the rules. Now a true dispel scroll, you are correct, I couldnt use.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu