Blutsauger said:
I'll be scoffing all day at a S3, T3 unit with no saves. My heavy hitters will plow into that unit and clean it off the board in a single turn. Even with ASF and Poison. Wood Elves still need to minimise losses in combat, and still need the option to spread or concentrate their fire at the players discretion, instead of all being required to fire in combat. Sure, they got a bit better in combat, but not enough that 30 of them are ever going to be a good idea.
Yeah but, full round of shooting, full round of shooting, stand and shoot, then they asf with double re-rolls, armor piercing, and poison.
Your heavy hitter would need to be a deathstar to survive that. Granted at 500 some points the GG unit costs as much as a death star.
Now with three units of ten, your heavy hitter kills one unit after losing about a rank after the three rounds of shooting and the combat. The other two units would have tried to help, but getting forests within range to hit the same things is hard. You could put them outside of the forest, but then it is no different then the
horde of 30 except 20 of yours don't gain forest benefits, and I will just break your 10 unit reform and charge another ten unit.
In both scenarios we both lose 30 GG, except I had 20 more guys with extra forest rules in the fight.
Not too mention basically everything in the wood elf army is str 3 toughness 3 no saves. If they do have higher toughness/saves then they don't rank up and most of them are still super squish. The only thing not made of paper in the army are treekin and treemen, and they die to fire faster than most other monsters.
I'm not saying MSU style of GG isn't an option, it is definitely viable, I just think as far as a ranked infantry block goes, GG are the best the wood elves have to offer. Lets face it, dryads got nerfed, and eternal guard are crap outside of forests (which you will never have to fight them in). So they argument isn't really 30 or 10, but what would you field as your ranked up unit instead of the GG?