Okkam's Mind Razor Rule Change

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Yorga said:
eggspr said:
a) failing to cast by not throwing enough dice which is a 50/50 chance that he has razor as his other spell or

Oh my...where you play spells are not openly rolled before the game? I've never seen that style of play. How can you be sure your opponent is honest about what spells he got?

Ha no I didn't mean it like that (though that would be horrible).

I mean that you'd have 2 seperate lvl 2 casters.

Say for instance, the first has Miasma and Pit.
The other has Withering and Razor.

The 2nd tries to throw 4 dice at Withering, and fails to cast. Now your Razor plans are snafu.

Don't get me wrong, I'm still going to try this out. I'm just focusing on the negative :slapface:
 
What the "big" spells do is push the game more and more into the "must create bigger units in order to survive" mindset, step up adds to this.

The step up rule is fine but when the spells that make me yawn are taken into account, games become more and more bland as it's just a few big blocks on the table being pushed forward. It's like 6th edition WoC.

Not every army has access to shadow, either, which is definitely the strongest lore in the game and has the two best spells (miasma and razor).
 
I think the opposite of promoting larger units.

I think it promotes more units because 1 large unit can be devastated by a spell and makes players think twice about "death star" units because if you loose all your eggs in that one basket the game is over :slapface:. That's the reason i don't field 40 GG anymore.

As for saving the power dice for dispelling mind razor I do understand you have to look at what you opponent is casting and use your dispel dice accordingly. I just did not wont to make an endlessly long post on dispel tactics (that should be for another thread). And if you want to I.F. the spell go right ahead it will eventually bite you and 6 dice don't always mean an I.F. result well unless your tactless the broken elf-lord.

Ohh and BTW once i find out which caster has the spell which character do you think my varghulf and deathmages will be targeting hmmm :suck:
 
actually, throwing 6 dice on a spell only give you around 26,3% chances of rolling 2 or more 6's.
 
Xivigg said:
actually, throwing 6 dice on a spell only give you around 26,3% chances of rolling 2 or more 6's.

Tell me. I tossed 18 dice in a tournament I played last week trying to get some hits that needed a 6 and didn't roll a bloody one!:slapface:
 
Yorga said:
Xivigg said:
actually, throwing 6 dice on a spell only give you around 26,3% chances of rolling 2 or more 6's.

Tell me. I tossed 18 dice in a tournament I played last week trying to get some hits that needed a 6 and didn't roll a bloody one!:slapface:

A ~3.76% chance that is
 
Look at the tournament winning armies, the vast majority go by the "big unit" formula.

Even if your opponent fails to get an IF with 6 dice, they've probably rolled so high that you can't dispel their attempt anyway. Magic in this edition did not need a boost but it seems GW thought otherwise.


As far as protecting casters in a VC army goes, bunker them up and keep 1" away from the back of a mainline block and you are safe.
 
Seneschal said:
As far as protecting casters in a VC army goes, bunker them up and keep 1" away from the back of a mainline block and you are safe.

That's my idea with my necromancer list. Stay one inch behind the Cyrpt Horrors and right next to the mortis engine.
 
Have decided yet as to wheather we can use highest in unit or Ip.
One more argument for it to work is the TG scream as it is not a leadershp test but you can use IP against it.
 
Pladvoncarstein said:
Have decided yet as to wheather we can use highest in unit or Ip.
One more argument for it to work is the TG scream as it is not a leadershp test but you can use IP against it.

That's true. IP helps victims survive the scream as their mighty leader puts iron into their spine. :) Leaderless mean have their heart burst from sheer fright.
 
Could someone provide screens of said change? I'm having this up for discussion among those who i play against and they think i'm delirious. I need some cold hard proof but i can't find the changes myself.

/sudor
 
The change is just in the wording of the errata for the spell, and how it used to be worded. They took out the word 'profile' which meant it was each models leadership , now it just says 'leadership' which means inspiring presence or a character in a unit bestowing their ld to the unit
 
Sudor said:
Could someone provide screens of said change? I'm having this up for discussion among those who i play against and they think i'm delirious. I need some cold hard proof but i can't find the changes myself.

/sudor

Some guy googled it and put up a sceen link of 1.5 earlier in this thread or the New FAQ thread. If anyone has not updated their FAQ to 1.6 then they'll still have 1.5. Put the two pages down side by side and VIOLA!
 
Yorga said:
Sudor said:
Could someone provide screens of said change? I'm having this up for discussion among those who i play against and they think i'm delirious. I need some cold hard proof but i can't find the changes myself.

/sudor

Some guy googled it and put up a sceen link of 1.5 earlier in this thread or the New FAQ thread. If anyone has not updated their FAQ to 1.6 then they'll still have 1.5. Put the two pages down side by side and VIOLA!


Yeah found it. Thnx!
 
I'm not sure if this was brought up yet, or if it is a valid argument, but:

Checking the spanish version of the FAQ, it still says "profile leadership" on the current changes.

I guess they messed up the English version, hehe.
 
is it? D:

If I knew german as I did in the 90s I'd check that FAQ hahaha.

Well, if consensus is that part is now missing from the spell, let me know :D
 
kevin.hopkins7 said:
I think that was brought up, or it might have been another issue, the Spanish one was considered the erroneous one

The Spanards messed up the No Overrun after crumbling rule also. Wrote yes instead of 'no'. Doesn't get anymore wrong than that. :slapface:
 
Oh yeah! I can see that

also, in the VC FAQs, they mistook the Terrogheist with a Vargheist.

Because in spain (and Mexico, perhaps) Vargheist screams to you!!

...

just kidding, I won't use 3x Death Shrieks with my vargheists, but it does really make you wonder how much care they put into this. I'm glad I have the english army book =)
 
Fellow Lords and Ladies. I think we have missed the real change between 1.5 and 1.6a. Look closely at the two.

Old rule.

Reference Section – The Lore of Shadow, Okkam’s Mindrazor
Change “[...]Models in the target unit use their Leadership instead of Strength when rolling To Wound with[...]” to“[...]Models in the target unit use the Leadership Characteristic written on their profile, instead of their Strength,for[...]

new rule

Reference Section – The Lore of Shadow, Okkam’s
Mindrazor.
Change “[...]when rolling To Wound with[...]” to
“[...]for[...]”

The only real part they are changing is in the first sentence, last part."when rolling To Wound with) to "when rolling To Wound "for".

That is the only change. They didn't remove the whole last section "to“[...]Models in the target unit use the Leadership Characteristic written on their profile, instead of their Strength,for[...]
 
midean said:
Fellow Lords and Ladies. I think we have missed the real change between 1.5 and 1.6a. Look closely at the two.

Old rule.

Reference Section – The Lore of Shadow, Okkam’s Mindrazor
Change “[...]Models in the target unit use their Leadership instead of Strength when rolling To Wound with[...]” to“[...]Models in the target unit use the Leadership Characteristic written on their profile, instead of their Strength,for[...]

new rule

Reference Section – The Lore of Shadow, Okkam’s
Mindrazor.
Change “[...]when rolling To Wound with[...]” to
“[...]for[...]”

The only real part they are changing is in the first sentence, last part."when rolling To Wound with) to "when rolling To Wound "for".

That is the only change. They didn't remove the whole last section "to“[...]Models in the target unit use the Leadership Characteristic written on their profile, instead of their Strength,for[...]

OMG! Will this thread never end? Amendments are changes to the actual book. Take the lastest amendment and hand write it in. Now tell me where you see the word 'profile' ANYWHERE in the paragraph? GW 'added' that word with 1.5. They deleted that word with 1.6a. 'Nuff said already! :slapface:
 
Yorga said:
OMG! Will this thread never end? Amendments are changes to the actual book. Take the lastest amendment and hand write it in. Now tell me where you see the word 'profile' ANYWHERE in the paragraph? GW 'added' that word with 1.5. They deleted that word with 1.6a. 'Nuff said already! :slapface:

No this will never end unfortunatly.

Reading this "Where a version number has a letter,
E.g. 1.1a, this means it has had a local update, only in that
language, to clarify a translation issue or other minor
correction."

Wich to me indicates that the 1.6a change is only in the english version. I don't speak other then swedish and english so I can't really check. But from what I understand, that change was not in the spanish version.

And yes I understand what you are writing, but i'm not sure that is the correct way to read the errata.

Where does it say that you should discard previous changes to the rule in newer versions? If you rewrite the rule in the book with the changes from 1.5, and then apply the changes from 1.6a on that, then you can still see the word 'profile' written on the ppater in front of you.
 
I think it is a natural assumption that older versions of the FaQ no longer have any say in any matter simply because they aren't accessible on the GW web page. If you can't trace a rule back to an official GW document supplied by GW themselves then I don't think you can use it as a source.
 
Yeah I have t agree with Yorga and Mad'at now that I look at more. Someone new to the game comes in and reads the new FAQ he's gonna follow what it says. He's not going to know anything about "profile" not being there. Although I don't think it's meant to be that way, that's the way it is.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu