New VC - can't heal characters?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Von said:
"Unless specifically stated otherwise, spells and magic items that restore lost Wounds cannot heal characters or their mounts" ('Resurrecting Fallen Warriors', p26).

"Wounds gained are distributed as described in Resurrecting Fallen Warriors" ('Invocation of Nehek', p. 60, col. 1). No specific statement = no healing characters with Invocation.

"If the target consists of a single model, such as a lone character or a Corpse Cart..."

That wording would make lone characters viable targets IMO, but not the ones that have joined units, as you quoted. The sentence you took out refers to characters that have joined units. The point is reinforced in the final sentence: "If a character has joined a unit, only the unit will recover lost wounds."
 
Von said:
"... the Wizard (or another friendly model within 12") instantly recovers a single Wound lost earlier in the battle" ('The Curse of Undeath', p. 60, header). This is not a specific statement that 'Resurrecting Fallen Warriors' does not apply. However, as the Wizard will always be a character, this rule cannot function unless 'Resurrecting Fallen Warriors' does not apply to it.

True, however, there is no reference in the lore attribute to restore wounds "as per 'Resurrecting Fallen Warriors'(hereafter referred to in this topic as RFW by me)", unlike IoN. Every other ability that raises (Kemmlers Chaos Tomb Blade for example) references the RFW rule for allocating wounds back to units, As the rule is not referenced by The Curse of Undeath, and its initial premise is healing a character (the wizard casting the spell) I do not see it as unreasonable to believe the omission is deliberate, and that the lore attribute does exactly as it says on tin, heal the wizard or another friendly model within 12".

That said I'll be running this by my local gaming group/s over the next while (before picking any match lineups so opinions are unbiased lol) and, if the situation ever arose that this was a problem in game, I wouldn't argue the point. I can see the merit of the opposing principle, and wouldn't want to ruin a game based on RAW/RAI and interpretation.

PS - I'm very impressed with the level of maturity with which people are able to debate (note the word debate, not argue) this topic.
 
Yea well, they better FAQ the resurrecting blood knights and Hexwraiths part anyway. As it is now, you can resurrect up to 1+WL of them both...

"infantry regains d6+caster level wounds, other troop types gain 1+caster level wounds, however, models with the vampiric , ethereal, or large target special rules can never regain more than 1 wound per successful casting."

The bolded part states models. But we are targeting a unit of models in the case of Hexwraiths and blood knights. Each model in these units only got 1 wound, so even if you raised 5 in one cast, you would only put one wound on each model..

And to make it even worse, it works differently on a unit of vargheist, depending on how many wounds it has lost. If it has lost 1 model and 1 wound on the next one. It would bring back one wound on the vargheist who already lost a wound, then because all the models are at full wounds capacity it will go on to bring back the lost model with just one wound.

But if you lost 1 model, and one model has taken 2 wounds, it would just heal 1 wound on the model that has taken 2 wounds...

Really strange...


When I play I will heal my characters with the lore attribute, but I will not heal my blood knights, hexwrights or vargheists any more than 1 wound/cast. I will however start doing so if my opponent forbids me to heal my characters with the lore attribute. Because if he starts to take the rules to court, I will be damned if I don't ^^
 
Well people are saying that we cant heal characters as resurrecting fallen warriors states that characters or mounts cannot be healed by spells unless stated otherwise.
Lore attributes are considered spells by GW.
However our lore attribute lets us heal the wizard, who is a character => it does state that we can heal characters => we can heal characters within range.
 
@Texhnology: I was all ready to say you'd misinterpreted the rules, when I double checked and found that technically you're right.

I'm certain they intended to use the word unit rather than model (and that's how I'll play it) but it looks like another GW rules glitch has got past the playtesters (no seriously, it was play tested by a whole six people! It says so in the book credits).
 
Originally Posted by Warriors of Chaos FAQ 1.4
Q: Can a model with the Third Eye of Tzeentch cast any spells
from the Lore of Life as the lore attribute allows him to recover
Wounds lost earlier in the battle? (p111)
A: Yes, apart from Regrowth. The lore attribute’s effect is not
part of the spell itself.

Doesn't this say that the lore attribute is not part of a spell?
 
Pietr Von Carstein said:
Well a lad on warsseer said that it said the opposite of that in the tomb kings and warriors faq. The faq section on gw is down so I cant check.
Still the point about it stating that I can heal characters stands.

I can se the section, here is the adress
http://www.games-workshop.com/gws/content/article.jsp?categoryld=1000018&pIndex=1&aId=3000006&multiPageMode=true&start=2

Anyway, I can not find any thing in the FAQ that says. "lore attribute is a spell"
 
OK... my €0.02:

IoN: - Can heal regular units as per spell description and RFW rules.
- Heals one Wound on Vampire/Incorporeal/Large unit (I'm with Dan_Lee on this being a mistype), not one Wound/Model in case of e.g. Vargheists.
- Can not heal Wounds on Characters/Mounts, either in units or on their own, as per the RFW rules. (So Necromancers on CC kinda suck?)

Curse of Undeath: - Can restore a Wound to caster or any one multi-wound model in 12" (character, monster, chariot, or one guy in a unit of multi-wound models), since not technically a spell, and in any case not refering to the RFW rulings. In any case, the caster being (obviously) a CM, RFW seems inherently circumvented by the Lore Attribute.
 
Dreadgrass said:
True, however, there is no reference in the lore attribute to restore wounds "as per 'Resurrecting Fallen Warriors'(hereafter referred to in this topic as RFW by me)", unlike IoN. Every other ability that raises (Kemmlers Chaos Tomb Blade for example) references the RFW rule for allocating wounds back to units, As the rule is not referenced by The Curse of Undeath, and its initial premise is healing a character (the wizard casting the spell) I do not see it as unreasonable to believe the omission is deliberate, and that the lore attribute does exactly as it says on tin, heal the wizard or another friendly model within 12".

Neither do I. However, the operative word in RFW is 'specifically' and the Curse wording does not contain a specific exception.

Understand that I agree with you; however, gits are everywhere, and my primary goal in gaming life remains my own peace of mind. Hence why I'm going with what's written, rather than what's meant, no matter how obvious it is (and it is pretty obvious), 'cause it only takes someone who's as pedantic as me but not as nice to completely ruin a plan, a game and a day.

@ Raizi - I'd be wary about assuming a connection between discrete sentences. I want to agree with you but there's none of the punctuation that makes the meaning you're looking for explicit. See above paragraph - can't be bothered typing it out again.
 
texhnology said:
The VC lore attribute can only heal multi wound things, it can never ever resurect new things. That's totaly different from the Tomb kings lore attribute.
And then the VC lore attribute does not have anything to do with "resurecting the fallen" since it NEVER EVER resurects anything, it CAN NOT!

This has been my personal interpretation as well.
 
I suspect the RFW phrase is meant to govern allocation of wounds in a unit (although I agree that a RAW reading doesn't say this). As such, IoN would work on lone characters, but wounds gained by (say) a zombie bunker can't be allocated to a character within them. I would say that a RAW interpretation means that IoN can never work on characters, ever. Just because there's a reference to giving single wounds back to characters doesn't actually constitute an exception to the rule.

On the other hand, I would read the Curse of Undeath as being a special case for the wizard ONLY. That is, if you want to heal something else, the RFW rule still applies (it's an army rule, and doesn't need to be specifically invoked in a spell description to apply).

Rather than a playtesting bungle, I'd say this is a proof-reading bungle. It seems like the final result is a combination of two (or more!) different sets of rules regarding raising stuff that have been combined, and not adequately revised in terms of language. I suspect we're reading RFW from one ruleset, IoN from another, and CoU from yet another.
 
Re: agreeing and stuff, I should add that in the case of CoU, I'm genuinely unsure of what they intend with this. The "heal any model including characters" interpretation seems perfectly reasonable, but so does the alternative. Unlike IoN, where somebody arguing that it may absolutely never affect characters, despite the comment about characters, should be told to sit and swivel on the Nemesis Force Weapon they rode in on.
 
adsvampire said:
Zombieboy said:
A character on it's own is considered a unit so IoN could heal them in that instance. This is reinforced by the second sentence in the same box "If the target consists of a single model, such as a lone character or corpse cart, then it can never exceed it's starting wound value."

The rules specifically state that characters and their mounts cannot be healed unless stated otherwise.

Right, and besides what Zombieboy wrote, IoN 'specifically' states that Large Targets, ethereal or models with the vampiric rule can never gain more than one wound per successful casting. The seems to indicate the vampire or his large mount can regain one wound. This does however, seem to leave necromancers out in the cold.
 
Yorga said:
Right, and besides what Zombieboy wrote, IoN 'specifically' states that Large Targets, ethereal or models with the vampiric rule can never gain more than one wound per successful casting. The seems to indicate the vampire or his large mount can regain one wound. This does however, seem to leave necromancers out in the cold.

By the way, RAW bloodknights gain 1+wizard level of wounds seeing as it says that models with the vampire rule can only gain 1 wound. Each blood knight is only gaining one wound.
Its obviously not intended to work like that though, but some git might give it a go.
 
Zombieboy and others have it right.

Lone characters (those not in units) can be healed ("resurrecting fallen warriors" paragraph 1, sentence 2).

Characters in units cannot be healed by a spell or affect which targets the unit ("resurrecting fallen warriors" paragraph 3). So the spell Invocation will never heal a character that is inside a unit.

The Lore Attribute targets a Model within range, not a Unit, so a character within a unit can receive the benefit of the Lore Attribute.
 
Von said:
@ Raizi - I'd be wary about assuming a connection between discrete sentences. I want to agree with you but there's none of the punctuation that makes the meaning you're looking for explicit. See above paragraph - can't be bothered typing it out again.

I read the RFW wording again a few more times and I am beginning to see your point here. The thing that got me distracted was the mention of characters as 'targets' in the very beginning. This I interpreted (wrongly) to apply to IoN when it was just describing resurrecting powers and effects in general.

I will too refrain from using IoN to heal my characters and use the Lore Attribute for that instead. They still work very well together and the more I think about it, it will probably be for the better that way. Healing the units around you with a pulse and possibly restoring 2 wounds to a single character with a single casting is perhaps a tad overpowered. :)

@ Von - I'm sorry if I hit a nerve with my ranting. I personally like to play my games to the fullest but I never want to gain or benefit from a misinterpretation of rules nor actively pursue one.

Edit: hopefully we'll get that FAQ soon to clear things out.
 
Pietr Von Carstein said:
Yorga said:
Right, and besides what Zombieboy wrote, IoN 'specifically' states that Large Targets, ethereal or models with the vampiric rule can never gain more than one wound per successful casting. The seems to indicate the vampire or his large mount can regain one wound. This does however, seem to leave necromancers out in the cold.

By the way, RAW bloodknights gain 1+wizard level of wounds seeing as it says that models with the vampire rule can only gain 1 wound. Each blood knight is only gaining one wound.
Its obviously not intended to work like that though, but some git might give it a go.

Maybe it IS intended that way with Blood Knights.o_o Why allow Black Knights the benefit and not them? They cost twice as much. IoN cannot be spammed like days of yore. Most of our opponents will chose to dispel that one spell as the rest of our spells are so-so. I think the sentence to limit creatures that are large, vampiric or ethereal to one wound is to cover multi-wound models such as vargheist and characters. Seems to be the intent.
 
Mach_5 said:
Zombieboy and others have it right.

Lone characters (those not in units) can be healed ("resurrecting fallen warriors" paragraph 1, sentence 2).

Characters in units cannot be healed by a spell or affect which targets the unit ("resurrecting fallen warriors" paragraph 3). So the spell Invocation will never heal a character that is inside a unit.

The Lore Attribute targets a Model within range, not a Unit, so a character within a unit can receive the benefit of the Lore Attribute.

I love your succinct summary Mach. The only problem (guess I am playing devil's advocate here) is that lone necromancers (they are not infantry, they are characters) would get the casting Wizard's level plus one wound back. I guess it only seems odd if the lone wizard is a master necromancer.
 
Actually, a necromancer on foot is classed as Infantry (see the Summary at the back of the VC book). A lone necro on foot would get 1+casters level healed, though he couldn't go above his starting wounds.
 
Not sure why you'd have your Master Necromancer running around on foot all by his lonesome of course... :thumbsup: :grave:
 
Lone vamp is in range of Necro casting IoN, IoN hits him.

The wording of IoN references to RFW to determine if he can be healed and how much by. It says he can be healed to his starting wounds value, but not if he's in a unit. However he can't be healed at all by the spell unless the spell says other wise, so RFW references back to the original spell/item, which references to the RWF rules which references the spell....

Necro: OH SH1TE!!! IoN divides by zero destroying the WHF dimension, Chaos wins. :devil2:
 
Yorga said:
Pietr Von Carstein said:
Yorga said:
Right, and besides what Zombieboy wrote, IoN 'specifically' states that Large Targets, ethereal or models with the vampiric rule can never gain more than one wound per successful casting. The seems to indicate the vampire or his large mount can regain one wound. This does however, seem to leave necromancers out in the cold.

By the way, RAW bloodknights gain 1+wizard level of wounds seeing as it says that models with the vampire rule can only gain 1 wound. Each blood knight is only gaining one wound.
Its obviously not intended to work like that though, but some git might give it a go.

Maybe it IS intended that way with Blood Knights.o_o Why allow Black Knights the benefit and not them? They cost twice as much. IoN cannot be spammed like days of yore. Most of our opponents will chose to dispel that one spell as the rest of our spells are so-so. I think the sentence to limit creatures that are large, vampiric or ethereal to one wound is to cover multi-wound models such as vargheist and characters. Seems to be the intent.

The unit is Vampiric, you are targeting it. I think BKs only get one.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu