Sanai said:
Also, splitting the army into bloodlines... I don't like that idea. The army is not bland/boring because of people having the choice to mix and match. Adding bloodline restrictions to options or powers... how does restricting people add more variety? It just reduces the army to a few cookie cutter lists.... and guess what? Everyone will complain that the only viable armies will be strigoi ones, and that the rest aren't useable. The option to mix and match makes all the bloodlines viable, as you can make whatever build you like and just create a model/fluff that suits what you want.
The reason that "blandness" happens is the players faults for not creating fluffy/imaginative armies, and because the online player culture seems more obsessed with their army being tournament ready than being interesting.
Completly agree with you regarding the Blood Dragon riding the Terrorgheist option as well. That is definatly one otion I'd like to see removed.
A better alternative to adding bloodline restrictions, is adding bloodline options. Rather than saying "if your general is a blood dragon, you can only have blood knights, black knights and skeletons", instead make it be "If your general takes the blood dragon upgrade, you can take 1 unit of black knights as core for each black knight or blood knight unit you take as special/rare"
or
"if your general takes a strigoi upgrade, your ghouls get a scout move, and you may take varghulfs as special choices"
The way to make lists more interesting, is not to take away options, but to give people more options/variety, and then encourage them to be creative/imaginative by making their be as many viable options as possible.
For example of how adding restrictions doesnt improve flavour, look at the terrorgheist mount option. What did people do when they made ghoulkin mandatory to ride a terrorgheist? People just converted the blood dragon rider to ride it and gave him ghoulkin, which is completely unfluffy and unflavourfull.
As far as my personal opinions on Bloodlines go, I am not talking about bringing back the way they worked in 6th ed, with only a handful of powers for each etc. I am actually taklking of having a sort of a "common" powers section for all vampires, with as you say unique options for each of the Bloodlines on top of that (maybe even one really good power that automatically came with the bloodline). Aslo, if you choose one Bloodline, you have to pick all Vampires in the army from that same Bloodline, and they will all share a set of special rules unique to them etc. This would also, include som stat changes etc, but not be limited to that. It would make more options, but also make room to limit some uniquely powerful combiantion that don't really fit the fluff (Red Fury and Infinate Hatred to name one one sees used just about on EVERY fighter vampie Lord in a competitive list). By making Red Fury a Blood Dragon only power OR making Infinate Hatred a Strigoi one, this option could easily be eliminated, opening up for more varied Vampire Lord fighters.
I don't really see how you can make the claim that only Strigoi armies will be viable; as this will depend on a lot of factors, not the least who you are playing against and what the army options for a Strigoi army is in the first place. I am imagining seperate army lists for each bloodline, so that as you suggested, a Varghulf may bee a good fit for a Special choice in a Strigoi army, but it will also have limitations in their list to compensate.
I do however agree with you that if one is more or less limited to the current beastiary section of the 7the ed
VC book, it will be next to impossible to bring a decent amout of options to each Bloodline list, and they will probaby look and act pretty much the same. This "narrow view" one needs to work against to get it reight, but that far from makes it impossible to do. To solve this, more bloodline-specific units are needed, like the Blood Knights and some modifiactions as to how each kind of unit works for each seperate Bloodline list. Sure, it would be harder to do than just making a generic list, but I don't agree that all competitive players will be Strigoi Bloodline players, and even if they were, it wouldn't be worse that the same Ghoul/Grave Guard Deathstar unit armies led by one of the two kinds of Vampire Lord we see today. Ghouls armies with Graveguard support? I mean, what the H%#&? When have any undead fluff ever supported this idea?
When did Ghouls ever become the rank and file troops for any undead army? Would you everplace creatures that cowardly to hold the line? Even the Strigoi probably wouldnt use them this way on the battlefield in general. There is such a huge gap between how the undead beastiary section is presented in the fluff, and how they actually work in competitive lists today, that it is beyond frustrating.
I don't mind people playing competitivly with their lists, as that is as much a fun part of the game as anything else, but when the competitive list don't look like any kind of Vampire Counts army I've ever heard about, then the army list is just written poorly in my opinion. Asking people to take zombie units and skeltons instead of Ghouls to a tournament because it is more "according to the flufff" is the wrong way to go about it. The list needs to be written so that as a Vampire Count player, you WANT to bring along an army that is more in line with the fluff. If I have to guess, I'm pretty sure the opponents of Vampire Counts players that play competitivly are pretty tired of seeing the same "cheesy" list from just about every player they meet as well. They are surely expecting Skellies and Zombies to make an appearance from time to time to say the least.
But, to get back to it, I agree with you that Bloodlines should be made as enticing
options, not to enforce to many (although I would definatly want some) limitations.
As a final thought. I think it would be cool if the Bloodline was tied to your Vampire Lord in such a way that you had a tricle-down effect of special rules which would affect certain aspects of your army, which would make it advantageous to use the army under your command as they are presented in the various vampire fluff, or at least give you some tactical options.