holla holla get dolla said:
"No. I said VERY few are different"
Actually you've said both, these arguements have gone around in circles for 7 pages and you've said many things, things which have some truth to them but are buried under hyperbole and stubborness.
The thing is that, yes, VC does have poor internal balancing and some units excel at a disproportionately large number of scenarios when compared to others. Grave guard, rare choices and characters are the prime offenders here - arguably ghouls too but I think their uses are somewhat exaggerated. If you had just stated this than I think most here would've agreed with you, but the thing is you went way too far in saying that everything asides from those aforementioned units are worthless. Black knights, blood knights, fell bats, skeletons, etc. may not be as good all purpose units as grave guard are, but there are areas in which they shine. I've mentioned those areas before so I won't repeat myself
Another point of criticism I have to bring up is your stubborness. I've shown you the "math hammer" as you call it, and blood knights are undoubtedly the more efficient unit offensively compared to grave guard. You've refused to simply admit that and now we're on some ridiculous tangent and you're insisting that most people run their grave guards in horde formation. It's comical really, step back and see that
You're not going to convince anyone you're right when you present your ideas in a ludicrously exaggerated way, and then dismiss valid criticisms of those ideas. Keep an open mind, weigh what people say to you and don't be afraid to abandon former claims if you think you were wrong about them; just put your ideas out there and let people judge them for what they are
Ok and one last thing I think I should reply to before I leave:
"noooooo, your so very wrong, again, how long have you been here?"
You may have posted more than me but I've lurked for quite some time, and anyways my time spent on this forum isn't really relevant since it only takes 10 minutes to check out the army builds in the army list section
woah there smokey.
First off I never said Black knights, blood knights, and skeletons are worthless, if you actually read the forums as much as you claim to
which I find it hard to believe since you joined 2 days ago *cough* liar *cough*
you would see that I myself only run skeletons, no ghouls, That I am a firm believer in the Blood Knight death star and its abilities, and that I said Black knights are not what they used to be but they didnt take it so hard like some units like corpse carts. Fell bats I still believe there are better buys then them but thats besides the point.
You claim to know it all but your math hammer is FAR off, your percentages are FAR off, at least mine are ball park. what gets me aggravated is your laying out numbers like you've actually done the math, like you've actually existed in this forum long enough to know what the general consensus on the subject matter is.
Let me lay down the "Mathhammer" for you on Grave Guard vs. Blood Knights with helm of commandment vamp in the rear as most will agree it is apparent in most lists. lets assume we dont have drakkenhoff banner just to make it fair for the blood knights.
21x Grave Guard 348 pts
(I would never run them this low, most people dont, but for point comparisons lets assume they are deployed 7 wide)
Great weapons
FC
Banner of the barrows
4x Blood Knights 345 pts.
FC
Banner of blood keep
Defensive:
"Based on a 5 wide enemy unit, strength 3, toughness 3, WS 3 armor not really being a factor considering the strength of the attacks are already high, we will assume the blood knights charge, and i dont want to get into multiple rounds of combat."
Grave Guard
11 attacks hitting on 4's
11 x .5 = 5.5 misses
5.5 x .666666666666666666666667 = 3.6666666666666666666666667 missed wounds
1.8333333333333333333333 total wounds allocated
1.8333333333333333333333 x .3333333333333333333 = 1.22222222222222222222222833333 wounds suffered after saves
Total wounds suffered = ~1.2
Blood Knights
11 attacks hitting on 4's
11 x .5 = 5.5 misses
5.5 x .666666666666666666666667 = 3.6666666666666666666666667 missed wounds
1.8333333333333333333333 total wounds allocated
1.8333333333333333333333 x .833333333333333333333333 = .3055555555555555555558 wounds suffered after saves
Total wounds suffered = ~.3
still a possible wound done, this isnt factoring in luck, and your bad luck, the difference here is grave guard have the bodies to compensate for your opponents good luck and your bad luck.
Offensive:
"Based on a 5 wide enemy unit, strength 3, toughness 3, WS 3, 5+ armor, we will assume the blood knights charge, and i dont want to get into multiple rounds of combat."
Grave Guard
15 attacks hitting on 2+
15 x .16666666666666666666667 = 2.5 misses
12.5 hits wounding on 2+
12.5 x .16666666666666666666667 = 2.083333333333333333333333333375 missed wounds
10.416666666666666666666625 wounds allocated total
No armour saves = 10.416666666666666666666625 wounds
Total wounds = ~10.4 wounds
Blood Knights
13 attacks hitting on 3+
13 x .3333333333333 ect = 4.3333333333333333333329 misses
8.6666666666666666666671 hits wounding on 2+
8.6666666666666666666671 x .16666666666666666666667 = 1.444444444444444444447333333333341 missed wounds
10.11111111111111111111111111111111111573333334 wounds allocated total
No armour saves = 7.222222222222222219333333333766659
Wounds (Blood Knights) = ~7.2 wounds
edit: forgot the horses thanks Darius
Horses
4 attacks hitting on 4+ (remember steeds do not benefit from HoC)
4 x .5 = 2 misses
2 hits wounding on 3+
2 x .33333333333333 = .666666666666666 wounds missed
1.3 wounds before armor
5+ armor
1.3 x .8333333333333333333333333333
1.08333333333333333333333333333333 total wounds allocated
= ~1.1
Total Wounds (Blood Knights + Horses) = ~8.3
defensive wise shooting is a tottally different ball game, and honestly the 4+ ward isnt enough to cut down casualties significantly, its a small percentile that usually only comes into play with a single wound, and is dependent on another 50/50 dice roll.
soooooooooooooooooo
your theory that blood knights are more killy for their points is absurd, they are not, add another blood knight or 2 and your adding a whole new rank to the grave guard allowing them to effectively
horde adding 7 more attacks, you will only be able to squeeze 2 more blood knights into hand to hand before having to resort to support attacks (6 attacks) which then your adding enough blood knights to actually make them a force to be reckoned with considering they will survive to see combat.
among the slightly increased damage output of grave guard for point to damage ratio they also have abilities the blood knights do not, number one being multiple ranks, the ability to break steadfast and add a good amount of static combat resolution, the ability to benefit fully from IoN rather then a 1 wound limitation per casting, the ability to house characters while giving them a sense of protection, and enough wounds to not detract attacks as the game goes on and models are lost, as with the blood knights for every blood knight you lose, you basically lose 3 grave guard attacks.
not to mention the grave guards points are alot harder to earn then a 4 wound unit of blood knights and the grave guard have killing blow magical attacks which is invaluable.
hope ive proved the actual math hammer here, and if you argue about the helm of commandment not being viable, then ok, the grave guard still come out on top due to the extra attacks hitting and wounding at the same level.
you know what really gives you away?...
the fact that you said a majority of people dont run their grave guard
horde, and only 50% of lists include helm of commandment.