My philosophy: point to list comparison 8th edition

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Good post Mortus, I especially agree with the idea of being unpredictable. You have to change things up and throw everything you can at your opponent, keep them guessing and on their toes and it'll put you in a much better position for sure.

Oh yeah.........and pray to the dice gods before every game :)

One thing confused me though
Skeletons go deep, 5 wide, and with a war banner.

I thought the war banner cost 35pts which is above the skellies 25 max for banners? Am I wrong, because that would be awesome :)
 
The faq for the brb says:

If a item is in both the brb and the Army Books, use the point cost listed in the armybook.

Im paraphrasing, but that is the gist of it.

Effect from the BrB, cost from the armybook..

In some cases more expensive, in some cases less.
 
You (Mortus) and I are playing a different game. I would never use Ghouls to hunt Hydras, they eat small ghoul units (30 and less) in one round. For hydras and such I use wraiths, Coach or summoned Spirit hosts

Ghouls excel against all elves, dwarfs, empire, orcs, marauders, and even chaos warriors as long as they are not frenzied halberds. The Ghouls have the numbers and if you only get a single vanhel on them the combat wont even be exciting.

I just dont see how my GG will lose to any other units then deathstars if luck is kind of predictable. 2+, 2+ with 29 attacks equals a lot of kills. They also KB a lot of enemy characters unfortunate to be in combat with them.

I agree with you that all units need support, mine are almost always within 12" of my general so that he can help them. I often deploy one just one side of the table with my vampires to ensure my flanks dont get rolled up.

No serious tournament would allow the scenarios from the book. They are very unbalanced, especially the B&G and the Watchtower as they encourage Deathstars. The rest of the scenarios are just ways of adding randomness to the deployment phase.

I made a rough sketch of the list you implying that you were playing with. It came up as ~2150 points. Dont you field a bsb? Just a lord? No other characters? I assumed your 2 units of graveguard were 25 strong each. No great weapons or magic banners on them. Or are you playing larger games? Because im talking of ETC games.

Also if your horded units are easy meat for combo charges then your opponent have very killy units, then comes the question why he doesnt horde them? Almost everyone hordes their units. The advantage is just so great if your unit can dish the pain out. I also fail to see how 25 skellies will hold out infinately longer then 25 ghouls. Maybe your ghoul units are wiped out so quickly is because they are so small, just 5 more ghouls then my bunker.
 
Mortus946736 said:
The faq for the brb says:

If a item is in both the brb and the Army Books, use the point cost listed in the armybook.

Im paraphrasing, but that is the gist of it.

Effect from the BrB, cost from the armybook..

In some cases more expensive, in some cases less.

AWESOMESAUCE! That just makes my skellies that much better :)

You and Mortus are playing a different game. I would never use Ghouls to hunt Hydras, they eat small ghoul units (30 and less) in one round. For hydras and such I use wraiths, Coach or summoned Spirit hosts

Agreed, wraiths and BC would be my first choice, but ghoulies are a good fallback and they are our only core that has a decent shot at taking one down. I know the beastmasters have a high In but I think the ghouls will strike before the Hydra (In2 I think) combined with poisoned attacks and possible re-rolls, care of a well timed vanhels :devil2:

Also, due to their inherent awesomeness, most DE players will normally include 2 hydras and I don't always have wraiths in my list and the BC needs to wait till it is ethereal and even then it can only handle one at a time xD

I also fail to see how 25 skellies will hold out infinately longer then 25 ghouls. Maybe your ghoul units are wiped out so quickly is because they are so small, just 5 more ghouls then my bunker

Skellies run with HW&S plus banner will always hold out longer than ghouls, ghouls will just take more with them when they die :vampire3:

In regards to the list I normally run, its mostly 2500pts, and it is comprised of something like this:

Combat lord 380+ pts
Konrad
WK BSB (mostly with Drakenhof)
Wk assassain

30 GG - GW's, Banner
40 Ghouls
both in horde

35 skellies - now with war banner xD (5x7)

Black Coach and wraiths/vargulfs on 1 flank

Couple of doggy units to gain some deployment advantage/create a refused flank/be used to sit in front and draw charges etc

GG sit in the middle with ghouls and skellies either side, characters spread around. Keep infantry central, outmanouver where possible with the help of vanhels and try to draw the enemy in to where I want them to be then hit them with a big flank attack.

However, in saying all of that, it doesn't always work and like I think Mortus was trying to get across, and I whole heartadly agree, you have to change it up and keep them guessing. This is a fairly tried and proven tactic for me but if I took it every time I would be getting massacred left, right and centre lol
 
See it from the DE players perspective: what unit would you like to engage with your hydra? If the opponent got skellies then they would be my first pick. If he didnt then I would engage ghouls. Why? because they will likely only score one wound before the Hydra gets to attack and breathe on them. If the ghouls are not even in Horde then they would have even smaller chance to get a wound.

So if you are engaging hydras with ghouls then you are doing something wrong as its the Ghouls that the opponent would rather engage in your army. See?

For the Coach vs Hydra you really dont need to be ethereal, its a nice boon but even if you are not then the Hydra would not deal anymore then 2 wounds to you if he is lucky. As you will have the greater charge range and probably vanhels then you would get to charge, thats +1 and then you only need to make 1 wound to draw if he was lucky and breathed to score 2 wounds on you.

And the only way for a DE player to have 2 hydras is if you are playing with no restrictions, that would only be in a compfree tournament and I dont go there as they arent even close to fun.
 
holla holla get dolla said:
"No. I said VERY few are different"

Actually you've said both, these arguements have gone around in circles for 7 pages and you've said many things, things which have some truth to them but are buried under hyperbole and stubborness.

The thing is that, yes, VC does have poor internal balancing and some units excel at a disproportionately large number of scenarios when compared to others. Grave guard, rare choices and characters are the prime offenders here - arguably ghouls too but I think their uses are somewhat exaggerated. If you had just stated this than I think most here would've agreed with you, but the thing is you went way too far in saying that everything asides from those aforementioned units are worthless. Black knights, blood knights, fell bats, skeletons, etc. may not be as good all purpose units as grave guard are, but there are areas in which they shine. I've mentioned those areas before so I won't repeat myself ;)

Another point of criticism I have to bring up is your stubborness. I've shown you the "math hammer" as you call it, and blood knights are undoubtedly the more efficient unit offensively compared to grave guard. You've refused to simply admit that and now we're on some ridiculous tangent and you're insisting that most people run their grave guards in horde formation. It's comical really, step back and see that :clown:

You're not going to convince anyone you're right when you present your ideas in a ludicrously exaggerated way, and then dismiss valid criticisms of those ideas. Keep an open mind, weigh what people say to you and don't be afraid to abandon former claims if you think you were wrong about them; just put your ideas out there and let people judge them for what they are ;)

Ok and one last thing I think I should reply to before I leave:

"noooooo, your so very wrong, again, how long have you been here?"

You may have posted more than me but I've lurked for quite some time, and anyways my time spent on this forum isn't really relevant since it only takes 10 minutes to check out the army builds in the army list section ;)

woah there smokey.

First off I never said Black knights, blood knights, and skeletons are worthless, if you actually read the forums as much as you claim to

which I find it hard to believe since you joined 2 days ago *cough* liar *cough*

you would see that I myself only run skeletons, no ghouls, That I am a firm believer in the Blood Knight death star and its abilities, and that I said Black knights are not what they used to be but they didnt take it so hard like some units like corpse carts. Fell bats I still believe there are better buys then them but thats besides the point.

You claim to know it all but your math hammer is FAR off, your percentages are FAR off, at least mine are ball park. what gets me aggravated is your laying out numbers like you've actually done the math, like you've actually existed in this forum long enough to know what the general consensus on the subject matter is.

Let me lay down the "Mathhammer" for you on Grave Guard vs. Blood Knights with helm of commandment vamp in the rear as most will agree it is apparent in most lists. lets assume we dont have drakkenhoff banner just to make it fair for the blood knights.

21x Grave Guard 348 pts
(I would never run them this low, most people dont, but for point comparisons lets assume they are deployed 7 wide)
Great weapons
FC
Banner of the barrows

4x Blood Knights 345 pts.
FC
Banner of blood keep


Defensive:

"Based on a 5 wide enemy unit, strength 3, toughness 3, WS 3 armor not really being a factor considering the strength of the attacks are already high, we will assume the blood knights charge, and i dont want to get into multiple rounds of combat."


Grave Guard
11 attacks hitting on 4's
11 x .5 = 5.5 misses
5.5 x .666666666666666666666667 = 3.6666666666666666666666667 missed wounds
1.8333333333333333333333 total wounds allocated
1.8333333333333333333333 x .3333333333333333333 = 1.22222222222222222222222833333 wounds suffered after saves

Total wounds suffered = ~1.2

Blood Knights

11 attacks hitting on 4's
11 x .5 = 5.5 misses
5.5 x .666666666666666666666667 = 3.6666666666666666666666667 missed wounds
1.8333333333333333333333 total wounds allocated
1.8333333333333333333333 x .833333333333333333333333 = .3055555555555555555558 wounds suffered after saves

Total wounds suffered = ~.3

still a possible wound done, this isnt factoring in luck, and your bad luck, the difference here is grave guard have the bodies to compensate for your opponents good luck and your bad luck.

Offensive:

"Based on a 5 wide enemy unit, strength 3, toughness 3, WS 3, 5+ armor, we will assume the blood knights charge, and i dont want to get into multiple rounds of combat."


Grave Guard

15 attacks hitting on 2+
15 x .16666666666666666666667 = 2.5 misses
12.5 hits wounding on 2+
12.5 x .16666666666666666666667 = 2.083333333333333333333333333375 missed wounds
10.416666666666666666666625 wounds allocated total
No armour saves = 10.416666666666666666666625 wounds

Total wounds = ~10.4 wounds

Blood Knights

13 attacks hitting on 3+
13 x .3333333333333 ect = 4.3333333333333333333329 misses
8.6666666666666666666671 hits wounding on 2+
8.6666666666666666666671 x .16666666666666666666667 = 1.444444444444444444447333333333341 missed wounds
10.11111111111111111111111111111111111573333334 wounds allocated total
No armour saves = 7.222222222222222219333333333766659

Wounds (Blood Knights) = ~7.2 wounds

edit: forgot the horses thanks Darius

Horses
4 attacks hitting on 4+ (remember steeds do not benefit from HoC)
4 x .5 = 2 misses
2 hits wounding on 3+
2 x .33333333333333 = .666666666666666 wounds missed
1.3 wounds before armor
5+ armor
1.3 x .8333333333333333333333333333
1.08333333333333333333333333333333 total wounds allocated

= ~1.1

Total Wounds (Blood Knights + Horses) = ~8.3

defensive wise shooting is a tottally different ball game, and honestly the 4+ ward isnt enough to cut down casualties significantly, its a small percentile that usually only comes into play with a single wound, and is dependent on another 50/50 dice roll.

soooooooooooooooooo

your theory that blood knights are more killy for their points is absurd, they are not, add another blood knight or 2 and your adding a whole new rank to the grave guard allowing them to effectively horde adding 7 more attacks, you will only be able to squeeze 2 more blood knights into hand to hand before having to resort to support attacks (6 attacks) which then your adding enough blood knights to actually make them a force to be reckoned with considering they will survive to see combat.

among the slightly increased damage output of grave guard for point to damage ratio they also have abilities the blood knights do not, number one being multiple ranks, the ability to break steadfast and add a good amount of static combat resolution, the ability to benefit fully from IoN rather then a 1 wound limitation per casting, the ability to house characters while giving them a sense of protection, and enough wounds to not detract attacks as the game goes on and models are lost, as with the blood knights for every blood knight you lose, you basically lose 3 grave guard attacks.

not to mention the grave guards points are alot harder to earn then a 4 wound unit of blood knights and the grave guard have killing blow magical attacks which is invaluable.

hope ive proved the actual math hammer here, and if you argue about the helm of commandment not being viable, then ok, the grave guard still come out on top due to the extra attacks hitting and wounding at the same level.


you know what really gives you away?...

the fact that you said a majority of people dont run their grave guard horde, and only 50% of lists include helm of commandment.
 
I dont think the hoff is a waste in a block of ghouls. I do it now and then. The T4 of ghouls is good, you give them a regen save of 4+ and they are a very formidable group. I then keep my GG HW&S to keep them more protected than a simple 5+ AS and let them keep KB. I find that to make for a very balanced attack.

Like i said about 50 posts ago, and probably sometime again around 25 posts ago, you need some very simple elements to win at Warhammer.

Anvil Unit

Hammer Unit

Caster Bunker

Fast moving harrasers


You build your army with all these components and kit out any variety of characters at your disposal to properly support them, and you are giving yourself a chance to win.

Your opponent is gong to likely do the same thing to you.

The key to thus winning or losing is in the mind of the general. If you outplay your opponent, you CAN and WILL win.

You can take a an optimized list into a game, play it poorly, or even play it well and get outplayed, or have horrid luck with the dice and still lose the game.

No list is a 100% guaranteed success. We all can agree on that. So why can't we all thus also agree that no list is a 100% guaranteed failure either?

Graveguard will not always provide the staying power, or the killing power. Sometimes its better to take a skeletons over a ghoul. Sometimes, the Black Coach looks like the most broken model to ever see the battlefield. Other times it might as well be the Barbie Dream Car cuz it gets tied up and just sits and looks pretty.

Units are only as good and as bad as their deployment, their movement, and the situation. There are a million situations and the truth changes drastically if you change the name of the army you are fighting. Unit X works well on Elves of all sorts, but is horrible against Dwarfs. We see it time and time again, so lets not miss seeing the forest because of all the trees.
 
Ghurt said:
See it from the DE players perspective: what unit would you like to engage with your hydra? If the opponent got skellies then they would be my first pick. If he didnt then I would engage ghouls. Why? because they will likely only score one wound before the Hydra gets to attack and breathe on them. If the ghouls are not even in Horde then they would have even smaller chance to get a wound.

So if you are engaging hydras with ghouls then you are doing something wrong as its the Ghouls that the opponent would rather engage in your army. See?

For the Coach vs Hydra you really dont need to be ethereal, its a nice boon but even if you are not then the Hydra would not deal anymore then 2 wounds to you if he is lucky. As you will have the greater charge range and probably vanhels then you would get to charge, thats +1 and then you only need to make 1 wound to draw if he was lucky and breathed to score 2 wounds on you.

And the only way for a DE player to have 2 hydras is if you are playing with no restrictions, that would only be in a compfree tournament and I dont go there as they arent even close to fun.

I think you and I are playing a different game lol but I can see where you are coming from :)

13 attacks hitting on 3+.....................

I believe your mathhammer to be sound but don't forget the horses ;) they're not bad considering they're ST4. As for the HoC Forge, we've had this discussion before and not all of us are content to have our kick ass lord out of combat, I do see the amazing benefits of the Helm and I may actually run it for the first time this weekend perhaps (it just doesn't fit my fluff usually)

You can take a an optimized list into a game, play it poorly, or even play it well and get outplayed, or have horrid luck with the dice and still lose the game.

No list is a 100% guaranteed success. We all can agree on that. So why can't we all thus also agree that no list is a 100% guaranteed failure either?

I am in complete agreeance (is that a word? lol) with this statement. Like it has been said many times before, at the end of the day, it all comes down to the dice :devil2:
 
Darius the Insane said:
13 attacks hitting on 3+.....................

I believe your mathhammer to be sound but don't forget the horses ;) they're not bad considering they're ST4. As for the HoC Forge, we've had this discussion before and not all of us are content to have our kick ass lord out of combat, I do see the amazing benefits of the Helm and I may actually run it for the first time this weekend perhaps (it just doesn't fit my fluff usually)

Ahh thanks for the heads up, all fixed. the outcome is still the same

Grave Guard > Blood Knights

in a Point-Use stand point.

Now!

things change as points go up, if you have 2 ranks of 6 blood knights you are actually throwing out more attacks then Grave Guard, improved mobility of course, and the ability to stay alive more reliably, you can break ranks, you can house characters and provide a look out sir, you will be alive long enough to be rejuvenated by blood drinker, and you have an extra static combat resolution of 1.

at the 10 unit strength of blood knights + characters I believe blood knights become a very good buy, their lack of restraint hurts them tho I feel.

4 blood knights? no they are simply to costly, they have to be babied by casters, and lack the wounds to survive a mishap, and free points to your opponent, and once they are gone your going to have to struggle to get those points back since likely you lost your only fighty unit that will actually do damage, we all know skeletons dont do jack, if your running ghouls you have a small chance i suppose.
 
@forge
Another problem with your example is that you have the grave guard hitting on 2's, where as it should be 3's (they'd need a 4 normally and the BoB gives +1).

Also you gave the blood knight unit the banner of blood keep, which is useless when it comes to damage output. Essentially you inflated their cost by 50% for no reason:thumbsdown:
 
holla holla get dolla said:
@forge
Another problem with your example is that you have the grave guard hitting on 2's, where as it should be 3's (they'd need a 4 normally and the BoB gives +1).

Also you gave the blood knight unit the banner of blood keep, which is useless when it comes to damage output. Essentially you inflated their cost by 50% for no reason:thumbsdown:

If you read the post HoC is a likely fielding option, and is ~90%+ likely to be included in a list,

even without helm of commandment the Grave Guard still come out on top.

Hmmmmm soooo your going to take a 4 man unit of blood knights with only a 2+ armour save to keep them up?

welllllll I could go back and do some more math on how likely it is you will loose 2 or more blood knights to shooting and magic before you get to combat reducing your attacks significantly, a problem Grave guard dont nessecarily have because they have the bodies to soak up wounds. But that would take to long and has to many factors, but ask the community how long a 4 wound unit will survive with only a 2+ armor save and no ward, i know against hand gunners you only get a 4+ save, cannons no save, hell storm rocket launcher 4+, organ gun 4+, hell blaster volley gun 4+, bolt throwers no armor, rock throwers 3+ or 4+, crossbows 3+ (or are they armor piercing too? in that case 4+), there are magic items in the game like the dark elf throwing stars or bow that will kill that unit in one go. Magic is a tottally different story, the amount of high strength magic missiles,and ones that ignore armor will be the downs of 4 blood knights.

how many games of 8th have you really played? I dont see anyone take small units of heavy calvary anymore for the fact they are expensive and there are many more things to deal with them, they cant be blocked by troops or forests as well and arnt as good in combat anymore.
 
@forge
If you're giving GG character support but not the blood knights, it's an unfair comparison.

As for their resilience to shooting, we've already established that GG are better there :) The fact is, you're pitting 220 points worth of blood knights against 350 points of grave guard in order to establish that the latter is better offensively. Take away the superfluous banner of blood keep, command models, and add an extra 2 or 3 BK's, it'll make a world of difference ;)
 
Actually they are more easy to kill then you say Forge.

Organ Gun and Hellblaster are armourpiercing. So their save would be 5+.
 
holla holla get dolla said:
@forge
If you're giving GG character support but not the blood knights, it's an unfair comparison.

As for their resilience to shooting, we've already established that GG are better there :) The fact is, you're pitting 220 points worth of blood knights against 350 points of grave guard in order to establish that the latter is better offensively. Take away the superfluous banner of blood keep, command models, and add an extra 2 or 3 BK's, it'll make a world of difference ;)

Actually character support is added to both of them, both units are thought to have HoC on them, it is a likely scenario because you will most likely see helm of commandment in a list, and if grave guard are in hand to hand your most likely going to put it on them, but like I said even without helm of commandment they still beat out the blood knights.

first off, you said 4 blood knights, your going to take a standard and blood keep banner if you actually want to make it to hand to hand with something, ok so remove a couple grave guard, same effect, the numbers remain the same. 1 less attack on your profile.

No.... your really not, the amount of blood knights that will make it to combat if you dont have the banner would be less then they are now with the banner, your number processing skills are working as if your in combat first turn, or as if your not going to be shot at or magic'ed to death, your creating an unrealistic scenario, im being REAL, in a REAL application of the game, and even then your getting 4.2 something grave guard for every blood knight, thats 4 attacks instead of 3, 4 wounds instead of 1, a consistent strength of 6 and killing blow.

YOU are not accepting the numbers, and thats YOUR problem.
 
Ok Forge, my friend, here is the deal:
Blood knights are fast, they have lots of attacks, their attacks are consolidated into few models and they count as vampires. Those are their benefits, use them as you will, I don't care about arguing this further.
 
holla holla get dolla said:
Ok Forge, my friend, here is the deal:
Blood knights are fast, they have lots of attacks, their attacks are consolidated into few models and they count as vampires. Those are their benefits, use them as you will, I don't care about arguing this further.

First point is valid, second and third are basically the same point, they are consolidated but their bigger base size detracts from that and if anything thats bad considering losing one is like losing 3 grave guard attacks, and they dont end up having more attacks until higher point values when you start adding 6 x ? which the rest of the extra attacks suffer from diminishing returns as you may only make 1 support attack from the second rank rather then the full 3, they have a possible 3 more attacks against a 5 wide unit when maxed out at 12 blood knights. I dont see your 4th point as much of a bonus, in fact kind of a downfall, among being vampire even tho they are cavalry too they only regain 1 wound from IoN compared to the grave guards d6, sure they can march on their own, but likely a vampire will be close enough to allow the grave guard to march.

im not saying blood knights arnt viable, but in small units, ultimately in small point values because you cant afford enough they are not viable.

you still never told us where your percentages based on community preference to items and formations such as grave guard horde and helm of commandment came from, i mean you said you've been on these forums for awhile right??
 
@Holla. First... let me welcome you to the club. There is punch and pie and a short movie to shown later. *Cheers*

What it really boils down to is that since Forge doesnt like cavalry and cant make them useful, it is probably just a playstyle issue. You and I probably have no problems getting them into combat unscathed. (i spent 100 posts explaining the same things to him, so i get it) but Forge may not be that good with cavalry units. Using those types of units takes a different mindset on how you deploy, how you move, where your terrain needs to go to help shield them. Those are things that perhaps we are better at doing and thus we are able to see a huge benefit to Black Knights or Blood Knights. Forge will likely respond saying that the people we play with must just suck to allow such things to happen... maybe - maybe not... I don't play at Forge's gameshop so I wont pretend to know the level of competition there. It could be the armies you play against the most, or the local metagame in general.

Regardless, for every good reason you or anyone else for that matter can come up with for why they are worth the points, Forge just isnt going to budge from his mindset.

I enjoy the flexibility that our army has. I mean we don't get any shooting, we have no fast cav anymore, so why take out the monsters, warbeasts, and cavalry also? Infantry is now the core of every army, so we are going to have some of them, but I just can't limit myself to only infantry... i dont care how good Graveguard are. If taking Blood Knights is a disadvantage... well it certainly one I have learned to overcome.

again, Holla, welcome to the club.
 
Gladius Rex said:
@Holla. First... let me welcome you to the club. There is punch and pie and a short movie to shown later. *Cheers*

What it really boils down to is that since Forge doesnt like cavalry and cant make them useful, it is probably just a playstyle issue. You and I probably have no problems getting them into combat unscathed. (i spent 100 posts explaining the same things to him, so i get it) but Forge may not be that good with cavalry units. Using those types of units takes a different mindset on how you deploy, how you move, where your terrain needs to go to help shield them. Those are things that perhaps we are better at doing and thus we are able to see a huge benefit to Black Knights or Blood Knights. Forge will likely respond saying that the people we play with must just suck to allow such things to happen... maybe - maybe not... I don't play at Forge's gameshop so I wont pretend to know the level of competition there. It could be the armies you play against the most, or the local metagame in general.

Regardless, for every good reason you or anyone else for that matter can come up with for why they are worth the points, Forge just isnt going to budge from his mindset.

I enjoy the flexibility that our army has. I mean we don't get any shooting, we have no fast cav anymore, so why take out the monsters, warbeasts, and cavalry also? Infantry is now the core of every army, so we are going to have some of them, but I just can't limit myself to only infantry... i dont care how good Grave guard are. If taking Blood Knights is a disadvantage... well it certainly one I have learned to overcome.

again, Holla, welcome to the club.

if you read through this thread, or anywhere in this forum, I have not completely dismissed Blood Knights and Black knights...... I said running them like you would in 7th (small) is digging yourself into hole from the get go, creating a unit that will survive till the end of the game that you are dumping a fair amount of points into should be your goal, a 4 wound unit is not one. I will repeat my self for the 100th billionth time, Blood Knights are GREAT at around 10 strong including the characters inside, Black Knights are the cheaper alternative to this, not as effective, and I actually feel like they are more of a waste of points then KoBK unless your using them as a character delivery system.

ive been trying to make a viable 2000 point list containing cavalry allll day and nothing comes close, 2500 points i could do it all day.
 
When 8th ed first came out, i lacked the models to make enough core to play at any game larger than 2K.

I played probably 10-15 games at 2k before i got enough core model to expand my core up to a 3K game.

In over half of those lists at 2k, about half if not more didnt include a single special unit.

No graveguard, no black knights, no spirit hosts.

I was still tinkering with ways to build lists in 8th ed and was trying to figure out how better at 2K to include special units. I even wrote a post about it on this forum.

25% core
25% rare
25% heroes
25% specials

even with these lists, I was still winning games.

I did everything from ghoul bumrushes to Blood Knight rolling deathstars. Then I started finding good ways to trim down my heroes and Lord to allow for special units. Unfortunately, it is much easier to squeeze in the cheaper special units. Unit of 3 Fel Bats, or 3 bases of Spirit Hosts. A set of 5 Black Knights. So I started trying them and had even more success. So by the time I got around to playing at even 2.5 K where I could slip in graveguard units with enough models to do their job, I had already found solid ways to untize alot of the other units. I had also found ways to play completely without graveguard and still win.

Most of those lists also do not include the Helm of Command. I know you don't like the new fear rules, but at lower points my Screaming Banner BSB actually did some good at creating the same effect while allowing my Lord to enter combat and make up some of the difference.

These are things that I am aware you just wont do. You are alot like my Warriors of Chaos friend who mathhammers out everything and looks at me like I am insane. Then i play him and I win and he scratches his head and wonders why the math didnt hold true.

I think the key Forge for ya is to make one of the lists you are toying with and just try it out. Odds are that it will take you a few attempts with that sort of list to find ways to make it work, but you may be a bit suprised.

I know that you cant point justify alot of things, but i cant cost justify the money i spent on the rest of these units to now deem them "unworthy" to ever see the gametable.
 
Gladius Rex said:
When 8th ed first came out, i lacked the models to make enough core to play at any game larger than 2K.

I played probably 10-15 games at 2k before i got enough core model to expand my core up to a 3K game.

In over half of those lists at 2k, about half if not more didnt include a single special unit.

No graveguard, no black knights, no spirit hosts.

I was still tinkering with ways to build lists in 8th ed and was trying to figure out how better at 2K to include special units. I even wrote a post about it on this forum.

25% core
25% rare
25% heroes
25% specials

even with these lists, I was still winning games.

I did everything from ghoul bumrushes to Blood Knight rolling deathstars. Then I started finding good ways to trim down my heroes and Lord to allow for special units. Unfortunately, it is much easier to squeeze in the cheaper special units. Unit of 3 Fel Bats, or 3 bases of Spirit Hosts. A set of 5 Black Knights. So I started trying them and had even more success. So by the time I got around to playing at even 2.5 K where I could slip in graveguard units with enough models to do their job, I had already found solid ways to untize alot of the other units. I had also found ways to play completely without graveguard and still win.

Most of those lists also do not include the Helm of Command. I know you don't like the new fear rules, but at lower points my Screaming Banner BSB actually did some good at creating the same effect while allowing my Lord to enter combat and make up some of the difference.

These are things that I am aware you just wont do. You are alot like my Warriors of Chaos friend who mathhammers out everything and looks at me like I am insane. Then i play him and I win and he scratches his head and wonders why the math didnt hold true.

I think the key Forge for ya is to make one of the lists you are toying with and just try it out. Odds are that it will take you a few attempts with that sort of list to find ways to make it work, but you may be a bit suprised.

I know that you cant point justify alot of things, but i cant cost justify the money i spent on the rest of these units to now deem them "unworthy" to ever see the gametable.

trust me ive ran it all with the pre copy of the 8th edition rulebook, small units of cavalry fail in comparison to infantry point to point wise, especially ours since it is so damn expensive. Larger numbers they are quite good! but with the new point allocation rules its much harder to do that at lower point values. math hammer works for me, my only losses are due to lists that relied on magic to much sending my key unit into something very dangerous only to roll low on my power dice pool and the silly hydra with killing blow eats my lord.

Math Hammer is what this game comes down to, the math cuts down on the random luck aspect of the game reducing your percentage of failure, if you have 2 players playing at the top tactical level, the person that did the math and has the optomized list will win. And frankly, if I played anything less then the most optimized lists or close to it I would surely lose, as I write a good deal of my opponents lists as well which are tip top.
 
@gladius rex
Ty for the welcome, and yes your gaming environment plays a large role in determining what is useful :) Generic lists for me, in my environment, are rather weak, since their strengths and weaknesses are visible from the onset of the battle. I find that the best way to make a list is to include solutions for as many possible problems as possible, and secondly to make those solutions as creative as possible. This philosophy allows me to respond to everything that's thrown at me, to some extent, and to catch my opponents off-guard while doing so ;)
 
I would love to play a game against you, it would be more a chess match than anything else, but as you read through the forums here, you will see that I hold a similar philosophy and agree with you 100%
 
I've just read through all this and it's quite a discussion,everyone of you has valid points and a lot of it does come down to who you play and the environment your in,I go to my local GW and there are some people I've played who are frankly rubbish but then there are others that are quite a challenge

I've being playing warhammer since 5th ed and the only army I've had is undead then vampire counts and I've won a LOT of my games over the years,my best friend is still to beat me using the unliving,now no offence forge but I am shite at maths,I just can't do it so mathhammer means nothing to me,it's tactics that have won me my games and thinking differently to my opponent,doing the unexpected,I'm not trying to insult you or the way you play,just maybe try not turning it into just numbers

And the whole bloodknights thing it's quite obvious that you use as said deployment and terrain to force your opponent into a position where he's vulnerable and you strike,comparing them to the same points of graveguard is just silly,they fulfill different roles,if you horde your graveguard (which I don't) there not flankers there part of your battleline they can handle themselves while your "useless" small bloodknights crash into a unit in combat with your skeles breaking them,you can't compare them with just numbers,it's a strategy game

Sorry that was quite a rant but it's taken me a while to read through all the posts :) lol
 
I agree with you as well Crovax. I play against people who have been playing since 4th ed. They have done tournaments and placed well (i think even won a few) and while i think Forge is right about mathhammer in 7th ed, where things were much more easy to rely on, right now things are a crap shoot.

you got very unreliable magic phases, even with MotBA, there is no guarantee you are going to have success

you have random charge ranges, so you can't deploy via math and know exactly what your range or your enemies range is going to be

you have alot more attacks and you cant negate attacks back via things like ASF, so now you cant just go all out offense anymore, you gotta be able to take a hit as well

you also cant rely on regeneration and ward saves to negate your crumbling or let static combat res win the day.

with the changes to these sorts of core rules, the game shifed, in my opinion, more away from mathhammer instead of into it. I think its why my Mathhammer number crunching Warriors of Chaos friend loses to me. He streamlines his lists based on the math and then you toss in the true chaos of the dice, and that plan can go awry pretty quickly.

In my most recent game with him, my block of 30 ghouls (escorted by a WK with the Hoff BSB) ran into his block of 50 Khorne Mauraders with greatweapons (str 5). By his calculations, he should have won that fight, but he didnt. My ghouls made mincemeat of his unit and after he lost a round of combat and frenzy, even the mathhammer started to look in my favor. He had planned on hitting my flank with a unit of chosen, but was dissappointed to learn my flank was protected by a big nasty Varghulf. No, the Varghulf didnt kill enough chosen to make back his points, but he did hold off that unit long enough for the Mauraders to break and for the ghouls to persue, which moved them out of the charge range of the chosen, who had defeated the pesky Varghulf.

Now does that mean the Varghulf was a waste because mathwise he couldnt beat the Chosen in a toe to toe showdown? Of course not, he turned the tide in a valiant death by himself not having a flank and protect the flank of my ghoul anvil unit.

My hammer unit of Graveguard ended up in an unfortunate spot, tied up with a LONG charge by his Warriors unit and an unsuspecting rampage by the Hellcannon. I had to deploy my Black Coach to rear charge the Hellcannon to get it out of my flank so my Graveguard could handle the threat of the Chaos Warriors (who were warded up with Tzneetch). Did the Black Coach kill the Hellcannon? no. But his rear charge swung the CR back to my favor by 1 instead of it being a 1 for my opponent who had the flank charge on me. Did it kill anything? No. Did it cause me to win this long drawn out battle? It sure did.

Once engaged in melee, our unbreakable status allows us the unmathable advantage of attrition. Even small bonuses in CR can swing the difference and with IoN.

So what about Blood Knights? Could they have done either of those jobs? Could they have held up against a set of Chosen? Hell yeah they could have. In fact those Chosen would be scared to death. I probably would have charged those chosen just to keep them out of my flank or at least kept my blood knights in position to charge the Chosen after they charged the ghouls. Either way, their presence would have had the same effect as the martyred Varghulf did. Could they have rear charged the Rampaging Hellcannon. yup but unlike the Coach, if it had been Blood Knights, that Hellcannon would have been a speed bump. Forget shifting the CR to my side, that is outright obliteration with S7 hits.

Did my opponent apply good strategy? Sure he did. He had a beefy anvil unit of Warded Warriors. He had a killy unit of GW mauraders and Chosen. He even had an artillery piece and a warshrine to aid his cause and give him some early round shooting. But through careful movement and deployment, i was able to break up his strategy, get the vital counter charges I needed to ensure that he didnt break up my gameplan and with a little luck, I won the game.

mathammer need not apply.
 
Gladius Rex said:
I agree with you as well Crovax. I play against people who have been playing since 4th ed. They have done tournaments and placed well (i think even won a few) and while i think Forge is right about mathhammer in 7th ed, where things were much more easy to rely on, right now things are a crap shoot.

you got very unreliable magic phases, even with MotBA, there is no guarantee you are going to have success

you have random charge ranges, so you can't deploy via math and know exactly what your range or your enemies range is going to be

you have alot more attacks and you cant negate attacks back via things like ASF, so now you cant just go all out offense anymore, you gotta be able to take a hit as well

you also cant rely on regeneration and ward saves to negate your crumbling or let static combat res win the day.

with the changes to these sorts of core rules, the game shifed, in my opinion, more away from mathhammer instead of into it. I think its why my Mathhammer number crunching Warriors of Chaos friend loses to me. He streamlines his lists based on the math and then you toss in the true chaos of the dice, and that plan can go awry pretty quickly.

In my most recent game with him, my block of 30 ghouls (escorted by a WK with the Hoff BSB) ran into his block of 50 Khorne Mauraders with greatweapons (str 5). By his calculations, he should have won that fight, but he didnt. My ghouls made mincemeat of his unit and after he lost a round of combat and frenzy, even the mathhammer started to look in my favor. He had planned on hitting my flank with a unit of chosen, but was dissappointed to learn my flank was protected by a big nasty Varghulf. No, the Varghulf didnt kill enough chosen to make back his points, but he did hold off that unit long enough for the Mauraders to break and for the ghouls to persue, which moved them out of the charge range of the chosen, who had defeated the pesky Varghulf.

Now does that mean the Varghulf was a waste because mathwise he couldnt beat the Chosen in a toe to toe showdown? Of course not, he turned the tide in a valiant death by himself not having a flank and protect the flank of my ghoul anvil unit.

My hammer unit of Graveguard ended up in an unfortunate spot, tied up with a LONG charge by his Warriors unit and an unsuspecting rampage by the Hellcannon. I had to deploy my Black Coach to rear charge the Hellcannon to get it out of my flank so my Graveguard could handle the threat of the Chaos Warriors (who were warded up with Tzneetch). Did the Black Coach kill the Hellcannon? no. But his rear charge swung the CR back to my favor by 1 instead of it being a 1 for my opponent who had the flank charge on me. Did it kill anything? No. Did it cause me to win this long drawn out battle? It sure did.

Once engaged in melee, our unbreakable status allows us the unmathable advantage of attrition. Even small bonuses in CR can swing the difference and with IoN.

So what about Blood Knights? Could they have done either of those jobs? Could they have held up against a set of Chosen? Hell yeah they could have. In fact those Chosen would be scared to death. I probably would have charged those chosen just to keep them out of my flank or at least kept my blood knights in position to charge the Chosen after they charged the ghouls. Either way, their presence would have had the same effect as the martyred Varghulf did. Could they have rear charged the Rampaging Hellcannon. yup but unlike the Coach, if it had been Blood Knights, that Hellcannon would have been a speed bump. Forget shifting the CR to my side, that is outright obliteration with S7 hits.

Did my opponent apply good strategy? Sure he did. He had a beefy anvil unit of Warded Warriors. He had a killy unit of GW mauraders and Chosen. He even had an artillery piece and a warshrine to aid his cause and give him some early round shooting. But through careful movement and deployment, i was able to break up his strategy, get the vital counter charges I needed to ensure that he didnt break up my gameplan and with a little luck, I won the game.

mathammer need not apply.

You have a weird interpretation of mathhammer, it has nothing to do with charge ranges (at least in 7th) it does kind of now but its percentages.

Actually...... the ghouls are more likely to win that fight, id do the math for you if it wasnt horribly obvious, the regen banner sways the fight.

what makes mathhammer different in 7th then it is in 8th?

7th edition was guesshammer
8th edition is luckhammer

combat and shooting remains basically the same so mathhammer is exactly the same.

Chosen even being attacked on the flank by Blood Knights should beat up a blood knight unit, their initiative is higher, they likely have halberds, meaning your 2+ armor is now a 4+ hitting on 3+ with 2 attacks a piece wounding on 3's if they are khorne its even worse, most likely tzeetch tho.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu