New Vc wave could be incoming (Should rumourmongers be believed).

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Malisteen, your argument is pretty silly.
Them not being counts if fine, its merely a title. The vampire bit is the important bit.
Also, nagash was a necromancer yes, but so is manfredd and Arkhan. None of those 3 are in any way mortal humans.
 
Actually, there's plenty in the current army book about powerful necromancers leading armies of the dead. Check out the timeline. Page 30:
The Black Death unleashed by the Skaven wipes out nine tenths of the Empire's population. Skaven erupt from their hidden tunnel systems and overrun the land. In Sylvania the Necromancer Vanhal raises a huge Undead army from the bodies of the plague's victims and turns back the Skaven invaders.
Vanhal builds the fortress of Vanhaldenschlosse and carves out a powerful Undead empire. Over the following decade Vanhal, the remnants of the Empire, and the Skaven fights a prolonged war against each other. The war ends when Vanhal is assassinated and his Undead horde wiped out.

Dieter Helsnicht is discovered to be a Necromancer and driven out of the Empire city of Middenheim. He escapes to the Forest of Shadows where he raises a large Undead army and attacks the Empire. He annihilates one Empire army that is sent to stop him, but is defeated at the Battle of Beeckerhoven by a combined Empire and Kislevite force. Dieter's body is never recovered.

Kemmler is also mentioned, and there is more about Vanhal on pages 42 and 43.
 
I agree with you Sanai, that a few special lord level necromancers would be OK with me. In terms of special characters, I would like a few more options from different blood lines perhaps.

I really hate gw policy of keeping everything hidden...makes it extremely difficult to know what, and when to buy things. :thumbsdown:
 
You mean, like vampire lords are increadibly rare and special? Lords are rare and special in general. They already aren't plain old regular dudes, or they wouldn't have been able to become lord-level characters to begin with. Besides, how many of those do we have as named characters? Hellsnitch, Kemmeler, Vanhal, Kadon, ... that's at least as many named necromancer lords as there are for any given bloodline, so necro lords seemingly aren't any more rare then Necrarch Lords, or Blood Dragon lords, etc.

Is it so much to ask for a non-vampire led warhammer army that includes wights and zombies? I mean, that was practically the the default of the undead in warhammer, up until the VC/TK split. The current undead situation would be like splitting the lizardmen book between a "Saurus Warriors" army book and a "Skink Hunters" army book, and dropping slann because they aren't in either book's title.

It's seems especially odd to me that anyone would be against it because nothing would prevent vamp fans from continuing to run with their vamp lords. Why harsh on the option, for those who want it?


All that said, I don't have any problem with fielding special characters, so as long as there's some sort of pro-nagash necromancer character in the lords section of whatever new book we eventually get, I'll be happy.
 
Kadon wasn't neccesarily a necromancer, and lord levels arent anywhere near as rare as you make them out to be, seeing as how every army has them. Anyone with a keep and 40 or so men at arms to boss around is a lord level character. (his master at arms and his noble sons are hero levels). Vampires are also really common in the warhammer world, especially according to nights dark masters. They are secretly present in every major city, every level of nobility, every province.
Also, a lord level necromancer in 8th would be pretty damn inneffective, and the lizardmen analogy is completely innapropiate, as the skinks and saurus are two parts of one society, while the nekheran tomb kings and sylvanian vampire counts are two vastly different groups divided geographically by thousands of miles and culturally and aesthetically by many thing.
 
And the bloodlines aren't divided by culture, goal, prefered style of combat, or location? How many named necrarchs are there? Three? And each one killed the one before? And as a group they eschew conquest for holing themselves up in remote towers killing off local flora and fauna? And yet you'd have me believe that a necrarch lord marshaling an undead host to set about conquering his neighbors is a more common sight then a necromancer lord doing the same? When there are several stories of the latter, and, to my knowledge, none of the former?

Necromancers gathering legions of the undead to set about crushing their enemies are an iconic part of undead fluff in Warhammer, and they should be fieldable in the game. We don't need a third army for them, because they'd have exactly the same army as vampire counts, just with necromancers as an additional option. Not even the only option. Kadon (yes, a necromancer, he was only a small time sorcerer until the crown of Nagash flooded him with the great necromancer's knowledge and power), worked with Ushoran - an example of a necromancer lord and vampire lord both in the same faction. Why shouldn't I be allowed to field this on the table?
 
One of the problems I see with Necromancer Lords, is that they would have to be generals in most instances (at least that would be most logical) and then many of the units of a Vampire army just wouldn't fit (the Vampires themselves, Blood Knights, Varghulf, Black Coach etc; just to name the already existing units which don't really fit a Necromancer Lord army).

I don't have a problem with a Necromancer Lord army as such, but basing it on the Vampire Counts army list, sharing the same units, background stories etc, just makes them less than they could be on their own. I think Kemmler is awesome to be honest, but I really don't see that many of the current unit types in the Vampire Counts beastiary under his command, and certainly not enough that Necromancer Lord type army list would have some variation to them.

It is possible to include them in a VC list, even story-wise etc to a certain degree, but I don't truly think the Vampire Counts army list would benefit from it as a whole theme-wise, although having a "cheap" wizard lord to back up a powerful fighter-type Vampire Lord would certainly come in handy tactically. Still think this Lord combination could very easily become too good, especially combined with all the various hero choices that the Vampire Counts now have...

One thing that one also has to consider as one reads the Vampire fluff of Warhammer, is the lesson of Konrad, which I think most power hungry vampires would know. Basing your power on the magical talents of others is not exactly the way to go if you want to remain in charge yourself...
 
I like to see the necromancer making an comeback in the Lord options.
I really don't see why certain units wouldn't fit a Necromancer and do fit for a Vampire of any given bloodline. Meaning you could make the same argument for Vampire from Bloodline X with units Y. As there are no current restrictions for bloodlines except for the recently released terrorgheist.
 
Tim said:
I like to see the necromancer making an comeback in the Lord options.
I really don't see why certain units wouldn't fit a Necromancer and do fit for a Vampire of any given bloodline. Meaning you could make the same argument for Vampire from Bloodline X with units Y. As there are no current restrictions for bloodlines except for the recently released terrorgheist.

This is all purely hypotetical offcourse, but I wouldn't like to see the old Bloodlines returned if not done so that they each have seperate units unique to each Bloodline either. It would require seperate army lists for each Bloodline, with at least 1-2 unique units for each to properly differentiate them. I'm hoping that this is what GW is going for in 8th, and not the same "booring" army list/Beastiary section as in 7th ed. By seperating the Bloodlines again, GW would also sell more models (how many of us would only play one of the Bloodlines after all?), and this is perhaps the biggest reason I think (and hope) they will bring them back. They need to do a much better job than those original alternate Bloodlines army list from back of the 6th ed book though, to get it right, and to make each Bloodline have its own feel to its armies, as well as to differentiate them more tactically.

We are after all discussing the 8 ed VC book here, so how the current VC book works as far as restrictions go matters very little, as there are no proper Bloodline army lists as according to the fluff in the 7 ed book. They sacrificed all this for the glory of the Von Carsteins in 7 ed, which is a shame both fluff wise as well as allowing VC's to have different lists and tactics, making the army a whole lot of fun. Chaos Warriors wouldn't be half as fun if they always consisted of Chaos Undivided lists either to give one example as to why some diversity can be good.
 
Uziel said:
Tim said:
I like to see the necromancer making an comeback in the Lord options.
I really don't see why certain units wouldn't fit a Necromancer and do fit for a Vampire of any given bloodline. Meaning you could make the same argument for Vampire from Bloodline X with units Y. As there are no current restrictions for bloodlines except for the recently released terrorgheist.

This is all purely hypotetical offcourse, but I wouldn't like to see the old Bloodlines returned if not done so that they each have seperate units unique to each Bloodline either. It would require seperate army lists for each Bloodline, with at least 1-2 unique units for each to properly differentiate them. I'm hoping that this is what GW is going for in 8th, and not the same "booring" army list/Beastiary section as in 7th ed. By seperating the Bloodlines again, GW would also sell more models (how many of us would only play one of the Bloodlines after all?), and this is perhaps the biggest reason I think (and hope) they will bring them back. They need to do a much better job than those original alternate Bloodlines army list from back of the 6th ed book though, to get it right, and to make each Bloodline have its own feel to its armies, as well as to differentiate them more tactically.

We are after all discussing the 8 ed VC book here, so how the current VC book works as far as restrictions go matters very little, as there are no proper Bloodline army lists as according to the fluff in the 7 ed book. They sacrificed all this for the glory of the Von Carsteins in 7 ed, which is a shame both fluff wise as well as allowing VC's to have different lists and tactics, making the army a whole lot of fun. Chaos Warriors wouldn't be half as fun if they always consisted of Chaos Undivided lists either to give one example as to why some diversity can be good.

I totally agree though, there should be a rule like (this unit can only be taken by a vampire of bloodline x,y and z) etc. etc. I wouls really like that. Now there isn't such rule and I don't think there will be. Thus this should not be an argument for the lord necromancer option.
That's the point I wanted to put out there. :vampire3:
 
Thats fine Tim. I am arguing from a "pure" Bloodlines standpoint for one thing, and as I've stated earlier I don't mind having a Necromancer army as such, but I am against bringing them back as a Lord choice in a Vampire based army, as it doesn't really fir well fluff-wise and dillutes some of the army theme. Yes there have been some powerful "special character" necromancers in the undead fluff over the years, but they have not typically (if ever) included any Vampire units in their army. This includes any current-day units with the Vampire special rule as well...

Seing options for making a Kemmler/Krell type army would be fun I think, but if one removes the 7.ed units that really wouldn't fit under their command, it doesn't really leave much to choose from. Tactically, they could perhaps do with some ranged weaponry at least (Skeletal Bolt Thrower at least), since they will most likely suffer in close combat, especially with the terrible Zombie/Skeleton rules still in play from 7 ed (I am however assuming that something will be done here).
 
The only thing I want is cheaper zombies. 1 or 2 pt zombies would be nice. Then I can actually field them as they should be fielded.

Although, with the new 8th ed. rules they don't seem to be all that bad. Other than losing combat and disintegrating themselves. Which is why they should be 1 or 2 points per model. This would allow me to field blocks of 100 zombies, give them plenty of ranks to eat a charge and still hold for multiple zombie charges.

Ohhhh... if only.
 
The biggest problem I can see with necro lords is the idea of one being your general.
1# No self respecting vampire will serve a necromancer, so that means blood knights, vampire heroes, etc...
2# Everyone will whine and complain for the rest of 8th edition about how the necromancer lord choice is unuseable because it has no access to armour (I doubt they will keep nightshroud, and it isnt very good anyway), has crappy stats, no access to vampiric powers(meaning even with level 4 and magic items, it will still be inferior to vampries for casting) and..... if it dies (which it will) your entire army crumbles (and crumbling or some other form of it is not an option to leave out, as one of the main points of an undead army is that the generals will is what keeps the whole army running)

Also, splitting the army into bloodlines... I don't like that idea. The army is not bland/boring because of people having the choice to mix and match. Adding bloodline restrictions to options or powers... how does restricting people add more variety? It just reduces the army to a few cookie cutter lists.... and guess what? Everyone will complain that the only viable armies will be strigoi ones, and that the rest aren't useable. The option to mix and match makes all the bloodlines viable, as you can make whatever build you like and just create a model/fluff that suits what you want.
The reason that "blandness" happens is the players faults for not creating fluffy/imaginative armies, and because the online player culture seems more obsessed with their army being tournament ready than being interesting.

A better alternative to adding bloodline restrictions, is adding bloodline options. Rather than saying "if your general is a blood dragon, you can only have blood knights, black knights and skeletons", instead make it be "If your general takes the blood dragon upgrade, you can take 1 unit of black knights as core for each black knight or blood knight unit you take as special/rare"
or
"if your general takes a strigoi upgrade, your ghouls get a scout move, and you may take varghulfs as special choices"
The way to make lists more interesting, is not to take away options, but to give people more options/variety, and then encourage them to be creative/imaginative by making their be as many viable options as possible.

For example of how adding restrictions doesnt improve flavour, look at the terrorgheist mount option. What did people do when they made ghoulkin mandatory to ride a terrorgheist? People just converted the blood dragon rider to ride it and gave him ghoulkin, which is completely unfluffy and unflavourfull.

Also, the bloodlines are different cultures yes, but only in the same way that nuln is different to talabheim is different to averland, not in the same way that the tomb kings is different to vampire counts. (the difference between the TK and VC is more like the difference between the Empire and the Bretonians)
 
A better alternative to adding bloodline restrictions, is adding bloodline options. Rather than saying "if your general is a blood dragon, you can only have blood knights, black knights and skeletons", instead make it be "If your general takes the blood dragon upgrade, you can take 1 unit of black knights as core for each black knight or blood knight unit you take as special/rare"
or
"if your general takes a strigoi upgrade, your ghouls get a scout move, and you may take varghulfs as special choices"
The way to make lists more interesting, is not to take away options, but to give people more options/variety, and then encourage them to be creative/imaginative by making their be as many viable options as possible.

+1

GW started to do this a bit in 40k, primarily with special characters (a whole separate debate, I know) and it makes a huge difference. It makes the Grey Knights book have some options, especially given that they only have one troops choice to begin with. They also did it with Dark Eldar and it works, making some models (namely wracks) worth taking, since you don't have to have a named character, just a haemonculus.

This sounds like a good way to go, especially in terms of stream lining. You know, "pick your 100 points worth of powers and go." Limiting people to bloodline specific choices will only lead to even more WAACiness and cookie cutter lists, since it would be much more difficult to balance 5+ bloodline armies in one book and then balance each of them against the other armies in the game.
 
Sanai said:
Also, splitting the army into bloodlines... I don't like that idea. The army is not bland/boring because of people having the choice to mix and match. Adding bloodline restrictions to options or powers... how does restricting people add more variety? It just reduces the army to a few cookie cutter lists.... and guess what? Everyone will complain that the only viable armies will be strigoi ones, and that the rest aren't useable. The option to mix and match makes all the bloodlines viable, as you can make whatever build you like and just create a model/fluff that suits what you want.
The reason that "blandness" happens is the players faults for not creating fluffy/imaginative armies, and because the online player culture seems more obsessed with their army being tournament ready than being interesting.

Completly agree with you regarding the Blood Dragon riding the Terrorgheist option as well. That is definatly one otion I'd like to see removed.
A better alternative to adding bloodline restrictions, is adding bloodline options. Rather than saying "if your general is a blood dragon, you can only have blood knights, black knights and skeletons", instead make it be "If your general takes the blood dragon upgrade, you can take 1 unit of black knights as core for each black knight or blood knight unit you take as special/rare"
or
"if your general takes a strigoi upgrade, your ghouls get a scout move, and you may take varghulfs as special choices"
The way to make lists more interesting, is not to take away options, but to give people more options/variety, and then encourage them to be creative/imaginative by making their be as many viable options as possible.

For example of how adding restrictions doesnt improve flavour, look at the terrorgheist mount option. What did people do when they made ghoulkin mandatory to ride a terrorgheist? People just converted the blood dragon rider to ride it and gave him ghoulkin, which is completely unfluffy and unflavourfull.

As far as my personal opinions on Bloodlines go, I am not talking about bringing back the way they worked in 6th ed, with only a handful of powers for each etc. I am actually taklking of having a sort of a "common" powers section for all vampires, with as you say unique options for each of the Bloodlines on top of that (maybe even one really good power that automatically came with the bloodline). Aslo, if you choose one Bloodline, you have to pick all Vampires in the army from that same Bloodline, and they will all share a set of special rules unique to them etc. This would also, include som stat changes etc, but not be limited to that. It would make more options, but also make room to limit some uniquely powerful combiantion that don't really fit the fluff (Red Fury and Infinate Hatred to name one one sees used just about on EVERY fighter vampie Lord in a competitive list). By making Red Fury a Blood Dragon only power OR making Infinate Hatred a Strigoi one, this option could easily be eliminated, opening up for more varied Vampire Lord fighters.

I don't really see how you can make the claim that only Strigoi armies will be viable; as this will depend on a lot of factors, not the least who you are playing against and what the army options for a Strigoi army is in the first place. I am imagining seperate army lists for each bloodline, so that as you suggested, a Varghulf may bee a good fit for a Special choice in a Strigoi army, but it will also have limitations in their list to compensate.

I do however agree with you that if one is more or less limited to the current beastiary section of the 7the ed VC book, it will be next to impossible to bring a decent amout of options to each Bloodline list, and they will probaby look and act pretty much the same. This "narrow view" one needs to work against to get it reight, but that far from makes it impossible to do. To solve this, more bloodline-specific units are needed, like the Blood Knights and some modifiactions as to how each kind of unit works for each seperate Bloodline list. Sure, it would be harder to do than just making a generic list, but I don't agree that all competitive players will be Strigoi Bloodline players, and even if they were, it wouldn't be worse that the same Ghoul/Grave Guard Deathstar unit armies led by one of the two kinds of Vampire Lord we see today. Ghouls armies with Graveguard support? I mean, what the H%#&? When have any undead fluff ever supported this idea?
When did Ghouls ever become the rank and file troops for any undead army? Would you everplace creatures that cowardly to hold the line? Even the Strigoi probably wouldnt use them this way on the battlefield in general. There is such a huge gap between how the undead beastiary section is presented in the fluff, and how they actually work in competitive lists today, that it is beyond frustrating.

I don't mind people playing competitivly with their lists, as that is as much a fun part of the game as anything else, but when the competitive list don't look like any kind of Vampire Counts army I've ever heard about, then the army list is just written poorly in my opinion. Asking people to take zombie units and skeltons instead of Ghouls to a tournament because it is more "according to the flufff" is the wrong way to go about it. The list needs to be written so that as a Vampire Count player, you WANT to bring along an army that is more in line with the fluff. If I have to guess, I'm pretty sure the opponents of Vampire Counts players that play competitivly are pretty tired of seeing the same "cheesy" list from just about every player they meet as well. They are surely expecting Skellies and Zombies to make an appearance from time to time to say the least.

But, to get back to it, I agree with you that Bloodlines should be made as enticing options, not to enforce to many (although I would definatly want some) limitations.

As a final thought. I think it would be cool if the Bloodline was tied to your Vampire Lord in such a way that you had a tricle-down effect of special rules which would affect certain aspects of your army, which would make it advantageous to use the army under your command as they are presented in the various vampire fluff, or at least give you some tactical options.
 
What units are inappropriate for armies led by necromancers? Blood Knights, maybe Vampire heroes. Um, that's it? Varghulf's have lost their minds to bestial madness, I don't see why they would object. Black Coaches - well in that case clearly the vampire lord had been in charge and had been defeated in combat, leaving the necromancer to construct the coach in an attempt to revive them.

As for vampire heroes and lords sharing space with necro lords in the same army, it's happened in the fluff at least once (again, Ushoran and Kadon). I see no reason why alliances couldn't be formed there. Especially with Blood Dragons, who would frequently require the aid of necromancers to rouse a sufficiently large army to go conquering with, anyway. And even without alliances, vampires can be bound by sorcery, and if any caster would be mad, powerful, and knowledgeable enough to attempt such a feat, it would be a necromancer lord.

Compare to any of the bloodlines. Ghouls don't make much sense for lahmians or blood dragons. Blood knights don't belong in strigoi or necrarch armies. And army built for a fluff theme will find that some units or characters in the army don't belong. Why should this serve as a barrier to necromancer lords, but not to any of the bloodlines?

There's also no reason why a necro lord's leadership would have to be greater then a vampire hero's leadership, allowing for vampyric generals even if the necro was your only lord. Honestly, it's a bit odd that the vamp hero's leadership is as low as it is to begin with.

As for what place the necro would serve in your army - that should be obvious. The role of inexpensive mage lord. A lord capable of bringing the obligatory magical support that an undead army requires without spending a bunch of extra points on melee stats or costly (if awesome) vampyric powers. A caster lord you could run in smaller games (say, 1250 to 1500 points or so) when it's hard to fit a vamp lord at all, or in a larger game as a second lord when two vampire lords would still be too expensive, or as a support caster in a big game where your vamp lord is winging it around on a zombie dragon and you want another caster in your lines to do the usual buffs & rezzing duties. Or a lord you could run in an undead horde army that wants to spend more points on the troops and fewer on the characters.

The trick is to make vampyric powers and abilities worth the cost, so that a vampire is attractive as a more powerful, more expensive lord choice, but the necro still has a place as the discount option.
 
You missed my point, I have no problem with necros and blood dragons working together, I have a problem with the idea of a vampire serving "under" a necromancer general.
And also, you still havnt answered the problem that with a necromancer lord as general, your army is incredibly vulnerable to crumbling having such a fragile general.
 
Well can't vampire be bound to the will of a powerful necromancer lord through strong magic, similar to the way that you can include vampire counts as as alliances in SoM.
And wouldn't it be up to every player to decide if he want a necromancer lord as general. Then you can choose between a resilient but expensive vampire lord or the more fragile, but much cheaper, necromancer lord and play a bit of gamble.
 
I'm assuming everyone who complains about the fluff not supporting powerful necromancers (apart from the relatively long list of powerful named necromancers already mentioned) is basing this on the fluff in the current army book. That fluff was written after GW decided to downgrade all necromancers to lowly level 1's. In previous army books the fluff supported powerful necromancers no problem. If they were to return in our next army book GW would simply be undoing the fluff edit they made in our current book.

For those of you who worry about a vampire following a necromancer: a) there's no reason to take the necromancer as your general if you don't want to, and b) if we keep the current "general must be a vampire" rule then it can't happen anyway.

We could also get the best (or at least a mix) of both worlds, getting a necromancer that is level 3 with no choice of an upgrade to level 4, who only knows the three necromancy spells.

Personally I'm fairly certain we'll see the return of a vampire lord, as only having one non-special character lord choice is unheard of when you look at other armies. All new 8th Ed books (I believe) have had a new hero or lord type added in (it almost guarantees new sales for GW).
 
Malisteen said:
What units are inappropriate for armies led by necromancers? Blood Knights, maybe Vampire heroes. Um, that's it? Varghulf's have lost their minds to bestial madness, I don't see why they would object. Black Coaches - well in that case clearly the vampire lord had been in charge and had been defeated in combat, leaving the necromancer to construct the coach in an attempt to revive them.

As for vampire heroes and lords sharing space with necro lords in the same army, it's happened in the fluff at least once (again, Ushoran and Kadon). I see no reason why alliances couldn't be formed there. Especially with Blood Dragons, who would frequently require the aid of necromancers to rouse a sufficiently large army to go conquering with, anyway. And even without alliances, vampires can be bound by sorcery, and if any caster would be mad, powerful, and knowledgeable enough to attempt such a feat, it would be a necromancer lord.

Compare to any of the bloodlines. Ghouls don't make much sense for lahmians or blood dragons. Blood knights don't belong in strigoi or necrarch armies. And army built for a fluff theme will find that some units or characters in the army don't belong. Why should this serve as a barrier to necromancer lords, but not to any of the bloodlines?

There's also no reason why a necro lord's leadership would have to be greater then a vampire hero's leadership, allowing for vampyric generals even if the necro was your only lord. Honestly, it's a bit odd that the vamp hero's leadership is as low as it is to begin with.

As for what place the necro would serve in your army - that should be obvious. The role of inexpensive mage lord. A lord capable of bringing the obligatory magical support that an undead army requires without spending a bunch of extra points on melee stats or costly (if awesome) vampyric powers. A caster lord you could run in smaller games (say, 1250 to 1500 points or so) when it's hard to fit a vamp lord at all, or in a larger game as a second lord when two vampire lords would still be too expensive, or as a support caster in a big game where your vamp lord is winging it around on a zombie dragon and you want another caster in your lines to do the usual buffs & rezzing duties. Or a lord you could run in an undead horde army that wants to spend more points on the troops and fewer on the characters.

The trick is to make vampyric powers and abilities worth the cost, so that a vampire is attractive as a more powerful, more expensive lord choice, but the necro still has a place as the discount option.

Regarding the Varghulf, I don't think it would object as such, it would in all likelyhood just kill the poor smuck of a Necromancer playing around with its food supply (he might look a bit tasty himself as well). The idea that Necroamcers can dominate Vampires with any kind of success in the Old World is pretty far fetched to begin with. Even Nagash had problems doing this, and had to forge the Carstein Ring to enforce this for as long as this lasted.
Your reasoning for bringing along a Black Coach in a Necromancer army is plausible though, even though it is not very probable.

As far as alliances go with Necromancers and Vampires, well, there is a chapter about alliances in the army book if I am not mistaking. What we are talking about here is making the combination a regular thing and probable (fluff-wise), not something that has happened once or twice in ancient history. Yes, it can obviously happen (as long as two lords share the same common goals, just about anyone can ally themselves, at least for a while). By that reasoning, Empire and Dwarfs could be one army as well.
What I'm saying is that making it happen regularly will bring some of the focus away from the Vampires. We already have both Lords, Thralls and Necromanccers to do the spell casting in the list. Do we really need Necomancer Lords as well? Can it be justified? I'd much rather see our units becoming more usefull without the aid of enormous amounts of summoning spells being cast, than to include more and better wizards to spam more useless troops. Kind of booring tactically the way it works now. Also, a Necromancer Lord should only really know true Necromancy spells, and there are only 3 of those featured in the 7.ed book...

Completly agree that Ghouls don't make much sense in Blood Dragon and Lahmia lists.
Same goes for Blood Dragons in Necrarch, Strigoi and in my opinion for the Von Carsteins as well.
You are a bit off regarding the idea that lood Dragons would require many or a few powerful necromancers to raise an army to conquer with, as the aim of Blood Dragons are not typically really to summon great armies and conquer land in the first place. They typically have small, elite armies, featuring lots of Vampires and Wights, and they fight for fighting sake, to prove their worth etc.
I don't mind Necromancer Lords leading armies, but I would not build it on the 7.ed VC book, as there are so many of the current undead units that don't really work well in 8.ed; especially when not supported by powerful close combat characters. An army led by Necromancers, is in my opinion best supported by the fluff of Nagash etc. I magine most of his current Dark Lords to be Necromancers/Liches after all... Basing this army around Nagash, could also be a good way to introduce some new units, able to fight without the aid of Vampires in the front lines.

Regarding the Vampire Thrall's low Ld score, I agree with you, especially since the 7.ed list is so obviously Von Carstein based. I could see it on an insane Strigoi Thrall, but for the rest I'd think LD 8 would be more appropriate for Thralls.
 
Sanai said:
You missed my point, I have no problem with necros and blood dragons working together, I have a problem with the idea of a vampire serving "under" a necromancer general.

Actually, I didn't miss your point. In fact, I addressed it in four distinct ways. To summarize why the existence of vampire heroes should preclude the possibility of a necromancer general: First, because it's happened in the fluff (Ushoran and Kadon). Second, because necromancer lords have the capacity to magically bind vampires (see storm of magic), so nothing says that a vampire hero in their army has to be there of their own will any more then the wights or wraiths or skeletons. Third, because nothing forces you to use vampire heroes in the first place, what with wights, hero necromancers, banshees, and wraiths all as viable choices; after all, any themed army is going to have some options that don't fit - that's how themes work - and none of the bloodlines are any exception (with the possible exception of the vanilla von carsteins). Finally, because I would prefer if necro lords and vampire heroes had the same leadership. Then even if a vampire hero is leaving the running of the army to the more magically focused necromancer lord, as a blood dragon might, it's still operating under its own leadership and isn't being 'led' if the player doesn't want to fluff it that way.


And also, you still haven't answered the problem that with a necromancer lord as general, your army is incredibly vulnerable to crumbling having such a fragile general.

You will protect the general the same way we do now - and the same way we'll protect vampire generals in any new book - the same way we protected necromancer lords and liches in the old undead days - by bunkering them. Besides, I don't for a second believe that they'll improve vampyric durability to the point that it will be a good idea to run a melee general in an army that suffers from crumbling anyway.

Your necro will carry the same 4+ ward that a vampire lord would, and will cower in a skellie bunker behind your battle lines just as a necrarch lord would - only he'll be cheaper and less powerful, because, again, that's the point of having him as an option, to allow a magically dependent army access to a functional mage lord at a discount for players who would rather spend the extra points on more troops rather then special powers.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu