Najo might be crazy!

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Does Najo have the right kind 'o crazy?

  • Yes! Have at it! Build Najo-hammer and let's see what you can do mate! Your crazy is my kinda crazy!

    Votes: 14 53.8%
  • Most likely. Najo-hammer may be the crazy we need, but I'm not 100% yet. I'd give ya a fair go at it

    Votes: 2 7.7%
  • Najo-hammer? Serious? Don't you like Age of Sigmar? Call me skeptic...you got to prove it

    Votes: 6 23.1%
  • Even Najo-hammer can't soothe my soul .. with Warhammer gone...I am only blackened and dead inside

    Votes: 4 15.4%

  • Total voters
    26
  • Poll votes is visible for users with special permission.
It's a real shame. As you all say, without official support anybody will struggle with gaining universal consensus, although I'm sure the only legal hurdle would be charging money for the new material.

I reckon as long as you can get the seal of approval from Carpe Noctem, or even your local store or gaming group, it's got to be worth it. And when it's out there, you'll then be able to gain the approval of a larger audience. Who knows, maybe in a year or two we'll all be talking about Najohammer rather than the existing options that, despite previous success, don't seem to be gaining purchase just yet.
 
Take a look at pathfinder and dungeons and dragons. If a fan-made game is good enough that it gets the vast majority of the players to agree it is far superior to warhammer 8th then it could turn into the next pathfinder scenario. Currently there aren't any games out there that are 1. A really good game and 2. are a lot like warhammer fantasy. I'm a big fan of KoW but it's just not a lot like WHFB.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet and Tawg
Take a look at pathfinder and dungeons and dragons. If a fan-made game is good enough that it gets the vast majority of the players to agree it is far superior to warhammer 8th then it could turn into the next pathfinder scenario. Currently there aren't any games out there that are 1. A really good game and 2. are a lot like warhammer fantasy. I'm a big fan of KoW but it's just not a lot like WHFB.

This is how I view the situation. It's something where the domain is open enough (Fantasy in general, and dice are not copy righted). So an upstart could potentially make a version of the game they view as superior to replace the void filled by GW's bailing on it. The problem is that it had problems as a game, and much of that would still exist for the new company, and releasing rules with no accompanying models would potentially be an issue as then GW's claim that they are simply making a game based on their IP would be stronger. So it would take industry knowhow and connections to truly get something like this off the ground.

It's also quite a bit different because there is no open game license granted by GW to the basic mechanics of the game, so there would have to be dramatic changes so that it is not exactly as WHFB was or again, they would be stepping on toes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet
I don't think it'd be commercially viable because of the IP issue, no sensible companybwould go near a fight with GW.

My ideal endgame scenario would be GW seeing there's a market for 9th for whatever reason, and printing the most popular mod as 9th Edition; make it a £45 book with every army inside and offer parallel online stats for new units as they're released. Minimum effort to proofread, put the royal seal on it and start cashing in!
 
I don't think it'd be commercially viable because of the IP issue, no sensible companybwould go near a fight with GW.

My ideal endgame scenario would be GW seeing there's a market for 9th for whatever reason, and printing the most popular mod as 9th Edition; make it a £45 book with every army inside and offer parallel online stats for new units as they're released. Minimum effort to proofread, put the royal seal on it and start cashing in!

But then players would decry GW for stealing from the community. Even though it's as many people have stated, that many players would be united much more easily and with no struggles if it was simply extended from GW. Where as any fan-based tweak on the game, no matter depth pulled form various editions, even if it was truly a magnificent meld of everything people loved from each iteration of the game.. it simply will be a suggestion, and players will just as easily ignore it for a different version made by another fan.

The whole GW borrowing the idea and "coming to their senses" to market the alternative and more depth version of Warhammer, even if it came from a community, could potentially be handled delicately enough to not draw ire, but it is likely it would still have people up in arms against them. Or maybe I'm wrong, and players really only want their points values back and their "organized" play to guide their army construction, and correcting those sorts of issues would leave even nay-sayers with an odd sense of forgetfulness over the whole mess, glad to have their game back. But I think it's more likely they'd just get burned.
 
I guess so. Ho hum, at least we've got Warhammer! I know I won't be able to bring any homebrew rules to my games anyway, my mates don't even want to play allies! So without End Times I'm still rocking Vampire Counts, still no archers or catapults and my carrion are counts-as Fell Bats... Wargaming's a cruel mistress.
 
I think the problem is, without the 'official' moniker, no one will ever be convinced that someone else's ideas are better than their own ideas. For instance, I might think the 50% Lords and Heroes limit is stupid, while someone else loves it.

Without an independent arbitrator to set out the way to play, then every game of 8th edition has a new phase called the haggling phase, which takes place prior to list building. Do you want to play with my house rules, or yours? Should we use End Time stuff, or not?

This is why I gave up on modding 8th edition. Every group, and even different players within groups are going to have different ways they want to play the game, which makes organising games and working on lists between games extremely difficult.

For instance, I think laser guided cannonballs are stupid. If I were to re-write 8th I'd make them work exactly the same as bolt throwers. But the Dwarf player in my group might strongly oppose such an idea. So each game between us becomes a sort of business deal where I get upset if his laser guided cannonballs ping my Vampire Lord on Zombie Dragon on turn one, but he gets upset if his nerfed bolt throwers do nothing at all. Further, it makes pick-up games nearly impossible. Each player would need to truck nearly their entire collection to each games night, then spend time building a list before the game based on the agreed house rules they've decided to use for that game. As opposed to just working out a 2250 list and playing against whoever shows up.

I mean, I'm not saying don't bother. If you want to have a crack at it then far be it from me say it's a waste of time. I just don't think the end result will be a cohesive, rebuilt version of 8th edition.
My thoughts on all the variety and opinions on what is best (which is why I don't want to build by committee, though I am very open to input) is that there is common sense changes that can be agreed on by veteran players. Laser-cannons, low/no risk 6-dicing spells, bringing back normal terrain and toning down mysterious terrain, curbing the nuke spells, balancing the lores... these things are all easy to agree on. Of course how to do it is the tricky part, but I think moving towards streamlining while keeping true to Warhammer's feel is one key to doing it right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet
Excellent! I'm a Wallace myself, father was from Belfast, I reckon we headed west during the Plantation, then he came to London during the 60s looking for work.
 
My thoughts on all the variety and opinions on what is best (which is why I don't want to build by committee, though I am very open to input) is that there is common sense changes that can be agreed on by veteran players. Laser-cannons, low/no risk 6-dicing spells, bringing back normal terrain and toning down mysterious terrain, curbing the nuke spells, balancing the lores... these things are all easy to agree on. Of course how to do it is the tricky part, but I think moving towards streamlining while keeping true to Warhammer's feel is one key to doing it right.

My suggestion would be to go back to 6th and Ravening horde and then try and implement the good concepts from 8th properly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: najo
My suggestion would be to go back to 6th and Ravening horde and then try and implement the good concepts from 8th properly.
I am doing that to some extent. I agree that 6th is when the game was most balanced and streamlined and 8th has good evolution to key mechanics.

If there is a change that needs to occur that lays outside both 6th and 8th that is a better solution, I will implement it though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: logan054
Problem with 8th is far to many units have special unit on top of race specific rules. I think I covered my thoughts on this in your wishlist topic I noticed after making my post.
 
I'm sure a lot of the units' special rules could be covered with a potentially longer list of generic special rules, eg Wight Blades have Killing Blow?
 
And what 'generic rule' would you make to convey the hexwraith's signature ability to move through enemy units slicing as they went? Or would you remove the rule that most defined them, the rule that made them actually feel like hexwraiths on the table?

IMO, neither army rules nor special rules are a bad thing. They make the game interesting, and make the units feel interesting and unique in the way that 'generic rule that a dozen units in the game have' or 'plus one to stat X, minus one to stat Y' utterly fails to do.
 
Ethereal. The unique thing about Hexwraiths is their movement, I think other units (I can only think of Spirit Host) wouldn't have the move to pass clear through a unit to take advantage of this rule?

It's only a thought, but they really seemed to nail this with Warmachine and it made the game very accessible for me.
 
I'm sure a lot of the units' special rules could be covered with a potentially longer list of generic special rules, eg Wight Blades have Killing Blow?

I think it would be worth taking a look at ravening hordes for ideas. Units certainly had special rules, it just wasn't to the same volume as now. grave guard had D3 wounds (which was changed to killing blow). Undead had the undead rule. You didn't have bloodletters with daemon, then khorne rules and then all these rules tacted on. They had good stats.

Chaos warriors defining rule was marks of chaos. It wasn't some silly table. Then again ghouls also didn't have the undead rules.

I think now many units have rules for the sake of having rules and/or they could think of a better way to balance them.
 
They have gone to town on special rules haven't they! What's Dire Wolves got, 4 sets of special rules? And that's a core unit.

To be honest I don't mind the number of special rules, they're each minor game modifiers that add those characterful tweaks and if they're simple and generic, ie 3 or 4 lines in the core rulebook each, you can tailor a unit to perfectly represent your vision for them. Some of the most flexible like Regeneration (n) and Impact Hits (n) with their variable nature and simple mechanics could lead the way in this?

Of course, if you prefer special rules to be special this might not be for you... I certainly prefer how Ghouls were handled in the old Undead army book, being Undead meant something back then!
 
And what 'generic rule' would you make to convey the hexwraith's signature ability to move through enemy units slicing as they went? Or would you remove the rule that most defined them, the rule that made them actually feel like hexwraiths on the table?

IMO, neither army rules nor special rules are a bad thing. They make the game interesting, and make the units feel interesting and unique in the way that 'generic rule that a dozen units in the game have' or 'plus one to stat X, minus one to stat Y' utterly fails to do.

I'm on the opposite side of the spectrum here! I think special rules should be used extremely sparingly. For me, 'interesting and unique' comes from the modelling and the background for your units. At the end of the day, no matter how many minor stat differences and special rules differences there are between a bunch of heavy cavalry units, they're all essentially the same. There's just no NEED for all that granularity. They all act in the same manner, should be treated in the same manner, and often will achieve the same results on the tabletop. In effect, they could all have the same stats and the game would lose nothing.

You can add a few minor tweaks to differentiate them from one another, but GW really tried to redesign the wheel every time they re-wrote an army book, with special rules and exceptions to core rules sprinkled liberally all over everything. We have a prime example in the Terrorgheist. An attack made in the shooting phase, that wasn't technically a shooting attack, which ignored all the normal rules for other attacks made in the shooting phase, and worked completely differently to other types of attacks.

The old Tbat would have lose none of it's flavour or uniqueness by giving it an 8" shooting attack. Say, 6 shots at S8, and give the Tbat BS4 and Quick to Fire. It didn't need all that special rules stuff to make it different.
 
This is a perennial problem: too little detail and although the troop types operate correctly with maybe some scope to represent the varying quality of troops, in the end it can feel very 'red team vs blue team', which I understand to be the main gripe with Kings Of War; too much detail and if you're like me you'll find a 3000pt battle takes 6 hours! Fun 6 hours though...

I'm definitely a granular man when it comes to WHFB, although I can appreciate the other side of the argument I can play almost any other game for speed and simplicity; Warhammer's my immersive, clunky, time-consuming game and that's why I like it.

I do like what you have to say about Terrorgheists though, exceptions only serve to confuse the whole system, but I really do like that it's Leadership based.
 
Every time I read about people discussing what they like and dislike about the rules I feel like 6th ed comes up. And I cannot for the life of me find a damn pdf! I have heard people mention it too many times not to be curious. I've never played it as you might realize.

While the terrorgheist example above works, I think there are a lot of rules that really benefit from being fleshed out as special rules. I do agree with simplicity being a good thing though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dragonet
@GDD basically I think people liked the rules for 7th and the ravening horde rules for 6th. For me I think the HoC book as what kept me playing. People I feel like how 8th tried to make infantry more useful something that's s combination of the two would work well
 
This is a perennial problem: too little detail and although the troop types operate correctly with maybe some scope to represent the varying quality of troops, in the end it can feel very 'red team vs blue team'

I think playing some different historical games gave me some perspective on the matter, since those games are almost literally red vs blue. They're all men in some kind of armour with some kind of weapon. There's not a lot of difference between Athenian hoplites and Spartan hoplites for instance, and precious little difference between Gallic warriors and German warriors or Dacians or what-have-you. So you quickly learn to appreciate the difference between unit TYPES, rather than individual units, and special rules are used very sparingly to highlight troops with abilities or equipment that was really different from their peers (like cataphract armour or naked fanatics).
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu