WHFB - 6th Not VC but it is still undead (TK)

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Bonemage

Zombie
Aug 15, 2007
4
Zombies
2
My friend who is playing Tomb Kings has asked me a question that I have a theory on but I can't seem to find a decent answer for online anywhere.

If you have your unit standard bearer get killed (chariot but not important to the question) and then you heal/raise the Standard bearer back (remember TK not VC) if that unit standard bearer had a magic banner. Does the magical Banner came back with the healed/raised character.

My opinion is yes because I believe you are "bringing back" models as opposed to raising new ones like in VC. But what do you guys think?
 
i have never came to this problem yet (i play VC and Skaven) but..
it sounds sounds reasonable
i would probbly smooth this over with my opponent before try as there are no rules saying you can't (nor any that say you can) but fluff wise it works too (kinda like necrons)
 
it would make senses that the std keeps his banner since you are just fixing him up..........but when did gw's rules make any sense.....so i cant tell to 100% on what is right or not
 
As a rule of thumb, we can only do what the rules say we can do. Does the rules say that TK can keep the magic standard in this case? If not, it's probably not legal.
 
First of all, in each and every army, the standard bearer model dies/is removed as the last model from the unit (excluding unit champion). If the standard bearer dies, the unit counts as destroyed. Therefore, if all killed models were consecutively removed from the unit, the last model standing will be the unit standard bearer (excluding unit champion and other characters). The champion alone does not make the unit, and he becomes an independant character, if he survives the combat. Also other characters who accompanied the unit when the standard bearer was still standing, no longer form a unit on their own if the standard bearer is slain. Should a unit champion remain alive with the other characters, they do not form a unit in this case also.

So, it is not possible to bring back the slain unit standard bearer with the Tomb Kings resurrection spell, because the unit was destroyed, and TK cannot summon new units (new summoned VC units do not have any command models, so in this case there's no difference).

The unit standard, and also a magical banner, is lost and captured by the enemy only when the last model was killed in close combat or crumbled as a result of lost combat. The enemy gets victory points only for the standards captured by units that were not broken or destroyed in combat afterwards.
 
Not true Veland, it could happen that champion and/or musician is around, while the standard is lost. As when it comes down to the last models, you can usually decide what models to pick off as casualties. Some like to take away the standard bearers in these cases, as they won't fall into enemy hands. So it's quite possible to resurrect a standard bearer, the question is whether the magic flag is brought back with it. I don't think so.
 
A fine post Veland, but much of what you say is not supported in the rules whatsoever! A Champion for example counts as a rank and file trooper in nearly all situations, so as long as he survives, the unit survives. However the rules indicate that if everyone but the Champion is killed in combat, and then the Champion breaks or is also killed, then the enemy gets the standard.

Do the Tomb King rules give any provision for bringing back dead characters (Such as a Liche Priest on a Casket of Souls)? If so I'd go with whatever they say about their magic stuffs.
 
OK, I don't pretend to write a new rulebook so it's possible I was wrong somewhere in my post :( I'll check later with the rulebook. I couldn't check it when I was writing the post. Sorry!

However, I'm quite sure you no longer get the option to choose who dies from the command group in 7th ed. This option was valid in 6th ed.

I think I was wrong with the champion not forming a unit when SB dies. That would be wrong, what would we do with units that have champions but not SBs?
 
Veland said:
However, I'm quite sure you no longer get the option to choose who dies from the command group in 7th ed.
What do you base that on? The only rank and file model that you can allocate attacks on is the champion. Everything else is up to the controlling player, which model(s) he want to remove.


Veland said:
I think I was wrong with the champion not forming a unit when SB dies. That would be wrong, what would we do with units that have champions but not SBs?
I take it SB is short for Standard Bearer? Anyway, that would be a unit without a standard then. What is the problem?
 
My take on it is quite simple.

1. The incantation heals the unit.
2. The standard bearer is payed for and magic banner is also paid for, and also is apart of the unit itself.
3. The incantation brings back specific models from said unit.

So, I´d say you keep the magical banner.
 
I fully agree, see no problem in that at all, the TK rules state that you have to bring back the command group (if any are dead) before R&F, that means you bring back the standard bearer complete with his standard, does not matter if it is magical. If the rules did not allow you to bring back a magical standard, then they would have stated that. As they dont then it comes back with any powers.
And Veland regardless of what the BrB says (even thought it doesn't) the spell actually states you must bring back the command first.
 
Yeah thats what I thought that you could because you are "healing" the unit so to speak as opposed to raising new models. The situation came up because there is a unit of chariots with full command and the banner one got killed and healed the unit back to full.

Thanks for the discussion guys I will try to check back in here more often.
 
FatOlaf said:
If the rules did not allow you to bring back a magical standard, then they would have stated that.
Like if the rules did not allow Ghouls to fly, then they would have stated that? Actually, it works the other way around. If the rules doesn't say we can, then we probably can't. You could make a case for either way in this situation.
 
N.I.B. said:
FatOlaf said:
If the rules did not allow you to bring back a magical standard, then they would have stated that.
Like if the rules did not allow Ghouls to fly, then they would have stated that? Actually, it works the other way around. If the rules doesn't say we can, then we probably can't. You could make a case for either way in this situation.

Hardly the same thing.

In this case the unit is healed, exactly like character is. Up to its full strength if enough wounds are healed. That is why I think the magical banner still belongs to the unit.
 
The banner is purchased as an upgrade to the unit, not the banner bearer specifically. This means that if he were to return that the banner would begin to take effect again.

The logic behind this is that the wording of the rule specifies that the banner is given to the unit and not to the particular bearer independently. This means if the unit still has the banner through hook nor crook then they get to use it in my opinion.
 
N.I.B. said:
Veland said:
However, I'm quite sure you no longer get the option to choose who dies from the command group in 7th ed.
What do you base that on? The only rank and file model that you can allocate attacks on is the champion. Everything else is up to the controlling player, which model(s) he want to remove.


Veland said:
I think I was wrong with the champion not forming a unit when SB dies. That would be wrong, what would we do with units that have champions but not SBs?
I take it SB is short for Standard Bearer? Anyway, that would be a unit without a standard then. What is the problem?

Sorry I was too busy to post earlier.

I admit that when the unit champion survives, the unit is still there and I made a mistake saying otherwise. No problem here.

I checked TK armybook, and the spell description says that command models can be brought back (champion first) as long as the unit still survives. IMO, if a standard bearer is to be summoned back, he brings his magical banner with him (if he had any), though the spell description does not specify it. I think it works this way due to the SB being "healed" or "resurrected", but on the other hand, you can claim that the magical banner could only be brought back with the standard if the spell description stated that explicitly. Then, a D6 roll could decide to keep the game going, I think.

Regarding the removal of standard bearer models as casualties, the rulebook says on p.80: "The enemy cannot specifically attack standard bearers as he can character models. Standard bearers are not normally removed as casualties, as it is assumed that if the standard bearer is killed, another warrior will pick up the banner and take his place. Therefore, the player always removes an ordinary warrior in preference to a standard bearer, even if the ordinary warrior is not in base contact with the enemy."

So, the controlling player is not allowed to make any choice here.

Similarly, regarding the musicians, the rulebook states: "Also, like standard bearers, the player does not remove musicians, but substitutes an ordinary model instead."

Here, the word "always" is missing. My interpretation is that in case of a dilemma, a musician is removed first and then the standard bearer, but the rule disallows removing musicians in preference to ordinary R&f models.

What about champions? The rulebook states: "Unlike standard bearers and musicians, enemy models can direct attacks against champions and kill them - if a champion is removed as a casualty he is not replaced by another model (see page 76). If the unit suffers enough wounds to kill every model in it, the champion is removed together with his comrades, being after all a rank-and-file model."

My interpretation is that if a champion is not killed by an attack directed specifically at him, he may only be killed if all other models in the unit (including musician and standard bearer) are already killed.

So, trying to figure it out in an example, if we have a unit that has 4 models (1 W each): 1 r&f, 1 musician, 1 standard bearer and one champion, and the champion is not attacked explicitly, the order of removing models as casualties is the following:
1 unsaved wound: 1 r&f model is removed.
2 unsaved wounds: 1 r&f model is removed and then the musician.
3 unsaved wounds: 1 r&f model is removed, the musician after him and then the standard bearer.
4 unsaved wounds: 1 r&f model is removed, the musician, the standard bearer and the champion at the very end.

When I read these rules, I can see no place for a controlling player to decide which models are to be removed since the order is decided by the rulebook. Can you read it in another way? Is there any other place in the rulebook which contains a rule granting this choice to the controlling player?

Linking these rules to the TK example, the spell may bring back the standard bearer only if the unit champion is still alive. If the unit did not have a champion at all, it was destroyed when the standard bearer (or last model) was killed.

The champion may be resurrected only if at least one model remains in the unit after champion's destruction but if the unit had a standard bearer, the surviving model must be the standard bearer.

So, that's my explanation. What's your opinion?
 
Your point is kinda right, but the controlling player can decide whether to lose the champion or the SB, it's one of those grey areas, that also does not really matter too much...
 
As I see is the alternative to recreating the magic banner with the standardbearer is that the killed standardbearer finds himfelt a new, non-magical banner before he is raised back into CC.
 
This is a questions that I'm surprised hasn't come up for VC because it very well could happen with a unit of Skeletons. If you have Full Command with the unit, and only the champion survives, when you raise more troops, do you get your standard bearer and musician back?

The book states: "The enemy cannot specifically attack standard bears as he can character models. Standard bearers are not normally removed as casualties, as it is assumed that if the standard bearer is killed, another warrior will pick up the banner and take his place. Therefore, the player always removes an ordinary warrior in preference to a standard bearer, even if the ordinary warrior is not in base contact with the enemy."

In short, the standard, magical or otherwise, could be dropped many times in the battle, as standard bearers get killed. It is just assumed to be picked up and the fight carried on. It doesn't matter whether the unit was 'healed' or 'new units created'. The banner is not applied to a particular model.

If you can imagine a unit set up 1 wide and 30 long of skeletons, and all the unit had was a standard bearer and regular models, in close combat that standard bearer could be killed over and over. Same thing if you only had a musician. This means that yes, both standards and musicians are applied to the unit and not a particular model in the unit. So if your unit is reduced to a single model and you raise 10 more, you get your standard and musician back.

For removing units, on pg. 81, it says: "If the unit suffers enough wounds to kill every model in it, the champion is removed together with the rest of his comrades, being after all a rank-and-file model. (spelling is really bad in that sentence.. who proof reads their books... and after is not in capitals). The after is clearly stated, so I don't think you get a choice.

@FatOlaf: It may not matter much until you need that extra +1CR from the standard to autobreak a unit, that a champion couldn't provide. In some cases, it may matter a great deal who you remove! (doesn't look like you have a choice though, the standard bearer goes down before the champion0
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu