Okkam's Mind Razor Rule Change

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I will still use model base LD for that as in Q&A there is:

Q: For Characteristic test, is the best value in the unit always used?
A: If the unit is required to take a characteristic test, the best value in the unit is used. If every model in a unit is required to take a characteristigg test, then each model uses its own best value insted.

Now in spell there is "Models in the target unit use their Leadership" not "Unit use their Leadership", so it's obvius for me that they use their own LD not from IP nor from hero in unit.

I know this Q&A is for characteristic test and it's not a test but it explain when to use model base value and when to use unit highest (IP)
 
Niltag said:
I will still use model base LD for that as in Q&A there is:

Q: For Characteristic test, is the best value in the unit always used?
A: If the unit is required to take a characteristic test, the best value in the unit is used. If every model in a unit is required to take a characteristigg test, then each model uses its own best value insted.

Now in spell there is "Models in the target unit use their Leadership" not "Unit use their Leadership", so it's obvius for me that they use their own LD not from IP nor from hero in unit.

I know this Q&A is for characteristic test and it's not a test but it explain when to use model base value and when to use unit highest (IP)

No offence dude but that is like scalping yourself with a spoon.
Why handicap yourself like that?

Anyways, this rule change is even more fun with batswarms
 
Yorga said:
Niltag said:
I will still use model base LD for that as in Q&A there is:

Q: For Characteristic test, is the best value in the unit always used?
A: If the unit is required to take a characteristic test, the best value in the unit is used. If every model in a unit is required to take a characteristigg test, then each model uses its own best value insted.

Now in spell there is "Models in the target unit use their Leadership" not "Unit use their Leadership", so it's obvius for me that they use their own LD not from IP nor from hero in unit.

I know this Q&A is for characteristic test and it's not a test but it explain when to use model base value and when to use unit highest (IP)

You'll be in a small minority. :rolleyes: I'm pretty sure GW spoke loud and clear when they went out of their way to remove the words "on it's profile" when they made the change from 1.5 to 1.6. Remember...this is in the Erata..not FAQ. And I wasn't sure of the wording for Inspiring Presence earlier but Johnny is right. The units may use the General's leadership. It makes no reference to being limited to leadership tests like Skaven's Strength in Numbers rule. And you simply cannot ignore the rule about unmodified leadership. It would make no sense at all to say a model's unmodified leadership is the highest leadership value in the unit and then turn around and say when you use Okram's ignore that other principal.

From 1.5 Errata:

Reference Section –

The Lore of Shadow,

Okkam’s Mindrazor

Change “[...]Models in the target unit use their Leadershipinstead of Strength when rolling To Wound with[...]” to“[...]Models in the target unit use the LeadershipCharacteristic written on their profile, instead of their Strength, for [...]

Now read the same section in the Errata for 1.6a. Note that in the beginning they say Errata is to correct mistakes in the book.

What GW did here was correct it one way with 1.5 and then changed it back with 1.6. I think their intent is clear.
 
Niltag said:
I will still use model base LD for that as in Q&A there is:

Q: For Characteristic test, is the best value in the unit always used?
A: If the unit is required to take a characteristic test, the best value in the unit is used. If every model in a unit is required to take a characteristigg test, then each model uses its own best value insted.

Now in spell there is "Models in the target unit use their Leadership" not "Unit use their Leadership", so it's obvius for me that they use their own LD not from IP nor from hero in unit.

I know this Q&A is for characteristic test and it's not a test but it explain when to use model base value and when to use unit highest (IP)

Characteristics tests rules apply for all characteristics save leadership. For leadership you always use the highest value in the unit. Look at p10 and p100.

So if you want to use characteristics tests as a precedence for rolls involving leadership then it support using the highest value in the unit rather than the model profile value
 
slightly off topic. but a question to those who say you use the models own LD ,what do you guys do about TG screams.

TG screams at a unit of temple guard with a slann. do you scream against ld 8 or ld 9 as the scream isnt a leadership test.
 
Pladvoncarstein said:
slightly off topic. but a question to those who say you use the models own LD ,what do you guys do about TG screams.

TG screams at a unit of temple guard with a slann. do you scream against ld 8 or ld 9 as the scream isnt a leadership test.

IP is used with the screams!
 
Yorga said:
Yorga said:
Niltag said:
I will still use model base LD for that as in Q&A there is:

Q: For Characteristic test, is the best value in the unit always used?
A: If the unit is required to take a characteristic test, the best value in the unit is used. If every model in a unit is required to take a characteristigg test, then each model uses its own best value insted.

Now in spell there is "Models in the target unit use their Leadership" not "Unit use their Leadership", so it's obvius for me that they use their own LD not from IP nor from hero in unit.

I know this Q&A is for characteristic test and it's not a test but it explain when to use model base value and when to use unit highest (IP)

You'll be in a small minority. :rolleyes: I'm pretty sure GW spoke loud and clear when they went out of their way to remove the words "on it's profile" when they made the change from 1.5 to 1.6. Remember...this is in the Erata..not FAQ. And I wasn't sure of the wording for Inspiring Presence earlier but Johnny is right. The units may use the General's leadership. It makes no reference to being limited to leadership tests like Skaven's Strength in Numbers rule. And you simply cannot ignore the rule about unmodified leadership. It would make no sense at all to say a model's unmodified leadership is the highest leadership value in the unit and then turn around and say when you use Okram's ignore that other principal.

From 1.5 Errata:

Reference Section –

The Lore of Shadow,

Okkam’s Mindrazor

Change “[...]Models in the target unit use their Leadershipinstead of Strength when rolling To Wound with[...]” to“[...]Models in the target unit use the LeadershipCharacteristic written on their profile, instead of their Strength, for [...]

Now read the same section in the Errata for 1.6a. Note that in the beginning they say Errata is to correct mistakes in the book.

What GW did here was correct it one way with 1.5 and then changed it back with 1.6. I think their intent is clear.

Uhhhhh thank goodness. It finally makes sense now that all the facts have been presented :thumbsup:

Still though... not sure if I'm going to base an entire army on a single level 2 Shadow Lore Vamp Hero (the other lvl 2 helps ensure one gets it) trying to spam Mindrazor...
 
I had kinda promised myself not to get into this debate, but I'll do it anyway...

As fas as I can tell, there IS a difference between "Leadership" and "Unmodified Leadership". As far as I can see, "Unmodified Ld" is the highest Ld value in the unit, but is it safe to assume that this is also the value to be used when talking about "Non-unmodified Leadership"? If so, why?

There are a lot of referencing to stuff involving Ld tests. I believe we agree that Mindrazor does not in any way involve an Ld test, so I do not think that rules regarding tests are relevant in this debate. If I am missing something crucial as to why they should be, then please elaborate. As for pages 10 and 100 of the BRB, they both mention how to take Leadership tests, not what Ld value to use for anything else.

/Devil's Advocate out:devil2:
 
Gokamok said:
As fas as I can tell, there IS a difference between "Leadership" and "Unmodified Leadership". As far as I can see, "Unmodified Ld" is the highest Ld value in the unit, but is it safe to assume that this is also the value to be used when talking about "Non-unmodified Leadership"? If so, why?
Well use of (modified) leadership is not defined anywhere but as you say Unmodified Leadership is.
I think it's safer to assume that Unmodified Leadership allows for less modification than (modified) Leadership. So if you are allowed to use highest leadership in unit for Unmodified Leadership, at the very least you should be able to do so as well for (modified) leadership.

True, it's not defined anywhere, but yeah, I think it is a lot safer to assume that Unmodified Leadership is MORE restrictive not LESS.
 
Smogg said:
Gokamok said:
As fas as I can tell, there IS a difference between "Leadership" and "Unmodified Leadership". As far as I can see, "Unmodified Ld" is the highest Ld value in the unit, but is it safe to assume that this is also the value to be used when talking about "Non-unmodified Leadership"? If so, why?
Well use of (modified) leadership is not defined anywhere but as you say Unmodified Leadership is.
I think it's safer to assume that Unmodified Leadership allows for less modification than (modified) Leadership. So if you are allowed to use highest leadership in unit for Unmodified Leadership, at the very least you should be able to do so as well for (modified) leadership.

True, it's not defined anywhere, but yeah, I think it is a lot safer to assume that Unmodified Leadership is MORE restrictive not LESS.

I believe it's a good assumption!
As far as I can see from a pure RAW point of view, then you're definitely allowed to use the Ld boost from Inspiring Presence, whereas the case for being allowed to use another characters Ld for Mindrazor seems slightly more iffy.
 
How do you get around the fact that GW amended the rule back to using leadership value? Your leadership is either that of the higest value in the unit OR the General's IP? GW said you DO NOT use the 'Profile' value.
 
Yorga said:
How do you get around the fact that GW amended the rule back to using leadership value? Your leadership is either that of the higest value in the unit OR the General's IP? GW said you DO NOT use the 'Profile' value.

I understand the rules, though i loathe GW for their emphasis on this stupid spell. It was bad enough that we had to worry about this crap with DE & HE, but with VC & Empire too? U suck, GW
Edit/ I'm totally sober while posting this.
 
Yorga said:
How do you get around the fact that GW amended the rule back to using leadership value? Your leadership is either that of the higest value in the unit OR the General's IP? GW said you DO NOT use the 'Profile' value.

Can you please tell me EXACTLY where in the BRB/FAQ/Errata, that GW tells us to use the highest Ld in unit/Inspiring Presence over the Ld of the individual model?
All I've been able to find so far, is stuff that I feel will potentially cause issues during a game, and not completely "set in stone" rules on this matter.

EDIT:
After re-reading my post, I felt like I sounded a bit trolly. That is NOT the case, I'm just trying to figure out exactly how well based the argument is.

DOUBLE-EDIT:
GAH! Why don't I read posts properly? (And why do I keep telling you guys that I edit, rather than just pretend I got it right in the first place) @Yorga: Exactly where does GW tell us not to use the profile value when using Mindrazor?
 
Gokamok said:
Yorga said:
How do you get around the fact that GW amended the rule back to using leadership value? Your leadership is either that of the higest value in the unit OR the General's IP? GW said you DO NOT use the 'Profile' value.

Can you please tell me EXACTLY where in the BRB/FAQ/Errata, that GW tells us to use the highest Ld in unit/Inspiring Presence over the Ld of the individual model?
All I've been able to find so far, is stuff that I feel will potentially cause issues during a game, and not completely "set in stone" rules on this matter.

EDIT:
After re-reading my post, I felt like I sounded a bit trolly. That is NOT the case, I'm just trying to figure out exactly how well based the argument is.

DOUBLE-EDIT:
GAH! Why don't I read posts properly? (And why do I keep telling you guys that I edit, rather than just pretend I got it right in the first place) @Yorga: Exactly where does GW tell us not to use the profile value when using Mindrazor?

In FAQ of the BRB 1.5 in the errata for Okrazm's Mindrazor they told us to use the value on the model's profile. See my copy of the exact section from 1.5 way up above. In 1.6 and 1.6a they deleted the words about using the leadership value of the profile. In other words they went back to just straight leadership. If someone whips out 1.5 on you at a tournament you whip out 1.6a and trump them. As Smogg has stated. Leadership is defined in two places. Page 10 and page 100. Then Inspiring Presence talks about your 'leadership'. Not your leadership test but your plan old leadership.

So I challenge you Gokamok, show me anywhere in the rule book or errata where it says that your leadership is only what is on your model's profile. I can show you three places where that is not the case. Four if you want to throw in the rule under mounted models as well. :innocent:
 
I like this change just from the aspect that it levels the playing field.

Now its not just elves that benefit from this spell and gives other armies a chance to be equally annoying. Anyways, if this is a players sole and only build for the use of this spell in the list then you know what spell you need to save your dice or scroll to dispel.
 
Aedin said:
Anyways, if this is a players sole and only build for the use of this spell in the list then you know what spell you need to save your dice or scroll to dispel.

People will just 6 dice it and get the IF like they always have. Man, I hate 8th edition...
 
@Yorga:
I'll buy the reasoning that there seems to be precedence for using highest Ld in unit/IP over the individual models statline. Especially, I feel that the change from 1.5 to 1.6 is close to hard evidence that Mindrazor is indeed meant to allow models to benefit from Ld boosts from characters.

/Surrender:grave:
 
Seneschal said:
Aedin said:
Anyways, if this is a players sole and only build for the use of this spell in the list then you know what spell you need to save your dice or scroll to dispel.

People will just 6 dice it and get the IF like they always have. Man, I hate 8th edition...

I actually think that Mindrazor is a great spell for creating game balance, since it VERY specifically punishes "power" units like Demigryphs, Mournfangs, Cavalry Deathstars and the like. Against most infantry, you'd benefit just as much from Soulblight, Hellish Vigour, Flaming Sword, etc. as you would from Mindrazor.
 
Also if you save dice for Razor it means I can get off Pit, Withering or Miasma. Shadow is a very deadly lore and saving all your dice for one spell would be a mistake.
 
Johnny-Crass said:
Also if you save dice for Razor it means I can get off Pit, Withering or Miasma. Shadow is a very deadly lore and saving all your dice for one spell would be a mistake.

That's very true, but with level 2 Vamp heros casting Pit and Withering, isn't there a high risk of

a) failing to cast by not throwing enough dice which is a 50/50 chance that he has razor as his other spell or
b) miscasting by throwing too many dice at a spell, which can really botch things up if you're saving razor until the end

With a lvl 2, you'd be throwing, what, 4 dice for Withering? 5 dice for Pit? 5 dice for Razor?

If only Master Necros could choose Shadow...
 
Its why I also have another Lvl2 shadow and a Lvl 4 death. ;) Shadow mages in a vacuum are not great but in conjunction it is hard to stop the spell combos.
 
eggspr said:
a) failing to cast by not throwing enough dice which is a 50/50 chance that he has razor as his other spell or

Oh my...where you play spells are not openly rolled before the game? I've never seen that style of play. How can you be sure your opponent is honest about what spells he got?
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu