question about Death Shriek

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Relying on the absence of the word "All" and the presence of the word "fire" just doesn't cut it for me.
I don't see how that backs up your assertion that you interpretation of the rules is somehow superior?

As for adding in words I think you'd have to agree that you are the only one to have done that with your FAQ edit?
 
To state the obvious it's basically a RaW / RaI argument.

VC
Q: Do items or spells that affect missile fire have any affect on a Banshee's Ghostly Howl?
A: No

This quote however doesn't leave room for maneuver.
 
ATP485 said:
To state the obvious it's basically a RaW / RaI argument.

VC
Q: Do items or spells that affect missile fire have any affect on a Banshee's Ghostly Howl?
A: No

This quote however doesn't leave room for maneuver.

Your right, for things that only affect missile fire. But for things that affect "other attacks", that is a different story.
 
Shriek attack falls into the catagory of "other attacks" that do not use a BS. Have to agree with Magpie.
 
the faq only mentions banshee howl though there isnt one for TG shrieck i had this argument with a guy at my club, he said fine faq states banshees wernt affected but then he argued for 20 mins that the death shriek wasnt mentioned in the faq so its affected in the end to shut him up we rolled for it. i agreed with eggspr but im sick of people arguing with me about it i usaly just say roll to see what rule works for the TG
 
midean said:
Shriek attack falls into the catagory of "other attacks" that do not use a BS. Have to agree with Magpie.

But 'other' is the key word there, and does not appear in the rule text.

My interpretation is that the rule refers to missile weapons that do not need to roll to hit - cannons, stone throwers etc.
 
midean said:
Shriek attack falls into the catagory of "other attacks" that do not use a BS. Have to agree with Magpie.

There people go misquoting again... Wheres "other"?? And now ppl are agreeing with misinformation and misquoting? Oh sigh... Whats this world coming to?? ;). Shall I post the rules for a 3rd time?

It's like that guy u play that literally bends the tape measure to hit your guy with the ________ even though if you don't physically touch the tape measure it doesn't hit anything... We all know that guy!!

Only this about words in a sentence... Don't bend the sentence.... Just read, and interpret. Life's easier that way :)
 
Beastmen book:
All enemy missile units are at -1 to hit. Weapons or attacks that do not use Ballistic Skill may only fire on the roll of a 4+.

death shriek is an "Attack" and it does not use BS what are we arguing about its clear cut! need 4+
so any shooting weapons are -1( that use BS) also any weapons or attacks that do not use BS EVERYTHING ELSE needs a 4+ to use EGGSPR sorry your grasping at straws besides beastmen are the weakest army by far let them have something LOL
 
Magpie said:
ATP485 said:
To state the obvious it's basically a RaW / RaI argument.

VC
Q: Do items or spells that affect missile fire have any affect on a Banshee's Ghostly Howl?
A: No

This quote however doesn't leave room for maneuver.

Your right, for things that only affect missile fire. But for things that affect "other attacks", that is a different story.

nailed it Magpie!! :thumbsup:
 
Seams about time I'd share my thought as well.

I'm with eggie, but my reasoning is somewhat different.

Q: Do items or spells that affect missile fire have any affect on a Banshee's Ghostly Howl?
A: No

So any spells that do, in any way, affect missile fire do not have any affect on the howl. Question: does the Chalice affect missile fire? Yes it does. Therefore it is an item that affects missile fire, and therefore it does not affect the howl. Weather the spell/item affect other stuff too is irrelevant.

I do realise that I'm stretching things here, and I might be completely wrong due to lack knowledge in the English language, but that's the way I read it.
 
I agree with your perspective, that seems the most logical answer. However, we probably need a new FAQ to set it straight. I think I would play it this way but if my opponent thought otherwise I would let him do it his way or dice it off
 
Mad said:
I'm with eggie, but my reasoning is somewhat different.

Boom!!

Coming to you straight from the most credible VC poster on this forum.

@ Mad At, it's ok buddy... the ends justify the means :)

And no... Shrieks aren't attacks... They're special non-shooting attacks that 100% do NOT "fire" ;) Never did, never will... FAQ or not.
 
Mad said:
Seams about time I'd share my thought as well.

I'm with eggie, but my reasoning is somewhat different.

Q: Do items or spells that affect missile fire have any affect on a Banshee's Ghostly Howl?
A: No

So any spells that do, in any way, affect missile fire do not have any affect on the howl. Question: does the Chalice affect missile fire? Yes it does. Therefore it is an item that affects missile fire, and therefore it does not affect the howl. Weather the spell/item affect other stuff too is irrelevant.

I do realise that I'm stretching things here, and I might be completely wrong due to lack knowledge in the English language, but that's the way I read it.

No you can't extend it like that. "Do things that affect missile fire....?" is the limit of the proposition and that restricts the question to "things that affect missile fire" and does not include "things that affect missile fire and the other effects of that thing that affect other things".

Think of it this way, the Chalice has two effects. One that affects "missile fire" and one that affects "attacks that do not use BS etc".

The FAQ only concerns itself with the first effect, not the second.

Having it's effect against missiles nullified does not then nullify all its other effects that affect other things.
 
If you want to be right out there I could argue Death shriek is not a banshee howl and therefore not in the FAQ and does not follow the same rules RAW vs RAI? Lets play with spirit as intended :innocent:

Its clear cut as can be As far as ONE item in ONE book affecting Shriek......

Come on guys be real here it effects everything in the shooting phase things with BS things without! all weapons and attacks so unless you think Shriek is a movement your just arguing for sake of it.

:vampire3:
 
Here I am all quoting stuff... 5th time's a charm? ;)

Chalice rule
All enemy missile units are at -1 to hit. Weapons or attacks that do not use Ballistic Skill may only fire on the roll of a 4+.

Why even mention BS if it didn't mean shooting attacks? Why mention fire if it isn't a shooting attack?

If it said, "All enemy missile units are at -1 to hit. All other weapons or attacks may only be used on the roll of a 4+." You'd have an argument.

But it doesn't... You want it to read that way... But please stop bending that tape measure... It's not going to help you.

I'd post the VC FAQ which exclude screams from missile fire, but then I'd be coming full circle to my post a week ago... And yes it does feel like I'm going around in circles. Shame that I doubt you'll get a FAQ about this as GW already said screams are excluded from items affecting missile units...
 
Your big argument is it doesn't say all other......

Really ? Your bending the tape in your favor Hindering beast men player by saying its a special attack not an attack... Still an attack bro special attack, magical attack, random attack, all are still attacks! Weapons and attacks. Does death shriek shoot no. First part does not apply no -1, is it an attack or weapon that does not use BS yes therefore applies. 4+

Good against seige machines and shreikers

You are rai not raw focusing on why fire is in there instead of go or use or any other word to start an action? But not on key word weapons and attacks that do not use. Bs skill !
 
Saying that a special attack is not an attack is like saying nehekheran (spelling?) undead aren't undead. Saying that you've quoted the same thing 5 times goes the other way too you know..

This is probably more than the 5th time anyone said this but:




All enemy missile units are at -1 to hit. Weapons or attacks that do not use Ballistic Skill may only fire on the roll of a 4+.

Weapons or attacks that do not use ballistic skill may only fire on a roll of a 4+

attacks that do not use ballistic skill may only fire on a roll of a 4+

do not use ballistic skill may only fire on a roll of a 4+

fire on a roll of a 4+

roll of a 4+

4+


what other word would you use instead of fire the death shriek? launch?


To you who fought someone who said the faq only covered the ghostly howl, not the death shriek. Your opponent should be okay with you ressurecting several hexwraiths then (Y) :)
 
Randar said:
Really ? Your bending the tape in your favor Hindering beast men player by saying its a special attack not an attack... Still an attack bro special attack, magical attack, random attack, all are still attacks! Weapons and attacks. Does death shriek shoot no. First part does not apply no -1, is it an attack or weapon that does not use BS yes therefore applies. 4+

It seems like you're metaphorically bending the tape just as much, to be honest.

Again, 'other' is the key word, because otherwise it's perfectly reasonable and logical to read the second sentence as a clarification of the first. The first sentence says that all missile weapons get -1 to hit. The second sentence then says what to do for missile attacks that don't use BS. i.e. it refers to missile weapons and missile attacks.

If it said "Other attacks that do not use BS...", then it would logically refer to non-missile attacks. However, the current wording seems like it's meant to be read as a clarification on the aforementioned missile weapons.
 
Vipoid said:
Randar said:
Really ? Your bending the tape in your favor Hindering beast men player by saying its a special attack not an attack... Still an attack bro special attack, magical attack, random attack, all are still attacks! Weapons and attacks. Does death shriek shoot no. First part does not apply no -1, is it an attack or weapon that does not use BS yes therefore applies. 4+

It seems like you're metaphorically bending the tape just as much, to be honest.

Again, 'other' is the key word, because otherwise it's perfectly reasonable and logical to read the second sentence as a clarification of the first. The first sentence says that all missile weapons get -1 to hit. The second sentence then says what to do for missile attacks that don't use BS. i.e. it refers to missile weapons and missile attacks.

If it said "Other attacks that do not use BS...", then it would logically refer to non-missile attacks. However, the current wording seems like it's meant to be read as a clarification on the aforementioned missile weapons.

I like you Vipoid :)

Well said.
 
Vipoid maybe but your interrupting not RAW again we can not add words or change words.
This could mean that or this etc all day
But we must go buy exactly what is written
No words added or subtracted.

Also if you argued this at a tourney or friendly game I doubt many if anyone would side with VC over beastmen. Our TG op as it is. I always let my opponents have it there way :)

If a 50% chance to not shriek will make you lose versus BM then you need to go back to drawing board big time lol

I win 90% of my matches so who cares if he gets a tiny advantage from X or Y



Also hex wraiths are 1+ caster level. :).
Ps I don't own any :)
 
How about this, a somewhat more RAI interpretation (although i think RAW is pretty clear too). The Chalice is an item that makes shooting difficult. The VC FaQ says that the howl is immune to stuff that affects shooting. In other words, the howl is not to be seen as a shooting attack and therefore stuff that makes shooting harder have no effect.
 
Mad said:
How about this, a somewhat more RAI interpretation (although i think RAW is pretty clear too). The Chalice is an item that makes shooting difficult. The VC FaQ says that the howl is immune to stuff that affects shooting. In other words, the howl is not to be seen as a shooting attack and therefore stuff that makes shooting harder have no effect.

amen to that!
 
Randar said:
Vipoid maybe but your interrupting not RAW again we can not add words or change words.

Just as you can't add the word 'other', which completely changes the meaning of the sentence.

Because, without that word, my interpretation is the most logical one.


Randar said:
Also if you argued this at a tourney or friendly game I doubt many if anyone would side with VC over beastmen. Our TG op as it is. I always let my opponents have it there way :)

I'm sure no one is doubting your generosity. However, saying 'I always let my opponents have their way.' is not a valid rules argument.

Nor is 'VC is stronger than beastmen, so all rules debates must automatically be ruled in favour of beastmen.'

Here's the thing - in a tournament, you could well be right. But then, tournaments tend to require swift judgements, and rarely have time to ponder each rule and faq. Which way the ruling goes is far less important, compared to simply giving a ruling, so that the game can continue.

Furthermore, some tournaments don't allow terrorghiests to scream into combats they're not a part of. In other words - their rulings sometimes directly disobey official (and very clear) faqs.

So, in either case, a tournament ruling is not a good thing to base your argument on. Especially a hypothetical tournament that doesn't actually exist, and has made no such ruling. :rolleyes:

Randar said:
If a 50% chance to not shriek will make you lose versus BM then you need to go back to drawing board big time lol

Again, this is an illogical argument, and one that I can easily turn around. i.e. if not having that 50/50 chance will cause the Beastman player to lose, then he needs to go back to the drawing board.
 
I do not need to add any words or interrupt anything it's plain as day. Weapons or attacks no bs = 4+

Over years I have seen some very confusing rules and things needing a FAQ desperately. This to me is a no brainier big time!
Very clear rule. RAW no interputing needed.

Seen some good arguments too. This is just silly.......
 
Randar said:
I do not need to add any words or interrupt anything it's plain as day. Weapons or attacks no bs = 4+

Again, you can't ignore the first sentence. The reason being that it gives the second sentence context.

What you're doing is taking the last sentence on its own, and treating it like a completely separate effect.

If you insist on doing that, then it does indeed affect the terrorghiest scream; as well as any other attacks that don't need to roll to hit. It also affects magic attacks, close combat attacks etc. (both the opponent's and those belonging to the controlling beastman player), and it will last until the end of the game (or the model with the chalice dies).

You see, the first sentence also states which phase the item effects, and how long the effect lasts.

If you treat the second sentence as completely separate from the first (which is exactly what you're doing), then you can't take the duration or activation information from the first sentence either.

So, you must treat that last sentence as a continuous effect that lasts until the end of the game.

On the other hand, if you take the second sentence in context, then it logically refers to missile weapons and missile attacks that do not use BS.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu