New VC - can't heal characters?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Honestly with the spells it's everyone else adapting to the new book, either it's "VDM doesn't let you move and ASF/reroll to hit."(they think it's the old spell just with a bubble upgrade) or it's "There's no way you can have ASF, Rerolls to hit, to wound, and heal half your units with just 2 spells! Either you're cheating or there's a rule/errata/something you read wrong."
 
Pyre said:
The only loophole I see is the lone necromancer. Technically he does indeed regain 1d6+level in wounds from IoN, even one cast by himself if he's out alone.

Not so much a loop hole. A wounded lone necromancer is only going to need one wound healed. He has 2 wounds to begin with. If by chance it is a wounded Necro Lord on his own then the most you are talking about is 2 wounds. So how much of a loop hole is it?
 
I`m sorry if this comes out wrong. but OMG people here are really really bad at reading when it comes to RFW: "Unless specifically stated otherwise, spells and magic items that restore lost wounds cannot heal characters or there mounts" that is clear enough. But when you read through the posts here, then am I to understand that just because it says in IoN that you can heal models with the "vamp" rule, then sudtently this is another word for "character"? I`m sorry, but that is really really lame (to say the least) and you will not find a single turnamant organizer that will ever take your side on this.

On a last not, the Lore Atribute says "the wizard, or another model within 12"" Again, the word "model" is not the same as the word "character". Yes the FaQ will most likely change this, BUT again it might not, so saying RAI is bla bla bla... is just bull, unless you are a GW Employee...
 
Fallen Pony said:
I`m sorry if this comes out wrong. but OMG people here are really really bad at reading when it comes to RFW: "Unless specifically stated otherwise, spells and magic items that restore lost wounds cannot heal characters or there mounts" that is clear enough. But when you read through the posts here, then am I to understand that just because it says in IoN that you can heal models with the "vamp" rule, then sudtently this is another word for "character"? I`m sorry, but that is really really lame (to say the least) and you will not find a single turnamant organizer that will ever take your side on this.

On a last not, the Lore Atribute says "the wizard, or another model within 12"" Again, the word "model" is not the same as the word "character". Yes the FaQ will most likely change this, BUT again it might not, so saying RAI is bla bla bla... is just bull, unless you are a GW Employee...

Tell me on the doll where Mr. Von Carstein touched you.
...

Cool your jets dude.
 
Wow a pretty big confusion over this, when I don't think there really needs to be:

ION "as described in Resurrected Fallen Warriors" therefore no character healing.

For the lore attribute yes you can here is why:

P26, Resurrecting Fallen Warriors, "Unless specifically stated otherwise, spells and magic ites that restore lost Wounds cannot heal characters or their mounts."

P60, The Curse of Undead specifically states, and I quote, (always wanted to say that :D) "the Wizard (or another friendly undead model within 12") instantly recovers a single Wound".

That is specifically stating any model, character, model in a unit, cavalry, monster etc.. can heal a wound. So if the Vampire casts it yes he can, if his buddy is within 12" he can. It does not follow the Resurrecting Fallen Warriors rule.

People need to E-Mail gamesfaqs@games-workshop.co.uk to get them to clarify it for the FAQ, but thats how I'll play it until specifically stated by GW.
 
maxtoreador said:
Well they need to hurry up anyway, whether it's our discussion here or the fact I've got 3 opponents that refuse to play against my VC in our campaign till some rules (in their words) 'get fixed'.

They should grow up. There's nothing broken in the new book (except maybe people wanting to heal full units of blood knights in one IoN).

maxtoreador said:
On a side note: Top of their 'fixed' list is half our spells and the hexwraiths, which most of the local shops have made 'house rules' on already. Having to get the wraiths 1" from the enemy before you can run through them because you have to 'complete their movement 1" away from the the ran through one?' Zomething zounds fishy.

If your local stores are determined to make arbitrary changes to an army, with no reference to the actual rules, then you've got a problem no amount of FAQs will fix.

Hexwraiths can't finish their move within 1" of a unit (just like all other units). Other than that there are no other restrictions. Having tried them out it is already hard to get them through units more than 1-2 times in a game.
 
Is it my mistake or the ''ressurecting fallen warriors'' refers to fallen units-models-characters and should not be mixed with the ION spell that
heals characters that are not ''fallen''. In other word a wounded character can be healed but a ''fallen'' cannot be raised back. Looks like a clarification to me. Just a thought though...:innocent:
 
maxtoreador said:
Well they need to hurry up anyway, whether it's our discussion here or the fact I've got 3 opponents that refuse to play against my VC in our campaign till some rules (in their words) 'get fixed'.

Ugh. That sucks man. Nothing like players who are so committed to "gotta always win" that they refuse to play people. The game is filled with random dice. Even if the VC did have "broken" things (which I don't feel they do), the dice still can go against a player at any time.

People spend far too much time reading rules and imagining how they could work in the most devasatating math-hammered scenario, rather than just playing the damn game and seeing how often things go imperfectly.

Cheers.
 
Crypt Keeper said:
Wow a pretty big confusion over this, when I don't think there really needs to be:

ION "as described in Resurrected Fallen Warriors" therefore no character healing.

For the lore attribute yes you can here is why:

P26, Resurrecting Fallen Warriors, "Unless specifically stated otherwise, spells and magic ites that restore lost Wounds cannot heal characters or their mounts."

P60, The Curse of Undead specifically states, and I quote, (always wanted to say that :D) "the Wizard (or another friendly undead model within 12") instantly recovers a single Wound".

That is specifically stating any model, character, model in a unit, cavalry, monster etc.. can heal a wound. So if the Vampire casts it yes he can, if his buddy is within 12" he can. It does not follow the Resurrecting Fallen Warriors rule.

People need to E-Mail gamesfaqs@games-workshop.co.uk to get them to clarify it for the FAQ, but thats how I'll play it until specifically stated by GW.

This is how it seems to me too. Someone else earlier in the thread also said this I think but to me it would seem that IoN is the only thing in the book really that applies to Resurrecting Fallen Warriors as it is the only thing that makes reference to it. Unless it was an oversight (and I don't think it is) the RFW rule seems to be purposefully omitted from the Lore Attribute.
 
As this cropped up in a game I was recently in I decided to try to work out for myself just exactly how IoN, RFW and the Vampire Lore Attribute were supposed to work out and how I would play them once and for all.

I researched several forums and read a number of threads about IoN etc. with many cogent arguments for this or that interpretation and eventually decided that I would go through the rules myself in the light of these informed debates to see what I could conclude.

The conclusion of all this is rather odd; there isn’t an argument at all, the rules are perfectly clear.

Before we start I’d like to address two assumptions that I’ve seen in a lot of arguments, neither of which necessarily apply:

1. GW rules are badly written. Don’t get me wrong I’m not saying that GW rules writers don’t make mistakes, but I see no reason to approach an argument such as this with the assumption that just because a sentence does not make immediate sense to a reader it is badly written.

2. A reader understands what the writer intended, regardless of what is actually written. This is putting the cart well before the horse, to say the least.

Vampire Lore Attribute

First up, let’s clear up the Vampire Lore Attribute debate:

The Vampire Lore Attribute does not resurrect anything, it only heals models that are already on the table, and therefore it is not subject to the RFW rule.

I think it is worth noting that the Vampire Lore Attribute is written in exactly the same wording as used in the Life Lore Attribute and I don’t think anyone has managed to yet successfully argue that the Life Lore Attribute cannot heal characters or that it resurrects dead models.

Resurrecting Fallen Warriors Rule

The killer statement here is near the end of the RFW rule:

‘Unless specifically stated otherwise, spells and magic items that restore lost Wounds cannot heal characters or their mounts. If a character has joined a unit, only the unit will recover lost Wounds.’

A number of people have interpreted this to mean two things:

1. That unless it is explicitly stated that something can heal a character or mount it cannot. There is however a significant difference between the words ‘specifically’ and ‘explicitly’, they do not mean the same thing.

2. The statement of exception needs to be in the spell/item description. This is rarely stated by anyone but if you read the arguments carefully it is fairly implicit. Interestingly few people seem to realise that a specific exception can appear anywhere else, most notably in the RFW rule itself, which is the logical place to put it.

How is this relevant? Well further up the RFW rule we have the following sentences:

‘Some magic spells and items can resurrect fallen warriors in an Undead unit by restoring a number of Wounds’ worth of models to the unit. If the target consists of a single model, such as a lone character or Corpse Cart, then it can never exceed its starting Wounds value.’

‘If a target consists of a single model...’ this is specific and, although it does not explicitly say so, it is directly implicit in the sentence that a lone model can be healed and even goes on to give the example of a lone character. If such healing were not implicit then the sentence would be meaningless and rather redundant.

Therefore any character, or character mount combo, that is running around as a single model unit can be healed by through the RFW rule.

Indeed this interpretation is then backed up by the second sentence of the killer statement quote ‘If the character has joined a unit...’ I cannot see any reason for the existence of this sentence in any other interpretation of the RFW rule.

It is perhaps worth noting that the examples given in the sentence also includes a Corpse Cart, which may be taken as a mount by a Necromancer. Are we suggesting that a Corpse Cart that isn’t a mount can be healed but that one that is a mount cannot?

Invocation of Nehek Spell

Okay, so we have established that lone models can be healed by this spell, both characters and their mounts. One final area of debate exists however and that is to do with how the IoN spell is written, specifically:

‘The target units immediately regain a number of Wounds as follows: infantry gain d6 plus the caster’s Wizard level in Wounds (roll for each unit); other troop types targeted gain 1 plus the caster’s Wizard level in Wounds. However models with the Vampiric, Ethereal or Large Target special rules can never regain more than 1 Wound per successful casting.’

A number of people have interpreted the last sentence to mean that a unit with Vampiric, Ethereal or Large Target special rules can only regain one Wound per casting or that a unit with such a rule regains one Wound per model in the unit, but that is not actually what the sentence states at all.

To illustrate what the sentence actually says let us first look at how many wounds a normal unit regains, this is subject to two variables:

1. The amount of Wounds the spell generates. Which is 2d6+WL, 1d6+WL or 1+WL Wounds regained, depending on the exact unit type.

2. The number of Wounds required to return the unit back to its starting size. RFW rule, first sentence of paragraph 3, although even it notes that there are exceptions to this.

A target unit will regain a number of Wounds equal to the lower of the two variables.

Please note that a Corpse Cart, even one with a Necromancer on, is neither Vampiric, Ethereal or a Large Target and thus will regain Wounds according to the above two variables which, given that they have six or seven Wounds between them, might make Necromancers on Corpse Carts slightly more viable than they are in other interpretations.

As for units which are Vampiric, Ethereal or Large Targets if we apply the rules directly as written we can see that how many Wounds they regain is the lowest of the following three variables:

1. The amount of Wounds the spell generates. Which is 1d6+WL or 1+WL Wounds regained, depending on the exact unit type.

2. The number of Wounds required to return the unit back to its starting size. RFW rule, first sentence of paragraph 3, none of the exceptions applying to these unit types.

3. The number of models currently in the unit.

The last sentence quoted from the IoN spell above does not overwrite any of the normal variables, in fact it does not alter them at all, and instead it adds another variable to the calculation, providing another way of capping the amount of wounds a unit regains.

There is a certain sense to this, especially if we consider how wounds are removed from multi-wound model units. If I attack a unit of six ogres and inflict three wounds then we remove a whole model, but no-one is suggesting that all of my attacks are aimed at the one model, we are instead removing the single model to represent the unit’s overall loss of effectiveness. So if we are restoring effectiveness to a unit through a spell then the number of models might well provide a limit to how much restoring we are able to do, despite the fact that we are adding whole models to a unit consisting of otherwise unwounded models.

And yes I am aware that if the spell is then recast on the same unit before it is further wounded then the logic fails a bit, but this is always going to be, at best, an approximation.

Slightly oddly, units consisting entirely of Vampiric characters cannot be healed at all according to all this, which is a bit odd.

My apologies for the length of this post, I hope it all makes sense and that the arguments herein are in an understandable sequence.

I honestly do believe that there is not in fact an argument here at all; that the rules, as written, make perfect sense and I shall be playing them as such from now on.

Should be fun at the next tourney

D
 
Mach_5 said:
Zombieboy and others have it right.

Lone characters (those not in units) can be healed ("resurrecting fallen warriors" paragraph 1, sentence 2).

Characters in units cannot be healed by a spell or affect which targets the unit ("resurrecting fallen warriors" paragraph 3). So the spell Invocation will never heal a character that is inside a unit.

The Lore Attribute targets a Model within range, not a Unit, so a character within a unit can receive the benefit of the Lore Attribute.

I think this is right and how Ill play it until a FAQ says different.
 
damian said:
It is perhaps worth noting that the examples given in the sentence also includes a Corpse Cart, which may be taken as a mount by a Necromancer. Are we suggesting that a Corpse Cart that isn’t a mount can be healed but that one that is a mount cannot?

That wouldn't be that odd considering GW previous ruling (I'm looking at you pegasuses who cannot auto die by KB unless the guy riding you is better at fighting than average).

damian said:
2. The statement of exception needs to be in the spell/item description. This is rarely stated by anyone but if you read the arguments carefully it is fairly implicit. Interestingly few people seem to realise that a specific exception can appear anywhere else, most notably in the RFW rule itself, which is the logical place to put it.

I don't think this argument holds. RFW pretty much says that any ability that can heal undead stuff do so through this rule. Therefore everything would go through this loophole. Nothing can heal characters (unless specifically stated otherwise) but since the rules for RFW say characters can be healed (albeit a bit fuzzy) everything can effectively heal character, rendering the second last sentence of the last paragraph of the rule RFW completely useless and not contributing with anything. I can see that in a way RAW this is in fact the case but I don't think that is what GW wanted, thus proving that GW writes rules badly.

You arguments are pretty good all around but I don't think we can really get a definite answer for this one until we get a FaQ.

EDIT: Also, welcome to the forums. Pretty d#%& impressive to start of with a post like that one xD
 
Mad said:
I don't think this argument holds. RFW pretty much says that any ability that can heal undead stuff do so through this rule. Therefore everything would go through this loophole.


Anything written within the "RESURRECTING FALLEN WARRIORS" box apply to any case within the VC list where you resurrect fallen warriors. More specifically "...by restoring a number of wounds' worth of models to the unit"

Whatever is written in the box only matters if the effect can resurrect fallen warriors. GW has even been nice to reference the rule clearly in those cases.

The rule "Unless specifically stated otherwise, spells and magic items that restore lost wounds cannot heal characters or their mounts" does not limit healing of characters in general. It only apply within the context of the RESURRECTING FALLEN WARRIORS section. (If the spell can resurrect fallen warriors)

Just as the rule "A model is assumed to have sufficient javelins to last the battle" does not give your entire army javelins. It only apply within the context of the JAVELIN section. (if your model is equipped with a javelin)
 
I know that, but pretty much every single spell or ability that dose heal VC stuff do so through the RFW rule, the exception is the lore attribute, and wyrding well, and possibly some more things. Most importantly IoN goes through it. GW might have intended it to be so that everything that uses RFW can target characters because the rule is a exception to itself, I don't know. RAW I can see Damian being right, but I just find it silly if RFW would be an exception to itself.
 
Can't wait for the FAQ on this one.

Then again, I'll jump in with both rotted feet on it too...

I think a quirk of writing expository text has confused many. Generally an author keeps to one idea per paragraph, and leads off that idea in the first sentence. Complex thoughts may render that moot, however.

In the case of RFW, we can see that there are three main contexts. The first paragraph deals with *how* you resurrect fallen warriors. The second paragraph deals with wastage consistently. The third deals, I believe, exclusively with units, and this is where the whole confusion grows. If you misinterpret the context of units, you'll think they contradicted themselves. Keeping the third paragraph in the context of units-ruling alone, it ties in nicely with what has been written elsewhere.

I believe, if GW had to do it all over again, they'd make this addendum in the third paragraph:
"A unit cannot usually be taken beyond its starting size, though certain powers, spells and special rules may provide exceptions. Unless specifically stated otherwise, spells and magic items that restore lost Wounds cannot heal characters or their mounts THAT EXIST IN COMBINED UNITS. If a character has joined a unit, only the unit will recover lost Wounds."

The capped text keeps to the context, keeps to the spirit of the rules, ties the 2nd and 3rd lines together, doesn't contradict verbiage and the example in the first paragraph and resolves all the confusion once and for all. (Then we worry about a unit comprised of only characters, LOLZ)

And it's how I'll play it unless a Judge tells me otherwise.
 
That's the vibe I was getting as well, Banshee. I wonder if a zealous editor tried to break up what appeared as a run-on sentence, unintentionally making a single statement two completely different and unrelated thoughts.

The last two sentences should probably be one sentence:

"Unless specifically stated otherwise, spells and magic items that restore lost Wounds cannot heal characters or their mounts if a character has joined a unit, only the unit will recover lost Wounds."

And it would hold to the idea of proper paragraph structure as well.
 
Bingo! An even more precise and concise answer than mine. Remove the period and fuse the sentences back together and all is well. Ya know, we get so fixated upon what is there and what that reality means, when a simple application of out-of-the-box thinking offers a more streamlined solution.

Wouldn't be the first time someone's wayward period confused a huge pack of guys...
 
I am still of the opinion that they simply clarified the fact that vampires cannot be taken above their starting wounds value, in the wrong place. This leads to confusion.

I do beleive our lore is intended to heal any models in range, however it also does not give us express permission to do so. (other than "model" which oddly enough are what I use to represent characters. :)
also, the lore attribute does give us a roundabouts permission to heal characters, guess who cast the spell! A character, who may heal him/herself with it, that in itself is a loose permission to heal characters.

What gets me is why are ppl saying Bloodknights only get 1 wound per unit? Clearly they get 1+level.. each "model" within the unit may recover 1 wound, as they are vampiric 1 wound per casting is their limit. So a lvl 1 caster can raise 2 bloodknights a level 4 caster could raise 5.
I don't understand why that would require any clarification, it cannot be written more clearly.
 
I`m sorry if this comes out wrong. but OMG people here are really really bad at reading when it comes to RFW: "Unless specifically stated otherwise, spells and magic items that restore lost wounds cannot heal characters or there mounts" that is clear enough. But when you read through the posts here, then am I to understand that just because it says in IoN that you can heal models with the "vamp" rule, then suddenly this is another word for "character"? I`m sorry, but that is really really lame (to say the least) and you will not find a single turnamant organizer that will ever take your side on this.

No the confusion comes from the fact that in RFW it states that Characters and Corpse Carts can never exceed its starting wound value, nothing to do with the word Vampiric. Read before you write.


I fail to see where the confusion lies with the whole thing guys.

Within the footnote to RFW (Footnote) it says that Unless specifically stated otherwise, spells and magic items that restore lost wounds cannot heal characters or their mounts.

IoN specifically states that wounds gained are distributed as described in RFW

RFW specifically states that Characters or Corpse Carts can never exceed their starting wounds value NOT that Characters cannot be healed by IoN.

The last two paragraphs within the box for RFW are footnotes put there to stop people abusing the rules.

Example no:1 is that raised models cannot displace enemy models. Something that peeved off a lot of people.

Example no:2 No raising your Vamps 1 wound horse when it dies just because it's in a unit of Black Knights! And NO Giving the 2 wounds to your Vamp instead of your Black Knights!

If your Vamp is in a Unit then he benefits from look out sir. If your Vamp is on a ZD then to benefit from IoN he needs to be within 6"-12" of a Caster which is not something that you bring a ZD to the table to do.

If your Vamp is mounted and alone and his horse gets shot out from under him he's on foot and that horse can not come back, there is no mount left to heal.

The Curse of Undeath is for everyone, your Vamp is out with his AT which gets blasted by a cannon ball and survives (Just) because your opponent rolled a 2, your Vamp casts a VC lore spell and then restores 1 wound to his AT with TCOU.

The RFW rule is the first very large paragraph, the two little paragraphs are footnotes. Footnote says "Unless specifically stated" and IoN specifically states "RFW"

That is RAW not RAI something seems to have been mixed up. You are all stating RAI being that the footnote is Intended to have presidence which it is not.o_o
 
Oh and (sorry for the double post) The only reason the IoN directs you to RFW is for distributing wounds, which starts from the 8th sentence down, "First, the unit Champion is resurrected-if there was one-and then the Musician. Standard bearers.........." etc.

The rules for IoN are written in the spell description "IoN is an Augment spell that targets ALL friendly Undead units...."

White Kings, Necromancers and Vampires are ALL Undead units.

Question, what in our army is a Large Target that isn't a mount for a Character?
 
Terrogheists...
They do not have to have a character on them.


I am still surprised there is so much concern about this rule to be honest.

Nothing can be taken above its starting wounds value!

Exceptions..
Zombies - The newly dead
Skeletons - Master of the Dead.
Wolves and bats - Summon creatures of the night.

Invok cannot heal a character or his mount, ever!
No spell in the Lore of Vampires can heal a character or their mount, none give permission to do so.


Infantry heal at a rate of 1D6+Level (2-10 wounds level and dice dependant)
Grave Guard
Skelletons
Zombies
Crypt Ghouls

Exception..
The newly dead. (2d6 for zombies)

Everything else in the book heals at the rate of 1+Level (2-5 wounds)
Exceptions..

Steps.
1, Is the model Vampiric?
2. Is the model Ethereal?
3. Is the model a Large Target?
4. None of the above.

None of the above: The Unit gains between 2-5 wounds. This cannot take them above their starting value of models or wounds!

This includes;
Fell bats
Bat swarms
Crypt horrors
Corpse Cart
Black Knights
Dire Wolves

The above gain 2-5 wounds dependent on caster level.


Vampiric; step 1! the model is Vampiric, these units gain 2-5 wounds level dependant, within the guidelines, each model in the unit is restricted to 1 wound per casting.

Blood Knights (More on these later)
Vargheists (Maximum 2 wounds unit wide per casting, assuming 1 Gheist has taken a single wound and 1 has died. This is down to the models being Vampiric! and Multiwound! As they are Vampiric they gain a maximum 1 wound per model. If a Gheist has taken 2 wounds and 1 has died, you restore the wounded Gheist to 2 wounds, then waste the rest as he is not fully healed and you may not raise another, untill the rest of the unit is fully healed, hard to do with them being Vampiric as this restricts each model in the unit to a maximum 1 wound per casting. If one Vargheist has taken 1 wound and you cast invok, he would be restored to 3 full wounds, this allows you to bring one back from the dead on 1 wound, the limit of wounds a Vampiric model can gain per casting.
Varghulf 1 wound per casting (the others are wasted)
Black Coach, also Vampiric, 1 wound per casting.


Step 2, Ethereal, is a model in the unit Ethereal? If so the unit gains 2-5 wounds, each model is limited to 1!

Spirit hosts, 1 wound per base! Restricted in the same manner as Vargheists. Fully heal each base before ressurecting new ones, this means commonly you will restore 1-2 wounds maximum per casting.

Hexwraiths, again Ethereal, 1 wound per model, unit as a whole gains 2-5 wounds. (so that is 2-5 knights you get back)

Cairn Wraiths, Ethereal, 2-5 per unit, 1 per model, must fully heal existing models before returning new ones, 1-2 wounds per unit max again.



Step 3
Large Targets
Terrogheist 2-5 wounds, however it is a large target and therefore limited to 1 wound, the rest are wasted.
Mortis Engine, 2-5 wounds, limited to 1 as it is a large target.

Now...

Lore attribute!
This is not a spell or magic item, it can heal characters and mounts at a rate of one wound per casting, where you spend that wound is your buiseness, character? His mount? A nearby Varghulf, up to you!


Bloodknights again, not infantry so 2-5 wounds level dependant.
they are vampiric, so each model may gain 1 wound, oddly enough they have only 1. so each casting returns 2-5 knights.


Bloodknights, also known as "are you taking the piss? 50 points per sodding model, WS and S 5, T4, AS of 2, frenzied, unbreakable and I can raise these at the rate of 2-5 per casting on a roll of 6?

^^
That is how it all works, it works fine too, with that one exception of "BloodyhellthesearecheesyandshouldbebasedoncrackersKnights"


My reccomendation, keep it as it is, but spend 2 points per model (knight and steed) This restricts a level 1 to 1 knight raised, a level 4 to 2 knights raised.

This allows the spell to work perfectly, balances it out, has no knock on effect on other units of Ethereal/Vampiric models
 
Where does it say that a Character can never be healed?

That is what we are discussing not how to heal everything else. Characters CAN be healed but never beyond their starting value. IoN explicitly says to use RFW and RFW states that Characters can not be healed beyond their starting value.

If a spell or magic Item does not refer to RFW then it doesn't heal a Character, if it does refer you to RFW then it DOES HEAL CHARACTERS.
 
IoN explicitly says to use RFW and RFW states that Characters can not be healed beyond their starting value.

Good.. now we know a Vampire with 3 wounds cannot be healed to have 4, that a Chariot with 4 wounds cannot be healed to have 6. Is this permission to heal a character with ION? No! IT doesn't even hint at anything of the kind.

IoN explicitly says to use RFW and RFW states that Characters can not be healed by spells or magic items that restore wounds, unless specifically stated otherwise.

IoN offers no such exception.
RFW offers no such exception and even goes as far to specifically point out that you cannot heal characters or their mounts.

The top line is nothing more than "water is wet" obviously you cannot take a character with 3 wounds on his profile and heal him to have 10. This had to be written somewhere. It doesn't say "YOU CAN HEAL CHARACTERS! (I can use caps too..) It says that when healing lone models such as..... you cannot take them above their starting value. (big surprise)

It then lays out the rules for RFW, which end in a clear ruling that characters cannot be healed unless the spell offers a specific exemption, which does not exist.
If IoN, which does not give permission (nor deny it) to heal characters, loops round to RFW, which clearly denies permission to heal characters and mounts, there is really nothing to argue about.

Other than wishfull thinking that a sentance which says "you cannot take lone models above their starting vallue" is somehow permission to heal characters.. Even if it was (it isnt) it then goes on to point out that you cannot heal characters in another paragraph.

In simple terms;
A lone model such as a character cannot be taken above his starting wounds value. (The lore attribute allows these models to be healed, so it has to be noted)
Characters cannot be healed unless specifically stated, it is not stated in any spell that they can, so they cannot!

Claiming that a rule stating characters cannot be taken beyond their starting value, is a permission to heal characters is just nonsence. :clown:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu