New Wood Elves inbound.

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
RarerMonsters said:
First off, although I know Matt Ward hate is popular

I think Matt Ward is actually a good example of why game developers shouldn't be gamers themselves. He has his favourite armies and he over powers them because at his core he's a power gamer. It's a good example of why I won't play against fan dexes. You can claim they're balanced all you like, but they're made by gamers and gamers don't balance books properly.

I don't hate the guy, he's just doing what we'd all do if we were give then keys to the kingdom.
 
Ripper said:
RarerMonsters said:
First off, although I know Matt Ward hate is popular

I think Matt Ward is actually a good example of why game developers shouldn't be gamers themselves. He has his favourite armies and he over powers them because at his core he's a power gamer. It's a good example of why I won't play against fan dexes. You can claim they're balanced all you like, but they're made by gamers and gamers don't balance books properly.

I don't hate the guy, he's just doing what we'd all do if we were give then keys to the kingdom.
Well, he's on record saying Wood Elves are his favorite army and they're by no means overpowered, and on the whole the three Elven codexes are probably the best balanced releases of 8th so far.

Moreover, they're exciting books with a variety of good options and fewer bothersome mandatory choices. I vastly prefer his design over Phil Kelly's "Take 3 bad choices for every 1 useful one"
 
RarerMonsters said:
Well, he's on record saying Wood Elves are his favorite army and they're by no means overpowered, and on the whole the three Elven codexes are probably the best balanced releases of 8th so far.

Moreover, they're exciting books with a variety of good options and fewer bothersome mandatory choices. I vastly prefer his design over Phil Kelly's "Take 3 bad choices for every 1 useful one"

I think the last Fantasy Book Phil put out was Vampire Counts. :innocent:

Actually I think Wood Elves are the worst of the three elven books. He did great work with High Elves and Dark Elves. :thumbsup: Dark Elves by far seem to have the most options for builds. If you ask me, the Wood Elf book seems like Mat was burned out by then and said "Screw it! I'll just make them a combination of both of the others...except with no powerful magic items."
 
Yorga said:
I think the last Fantasy Book Phil put out was Vampire Counts. :innocent:
Warriors of Chaos.

And yeah, I'm not fond of his VC book. The options available nose-dived since the last edition, our core is abysmal compared to the standard of 8th, and Vampire Lords are a barely playable liability... but I'm not here to hash that out.

Actually I think Wood Elves are the worst of the three elven books. He did great work with High Elves and Dark Elves. :thumbsup: Dark Elves by far seem to have the most options for builds. If you ask me, the Wood Elf book seems like Mat was burned out by then and said "Screw it! I'll just make them a combination of both of the others...except with no powerful magic items."
Not sure why, they seem that way because they emphasize something both of the others were decently good at (shooting) and gives them the tools to push it even farther.
 
Interesting that people seem to think this wood elf book is weak, this week at my group there were three wood elf armies (compare to zero the week before) and everyone was going on and on about how they're the best elves now...

Like most things, it all comes down to your local meta and the quality of the players.
 
RarerMonsters said:
Yorga said:
I think the last Fantasy Book Phil put out was Vampire Counts. :innocent:

Warriors of Chaos.

Umm...Robin Cruddace wrote MY WoC Book. You have a different publication? :|

Ripper said:
Interesting that people seem to think this wood elf book is weak, this week at my group there were three wood elf armies (compare to zero the week before) and everyone was going on and on about how they're the best elves now...

Like most things, it all comes down to your local meta and the quality of the players.

And how did they do? And how long do you think it will take people to counter their new tricks?
 
Blutsauger said:
MasterSpark said:
Blutsauger said:
Did they get a prowess rule? Do they access to many magical shooting attacks?

What I've heard and read they get both martial prowess and murderous prowess, but only if they're in a wood terrain piece. And they can upgrade their core archers with a variety of magical arrows.

So Hexwraiths are out. I have to say, I really don't like this blending of high and dark elves for the Woodies. I would have preferred their own lore, and their own prowess rule. Give them a bit of individual identity.

Did the waywatchers keep killing blow?

Don't count the hexwraiths out. Wood elves can hit damn near anything, but wont wound anyone. They only need to survive one turn to reach the woods the glade guard are likely hiding in then simply run through them and not only kill with basically every free hit, but end out of their shooting arc. Another turn of charging through with your wraiths and the unit is basically gone.

The wood elf book has the same weaknesses as the old one, super expensive units that simply cant wound anything. High toughness units will win the match vs them nearly every time.
 
Hexwraiths are T3 and WE poisoned arrows are magical. I'd be wary of using them against the Woodies. It won't be just one GG unit firing at them either as scouts will be present and most likely will be marching and firing closer to the enemy than then GG would be, thus providing a bait unit that will rally easily on high leadership.
 
Seneschal said:
Hexwraiths are T3 and WE poisoned arrows are magical. I'd be wary of using them against the Woodies. It won't be just one GG unit firing at them either as scouts will be present and most likely will be marching and firing closer to the enemy than then GG would be, thus providing a bait unit that will rally easily on high leadership.

So two glade guard units and some scouts. That is a good 1.2k points worth of units, there goes your dryads, or a special choice. Wood elves pay premium for the strengths they get with no discounts for their weaknesses. A unit of 30 GG runs 510~ points with the poison arrows. If they want nearly half their points (in a 2500 game) focusing your one unit of hexies then your golden.
 
It won't even take that many units to deal with the hex wraiths, though. One GG unit will be enough to whittle down a unit of 5 to 1 or 2 in one round, then there is the stand and shoot.
 
Seneschal said:
It won't even take that many units to deal with the hex wraiths, though. One GG unit will be enough to whittle down a unit of 5 to 1 or 2 in one round, then there is the stand and shoot.

A unit of ten is still cheaper then his unit, and you don't need many considering he wont get a stand and shoot. Zero reason to charge them with hexwraiths when you can just run through them for the same effect and be out of their arc of shooting the next round allowing you to either charge them from the back or run back through them.

Edit: Not too mention you are still wasting his 500 point units time with your 200-300 point one.
 
who plays 30 man strong units of GG?
i only see them in tens. i would only play them in tens. focus fire from 3 units or spread out on different targets. your choice

then there is,as mentioned, scouts. and waywatchers.

dryads dont scare anyone nomore, we wont see much of them.
treekin i can see be somewhat workble( alot like our crypt horrors)
 
Melle said:
who plays 30 man strong units of GG?
i only see them in tens. i would only play them in tens. focus fire from 3 units or spread out on different targets. your choice

then there is,as mentioned, scouts. and waywatchers.

dryads dont scare anyone nomore, we wont see much of them.
treekin i can see be somewhat workble( alot like our crypt horrors)

Can fire three ranks worth when in a forest so minimum 15 with the new book.

With the tree spirits being less desirable wood elves are running out of things to field for real combat. Their best unit for fighting are the wild riders which are just worse versions of our blood knights and we already don't take those.

Basically you'll see a lot of waywatchers glade guard and warhawk riders for most of the army (after the two new units fall to the wayside after some time in the spotlight). Which all have a very tough time vs high toughness, which only the glade guard can somewhat mitigate with poison. Meaning they would need to field a lot of them.
 
I doubt Wood Elves will ever want to be depending on their rank bonus in combat, so Glade Guard will probably be in units of ten, deployed three wide. All ten will get to shoot if they're in a wood. If not you only lose out on 2 or 3 shots.
 
I still think you'll only see units of 10, deployed five wide. You get all your shots no matter what, and if you get into combat, you only lose a unit of ten, instead of a unit of 30.
 
Blutsauger said:
I still think you'll only see units of 10, deployed five wide. You get all your shots no matter what, and if you get into combat, you only lose a unit of ten, instead of a unit of 30.

That just makes them easier to pick off. Killing that unit of ten will be easy and I will get full points for it, even if I lose a unit to another units shooting afterwords his unit will nearly always be more expensive then mine.

Glade Guard will likely be put into units of 30 because they are the archers and the blocked ranks of the army. The only difference between Glade Guard and Eternal Guard is a 5+ armor save, but glade guard can shoot (really well) and that means they can stay in the woods all game and gain all the benefits therein. (which makes them much stronger then a 5+ armor save)
 
LordTobiothan said:
Blutsauger said:
I still think you'll only see units of 10, deployed five wide. You get all your shots no matter what, and if you get into combat, you only lose a unit of ten, instead of a unit of 30.

That just makes them easier to pick off. Killing that unit of ten will be easy and I will get full points for it, even if I lose a unit to another units shooting afterwords his unit will nearly always be more expensive then mine.

Glade Guard will likely be put into units of 30 because they are the archers and the blocked ranks of the army. The only difference between Glade Guard and Eternal Guard is a 5+ armor save, but glade guard can shoot (really well) and that means they can stay in the woods all game and gain all the benefits therein. (which makes them much stronger then a 5+ armor save)

Alot of wood elf players are used to running a MSU list and I think will continue to do so with small units of glade guard but having them in larger units also has some merit.
Although they will be harder to move around and in a way easier for the enemy to pin down it will be harder to get the points for them.

I think we will see glade guard units in very varying sizes.
 
LordTobiothan said:
That just makes them easier to pick off. Killing that unit of ten will be easy and I will get full points for it, even if I lose a unit to another units shooting afterwords his unit will nearly always be more expensive then mine.

I see what you're saying, but if I can kill a unit of ten I can kill a unit of 30 just as easily. They're only T3 with no save, they die just as quick as zombies. Historically, Wood Elf players take many small units rather than larger units, because then I can only kill one unit at a time. It will take me three times the resources to deal with three units.
 
Blutsauger said:
LordTobiothan said:
That just makes them easier to pick off. Killing that unit of ten will be easy and I will get full points for it, even if I lose a unit to another units shooting afterwords his unit will nearly always be more expensive then mine.

I see what you're saying, but if I can kill a unit of ten I can kill a unit of 30 just as easily. They're only T3 with no save, they die just as quick as zombies. Historically, Wood Elf players take many small units rather than larger units, because then I can only kill one unit at a time. It will take me three times the resources to deal with three units.

You make assumptions you should not make my friend. How many woods do you suspect will be on the table? How many will be positioned to where he can still see and shoot at the same unit from each archer unit?

The difference between killing elves and zombies is that the elves hit you first. 10 guys in a wood and 2 units of 10 outside of woods are lambs for the slaughter. Now a 30 man unit in the woods, attacks you first, re-rolls to hit and to wound, and has poisoned attacks. 30 poisonous attacks with double re-rolls is nothing to scoff at.

It actually makes them a better CC unit then eternal guard that are outside of the woods (and since you cant get anything to charge your eternal guards in the woods they will never be fighting in them)

Wood Elves historically took smaller units so you would kill less at a time, but they also relied on one turn combats with their units that charge. A 5 man war dancer unit was fine in 7th, you would clear the front line, they test on modified leadership, break, and get run down. 8th edition rolled around and now things get step up and steadfast, those same 5 war dancers now die in that combat every time, and either lose, or cant break the unit they charged.
 
People still used MSU in 8th before the new book and most likely will now too. The thing that could have killed it is loosing the mo movement pentalty to shooting but the arrows fix that so it should still be viable.
One advantage of having 3 units of 10 is that you can still shoot with the remaining two if one is charged. If you only had one of 30 it would only require one enemy unit to prevent all the shooting.
I would not be surprised to see one large unit supported by some smaller units though.
 
LordTobiothan said:
You make assumptions you should not make my friend. How many woods do you suspect will be on the table? How many will be positioned to where he can still see and shoot at the same unit from each archer unit?

The difference between killing elves and zombies is that the elves hit you first. 10 guys in a wood and 2 units of 10 outside of woods are lambs for the slaughter. Now a 30 man unit in the woods, attacks you first, re-rolls to hit and to wound, and has poisoned attacks. 30 poisonous attacks with double re-rolls is nothing to scoff at.

I'll be scoffing all day at a S3, T3 unit with no saves. My heavy hitters will plow into that unit and clean it off the board in a single turn. Even with ASF and Poison. Wood Elves still need to minimise losses in combat, and still need the option to spread or concentrate their fire at the players discretion, instead of all being required to fire in combat. Sure, they got a bit better in combat, but not enough that 30 of them are ever going to be a good idea.
 
Blutsauger said:
I'll be scoffing all day at a S3, T3 unit with no saves. My heavy hitters will plow into that unit and clean it off the board in a single turn. Even with ASF and Poison. Wood Elves still need to minimise losses in combat, and still need the option to spread or concentrate their fire at the players discretion, instead of all being required to fire in combat. Sure, they got a bit better in combat, but not enough that 30 of them are ever going to be a good idea.

Yeah but, full round of shooting, full round of shooting, stand and shoot, then they asf with double re-rolls, armor piercing, and poison.

Your heavy hitter would need to be a deathstar to survive that. Granted at 500 some points the GG unit costs as much as a death star.

Now with three units of ten, your heavy hitter kills one unit after losing about a rank after the three rounds of shooting and the combat. The other two units would have tried to help, but getting forests within range to hit the same things is hard. You could put them outside of the forest, but then it is no different then the horde of 30 except 20 of yours don't gain forest benefits, and I will just break your 10 unit reform and charge another ten unit.

In both scenarios we both lose 30 GG, except I had 20 more guys with extra forest rules in the fight.

Not too mention basically everything in the wood elf army is str 3 toughness 3 no saves. If they do have higher toughness/saves then they don't rank up and most of them are still super squish. The only thing not made of paper in the army are treekin and treemen, and they die to fire faster than most other monsters.

I'm not saying MSU style of GG isn't an option, it is definitely viable, I just think as far as a ranked infantry block goes, GG are the best the wood elves have to offer. Lets face it, dryads got nerfed, and eternal guard are crap outside of forests (which you will never have to fight them in). So they argument isn't really 30 or 10, but what would you field as your ranked up unit instead of the GG?
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu