Randar said:
Vipoid maybe but your interrupting not RAW again we can not add words or change words.
Just as you can't add the word 'other', which completely changes the meaning of the sentence.
Because, without that word, my interpretation is the most logical one.
Randar said:
Also if you argued this at a tourney or friendly game I doubt many if anyone would side with VC over beastmen. Our TG op as it is. I always let my opponents have it there way
I'm sure no one is doubting your generosity. However, saying 'I always let my opponents have their way.' is not a valid rules argument.
Nor is '
VC is stronger than beastmen, so all rules debates must automatically be ruled in favour of beastmen.'
Here's the thing - in a tournament, you could well be right. But then, tournaments tend to require swift judgements, and rarely have time to ponder each rule and faq. Which way the ruling goes is far less important, compared to simply giving a ruling, so that the game can continue.
Furthermore, some tournaments don't allow terrorghiests to scream into combats they're not a part of. In other words - their rulings sometimes directly disobey official (and very clear) faqs.
So, in either case, a tournament ruling is not a good thing to base your argument on. Especially a hypothetical tournament that doesn't actually exist, and has made no such ruling.
Randar said:
If a 50% chance to not shriek will make you lose versus BM then you need to go back to drawing board big time lol
Again, this is an illogical argument, and one that I can easily turn around. i.e. if not having that 50/50 chance will cause the Beastman player to lose, then
he needs to go back to the drawing board.