N.I.B. said:
Veland said:
However, I'm quite sure you no longer get the option to choose who dies from the command group in 7th ed.
What do you base that on? The only rank and file model that you can allocate attacks on is the champion. Everything else is up to the controlling player, which model(s) he want to remove.
Veland said:
I think I was wrong with the champion not forming a unit when SB dies. That would be wrong, what would we do with units that have champions but not SBs?
I take it SB is short for Standard Bearer? Anyway, that would be a unit without a standard then. What is the problem?
Sorry I was too busy to post earlier.
I admit that when the unit champion survives, the unit is still there and I made a mistake saying otherwise. No problem here.
I checked
TK armybook, and the spell description says that command models can be brought back (champion first) as long as the unit still survives. IMO, if a standard bearer is to be summoned back, he brings his magical banner with him (if he had any), though the spell description does not specify it. I think it works this way due to the SB being "healed" or "resurrected", but on the other hand, you can claim that the magical banner could only be brought back with the standard if the spell description stated that explicitly. Then, a D6 roll could decide to keep the game going, I think.
Regarding the removal of standard bearer models as casualties, the rulebook says on p.80: "The enemy cannot specifically attack standard bearers as he can character models. Standard bearers are not normally removed as casualties, as it is assumed that if the standard bearer is killed, another warrior will pick up the banner and take his place. Therefore, the player always removes an ordinary warrior in preference to a standard bearer, even if the ordinary warrior is not in base contact with the enemy."
So, the controlling player is not allowed to make any choice here.
Similarly, regarding the musicians, the rulebook states: "Also, like standard bearers, the player does not remove musicians, but substitutes an ordinary model instead."
Here, the word "always" is missing. My interpretation is that in case of a dilemma, a musician is removed first and then the standard bearer, but the rule disallows removing musicians in preference to ordinary R&f models.
What about champions? The rulebook states: "Unlike standard bearers and musicians, enemy models can direct attacks against champions and kill them - if a champion is removed as a casualty he is not replaced by another model (see page 76). If the unit suffers enough wounds to kill every model in it, the champion is removed together with his comrades, being after all a rank-and-file model."
My interpretation is that if a champion is not killed by an attack directed specifically at him, he may only be killed if all other models in the unit (including musician and standard bearer) are already killed.
So, trying to figure it out in an example, if we have a unit that has 4 models (1 W each): 1 r&f, 1 musician, 1 standard bearer and one champion, and the champion is not attacked explicitly, the order of removing models as casualties is the following:
1 unsaved wound: 1 r&f model is removed.
2 unsaved wounds: 1 r&f model is removed and then the musician.
3 unsaved wounds: 1 r&f model is removed, the musician after him and then the standard bearer.
4 unsaved wounds: 1 r&f model is removed, the musician, the standard bearer and the champion at the very end.
When I read these rules, I can see no place for a controlling player to decide which models are to be removed since the order is decided by the rulebook. Can you read it in another way? Is there any other place in the rulebook which contains a rule granting this choice to the controlling player?
Linking these rules to the
TK example, the spell may bring back the standard bearer only if the unit champion is still alive. If the unit did not have a champion at all, it was destroyed when the standard bearer (or last model) was killed.
The champion may be resurrected only if at least one model remains in the unit after champion's destruction but if the unit had a standard bearer, the surviving model must be the standard bearer.
So, that's my explanation. What's your opinion?